STRATASkip to the research
In Development, original XLVII plate

In Development

A 3 Hz cosine and a 5 Hz cosine produce identical samples when observed eight times per second: cos(2π·5n/8) = cos(2π·3n/8) for integer n. This constructed example demonstrates an ambiguity in the sampled record even though the underlying signals differ.

Nyquist’s 1928 transmission study and Shannon’s 1948 communication theory place bandwidth, noise, and recovery conditions within explicit mathematical models. Sampling rate, timing accuracy, and the assumed signal bandwidth determine which distinctions an observation can support.

Historical record

  1. A communications problem makes observation intervals matter.

    Harry Nyquist studies how a transmission system can carry distinguishable signals within a limited bandwidth. The problem ties the shape of a signal to the conditions under which another instrument can recover it.

  2. A communication model separates a message from its channel.

    Claude Shannon formulates a mathematical treatment of information, noise and coding. A recorded signal can now be assessed through explicit assumptions about what was sent, what the channel changes and what the receiver must distinguish.

  3. The reported number carries its uncertainty with it.

    JCGM 100:2008 preserves the Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement with minor corrections. Its framework asks how the measurement model and its inputs contribute to uncertainty in the reported result.

Two motions can leave the same sampled record.

In a constructed example, sample a cosine wave at eight measurements per second. A 3 Hz cosine and a 5 Hz cosine produce the same sample values: cos(2π·5n/8) equals cos(2π·3n/8) for integer n. The instrument has not lied, but its record cannot distinguish these two candidates without more information. Increasing the sample rate beyond 10 Hz can separate these particular frequencies when the signal is appropriately band-limited; anti-alias filtering and timing accuracy remain part of the measurement.

  • Overlay the two continuous curves and then show only the eight-per-second sample markers. The ambiguity becomes visible at the point where the curves disappear.
  • Repeat with a higher sample rate while keeping the underlying frequencies fixed. Changing the source and the instrument together would obscure the cause of improvement.
  • Flag a reconstruction for review when its bandwidth assumption is unknown. The next useful action is to recover the instrument settings or make a better observation.

Recordings and archives

Research sources

  1. Certain Topics in Telegraph Transmission Theory

    Harry Nyquist / IEEE reprint hosted by Washington University · Original treatment of transmission bandwidth and unambiguous signal interpretation.

  2. A Mathematical Theory of Communication

    Claude E. Shannon / Bell Labs · 1948 communication model, entropy and coding framework.

  3. Evaluation of measurement data—Guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement

    Joint Committee for Guides in Metrology / BIPM · JCGM 100:2008, reporting a result with a model and evaluated uncertainty.