STRATA
Skip to study
XLVII

I.04 / GNOSIS

Epistemology of science

When did an instrument, a prediction or a second observer change what counted as evidence?

A source-led introduction1 source references0 related experiments

Start with the question.

Scientific knowledge depends on the relation between an observation, the instrument that produced it, and the argument made from it. Galileo's Sidereus nuncius is a useful historical entry because its printed observations and illustrations make that relation visible. Studying scientific epistemology means asking what rival explanations could account for the same record and which further observation would distinguish them.

Reconstruct an observation as an argument.

Choose one sequence of positions or drawings in Galileo's book. Record what was directly seen, what was inferred about motion or surface shape, and what an alternative explanation would predict. Sketch the same observation from two viewing conditions so that the instrument's role is part of the account.

What would you inspect?

  • The separation between a recorded appearance and a conclusion about its cause.
  • Instrument limits, repeat observations, and changes in viewing conditions.

Take the next step.

Write the observation as a claim with premises, then specify one additional measurement that would make its strongest alternative less plausible.

Read the supporting material.

  1. Sidereus nuncius

    Library of Congress · Galileo's 1610 printed observations and illustrations; supports inquiry into instruments, observation, and argument.