STRATASkip to the research
What’s Left, original XLVII plate

What’s Left

Turing’s 1936 paper on computable numbers describes machines through explicit states and operations. His 1950 Computing Machinery and Intelligence survives as a typescript in the King’s College Cambridge archive, preserving the original formulation for comparison with later interpretations.

An archival correction changes a derived record without changing the historical source. W3C PROV represents entities, activities, agents, and their relationships; a corrected unit can retain its source image, transcription, justification, and unresolved alternatives.

Historical record

  1. A procedure receives a precise mathematical description.

    Turing’s paper on computable numbers describes machines through explicit states and operations. The work gives later readers a procedure they can inspect and reason about, even when the original mathematical problem differs from their own application.

  2. A typescript preserves the argument before its later reputation.

    The King’s College archive holds a typescript of Computing Machinery and Intelligence. The surviving document allows readers to return to Turing’s actual formulation and distinguish it from shorthand inherited through later discussions.

  3. A transformation can keep its parent record in view.

    W3C PROV represents the relationship between an entity, an activity and a responsible agent. Its formal vocabulary supports a practical habit: preserve a result’s derivation so a later correction does not erase the evidence it corrected.

A corrected unit should leave a recoverable trail.

Imagine an old measurement sheet whose column says millivolts but whose instrument range and calibration record indicate volts. Preserve the scanned sheet and its literal transcription first. A corrected table can then add an explicit conversion, the evidence used to justify it, the reviewer and the date. If the evidence does not settle the unit, retain both candidate interpretations and show how each changes the conclusion. This is an archival example, not a correction to a real published experiment.

  • Assign stable identifiers to the source image, transcription and corrected table. Their content hashes should differ because they are distinct records.
  • Compute the downstream result under both unit interpretations before deciding whether the uncertainty is material.
  • Place the unresolved unit in a review queue with a specific missing item, such as the instrument manual or original calibration sheet. An unexplained replacement value would close the question too early.

Recordings and archives

Research sources

  1. On Computable Numbers, with an Application to the Entscheidungsproblem

    Alan M. Turing / original paper hosted by University of Southern California · Original 1936 computation paper; no inference that every physical question is computable.

  2. Computing machinery and intelligence

    Alan M. Turing / King’s College Cambridge archive · Preserved typescript of the 1950 paper.

  3. PROV-DM: The PROV Data Model

    W3C · 30 April 2013 Recommendation: entities, activities, agents and derivation.

  4. Evaluation of measurement data—Guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement

    Joint Committee for Guides in Metrology / BIPM · JCGM 100:2008, reporting a result with a model and evaluated uncertainty.