STRATA
Skip to study
XLVII

II.08 / COSMIC

Cosmological inference, selection effects, and identifiability

Which combinations of cosmological parameters can two surveys determine independently?

A source-led introduction1 source references1 related experiments

Start with the question.

Cosmological inference combines a physical model with a model of how observations were selected and measured. Planck's parameter work makes model-dependent estimation explicit. Identifiability is the practical question of whether distinct parameter choices can produce nearly the same observable distribution. Selection effects matter because the objects or regions observed may represent the underlying population unevenly.

Construct a small selection effect.

Imagine a survey that records only sources brighter than a fixed threshold. At larger distances, intrinsically faint sources drop out, so the observed average luminosity rises even if the underlying population has not changed. Plot the full illustrative population and the selected subset with the same axes before interpreting the apparent trend.

What would you inspect?

  • Selection probability as a function of distance, brightness, and measurement quality.
  • Posterior correlations and predictions under alternative prior choices.

Take the next step.

Add an explicit selection model to one inference example and check whether the conclusion changes when its threshold or completeness estimate changes.

Put part of the question to work.

These models isolate a mechanism you can vary. Their assumptions define the part of this topic they can illuminate.

Try evidence and base rates.

Change one parameter, compare the numerical output, and export the result. The experiment loads when you open it.

Open its full page

Watch the quantities change.

12 seconds · Original model visualization · Silent

Evidence and base rates

Follow a screening result back through the population that produced it.

Read the explanation and method

A hypothetical batch contains 10,000 components. Detection is fixed at 99 percent and false flags at 5 percent.

The defect rate rises from 1 percent toward 20 percent. Orange shows actual defects that are flagged; cream shows sound items that are falsely flagged.

The posterior is true flags divided by all flags. Changing the starting population changes this fraction even when both screening rates stay fixed.

Method. Apply each conditional rate to its own population. True flags equal the defective population multiplied by the detection rate; false flags equal the sound population multiplied by the false-flag rate. Divide true flags by all flags to obtain the posterior probability.

Read the supporting material.

  1. Planck 2018 results. VI. Cosmological parameters

    Planck Collaboration · Cosmological parameter inference within named models and datasets; supports parameter and selection discussions.

Continue through the versioned study records.

Follow the comparisons.

Read the neighboring questions.