STRATASkip to the research
Keep It Down, original XLVII plate

Keep It Down

The Rogers Commission’s 1986 Challenger report examined communication and decision-making alongside the physical failure. Its record permits comparison between the engineering information available, the way it reached decision-makers, and the action that followed.

JPL’s 1999 preliminary Mars Climate Orbiter findings identified incompatible English and metric units in transferred information. A command, its recorded execution, and an independently observed state are different pieces of evidence; a handover must preserve those distinctions for the next investigation.

Historical record

  1. A mission record connects actions across shifts and vehicles.

    Apollo 11’s documented sequence runs from launch through lunar operations to recovery. Its mission archive makes it possible to follow changing states and responsibilities across an operation whose success depends on more than one person’s view.

  2. An investigation examines how engineering information reached decision-makers.

    The Rogers Commission delivers its Challenger report on 6 June. Alongside the physical failure, it identifies problems in communication and decision-making, preserving the evidence needed to examine how an organization acted on what it knew.

  3. A units mismatch exposes a failed interface between teams.

    JPL’s preliminary Mars Climate Orbiter findings describe incompatible English and metric units in transferred information. The lesson concerns the interface and its verification; each team’s internally familiar convention did not guarantee a shared meaning.

A handover is complete when the next person can recover the state.

Use a software simulation of a reservoir, not a live industrial installation. At time 14:03 the model contains 80 units and an outflow of 2 units per minute. A simulated stop at 14:05 leaves 76 units if inflow is zero and the rate is constant. The handover record should preserve the command time, observed state, units and any uncertainty about whether the command took effect. A successor must be able to distinguish the instruction from the observation.

  • Record the simulated state immediately before and after the command. A log entry saying stop requested is different from evidence that the outflow became zero.
  • Recompute the remaining reserve from the last trusted observation. If it disagrees with the displayed value, keep the discrepancy visible for investigation.
  • Name the next responsible person and the unresolved question. In a real installation, the authorized operating procedure and trained personnel determine the actual response.

Recordings and archives

Research sources

  1. Apollo 11 Mission Overview

    NASA · Mission dates, landing, recovery and mission objectives; NASA’s own mission record.

  2. Report of the Presidential Commission on the Space Shuttle Challenger Accident

    Presidential Commission / NASA archive · Original report delivered 6 June 1986; technical failure, management and communication findings.

  3. Mars Climate Orbiter Team Finds Likely Cause of Loss

    NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory · 30 September 1999 preliminary findings on a units mismatch and failed information transfer.

  4. PROV-DM: The PROV Data Model

    W3C · 30 April 2013 Recommendation: entities, activities, agents and derivation.