{
  "metadata": {
    "title": "XLVII failure atlas: Equations, evidence, limits, and historical transfer",
    "date": "2026-11-19",
    "version": "1.0",
    "entryCount": 340,
    "sourceRecordCount": 146,
    "distinctSourceUrls": 143,
    "equationContractCount": 83,
    "verificationCounts": {
      "proved-counterexample": 56,
      "conditional-risk": 220,
      "executed-check": 34,
      "primary-source-result": 30
    },
    "transferCounts": {
      "same-mathematics": 298,
      "shared-method": 215,
      "analogy": 38
    },
    "countInterpretation": "340 audit entries are not 340 independent mathematical mechanisms; repeated structures are explicitly cross-indexed. Sources are records, with repeated URLs retained when scope or inspection differs.",
    "coverageLimit": "An extensive audit of the supplied equation families and their related scientific methods; not a logically exhaustive enumeration of every possible failure, a universal literature census, or a proof of an open conjecture.",
    "originalReportSha256": "cf17d45d62b2f13d5e0245f77e4f63500280769602c29b16a8228542dcb4886e",
    "originalReportFile": "XLVII_Research_Report_2026-11-19.md",
    "currentClayCategories": {
      "Yang–Mills": "Unsolved",
      "P versus NP": "Unsolved",
      "Navier–Stokes": "Active",
      "Riemann hypothesis": "Unsolved",
      "Hodge conjecture": "Unsolved",
      "Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer": "Unsolved",
      "Poincaré": "Solved"
    },
    "sourcePolicy": "Primary sources control technical claims; generated summaries are discovery aids. Inspection depth is recorded. Original counterexamples and conditional audit deductions are distinguished from source results.",
    "siteStatus": "This companion analysis did not modify or redeploy the existing website."
  },
  "components": [
    {
      "id": "spin",
      "title": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "count": 90
    },
    {
      "id": "millennium",
      "title": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "count": 112
    },
    {
      "id": "history",
      "title": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "count": 72
    },
    {
      "id": "root",
      "title": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "count": 44
    },
    {
      "id": "quantum_history",
      "title": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "count": 22
    }
  ],
  "evidenceLegend": {
    "conditional-risk": "A concrete mechanism to test, not an error alleged to have occurred.",
    "executed-check": "A bounded numerical or exact calculation was executed; inspect its stated scope.",
    "proved-counterexample": "An explicit counterexample or algebraic deduction refutes a specific implication or weakened statement, not an open prize problem.",
    "primary-source-result": "A source establishes or announces a result within its recorded scope; inspection depth varies."
  },
  "relationshipLegend": {
    "same-mathematics": "Same formal mechanism under stated assumptions; physical identity is not implied.",
    "shared-method": "A diagnostic or research method transfers; the governing equations need not be the same.",
    "analogy": "A heuristic comparison that requires independent validation; no theorem or historical influence is inferred."
  },
  "equations": [
    {
      "id": "TFIM",
      "expression": "H_N(J,h)=-J\\sum_{i=1}^{N}Z_iZ_{i+1}-h\\sum_{i=1}^{N}X_i,\\quad Z_{N+1}=Z_1",
      "contract": "Pauli eigenvalues ±1; spin-one-half sites; uniform nearest-neighbor ring; even N=4 through 14 for the original table; J=1; h=0.5,1,1.5."
    },
    {
      "id": "GAP",
      "expression": "\\Delta_N=E_1-E_0,\\qquad E_0\\le E_1\\le\\cdots",
      "contract": "Full finite spectrum ordered with multiplicity. This definition is distinct from a gap above a degenerate ground manifold or a probe-specific threshold."
    },
    {
      "id": "H0",
      "expression": "H_0=-h\\sum_iX_i,\\qquad E_k=-Nh+2hk,\\qquad\\Delta(H_0)=2h",
      "contract": "h>0. For h<0 the gap is 2|h|; h=0 is completely degenerate. The level E_k has multiplicity binomial(N,k)."
    },
    {
      "id": "WEYL",
      "expression": "|E_i(H+V)-E_i(H)|\\le\\|V\\|,\\quad\\Delta(H+V)\\ge\\Delta(H)-2\\|V\\|\\ge 2h-2N|J|",
      "contract": "First inequality: ordered eigenvalues of finite Hermitian matrices of the same dimension. Last inequality: H=H0, V=−JΣZZ, and h>0. A negative lower bound is inconclusive."
    },
    {
      "id": "JW",
      "expression": "\\varepsilon(k)=2\\sqrt{J^2+h^2-2Jh\\cos k},\\qquad m=2|J-h|",
      "contract": "Ideal nearest-neighbor chain, J,h≥0, under a consistent Jordan–Wigner convention. Finite allowed k and physical fermion parity depend on the boundary and spin sector. The dispersion mass is not automatically every many-body or probe gap."
    },
    {
      "id": "SPECTRAL",
      "expression": "S_A(\\omega)=\\sum_{n>0}|\\langle n|A|0\\rangle|^2\\,\\delta\\!\\left(\\omega-\\frac{E_n-E_0}{\\hbar}\\right)",
      "contract": "Zero-temperature inelastic response for a chosen finite-system ground state. Elastic terms, degeneracy, momentum, finite temperature, and experimental broadening require explicit additions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SCALING",
      "title": "Critical finite-ring gap and sector energies",
      "expression": "E_NS=-2 csc(π/(2N)); E_R=-2 cot(π/(2N)); Δ_N=2 tan(π/(4N))~π/(2N)",
      "contract": "Even periodic Pauli-normalized chain, J=h=1; physical parity constraints retained. These are model-specific exact expressions, not a fitted extrapolation.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §5.3"
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
      "expression": "F=dA+A∧A; S[A]=(1/(4g²))∫|F|²",
      "contract": "Classical notation for the target gauge theory; a regulated formal path integral is not already a constructed quantum theory."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
      "expression": "spec(H) ⊆ {0} ∪ [Δ,∞), Δ>0",
      "contract": "Physical reconstructed Hamiltonian above the vacuum; units, Hilbert space, volume and regulator limits must be specified."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION",
      "expression": "|⟨A(x)B(0)⟩c| ≤ C(A,B)e^(−m|x|)",
      "contract": "A proposed correlation bound; conversion to a physical gap needs a suitable observable class and reconstruction assumptions."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-PNP",
      "expression": "P=?NP; ∃M,k,C ∀x: T_M(x)≤C(|x|+1)^k",
      "contract": "One uniform deterministic algorithm and one polynomial bound for every input of the decision language."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-PNP-WITNESS",
      "expression": "x∈L ⇔ ∃w, |w|≤p(|x|), V(x,w)=1",
      "contract": "Polynomial witness bound and polynomial-time verifier; verification alone does not construct witnesses efficiently."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-NS",
      "expression": "∂tu+(u·∇)u−νΔu+∇p=f; ∇·u=0",
      "contract": "Exact domain, data, force regularity, viscosity and solution class are part of the statement."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY",
      "expression": "(1/2)d||u||₂²/dt+ν||∇u||₂²=⟨f,u⟩",
      "contract": "Smooth admissible solutions with justified boundary/decay assumptions; weak solutions may satisfy an inequality instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-NS-SCALING",
      "expression": "uλ(x,t)=λu(λx,λ²t); ||uλ(·,t)||p=λ^(1−3/p)||u(·,λ²t)||p",
      "contract": "Three-dimensional scaling; transform the pressure and forcing consistently."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
      "expression": "ζ(s)=Σn≥1 n^(−s)=∏p(1−p^(−s))^(−1), Re(s)>1",
      "contract": "The displayed series/product domain must not be confused with meromorphic continuation."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-RH-XI",
      "expression": "ξ(s)=(s(s−1)/2)π^(−s/2)Γ(s/2)ζ(s); ξ(s)=ξ(1−s)",
      "contract": "RH concerns nontrivial zeta zeros, equivalently zeros of ξ; reflection symmetry alone is insufficient."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-RH-NEWMAN",
      "expression": "RH ⇔ Λ≤0; proved Λ≥0",
      "contract": "Two inequality directions are different; their conjunction would force Λ=0."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-HODGE",
      "expression": "cl: CH^p(X)⊗Q → H^(2p)(X,Q)∩H^(p,p)(X,C) is surjective",
      "contract": "X smooth projective over C; codimension p cycles and rational coefficients."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
      "expression": "rank E(Q)=ord_(s=1)L(E,s)",
      "contract": "Nonsingular elliptic curve over Q and analytically continued L-function."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL",
      "expression": "a_p=p+1−#E(F_p); L_p(s)=(1−a_pp^(−s)+p^(1−2s))^(−1)",
      "contract": "Displayed degree-two local factor applies at good primes; bad-prime factors differ."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD",
      "expression": "lim_(s→1)L(E,s)/(s−1)^r = Ω_E Reg(E) #Sha(E) ∏c_p / #E(Q)_tors²",
      "contract": "Schematic standard leading-coefficient convention; periods, regulator, models and finiteness hypotheses must be fixed."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-PC",
      "expression": "Closed connected 3-manifold M with π₁(M)=0 ⇒ M≅S³",
      "contract": "Topological Poincaré statement; closed means compact without boundary."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-E-RICCI",
      "expression": "∂tg=−2 Ric(g)",
      "contract": "Geometric evolution supporting the proof; its singularities require geometric analysis and controlled surgery."
    },
    {
      "id": "DIM",
      "title": "Dimensional analysis and nondimensionalization",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "OBS",
      "title": "Observation and measurement equations",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "STAT",
      "title": "Statistical estimators, probability and uncertainty",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "CAUSAL",
      "title": "Structural and potential-outcome causal models",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "INVERSE",
      "title": "Inverse problems and identifiability",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "ODE",
      "title": "Dynamical systems and evolution equations",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "MODEL",
      "title": "General modeling or approximation statements",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "DFT",
      "title": "Exact density-functional variational statement",
      "expression": "E0=min_n {F[n]+∫v(r)n(r)dr}",
      "contract": "Admissible densities and an exact functional for the stated problem. Approximate exchange-correlation functionals and numerical self-consistency introduce separate errors.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 6"
    },
    {
      "id": "QCHEM",
      "title": "Born–Oppenheimer factorization and molecular approximations",
      "expression": "Ψ(r,R)≈ψ_e(r;R)χ(R)",
      "contract": "Approximate electron/nuclear separation; nonadiabatic coupling, crossings, required observables and error regime must be examined.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 6"
    },
    {
      "id": "DATA",
      "title": "Data transformations and computation",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "PROVENANCE",
      "title": "Historical, bibliographic and computational provenance",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "OPT",
      "title": "Optimization objectives and algorithms",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "INFO",
      "title": "Sampling, communication and information",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "GR",
      "title": "General relativity and cosmological inference",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "SYMMETRY",
      "title": "Symmetry statements and their interpretation",
      "expression": "Family of application-specific equations; instantiate the exact model before applying a theorem.",
      "contract": "The mode records specify the observation, estimator, domain, units or causal assumptions that must be checked."
    },
    {
      "id": "CHSH",
      "title": "Local response inequality",
      "expression": "S=E00+E01+E10−E11; |S|≤2",
      "contract": "Local bounded outcomes and a common setting-independent hidden-variable distribution; trial definition, selection and statistical inference must match the claimed experiment.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §§3,5.4"
    },
    {
      "id": "BELLSTATE",
      "title": "Specified Bell state",
      "expression": "|Φ+⟩=(|00⟩+|11⟩)/√2; ⟨ZZ⟩=⟨XX⟩=1; ⟨ZX⟩=⟨XZ⟩=0",
      "contract": "Two qubits, fixed tensor ordering, normalization, state phase and Pauli conventions.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §5.4"
    },
    {
      "id": "CHSHANGLE",
      "title": "Angle-dependent quantum score",
      "expression": "A0=Z; A1=X; B0=cosθ Z+sinθ X; B1=cosθ Z−sinθ X; S=2(cosθ+sinθ)",
      "contract": "The declared pure Bell state and nondegenerate projective observables; angles must use a consistent unit. The maximum is 2√2 at θ=π/4.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §5.4"
    },
    {
      "id": "BELLNOISE",
      "title": "White-noise Bell family",
      "expression": "ρ_v=v|Φ+⟩⟨Φ+|+(1−v)I4/4; S(θ)=2v(cosθ+sinθ)",
      "contract": "Declared mixture has 0≤v≤1. Pauli-projective optimum is 2√2v; including deterministic observables gives max(2,2√2v). Thresholds are not universal noise or entanglement thresholds.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §5.4 and new audit"
    },
    {
      "id": "PPT",
      "title": "Partial-transpose criterion",
      "expression": "spec(ρ_v^T_B)={(1−3v)/4,(1+v)/4,(1+v)/4,(1+v)/4}",
      "contract": "For this family. PPT is necessary for separability generally and sufficient in dimensions 2×2 and 2×3; do not export sufficiency to arbitrary dimension.",
      "origin": "New audit of the Bell family"
    },
    {
      "id": "NOSIGNALLING",
      "title": "Unconditional marginal invariance",
      "expression": "Tr_B[(I⊗𝓔_B)(ρ_AB)]=Tr_B(ρ_AB)",
      "contract": "A local trace-preserving physical map on B with no additional communication or joint interaction. Outcome-conditioned branches are different objects.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §5.4"
    },
    {
      "id": "CHSHSTAT",
      "title": "Finite-trial Bell inference",
      "expression": "p=P_null(T≥T_observed) or a valid conservative null-tail bound",
      "contract": "The null class, sampling, memory assumptions, setting distribution, estimator, selection and stopping rule must be defined. A p-value is not a posterior probability of a theory.",
      "origin": "New audit of the Bell demonstration"
    },
    {
      "id": "POLYNOMIAL",
      "title": "Two reflection countermodels",
      "expression": "P(s)=[(s−1/4)²+1][(s−3/4)²+1]; Q(s)=[(s−1/5)²+1][(s−4/5)²+1]",
      "contract": "Complex variable. Both are invariant under s→1−s and conjugation, with off-axis roots. They refute a symmetry-only implication, not RH. Quarter and fifth variants have different coefficients.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §§5.5,6.3"
    },
    {
      "id": "RESIDUAL",
      "title": "Eigenpair residual",
      "expression": "r=Hv−Ev; ||v||=1",
      "contract": "Residual bounds require the correct operator class. A small residual alone does not establish lowest-level ordering, sector completeness or a rigorous two-sided eigenvalue enclosure.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §5.3 and new audit"
    },
    {
      "id": "FINITEFIT",
      "title": "Finite agreement and nonunique continuation",
      "expression": "g_c(N)=f(N)+c q(N)/(1+q(N)); q(N)=∏_(n∈S)(N−n)²",
      "contract": "Constructed functions agreeing on a finite set. They are not asserted to be alternative solutions of a specified physical Hamiltonian.",
      "origin": "New exact counterexample"
    },
    {
      "id": "NONNORMAL",
      "title": "Transient growth and pseudospectral sensitivity",
      "expression": "A=[[-1,K],[0,-2]]; e^(At)=[[e^(−t),K(e^(−t)−e^(−2t))],[0,e^(−2t)]]",
      "contract": "Dimensionless illustrative matrix. Stable eigenvalues establish asymptotic linear behavior, not a unit finite-time norm bound. A separate nilpotent matrix illustrates residual sensitivity.",
      "origin": "New exact counterexamples"
    },
    {
      "id": "SYMBOLIC",
      "title": "Domain-sensitive symbolic identities",
      "expression": "x/x=1 (x≠0); sqrt(x²)=|x| (real x)",
      "contract": "Track branches, excluded denominators and implication direction; substitute candidate roots into the original equation.",
      "origin": "New audit"
    },
    {
      "id": "VALIDATION",
      "title": "Validation and formalization contract",
      "expression": "∀x∈D: property(x), with D, evidence and proof dependencies explicit",
      "contract": "Empty domains, a different formal statement, unchecked axioms and generated-summary changes can undermine an intended inference without making the formal expression false.",
      "origin": "New audit"
    },
    {
      "id": "VORTICITY",
      "title": "Three-dimensional vorticity evolution",
      "expression": "∂tω+(u·∇)ω=(ω·∇)u+νΔω+curl f",
      "contract": "ω=curl u, incompressible velocity and justified differentiability. Three-dimensional stretching cannot simply be discarded using a two-dimensional argument.",
      "origin": "Audit of the Navier–Stokes equation"
    },
    {
      "id": "WEAKLIMIT",
      "title": "Weak limits and nonlinear products",
      "expression": "sin(nx) ⇀ 0; sin²(nx) ⇀ 1/2 on [0,2π]",
      "contract": "Weak L2 convergence against appropriate test functions. The example demonstrates a failed product interchange, not a solution of a target nonlinear PDE.",
      "origin": "New counterexample"
    },
    {
      "id": "NSNUMERIC",
      "title": "Discretized fluid evolution",
      "expression": "R_h=∂t u_h+(u_h·∇)u_h−νΔu_h+∇p_h−f",
      "contract": "A residual must be interpreted in a specified norm with discretization, boundary and divergence errors. Finite numerical evidence is not a continuum singularity or regularity proof.",
      "origin": "Future-simulation audit; no fluid solver was run here"
    },
    {
      "id": "PLANCK",
      "title": "Equilibrium spectral energy density",
      "expression": "u_ν=8πhν³/[c³(exp(hν/(k_B T))−1)]",
      "contract": "Equilibrium blackbody energy per volume per frequency. Radiance, wavelength density, emissivity and instrument response require appropriate transformations or models.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 1"
    },
    {
      "id": "PHOTOELECTRIC",
      "title": "One-photon stopping-energy relation",
      "expression": "eV_s=hν−Φ",
      "contract": "Specified material, work function, one-photon regime and corrected apparatus potential; maximum emitted kinetic energy is not every detector voltage.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 1"
    },
    {
      "id": "COMPTON",
      "title": "Free stationary-electron wavelength shift",
      "expression": "Δλ=h(1−cosθ)/(m_e c)",
      "contract": "The specified free-electron single-scattering kinematics; binding, initial motion, multiple scattering and cross sections are additional questions.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 1"
    },
    {
      "id": "CCR",
      "title": "Canonical commutation relation",
      "expression": "[X,P]=iℏ I",
      "contract": "An infinite-dimensional operator statement with domains; finite matrices cannot satisfy it on their whole space because the commutator trace vanishes.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 2"
    },
    {
      "id": "BASIS",
      "title": "Matrix representation of an operator",
      "expression": "A_nm=⟨ψ_n|A|ψ_m⟩",
      "contract": "A consistent basis, inner product and operator domain. Exact unitary equivalence is distinct from independently truncated approximations.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 2"
    },
    {
      "id": "UNCERTAINTY",
      "title": "Robertson preparation-variance inequality",
      "expression": "σ_A σ_B≥|⟨[A,B]⟩|/2",
      "contract": "Self-adjoint observables and a state in the appropriate domains with finite moments. It is not automatically an apparatus error-disturbance relation.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 2"
    },
    {
      "id": "BORN",
      "title": "Quantum probabilities",
      "expression": "p(a)=Tr(ρ M_a); M_a≥0; ∑_a M_a=I",
      "contract": "Normalized density state and a specified POVM. For continuous outcomes retain the correct measure and density interpretation.",
      "origin": "Audit of the historical quantum model"
    },
    {
      "id": "SCHRODINGER",
      "title": "Closed-system unitary evolution",
      "expression": "iℏ ∂t|Ψ⟩=H|Ψ⟩",
      "contract": "Specified self-adjoint Hamiltonian, domains, boundary conditions and closed-system approximation. A reduced subsystem need not evolve by the same pure-state equation.",
      "origin": "Earlier report cases 2 and 5"
    },
    {
      "id": "DIRAC",
      "title": "Free relativistic spinor equation",
      "expression": "(iℏ γ^μ ∂_μ−mc)ψ=0",
      "contract": "Consistent coordinate, gamma-matrix, signature and unit conventions. Free spinor dynamics is not a construction of interacting QED or a complete material model.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 3"
    },
    {
      "id": "REDUCED",
      "title": "Reduced state by partial trace",
      "expression": "ρ_S=Tr_E |Ψ_SE⟩⟨Ψ_SE|",
      "contract": "Specified system/environment partition. The marginal does not uniquely identify the global state or a measurement interpretation.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 5"
    },
    {
      "id": "DECOHERENCE",
      "title": "Suppression of reduced coherences",
      "expression": "ρ_ij(t) depends on environmental overlaps and the chosen basis",
      "contract": "A specified interaction model and basis are required; suppression of selected off-diagonal terms does not by itself select a unique global outcome.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 5"
    },
    {
      "id": "LINDBLAD",
      "title": "Completely positive Markovian generator",
      "expression": "dρ/dt=−i[H,ρ]/ℏ+∑_j(L_jρL_j†−{L_j†L_j,ρ}/2)",
      "contract": "Stated generator/semigroup assumptions and domains. An arbitrary open-system evolution need not be time-homogeneous Markovian; positivity and complete positivity are different requirements.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 5"
    },
    {
      "id": "HF",
      "title": "Single-determinant variational approximation",
      "expression": "E_HF=min_(normalized determinants Φ) ⟨Φ|H|Φ⟩",
      "contract": "Same Hamiltonian and well-defined admissible class; restricted ansatz, basis and local solver convergence are different limitations.",
      "origin": "Historical quantum supplement"
    },
    {
      "id": "VARIATIONAL",
      "title": "Energy and ground-space probability bounds",
      "expression": "E=Tr(ρH)≥E0; 1−Tr(P0ρ)≤(E−E0)/Δ",
      "contract": "Normalized state; second inequality requires a known positive gap above the ground space. Finite-shot estimates and approximate Hamiltonians are separate objects.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 6 and new audit"
    },
    {
      "id": "VQE",
      "title": "Hybrid variational objective",
      "expression": "E(θ)=⟨ψ(θ)|H|ψ(θ)⟩",
      "contract": "Exact normalized expectation for a fixed Hamiltonian; ansatz expressivity, trainability, estimator noise, optimizer behavior and total resources need separate evidence.",
      "origin": "Earlier report cases 6 and 9"
    },
    {
      "id": "BARREN",
      "title": "Gradient concentration in specified circuit ensembles",
      "expression": "Var(∂_θ E) can shrink exponentially under stated ensemble and cost assumptions",
      "contract": "A scoped result about particular architectures/ensembles, not every possible ansatz or cost function.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 9"
    },
    {
      "id": "GROVER",
      "title": "Unstructured quantum query count",
      "expression": "Q(N)=O(√N); N=2^n gives O(2^(n/2))",
      "contract": "A specified oracle access model. Oracle construction, input preparation, faults and readout are not free end-to-end resources.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 8"
    },
    {
      "id": "QCOMPUTE",
      "title": "Computational resource accounting",
      "expression": "T_total=T_preparation+T_oracle/circuit+T_correction+T_readout",
      "contract": "Schematic accounting rather than a universal numerical formula; define input length, access, accuracy, success probability and computational model.",
      "origin": "Earlier report cases 8 and 9"
    },
    {
      "id": "QEC",
      "title": "Logical-error suppression and threshold hypotheses",
      "expression": "p_L(d,noise,circuit,decoder)",
      "contract": "No universal formula is asserted. The noise model, correlations, leakage, logical operations, code distance and decoder determine the relevant claim.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 9"
    },
    {
      "id": "SHANNON",
      "title": "Information entropy",
      "expression": "H(X)=−∑_x p(x)log_2 p(x)",
      "contract": "A defined probability distribution and coding/communication task; entropy is not automatically semantic value or dissipated energy.",
      "origin": "Earlier report information lineage"
    },
    {
      "id": "LANDAUER",
      "title": "Specified ideal erasure scale",
      "expression": "Q_min=k_B T ln2 for erasing an unbiased bit in the stated ideal thermal setup",
      "contract": "Information distribution, correlations, physical memory, bath and reversibility assumptions matter. This is not a universal per-gate cost or a complete generalized quantum erasure law.",
      "origin": "Earlier report information lineage and new audit"
    },
    {
      "id": "REVERSIBLE",
      "title": "Reversible logical embedding",
      "expression": "(x,0)↦(x,f(x))",
      "contract": "Keep input and auxiliary records or uncompute them consistently; logical reversibility alone does not guarantee zero physical dissipation.",
      "origin": "Earlier report case 8"
    },
    {
      "id": "CLONING",
      "title": "Universal exact cloning obstruction",
      "expression": "c=c²⟨e_ψ|e_φ⟩ implies |c|≤|c|²",
      "contract": "Inner-product preservation of a deterministic universal exact cloner, with a fixed initial ancilla and final ancillary records included; impossible for nonorthogonal distinct pure states 0<|c|<1.",
      "origin": "Earlier report no-cloning lineage and new derivation"
    },
    {
      "id": "TELEPORT",
      "title": "State-transfer resource contract",
      "expression": "Shared entanglement + classical outcome + conditional correction",
      "contract": "Specified protocol; no independent second copy or controllable message without the classical outcome is implied.",
      "origin": "Earlier report teleportation lineage"
    },
    {
      "id": "AUX-SAT",
      "title": "An easy SAT family defeats a brute-force lower-bound claim",
      "expression": "F_n=x1∧⋯∧xn",
      "contract": "One enumeration visits 2^n assignments if all-true is last; reading the unit clauses solves this family in linear work. This does not classify unrestricted SAT.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §6.2"
    },
    {
      "id": "AUX-RATIONAL",
      "title": "Integral and rational span differ",
      "expression": "1∉2Z, but 1=(1/2)·2 in the rational span",
      "contract": "An elementary coefficient-ring example, not a geometric counterexample to the rational Hodge conjecture.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §6.5"
    },
    {
      "id": "AUX-EC",
      "title": "Finite-field point counts",
      "expression": "E:y²=x³−x; #E(F_p)=p+1+∑_x χ(x³−x)",
      "contract": "Good odd primes for this nonsingular reduction, quadratic character with χ(0)=0, point at infinity included. Finite counts do not certify rational rank or L-order.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §6.6"
    },
    {
      "id": "AUX-SPHERE",
      "title": "An already-round three-sphere under Ricci flow",
      "expression": "d(r²)/dt=−4; r²(t)=r0²−4t",
      "contract": "Unnormalized flow on a round S³; the calculation assumes sphere topology and does not classify arbitrary manifolds.",
      "origin": "Earlier report §6.7"
    }
  ],
  "equationIndex": {
    "TFIM": [
      "SPIN-001",
      "SPIN-002",
      "SPIN-003",
      "SPIN-004",
      "SPIN-005",
      "SPIN-006",
      "SPIN-007",
      "SPIN-008",
      "SPIN-009",
      "SPIN-010",
      "SPIN-011",
      "SPIN-012",
      "SPIN-013",
      "SPIN-017",
      "SPIN-022",
      "SPIN-029",
      "SPIN-034",
      "SPIN-050",
      "SPIN-051",
      "SPIN-052",
      "SPIN-054",
      "SPIN-061",
      "SPIN-062",
      "SPIN-063",
      "SPIN-064",
      "SPIN-068",
      "SPIN-072",
      "SPIN-086",
      "SPIN-088",
      "SPIN-090",
      "CROSS-003"
    ],
    "GAP": [
      "SPIN-002",
      "SPIN-006",
      "SPIN-008",
      "SPIN-010",
      "SPIN-014",
      "SPIN-015",
      "SPIN-016",
      "SPIN-018",
      "SPIN-019",
      "SPIN-020",
      "SPIN-021",
      "SPIN-022",
      "SPIN-024",
      "SPIN-026",
      "SPIN-027",
      "SPIN-028",
      "SPIN-030",
      "SPIN-034",
      "SPIN-035",
      "SPIN-036",
      "SPIN-040",
      "SPIN-041",
      "SPIN-042",
      "SPIN-043",
      "SPIN-044",
      "SPIN-045",
      "SPIN-046",
      "SPIN-047",
      "SPIN-048",
      "SPIN-049",
      "SPIN-050",
      "SPIN-051",
      "SPIN-053",
      "SPIN-055",
      "SPIN-056",
      "SPIN-057",
      "SPIN-058",
      "SPIN-059",
      "SPIN-062",
      "SPIN-063",
      "SPIN-064",
      "SPIN-065",
      "SPIN-066",
      "SPIN-067",
      "SPIN-070",
      "SPIN-073",
      "SPIN-074",
      "SPIN-075",
      "SPIN-076",
      "SPIN-077",
      "SPIN-078",
      "SPIN-079",
      "SPIN-080",
      "SPIN-081",
      "SPIN-082",
      "SPIN-083",
      "SPIN-084",
      "SPIN-085",
      "SPIN-087",
      "SPIN-088",
      "SPIN-089",
      "CROSS-003",
      "CROSS-004",
      "CROSS-005",
      "CROSS-036",
      "CROSS-041",
      "CROSS-043",
      "CROSS-045",
      "CROSS-046",
      "CROSS-047",
      "CROSS-058",
      "CROSS-063",
      "FORM-005"
    ],
    "H0": [
      "SPIN-001",
      "SPIN-060",
      "SPIN-085"
    ],
    "WEYL": [
      "SPIN-009",
      "SPIN-032",
      "SPIN-034",
      "SPIN-054",
      "SPIN-059",
      "SPIN-060",
      "SPIN-061",
      "FORM-008"
    ],
    "JW": [
      "SPIN-004",
      "SPIN-005",
      "SPIN-006",
      "SPIN-015",
      "SPIN-016",
      "SPIN-017",
      "SPIN-018",
      "SPIN-020",
      "SPIN-021",
      "SPIN-025",
      "SPIN-026",
      "SPIN-039",
      "SPIN-045"
    ],
    "SPECTRAL": [
      "SPIN-010",
      "SPIN-012",
      "SPIN-013",
      "SPIN-015",
      "SPIN-019",
      "SPIN-020",
      "SPIN-023",
      "SPIN-025",
      "SPIN-031",
      "SPIN-033",
      "SPIN-040",
      "SPIN-041",
      "SPIN-042",
      "SPIN-048",
      "SPIN-056",
      "SPIN-066",
      "SPIN-069",
      "SPIN-070",
      "SPIN-071",
      "SPIN-073",
      "SPIN-074",
      "SPIN-076",
      "SPIN-077",
      "SPIN-078",
      "SPIN-079",
      "SPIN-080",
      "SPIN-081",
      "SPIN-082",
      "SPIN-089",
      "SPIN-090"
    ],
    "SCALING": [
      "SPIN-011",
      "SPIN-023",
      "SPIN-024",
      "SPIN-026",
      "SPIN-027",
      "SPIN-028",
      "SPIN-029",
      "SPIN-030",
      "SPIN-031",
      "SPIN-032",
      "SPIN-033",
      "SPIN-035",
      "SPIN-036",
      "SPIN-037",
      "SPIN-038",
      "SPIN-039",
      "SPIN-040",
      "SPIN-055",
      "SPIN-060",
      "SPIN-063",
      "SPIN-064",
      "SPIN-065",
      "SPIN-068",
      "SPIN-069",
      "SPIN-071",
      "SPIN-075",
      "SPIN-083",
      "SPIN-084",
      "SPIN-085",
      "SPIN-086",
      "SPIN-087",
      "SPIN-090",
      "FORM-004"
    ],
    "MIL-E-YM-ACTION": [
      "YM-001",
      "YM-004",
      "YM-006",
      "YM-008",
      "YM-009",
      "YM-010",
      "YM-014"
    ],
    "MIL-E-YM-GAP": [
      "YM-001",
      "YM-002",
      "YM-003",
      "YM-004",
      "YM-005",
      "YM-006",
      "YM-007",
      "YM-008",
      "YM-010",
      "YM-011",
      "YM-012",
      "YM-013",
      "YM-014",
      "YM-015",
      "YM-016"
    ],
    "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION": [
      "YM-005",
      "YM-011",
      "YM-012",
      "YM-013",
      "YM-015"
    ],
    "MIL-E-PNP": [
      "PNP-001",
      "PNP-002",
      "PNP-003",
      "PNP-004",
      "PNP-006",
      "PNP-007",
      "PNP-008",
      "PNP-009",
      "PNP-010",
      "PNP-011",
      "PNP-012",
      "PNP-013",
      "PNP-014",
      "PNP-015",
      "PNP-016"
    ],
    "MIL-E-PNP-WITNESS": [
      "PNP-003",
      "PNP-005"
    ],
    "MIL-E-NS": [
      "NS-001",
      "NS-002",
      "NS-003",
      "NS-005",
      "NS-007",
      "NS-008",
      "NS-009",
      "NS-010",
      "NS-011",
      "NS-013",
      "NS-014",
      "NS-015",
      "NS-016",
      "CROSS-002",
      "CROSS-032",
      "CROSS-036",
      "CROSS-039",
      "CROSS-048",
      "FLUID-001",
      "FLUID-004",
      "FLUID-007",
      "FLUID-008",
      "FLUID-009"
    ],
    "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY": [
      "NS-003",
      "NS-004",
      "NS-005",
      "NS-010",
      "NS-012",
      "NS-014",
      "FLUID-005",
      "FLUID-006",
      "FLUID-007"
    ],
    "MIL-E-NS-SCALING": [
      "NS-004",
      "NS-006",
      "FLUID-001",
      "FLUID-002",
      "FLUID-003",
      "FLUID-004",
      "FLUID-005"
    ],
    "MIL-E-RH-ZETA": [
      "RH-001",
      "RH-002",
      "RH-004",
      "RH-005",
      "RH-006",
      "RH-007",
      "RH-013",
      "RH-014",
      "RH-015",
      "FORM-001"
    ],
    "MIL-E-RH-XI": [
      "RH-003",
      "RH-004",
      "RH-005",
      "RH-007",
      "RH-008",
      "RH-009",
      "RH-010",
      "RH-011",
      "RH-012",
      "RH-013",
      "RH-014",
      "RH-015"
    ],
    "MIL-E-RH-NEWMAN": [
      "RH-016"
    ],
    "MIL-E-HODGE": [
      "HOD-001",
      "HOD-002",
      "HOD-003",
      "HOD-004",
      "HOD-005",
      "HOD-006",
      "HOD-007",
      "HOD-008",
      "HOD-009",
      "HOD-010",
      "HOD-011",
      "HOD-012",
      "HOD-013",
      "HOD-014",
      "HOD-015",
      "HOD-016"
    ],
    "MIL-E-BSD-RANK": [
      "BSD-001",
      "BSD-002",
      "BSD-004",
      "BSD-005",
      "BSD-006",
      "BSD-007",
      "BSD-008",
      "BSD-009",
      "BSD-011",
      "BSD-012",
      "BSD-013",
      "BSD-014",
      "BSD-015",
      "BSD-016"
    ],
    "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL": [
      "BSD-001",
      "BSD-002",
      "BSD-003",
      "BSD-004"
    ],
    "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD": [
      "BSD-005",
      "BSD-006",
      "BSD-007",
      "BSD-008",
      "BSD-009",
      "BSD-010",
      "BSD-011",
      "BSD-012",
      "BSD-013",
      "BSD-014",
      "BSD-015",
      "BSD-016"
    ],
    "MIL-E-PC": [
      "PC-001",
      "PC-002",
      "PC-003",
      "PC-004",
      "PC-005",
      "PC-006",
      "PC-007",
      "PC-008",
      "PC-009",
      "PC-011",
      "PC-013",
      "PC-015",
      "PC-016"
    ],
    "MIL-E-RICCI": [
      "PC-007",
      "PC-008",
      "PC-009",
      "PC-010",
      "PC-011",
      "PC-012",
      "PC-013",
      "PC-014",
      "PC-015",
      "PC-016"
    ],
    "DIM": [
      "CROSS-001",
      "CROSS-002",
      "CROSS-003",
      "CROSS-031",
      "CROSS-048"
    ],
    "OBS": [
      "CROSS-001",
      "CROSS-004",
      "CROSS-005",
      "CROSS-006",
      "CROSS-007",
      "CROSS-008",
      "CROSS-009",
      "CROSS-010",
      "CROSS-017",
      "CROSS-025",
      "CROSS-026",
      "CROSS-029",
      "CROSS-034",
      "CROSS-035",
      "CROSS-037",
      "CROSS-047",
      "CROSS-051",
      "CROSS-053",
      "CROSS-054",
      "CROSS-060",
      "CROSS-063",
      "CROSS-064"
    ],
    "STAT": [
      "CROSS-005",
      "CROSS-010",
      "CROSS-011",
      "CROSS-012",
      "CROSS-013",
      "CROSS-014",
      "CROSS-015",
      "CROSS-016",
      "CROSS-017",
      "CROSS-018",
      "CROSS-019",
      "CROSS-020",
      "CROSS-021",
      "CROSS-022",
      "CROSS-023",
      "CROSS-024",
      "CROSS-026",
      "CROSS-027",
      "CROSS-028",
      "CROSS-030",
      "CROSS-035",
      "CROSS-037",
      "CROSS-038",
      "CROSS-039",
      "CROSS-040",
      "CROSS-046",
      "CROSS-049",
      "CROSS-050",
      "CROSS-051",
      "CROSS-056",
      "CROSS-060",
      "CROSS-061",
      "CROSS-063",
      "CROSS-064",
      "CROSS-071"
    ],
    "CAUSAL": [
      "CROSS-011",
      "CROSS-015",
      "CROSS-020",
      "CROSS-021",
      "CROSS-022",
      "CROSS-023",
      "CROSS-024",
      "CROSS-049",
      "CROSS-064",
      "CROSS-065",
      "FORM-010"
    ],
    "INVERSE": [
      "CROSS-007",
      "CROSS-020",
      "CROSS-023",
      "CROSS-025",
      "CROSS-026",
      "CROSS-027",
      "CROSS-028",
      "CROSS-029",
      "CROSS-030",
      "CROSS-049",
      "CROSS-052"
    ],
    "ODE": [
      "CROSS-032",
      "CROSS-033",
      "CROSS-034",
      "CROSS-035",
      "CROSS-036",
      "CROSS-039",
      "CROSS-040",
      "CROSS-041",
      "CROSS-042",
      "CROSS-045",
      "CROSS-046",
      "CROSS-047",
      "CROSS-054",
      "CROSS-065"
    ],
    "MODEL": [
      "CROSS-002",
      "CROSS-003",
      "CROSS-007",
      "CROSS-009",
      "CROSS-016",
      "CROSS-018",
      "CROSS-022",
      "CROSS-024",
      "CROSS-025",
      "CROSS-027",
      "CROSS-028",
      "CROSS-029",
      "CROSS-030",
      "CROSS-031",
      "CROSS-032",
      "CROSS-033",
      "CROSS-034",
      "CROSS-037",
      "CROSS-038",
      "CROSS-041",
      "CROSS-042",
      "CROSS-043",
      "CROSS-048",
      "CROSS-050",
      "CROSS-052",
      "CROSS-053",
      "CROSS-054",
      "CROSS-055",
      "CROSS-056",
      "CROSS-057",
      "CROSS-059",
      "CROSS-061",
      "CROSS-062",
      "CROSS-065",
      "CROSS-066",
      "CROSS-067",
      "CROSS-068",
      "CROSS-069",
      "CROSS-072"
    ],
    "DFT": [
      "CROSS-044"
    ],
    "QCHEM": [
      "CROSS-031",
      "CROSS-038",
      "CROSS-043",
      "CROSS-044",
      "CROSS-045"
    ],
    "DATA": [
      "CROSS-001",
      "CROSS-004",
      "CROSS-006",
      "CROSS-008",
      "CROSS-010",
      "CROSS-012",
      "CROSS-013",
      "CROSS-014",
      "CROSS-018",
      "CROSS-019",
      "CROSS-055",
      "CROSS-057",
      "CROSS-058",
      "CROSS-059",
      "CROSS-060",
      "CROSS-061",
      "CROSS-062",
      "CROSS-063",
      "CROSS-070",
      "CROSS-071"
    ],
    "PROVENANCE": [
      "CROSS-019",
      "CROSS-059",
      "CROSS-062",
      "CROSS-066",
      "CROSS-067",
      "CROSS-068",
      "CROSS-069",
      "CROSS-070",
      "CROSS-071",
      "CROSS-072"
    ],
    "OPT": [
      "CROSS-044",
      "CROSS-055",
      "CROSS-056",
      "CROSS-057",
      "CROSS-058"
    ],
    "INFO": [
      "CROSS-008",
      "CROSS-009",
      "CROSS-040",
      "CROSS-042"
    ],
    "GR": [
      "CROSS-051",
      "CROSS-052",
      "CROSS-053"
    ],
    "SYMMETRY": [
      "CROSS-068"
    ],
    "CHSH": [
      "BELL-001",
      "BELL-002",
      "BELL-009",
      "BELL-011",
      "BELL-012",
      "BELL-013",
      "BELL-014",
      "BELL-015",
      "BELL-022",
      "BELL-023",
      "BELL-024"
    ],
    "BELLSTATE": [
      "BELL-002",
      "BELL-022",
      "BELL-023"
    ],
    "CHSHANGLE": [
      "BELL-003",
      "BELL-004",
      "BELL-006",
      "BELL-019"
    ],
    "BELLNOISE": [
      "BELL-005",
      "BELL-006",
      "BELL-007",
      "BELL-021"
    ],
    "PPT": [
      "BELL-005",
      "BELL-007",
      "BELL-008",
      "QH-012"
    ],
    "NOSIGNALLING": [
      "BELL-009",
      "BELL-010",
      "QH-022"
    ],
    "CHSHSTAT": [
      "BELL-016",
      "BELL-017",
      "BELL-018",
      "BELL-019",
      "BELL-020",
      "BELL-021"
    ],
    "POLYNOMIAL": [
      "FORM-001",
      "FORM-002"
    ],
    "RESIDUAL": [
      "FORM-005",
      "FORM-006"
    ],
    "FINITEFIT": [
      "FORM-004",
      "QH-018"
    ],
    "NONNORMAL": [
      "FORM-006",
      "FORM-007"
    ],
    "SYMBOLIC": [
      "FORM-003"
    ],
    "VALIDATION": [
      "FORM-002",
      "FORM-009",
      "FORM-010"
    ],
    "VORTICITY": [
      "FLUID-009"
    ],
    "WEAKLIMIT": [
      "FLUID-008"
    ],
    "NSNUMERIC": [
      "FLUID-010"
    ],
    "PLANCK": [
      "QH-001",
      "QH-002"
    ],
    "PHOTOELECTRIC": [
      "QH-003"
    ],
    "COMPTON": [
      "QH-004"
    ],
    "CCR": [
      "QH-005"
    ],
    "BASIS": [
      "QH-005",
      "QH-006"
    ],
    "UNCERTAINTY": [
      "QH-007"
    ],
    "BORN": [
      "QH-008"
    ],
    "SCHRODINGER": [
      "QH-006",
      "QH-008"
    ],
    "DIRAC": [
      "QH-009"
    ],
    "REDUCED": [
      "QH-010"
    ],
    "DECOHERENCE": [
      "QH-010"
    ],
    "LINDBLAD": [
      "QH-011",
      "QH-012"
    ],
    "HF": [
      "QH-014"
    ],
    "VARIATIONAL": [
      "FORM-008",
      "QH-013"
    ],
    "VQE": [
      "QH-013",
      "QH-016"
    ],
    "BARREN": [
      "QH-016"
    ],
    "GROVER": [
      "QH-015"
    ],
    "QCOMPUTE": [
      "QH-015"
    ],
    "QEC": [
      "QH-017",
      "QH-018",
      "QH-021"
    ],
    "SHANNON": [
      "QH-019"
    ],
    "LANDAUER": [
      "QH-019"
    ],
    "REVERSIBLE": [
      "QH-020"
    ],
    "CLONING": [
      "QH-021"
    ],
    "TELEPORT": [
      "QH-022"
    ],
    "AUX-SAT": [
      "PNP-002"
    ],
    "AUX-RATIONAL": [
      "HOD-001"
    ],
    "AUX-EC": [
      "BSD-002"
    ],
    "AUX-SPHERE": [
      "PC-009",
      "PC-014"
    ]
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "SP-S01",
      "title": "Pfeuty, The one-dimensional Ising model with a transverse field",
      "year": 1970,
      "url": "https://www.math.ucdavis.edu/~bxn/pfeuty1970.pdf",
      "scope": "Primary exact solution of the ideal one-dimensional transverse-field model; conventions must be translated before using formulas.",
      "inspection": "Opened institution-hosted primary PDF; inspected model and excitation context. This catalogue does not claim a complete line-by-line proof audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S02",
      "title": "Lieb, Schultz, and Mattis, Two soluble models of an antiferromagnetic chain",
      "year": 1961,
      "url": "https://www.math.ucdavis.edu/~bxn/lieb1961.pdf",
      "scope": "Primary soluble-chain analysis, fermion transformations, variational limitations, and a hypothesis-dependent ground-state obstruction.",
      "inspection": "Opened primary PDF; inspected introduction and relevant scope. Do not transfer the paper’s obstruction to arbitrary spin-one-half models."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S03",
      "title": "Damski and Rams, Exact results for fidelity susceptibility of the quantum Ising model: the interplay between parity, system size, and magnetic field",
      "year": 2013,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1308.5917",
      "scope": "Parity-sector, system-size, and field dependence; preprint in 2013, journal volume 47 article 025303 in 2014.",
      "inspection": "Primary arXiv abstract and publisher metadata inspected. SciSpace extraction was abstract-limited; no page or equation numbers are claimed from unseen full text."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S04",
      "title": "Oshikawa, Universal finite-size gap scaling of the quantum Ising chain",
      "year": 2019,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1910.06353",
      "scope": "Finite-size gap scaling with boundary and defect choices; cautions against deriving the physical full gap from a mass-sign symmetry alone.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected; SciSpace abstract extraction cross-checked. Detailed paper formulas beyond the retrieved material were not independently audited."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S05",
      "title": "SciPy documentation: scipy.sparse.linalg.eigsh",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "https://docs.scipy.org/doc/scipy/reference/generated/scipy.sparse.linalg.eigsh.html",
      "scope": "Official API contract for sparse Hermitian eigenproblem targeting, convergence parameters, and return behavior.",
      "inspection": "Official documentation opened and relevant parameter/return sections read on 2026-11-19. Runtime versions for executed checks are recorded separately."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S07",
      "title": "Hastings and Koma, Spectral gap and exponential decay of correlations",
      "year": 2005,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/math-ph/0507008",
      "scope": "Theorems linking spectral assumptions and connected correlations under specified interaction hypotheses; 2005 preprint, 2006 journal publication.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract and revision history inspected. Used for theorem scope and direction, not an unrestricted converse or an invented quantitative constant."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S08",
      "title": "Hastings, An area law for one-dimensional quantum systems",
      "year": 2007,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/0705.2024",
      "scope": "A one-dimensional gapped-ground-state entanglement result; not a guarantee of efficient arbitrary real-time evolution.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected; no full proof or algorithmic complexity bound independently reconstructed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S09",
      "title": "White, Density matrix formulation for quantum renormalization groups",
      "year": 1992,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.69.2863",
      "scope": "Historical primary introduction of density-matrix renormalization; not a blanket error certificate for every DMRG calculation.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher search record and bibliographic details checked; full proof not audited."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S10",
      "title": "Tagliacozzo et al., Scaling of entanglement support for matrix product states",
      "year": 2007,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/0712.1976",
      "scope": "Finite-entanglement limitations and effective length scales in matrix-product approximations; 2007 preprint, 2008 journal publication.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected. The catalogue uses the finite-χ mechanism, not an unqualified exact numerical exponent."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S11",
      "title": "Troyer and Wiese, Computational complexity and fundamental limitations to fermionic quantum Monte Carlo simulations",
      "year": 2004,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0408370",
      "scope": "Generic sign-problem complexity obstruction; does not establish hardness or a sign problem for every instance.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected; no claim that the stoquastic ferromagnetic Ising example belongs to the difficult class."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S12",
      "title": "Suzuki, Relationship between d-dimensional quantal spin systems and (d+1)-dimensional Ising systems: equivalence, critical exponents and systematic approximants of the partition function and spin correlations",
      "year": 1976,
      "url": "https://academic.oup.com/ptp/article/56/5/1454/1860476",
      "scope": "Quantum–classical partition-function relationships and systematic approximants; not an identification of unitary real time with classical real time.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher search result read. Opening the publisher page was blocked by a redirect; no full-text equation or proof audit is claimed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S13",
      "title": "Fisher, Critical behavior of random transverse-field Ising spin chains",
      "year": 1995,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/prb/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevB.51.6411",
      "scope": "Disordered transverse-field chains; a separate ensemble from the clean ideal table.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher record and abstract scope inspected. No unverified rare-region exponent is quoted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S14",
      "title": "Lindblad, On the generators of quantum dynamical semigroups",
      "year": 1976,
      "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01608499",
      "scope": "Completely positive dynamical semigroups and generator structure under the paper’s hypotheses.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract inspected; no claim that every environment satisfies the Markovian assumptions."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S15",
      "title": "Kitaev, Unpaired Majorana fermions in quantum wires",
      "year": 2000,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/0010440",
      "scope": "A bulk gap with boundary-associated near-degeneracy in a specific fermionic wire model; not universal fault-tolerance certification.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected; used only for bulk-versus-boundary spectral distinction and historical mapping."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S16",
      "title": "Davis and Kahan, The rotation of eigenvectors by a perturbation. III",
      "year": 1970,
      "url": "https://epubs.siam.org/doi/abs/10.1137/0707001",
      "scope": "Primary perturbation analysis of spectral subspaces and eigenvector rotation.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher record opened and bibliographic identity checked; no theorem constant quoted from an unread proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S17",
      "title": "Cubitt, Pérez-García, and Wolf, Undecidability of the spectral gap",
      "year": 2015,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.04573",
      "scope": "Undecidability for a constructed family of translationally invariant nearest-neighbor two-dimensional lattice Hamiltonians with the specified promises.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected. The theorem is not applied to the exact Ising chain or to the logical status of Yang–Mills."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S18",
      "title": "Bausch et al., Size-driven quantum phase transitions",
      "year": 2015,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1512.05687",
      "scope": "Constructed Hamiltonians whose ground-state properties change beyond size thresholds; the abstract explicitly allows a constant spectral gap. Published in PNAS in 2018.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected and compared with SciSpace extraction. This is not cited as a theorem that the gap itself must secretly close."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S19",
      "title": "Coldea et al., Quantum criticality in an Ising chain: experimental evidence for emergent E8 symmetry",
      "year": 2010,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1103.3694",
      "scope": "Experimental quasi-one-dimensional material and excitation spectra; Science 327,177 (2010), deposited on arXiv in 2011.",
      "inspection": "Primary arXiv abstract and Oxford institutional record checked. A candidate URL 1001.0991 was rejected because it names an unrelated probability paper."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S20",
      "title": "Lieb and Robinson, The finite group velocity of quantum spin systems",
      "year": 1972,
      "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01645779",
      "scope": "Finite-range spin interactions and bounds on propagation of local-observable commutators.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract inspected; no arbitrary long-range extension is claimed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S21",
      "title": "Yang and Lee, Statistical theory of equations of state and phase transitions. I. Theory of condensation",
      "year": 1952,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.87.404",
      "scope": "Historical primary study of thermodynamic phase transitions and complex-variable structure.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract and publication date inspected. The finite-matrix analyticity argument in this catalogue is supplied directly, not attributed to an unseen proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S22",
      "title": "Zurek, Cosmological experiments in superfluids and superconductors",
      "year": 1995,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/cond-mat/9502119",
      "scope": "Author’s account of non-equilibrium defect formation, quench and relaxation scales, and condensed-matter/cosmology connections.",
      "inspection": "Primary author manuscript abstract inspected. A blocked 1985 Nature page was not treated as read; this accessible 1995 manuscript is used instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S23",
      "title": "Shirley, Solution of the Schrödinger equation with a Hamiltonian periodic in time",
      "year": 1965,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.138.B979",
      "scope": "Primary formulation of spectral analysis for time-periodic Hamiltonians.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher search record and publisher-hosted paper excerpt inspected. No driven-chain result is claimed to have been executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S24",
      "title": "Trotter, On the product of semi-groups of operators",
      "year": 1959,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1090/S0002-9939-1959-0108732-6",
      "scope": "Primary product-formula limit; concrete error estimates require additional operator assumptions.",
      "inspection": "Primary AMS metadata and author bibliography checked; no unsupported universal finite-step error constant quoted."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S25",
      "title": "Yao and Wang, Edge states and topological invariants of non-Hermitian systems",
      "year": 2018,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.01876",
      "scope": "Non-Hermitian skin effects and revised bulk–boundary correspondence in the specified model.",
      "inspection": "Primary abstract inspected. General nonnormal transient-growth reasoning is a mathematical transfer, not attributed as the paper’s central theorem."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-S26",
      "title": "Jordan and Wigner, Über das Paulische Äquivalenzverbot",
      "year": 1928,
      "url": "https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/BF01331938",
      "scope": "Historical primary transformation associated with fermionic statistics and subsequent spin-chain mappings.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract and bibliographic metadata inspected; full German paper not independently translated or proof-audited."
    },
    {
      "id": "SP-C01",
      "title": "Independent small-system spectral checks and algebraic countermodels",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "spin_checks.json",
      "scope": "Executed local N=4,8,14 calculations at h=0.5,1,1.5; six eigenpairs, parity and local-probe weights; N=4 boundary comparison and dense constructor; exact-form countermodels.",
      "inspection": "Executed with pinned runtime versions recorded in JSON. Floating residual checks are not rigorous interval certificates; no full N=14 dense diagonalization was performed."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S01",
      "title": "Clay Mathematics Institute: Millennium Problems",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/",
      "scope": "Current public categories and original prize allocation.",
      "inspection": "Opened 2026-11-19; list shows five Unsolved, Navier–Stokes Active, Poincaré Solved. Category is not proof verification."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S02",
      "title": "Clay Mathematics Institute: Navier–Stokes announcement",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/news/navier-stokes-announcement/",
      "scope": "Institutional statement on the announced result.",
      "inspection": "Opened the announcement dated 2026-09-11; apparent resolution enters evaluation. No award or complete proof audit inferred."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S03",
      "title": "Clay Mathematics Institute: Rules for the Millennium Prizes",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/rules/",
      "scope": "Publication, evaluation time, and acceptance requirements.",
      "inspection": "Opened current rules 2026-11-19. Administrative eligibility is separate from mathematical correctness."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S04",
      "title": "Arthur Jaffe and Edward Witten: Quantum Yang–Mills Theory",
      "year": null,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/yangmills.pdf",
      "scope": "Official target, quantum construction, mass gap, axioms, historical context.",
      "inspection": "Read opening formulation and selected sections of the official 14-page statement; not a proof of the conjecture."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S05",
      "title": "Stephen Cook: The P versus NP Problem",
      "year": null,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/pvsnp.pdf",
      "scope": "Exact classes, worst-case computation, NP completeness, historical framework.",
      "inspection": "Read formal definitions and selected historical discussion. Its historical hardware remarks are not current facts."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S06",
      "title": "Enrico Bombieri: The Riemann Hypothesis",
      "year": null,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/riemann.pdf",
      "scope": "Zeta continuation, functional equation, precise conjecture, equivalent viewpoints.",
      "inspection": "Read opening definitions and selected analytic discussion. Examples below are independently derived audit tests, not claimed new results."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S07",
      "title": "Pierre Deligne: The Hodge Conjecture",
      "year": null,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/hodge.pdf",
      "scope": "Rational projective target and limits of integral variants.",
      "inspection": "Read official five-page statement and bibliography; fixes coefficient ring, geometric category, and cycle map."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S08",
      "title": "Andrew Wiles: The Birch and Swinnerton-Dyer Conjecture",
      "year": null,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/birchswin.pdf",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, rational rank, analytic order, leading coefficient.",
      "inspection": "Read official five-page formulation. Distinguishes the rank assertion from refined arithmetic formula."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S09",
      "title": "Charles Fefferman: Existence and Smoothness of the Navier–Stokes Equation",
      "year": null,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/navierstokes.pdf",
      "scope": "Exact R3/periodic alternatives, admissibility, forcing, solution requirements.",
      "inspection": "Read official alternatives A–D. Forced counterexamples are permitted in C/D; rejecting a construction solely because it is forced is incorrect."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S10",
      "title": "John Milnor: The Poincaré Conjecture",
      "year": 2004,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf",
      "scope": "Topological statement, homology counterexample, dimension and historical development.",
      "inspection": "Read official eight-page account. Historical dates below are those documented in this primary expert account unless an original paper is separately cited. The PDF is dated May 2000, revised June 2004; its then-current remarks on proof completion are historical and are superseded by Clay's present Solved category."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S11",
      "title": "Konrad Osterwalder and Robert Schrader: Axioms for Euclidean Green's functions",
      "year": 1973,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01645738",
      "scope": "Euclidean reconstruction and necessary axioms.",
      "inspection": "Inspected publisher abstract/metadata; not a line-by-line reconstruction proof audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S12",
      "title": "Konrad Osterwalder and Robert Schrader: Axioms for Euclidean Green's functions II",
      "year": 1975,
      "url": "https://projecteuclid.org/journals/communications-in-mathematical-physics/volume-42/issue-3/Axioms-for-Euclidean-Greens-functions-II-with-an-Appendix-by/cmp/1103899050.pdf",
      "scope": "Corrected/extended reconstruction conditions.",
      "inspection": "Search retrieval exposed title and opening correction statement. Direct PDF open returned an iframe; full proof was not reviewed."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S13",
      "title": "Kenneth Wilson: Confinement of Quarks",
      "year": 1974,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/prd/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevD.10.2445",
      "scope": "Lattice gauge theory, strong coupling, continuum distinction.",
      "inspection": "Inspected publisher abstract. Scope includes strong-coupling results and their symmetry limitations; not a continuum mass-gap proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S14",
      "title": "Toby Cubitt, David Perez-Garcia and Michael Wolf: Undecidability of the spectral gap",
      "year": 2015,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1502.04573",
      "scope": "Algorithmic undecidability for a specified family of many-body lattice Hamiltonians.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract, version history and stated model family. No implication of undecidability for a particular Ising chain or Yang–Mills asserted."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S15",
      "title": "Theodore Baker, John Gill and Robert Solovay: Relativizations of the P=?NP Question",
      "year": 1975,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1137/0204037",
      "scope": "Opposite oracle worlds and limits of relativizing methods.",
      "inspection": "Inspected original publisher abstract and publication metadata. Oracle separation is not an unrelativized solution."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S16",
      "title": "Alexander Razborov and Steven Rudich: Natural Proofs",
      "year": 1997,
      "url": "https://mit6875.github.io/PAPERS/natural_proofs.pdf",
      "scope": "Conditional barrier to a specified family of circuit lower-bound methods.",
      "inspection": "Read definitions/opening barrier statement in the authors' paper. Strong pseudorandomness assumption must remain visible."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S17",
      "title": "Scott Aaronson and Avi Wigderson: Algebrization: A New Barrier in Complexity Theory",
      "year": 2008,
      "url": "https://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/algstoc.pdf",
      "scope": "Algebraic-oracle method barrier.",
      "inspection": "Read author PDF opening definitions and barrier statement; STOC 2008 version differs bibliographically from 2009 journal record."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S18",
      "title": "Peter Shor: Polynomial-Time Algorithms for Prime Factorization and Discrete Logarithms on a Quantum Computer",
      "year": 1995,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9508027",
      "scope": "Quantum algorithm model and scope of factoring/discrete logarithm algorithms.",
      "inspection": "Opened original author arXiv record, submitted 1995 and revised 1996; earlier conference algorithm dates to 1994."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S19",
      "title": "David Platt and Tim Trudgian: The Riemann hypothesis is true up to 3·10^12",
      "year": 2020,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2004.09765",
      "scope": "Rigorous finite-height zero verification.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract specifying interval arithmetic and height bound; not a claim about all heights."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S20",
      "title": "Brad Rodgers and Terence Tao: The de Bruijn–Newman constant is non-negative",
      "year": 2018,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1801.05914v5",
      "scope": "Heat-flow zero criterion, direction of inequality, revised boundary-energy argument.",
      "inspection": "Inspected abstract and 2021 revision comment. The announced inequality is Lambda>=0, while RH corresponds to Lambda<=0."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S21",
      "title": "Michael Atiyah and Friedrich Hirzebruch: Analytic cycles on complex manifolds",
      "year": 1962,
      "url": "https://hirzebruch.mpim-bonn.mpg.de/id/eprint/151/1/29_Analytic%20cycles%20on%20complex%20manifolds.pdf",
      "scope": "Integral cycle obstructions and coefficient sensitivity.",
      "inspection": "Read opening argument and cohomology-operation obstruction; received 1961, published 1962 as confirmed by Deligne's bibliography."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S22",
      "title": "Claire Voisin: A Counterexample to the Hodge Conjecture Extended to Kähler Varieties",
      "year": 2002,
      "url": "https://webusers.imj-prg.fr/~claire.voisin/Articlesweb/hodgeimrn.pdf",
      "scope": "Counterexample to a compact-Kähler extension, not to rational projective Hodge.",
      "inspection": "Read introduction and Theorem 1.1 in author PDF. A generated SciSpace summary incorrectly enlarged the scope; corrected using this primary text."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S23",
      "title": "Eduardo Cattani, Pierre Deligne and Aroldo Kaplan: On the locus of Hodge classes",
      "year": 1994,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/alg-geom/9402009",
      "scope": "Algebraicity of the Hodge locus in an algebraic family.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract; preprint 1994, journal publication 1995. Algebraicity of parameter locus does not construct each representing cycle."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S24",
      "title": "Benedict Gross and Don Zagier: Heegner Points and Derivatives of L-series",
      "year": 1986,
      "url": "https://wstein.org/papers/bib/Gross-Zagier_Heegner_points_and_derivatives_of_Lseries.pdf",
      "scope": "Height/derivative mechanism underlying important rank-one results.",
      "inspection": "Opened 97-page original-paper scan; parser provided limited metadata. Detailed hypotheses are not independently audited here; no unrestricted theorem is attributed."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S25",
      "title": "Victor Kolyvagin: Finiteness of E(Q) and SH(E,Q) for a subclass of Weil curves",
      "year": 1988,
      "url": "https://www.mathnet.ru/eng/im1225",
      "scope": "Heegner-point/Euler-system results under stated subclass hypotheses.",
      "inspection": "Inspected original journal abstract and bibliographic record; Russian 1988, English translation 1989. Scope is not every rank."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S26",
      "title": "Christophe Breuil, Brian Conrad, Fred Diamond and Richard Taylor: On the modularity of elliptic curves over Q",
      "year": 2001,
      "url": "https://math.stanford.edu/~conrad/papers/tswfinal.pdf",
      "scope": "Modularity theorem and its analytic consequences.",
      "inspection": "Read opening Theorem A in author PDF; modularity alone does not prove BSD."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S27",
      "title": "Manjul Bhargava and Arul Shankar: Ternary cubic forms having bounded invariants, and the existence of a positive proportion of elliptic curves having rank 0",
      "year": 2015,
      "url": "https://annals.math.princeton.edu/2015/181-2/p04",
      "scope": "Average Selmer statistics and positive-proportion results.",
      "inspection": "Inspected original journal abstract. Height ordering and family measure are part of the statement; positive proportion is not universality."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S28",
      "title": "Jean Leray: Sur le mouvement d'un liquide visqueux emplissant l'espace",
      "year": 1934,
      "url": "https://warwick.ac.uk/fac/sci/maths/people/staff/james_robinson/lf/leray.pdf",
      "scope": "Global generalized solutions and the energy/regularity distinction.",
      "inspection": "Read original introduction alongside translation. Leray explicitly distinguishes bounded kinetic energy from established smoothness."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S29",
      "title": "Terence Tao: Finite time blowup for an averaged three-dimensional Navier–Stokes equation",
      "year": 2014,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1402.0290",
      "scope": "Modified model retaining energy cancellation but developing blowup.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract and precise modified-model scope; not a counterexample to the original Navier–Stokes equation."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S30",
      "title": "Tristan Buckmaster and Vlad Vicol: Nonuniqueness of weak solutions to the Navier–Stokes equation",
      "year": 2017,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1709.10033",
      "scope": "Nonuniqueness in a stated finite-energy weak class.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract/version history. Do not silently add the Leray–Hopf energy inequality or smooth-data uniqueness class."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S31",
      "title": "OpenAI: Finite Time Blowup for Navier–Stokes",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "https://cdn.openai.com/pdf/32d9f210-8b73-45e0-91bc-82a30aef8a9a/navier-stokes.pdf",
      "scope": "Announced smooth-forced construction, Theorem 1.1 and claims for alternatives C/D.",
      "inspection": "Read opening theorem and proof organization of 166-page manuscript. No complete proof reconstruction, independent formal replay, or award determination performed."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S32",
      "title": "Peter Constantin, Mihaela Ignatova and Vlad Vicol: Regularity of asymptotically axisymmetric solutions to the 3D Navier–Stokes equations with analytic forcing",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.20803v2",
      "scope": "Regularity under analytic forcing and specified axisymmetric/anisotropic Type II assumptions.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract and revision date. Its additional hypotheses prevent an automatic contradiction with a smooth-forced announcement."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S33",
      "title": "Grisha Perelman: The entropy formula for the Ricci flow and its geometric applications",
      "year": 2002,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0211159",
      "scope": "Monotonicity, noncollapse and geometric control.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract and stated geometric consequences; no full Ricci-flow proof replay performed."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S34",
      "title": "Grisha Perelman: Ricci flow with surgery on three-manifolds",
      "year": 2003,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0303109",
      "scope": "Controlled surgery and corrections to auxiliary claims.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract, including explicit qualifications to earlier claims. Corrections must be tracked rather than silently propagated."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S35",
      "title": "Grisha Perelman: Finite extinction time for the solutions to the Ricci flow on certain three-manifolds",
      "year": 2003,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0307245",
      "scope": "Finite extinction under a specific prime-decomposition hypothesis.",
      "inspection": "Inspected author abstract. The result does not assert extinction for arbitrary closed three-manifolds."
    },
    {
      "id": "MIL-S36",
      "title": "Dennis DeTurck: Deforming metrics in the direction of their Ricci tensors",
      "year": 1983,
      "url": "https://projecteuclid.org/journals/journal-of-differential-geometry/volume-18/issue-1/Deforming-metrics-in-the-direction-of-their-Ricci-tensors/10.4310/jdg/1214509286.pdf",
      "scope": "Geometric evolution and gauge-adjusted parabolic formulation.",
      "inspection": "Read indexed excerpts of the original publication and author's improved version; direct author-PDF retrieval was blocked. No complete proof inspection claimed."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX00",
      "title": "XLVII cross-field counterexamples, independently executed",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "history_checks.py",
      "scope": "Sixteen small mathematical checks; these are constructed examples, not empirical prevalence estimates.",
      "inspection": "Executed with Python on 2026-11-19; assertions passed; numerical results in history_checks.json."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX01",
      "title": "Euclid, Elements I.1, in David E. Joyce's English presentation",
      "year": "c. 300 BCE; modern edition",
      "url": "https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/elements/bookI/propI1.html",
      "scope": "The equilateral-triangle construction and its use of intersecting circles; no claim that the proposition is false.",
      "inspection": "Full displayed proposition, construction, proof and editorial discussion inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX02",
      "title": "Euclid, Elements X.1, in David E. Joyce's English presentation",
      "year": "c. 300 BCE; modern edition",
      "url": "https://mathcs.clarku.edu/~djoyce/elements/bookX/propX1.html",
      "scope": "Repeated removal of more than half a magnitude; an Archimedean comparison enters the proof.",
      "inspection": "Full displayed proposition and proof inspected; modern commentary distinguished from ancient text."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX03",
      "title": "Buckingham, On Physically Similar Systems; Illustrations of the Use of Dimensional Equations",
      "year": 1914,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.4.345",
      "scope": "Dimensional similarity and dimensionless groups; a method does not establish completeness of a chosen variable list.",
      "inspection": "Publisher metadata and indexed excerpts of the scanned original paper inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX04",
      "title": "JCGM 100:2008, Evaluation of measurement data — Guide to the expression of uncertainty in measurement",
      "year": 2008,
      "url": "https://www.bipm.org/en/doi/10.59161/jcgm100-2008e",
      "scope": "Measurement model, uncertainty and covariance; not a claim that all nonlinear propagation is Gaussian.",
      "inspection": "Official BIPM record and indexed PDF passages inspected; not a line-by-line audit of the entire standard."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX05",
      "title": "NIST, Metrological Traceability",
      "year": "current reference inspected 2026",
      "url": "https://www.nist.gov/metrology/metrological-traceability",
      "scope": "Traceability claims require a measurement process and stated uncertainty, not only an instrument label.",
      "inspection": "Official NIST indexed FAQ passages inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX06",
      "title": "Mars Climate Orbiter Mishap Investigation Board, Phase I Report",
      "year": 1999,
      "url": "https://discovery.larc.nasa.gov/PDF_FILES/MCO_report_2.pdf",
      "scope": "Unit-interface mismatch and the broader verification and communication failures described by NASA.",
      "inspection": "Official 44-page PDF opened; indexed root-cause and discrepancy passages inspected. The report is dated 10 November 1999."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX07",
      "title": "ESA, Ariane 501 — Presentation of Inquiry Board report",
      "year": 1996,
      "url": "https://www.esa.int/Newsroom/Press_Releases/Ariane_501_-_Presentation_of_Inquiry_Board_report",
      "scope": "Official account of the 4 June 1996 failure and deficiencies in specification, software and testing.",
      "inspection": "ESA announcement and inquiry summary inspected; no unsupported bit-width detail is inferred from this summary."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX08",
      "title": "Shannon, Communication in the Presence of Noise",
      "year": 1949,
      "url": "https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/1697831",
      "scope": "Band-limited reconstruction and noisy communication; the alias example is independently derived.",
      "inspection": "Primary IEEE bibliographic record and abstract inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX09",
      "title": "Gibbs, Fourier's Series, 1899 note, reprinted in Scientific Papers volume 2",
      "year": 1899,
      "url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Scientific_Papers_of_Josiah_Willard_Gibbs,_Volume_2/Chapter_XIX",
      "scope": "Original public-domain note and correction concerning Fourier partial sums; no priority claim is made.",
      "inspection": "Primary-text transcription opened; its reprint identification and mathematical passage inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX10",
      "title": "Simpson, The Interpretation of Interaction in Contingency Tables",
      "year": 1951,
      "url": "https://math.bme.hu/~marib/bsmeur/simpson.pdf",
      "scope": "Conditional versus marginal associations; the catalogue counts are an illustrative arithmetic check.",
      "inspection": "Original paper PDF indexed excerpt and publisher bibliographic record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX11",
      "title": "Hurlbert, Pseudoreplication and the Design of Ecological Field Experiments",
      "year": 1984,
      "url": "https://www.zoology.ubc.ca/~bio501/R/readings/hurlbert%201984%20ecol%20monogr%20-%20pseudoreplication.pdf",
      "scope": "Experimental units and dependence in ecological designs; no universal prevalence estimate is adopted.",
      "inspection": "Original PDF abstract and definition passages inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX12",
      "title": "Neyman and Pearson, On the Problem of the Most Efficient Tests of Statistical Hypotheses",
      "year": 1933,
      "url": "https://stats.org.uk/statistical-inference/NeymanPearson1933.pdf",
      "scope": "Error probabilities, alternatives and power are properties of a specified testing procedure.",
      "inspection": "Original paper scan and publisher bibliographic record inspected at excerpt level."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX13",
      "title": "Wasserstein and Lazar, The ASA's Statement on p-Values: Context, Process, and Purpose",
      "year": 2016,
      "url": "https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/00031305.2016.1154108",
      "scope": "Six principles governing interpretation and reporting of p-values.",
      "inspection": "Official statement text and indexed principles inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX14",
      "title": "Benjamini and Hochberg, Controlling the False Discovery Rate",
      "year": 1995,
      "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/j.2517-6161.1995.tb02031.x",
      "scope": "FDR as a criterion distinct from the probability of any false discovery; original independence conditions matter.",
      "inspection": "Original publisher abstract and main summary inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX15",
      "title": "Rubin, Inference and Missing Data",
      "year": 1976,
      "url": "https://people.csail.mit.edu/jrennie/trg/papers/rubin-missing-76.pdf",
      "scope": "Conditions for ignoring a missingness mechanism in likelihood or Bayesian inference.",
      "inspection": "Original paper abstract and introductory conditions inspected; corroborated with author institutional repository."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX16",
      "title": "Greenland and Robins, Identifiability, Exchangeability, and Epidemiological Confounding",
      "year": 1986,
      "url": "https://scispace.com/papers/identifiability-exchangeability-and-epidemiological-3cu2ttmfvf",
      "scope": "Exchangeability and causal identifiability; a predictive adjustment variable need not remove bias.",
      "inspection": "SciSpace research search and targeted custom-column extraction; primary paper record, not a complete independent proof audit."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX17",
      "title": "Bareinboim and Pearl, Causal Inference and the Data-Fusion Problem",
      "year": 2016,
      "url": "https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/113/27/7345.full.pdf",
      "scope": "Causal identification, selection and transport between data sources under explicit structural assumptions.",
      "inspection": "Primary PDF indexed excerpts and author repository inspected; SciSpace targeted extraction cross-checked for overstatement."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX18",
      "title": "Kriegeskorte et al., Circular Analysis in Systems Neuroscience: The Dangers of Double Dipping",
      "year": 2009,
      "url": "https://www.nature.com/articles/nn.2303",
      "scope": "Bias when selection and assessment recycle the same noise.",
      "inspection": "Publisher record and indexed original-paper abstract inspected; PMC full-text opening hit a challenge page."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX19",
      "title": "Cawley and Talbot, On Over-fitting in Model Selection and Subsequent Selection Bias in Performance Evaluation",
      "year": 2010,
      "url": "https://www.jmlr.org/papers/v11/cawley10a.html",
      "scope": "Finite-sample model-selection criteria can themselves be overfit.",
      "inspection": "Primary JMLR abstract and open article record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX20",
      "title": "Kapoor and Narayanan, Leakage and the Reproducibility Crisis in Machine-Learning-Based Science",
      "year": 2023,
      "url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666389923001599",
      "scope": "Leakage in scientific prediction pipelines and information about models needed for assessment.",
      "inspection": "Publisher abstract, indexed paper passages and authors' research site inspected; no prevalence numbers reproduced."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX21",
      "title": "Tikhonov, On the Solution of Ill-Posed Problems and the Method of Regularization",
      "year": 1963,
      "url": "https://www.mathnet.ru/php/archive.phtml?jrnid=dan&option_lang=eng&paperid=28329&wshow=paper",
      "scope": "Historical primary anchor for regularization; the linear examples here are independently derived.",
      "inspection": "MathNet original publication record inspected; Russian full text was not independently translated."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX22",
      "title": "Kennedy and O'Hagan, Bayesian Calibration of Computer Models",
      "year": 2001,
      "url": "https://mail.tonyohagan.co.uk/academic/abs/calib.html",
      "scope": "Calibration, prediction and discrepancy between a simulator and reality.",
      "inspection": "Authors' abstract and primary-paper indexed excerpts inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX23",
      "title": "Brynjarsdóttir and O'Hagan, Learning about Physical Parameters: The Importance of Model Discrepancy",
      "year": 2014,
      "url": "https://scispace.com/papers/learning-about-physical-parameters-the-importance-of-model-143r08ooig",
      "scope": "Confounding of simulator parameters and model discrepancy; informative discrepancy knowledge can matter.",
      "inspection": "SciSpace primary-paper search result and targeted extraction inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX24",
      "title": "Gutenkunst et al., Universally Sloppy Parameter Sensitivities in Systems Biology Models",
      "year": 2007,
      "url": "https://journals.plos.org/ploscompbiol/article?id=10.1371/journal.pcbi.0030189",
      "scope": "Wide sensitivity spectra and well-constrained predictions alongside poorly determined individual parameters.",
      "inspection": "Primary open paper and abstract inspected; the title is not interpreted as a theorem about every biological model."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX25",
      "title": "Lorenz, Deterministic Nonperiodic Flow",
      "year": 1963,
      "url": "https://wind.mit.edu/~emanuel/Lorenz/EdLorenz/Deterministic_63.pdf",
      "scope": "Deterministic nonlinear dynamics can produce nonperiodic behavior and sensitive prediction.",
      "inspection": "Original paper PDF and publisher abstract inspected at excerpt level."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX26",
      "title": "May, Simple Mathematical Models with Very Complicated Dynamics",
      "year": 1976,
      "url": "https://ned.ipac.caltech.edu/level5/Sept01/May/May1.html",
      "scope": "Simple nonlinear population maps and changes of dynamical behavior.",
      "inspection": "Primary paper reproduction hosted by NASA/IPAC and Nature publication record inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX27",
      "title": "Holling, Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems",
      "year": 1973,
      "url": "https://www.annualreviews.org/content/journals/10.1146/annurev.es.04.110173.000245",
      "scope": "Distinct ecological meanings of local stability and persistence under disturbance.",
      "inspection": "Publisher record and indexed original PDF excerpts inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX28",
      "title": "Trefethen et al., Hydrodynamic Stability Without Eigenvalues",
      "year": 1993,
      "url": "https://people.maths.ox.ac.uk/trefethen/ttrd.pdf",
      "scope": "Non-normal operators can transiently amplify disturbances despite decaying eigenmodes.",
      "inspection": "Original paper PDF indexed text and abstract inspected; small matrix example separately executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX29",
      "title": "Boerlijst, Oudman and de Roos, Catastrophic Collapse Can Occur without Early Warning",
      "year": 2013,
      "url": "https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0062033",
      "scope": "Structured ecological models in which commonly monitored early-warning statistics can remain silent.",
      "inspection": "Primary open paper abstract and examples inspected; SciSpace corroborating record retrieved."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX30",
      "title": "Zwanzig, Memory Effects in Irreversible Thermodynamics",
      "year": 1961,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.124.983",
      "scope": "Projected macroscopic dynamics with memory; read with the 1972 correction.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract and date inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX31",
      "title": "Zwanzig, Nordholm and Mitchell, Memory Effects in Irreversible Thermodynamics: Corrected Derivation of Transport Equations",
      "year": 1972,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pra/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevA.5.2680",
      "scope": "The original authors identify neglected fluctuations and correct transport coefficients.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher correction abstract and date inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX32",
      "title": "Avron and Gordon, Born Oppenheimer Near Level Crossing",
      "year": 1999,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9911121",
      "scope": "Nonadiabatic behavior near crossings; not a universal error bound for arbitrary molecules.",
      "inspection": "Authors' arXiv abstract inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX33",
      "title": "Kohn and Sham, Self-Consistent Equations Including Exchange and Correlation Effects",
      "year": 1965,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.140.A1133",
      "scope": "Ground-state electronic methods and approximations; numerical convergence is separate from functional adequacy.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract, scope and date inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX34",
      "title": "Kramers, Brownian Motion in a Field of Force and the Diffusion Model of Chemical Reactions",
      "year": 1940,
      "url": "https://www.mit.edu/~kardar/research/seminars/translocation/Kramers1940.pdf",
      "scope": "Barrier escape and reaction velocity depend on thermal noise and environmental friction.",
      "inspection": "Original Physica paper indexed first-page and abstract passages inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX35",
      "title": "Knutti et al., Challenges in Combining Projections from Multiple Climate Models",
      "year": 2010,
      "url": "https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/23/10/2009jcli3361.1.xml",
      "scope": "Multimodel ensembles are not automatically independent samples from a calibrated probability distribution.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher text and authors' PDF indexed passages inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX36",
      "title": "Knox, Determination of Inflationary Observables by Cosmic Microwave Background Anisotropy Experiments",
      "year": 1995,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/9504054",
      "scope": "CMB inference, sky sampling and instrumental limitations under a stated cosmological model.",
      "inspection": "Authors' arXiv abstract and original APS paper indexed excerpts inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX37",
      "title": "Planck Collaboration, Planck 2018 Results VI: Cosmological Parameters",
      "year": "2018 preprint; 2020 journal",
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1807.06209",
      "scope": "Cosmological parameter estimates are conditional on likelihood, data treatment and cosmological model.",
      "inspection": "Authors' abstract and institutional published-paper records inspected; no new parameter inference performed."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX38",
      "title": "Kruskal, Maximal Extension of Schwarzschild Metric",
      "year": 1960,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.119.1743",
      "scope": "A coordinate singularity can be removed by changing the chart; this does not remove every curvature singularity.",
      "inspection": "Primary APS abstract and original-paper indexed excerpts inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX39",
      "title": "Goldberg, What Every Computer Scientist Should Know About Floating-Point Arithmetic",
      "year": 1991,
      "url": "https://docs.oracle.com/cd/E19957-01/806-3568/ncg_goldberg.html",
      "scope": "Finite representation, rounding, cancellation and arithmetic exceptions.",
      "inspection": "Authorized Oracle reprint opened and numerical examples inspected; own association example executed."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX40",
      "title": "Prentice, Surrogate Endpoints in Clinical Trials: Definition and Operational Criteria",
      "year": 1989,
      "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/sim.4780080407",
      "scope": "Methodological conditions for using a measured surrogate in place of a target outcome; no medical advice.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract and original publication date corroborated with PubMed."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX41",
      "title": "Lucas, Econometric Policy Evaluation: A Critique",
      "year": 1976,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1016/S0167-2231(76)80003-6",
      "scope": "Policy-dependent decision rules can change fitted relationships; not a theorem that every policy estimate fails.",
      "inspection": "Original publisher record and indexed abstract-level content inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX42",
      "title": "The Kybalion, Chapter II: The Seven Hermetic Principles",
      "year": 1908,
      "url": "https://sacred-texts.com/book/the-kybalion/chapter-ii-the-seven-hermetic-principles",
      "scope": "Primary modern esoteric text; its words are not physical operator definitions or evidence of ancient provenance.",
      "inspection": "Primary-text transcription opened; 1908 edition date corroborated in the prior XLVII source register."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX43",
      "title": "Schrödinger, Über das Verhältnis der Heisenberg-Born-Jordanschen Quantenmechanik zu der meinen",
      "year": 1926,
      "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/andp.19263840804",
      "scope": "Contemporary comparison of formulations and explicit documentary references; structural similarity and historical influence differ.",
      "inspection": "Publisher article metadata and displayed references inspected; prior XLVII report contains inspected textual excerpts."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX44",
      "title": "Robinson, Ecological Correlations and the Behavior of Individuals",
      "year": "1950 original; 2009 reprint",
      "url": "https://academic.oup.com/ije/article/38/2/337/658252",
      "scope": "Group-level and individual-level correlations need not agree.",
      "inspection": "Primary-text reprint and original American Sociological Review volume/date metadata inspected through indexed passages."
    },
    {
      "id": "HFX45",
      "title": "Kelly, A New Interpretation of Information Rate",
      "year": 1956,
      "url": "https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/j.1538-7305.1956.tb03809.x",
      "scope": "A historical connection between information and multiplicative growth; the catalogue gives its own two-outcome example.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher record and original Bell System Technical Journal scan excerpts inspected."
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-CHSH1969",
      "title": "Proposed Experiment to Test Local Hidden-Variable Theories",
      "year": 1969,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevLett.23.880",
      "scope": "Original CHSH experiment proposal and local-model bound; the 1970 erratum is separately acknowledged.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher abstract and original paper excerpt"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-TSIRELSON1980",
      "title": "Quantum generalizations of Bell's inequality",
      "year": 1980,
      "url": "https://www.ma.huji.ac.il/~ohadfeld/Tsirelson/download/qbell80.pdf",
      "scope": "Quantum restrictions on Bell correlations; bounded observables and specified causal structure.",
      "inspection": "Author-hosted original scan and publisher abstract"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-PERES1996",
      "title": "Separability Criterion for Density Matrices",
      "year": 1996,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9604005",
      "scope": "Positive partial transpose is necessary for separability.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-HORODECKI1996",
      "title": "Separability of Mixed States: Necessary and Sufficient Conditions",
      "year": 1996,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605038",
      "scope": "PPT is sufficient for separability in dimensions 2 by 2 and 2 by 3, not in general.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-BRANCIARD2011",
      "title": "Detection Loophole in Bell experiments: How post-selected local correlations can look non-local",
      "year": 2011,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1010.1178",
      "scope": "Local correlations after detection selection can exceed a bound applied to the wrong sample space.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract; SciSpace extraction used only as a discovery aid"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-MEMORY2002",
      "title": "Quantum nonlocality, Bell inequalities and the memory loophole",
      "year": 2002,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0205016",
      "scope": "Trial memory changes statistical treatment; the local expectation constraint and finite fluctuations must be separated.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract and original-paper passages"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-COINCIDENCE2004",
      "title": "Bell's inequality and the coincidence-time loophole",
      "year": 2004,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0312035",
      "scope": "Setting-dependent coincidence selection.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-GILL2003",
      "title": "Time, Finite Statistics, and Bell's Fifth Position",
      "year": 2003,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0301059",
      "scope": "Randomization and martingale treatment of Bell statistics.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-INDEPENDENCE2011",
      "title": "How much measurement independence is needed in order to demonstrate nonlocality?",
      "year": 2011,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1008.3612",
      "scope": "Quantitative relaxation of independence between settings and hidden variables.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-HENSEN2015",
      "title": "Experimental loophole-free violation of a Bell inequality using entangled electron spins separated by 1.3 km",
      "year": 2015,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1508.05949",
      "scope": "An actual event-ready experiment with explicit trial statistics and major loophole controls.",
      "inspection": "Author and publisher abstracts; no raw-data reanalysis claimed"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-PR1994",
      "title": "Quantum Nonlocality as an Axiom",
      "year": 1994,
      "url": "https://www.informationphilosopher.com/solutions/scientists/bell/Popescu_Rohrlich.pdf",
      "scope": "Original paper demonstrating that no-signalling does not by itself restrict correlations to quantum correlations.",
      "inspection": "Original-paper excerpt on archival mirror; metadata checked against author bibliography"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-TREFETHEN1993",
      "title": "Hydrodynamic Stability Without Eigenvalues",
      "year": 1993,
      "url": "https://people.maths.ox.ac.uk/trefethen/publication/PDF/1993_57.pdf",
      "scope": "Nonorthogonal eigenmodes and transient amplification in linearly stable systems.",
      "inspection": "Author-hosted original PDF"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-CLAY2026",
      "title": "The Millennium Prize Problems",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/",
      "scope": "Official category check on November 19, 2026; a category is not an independent proof verification.",
      "inspection": "Current official page"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-NSFORM",
      "title": "Existence and Smoothness of the Navier–Stokes Equation",
      "year": 2000,
      "url": "https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/navierstokes.pdf",
      "scope": "Official alternatives, domains, data and forcing conditions.",
      "inspection": "Official formulation inspected in the Millennium investigation"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-CALC2026",
      "title": "XLVII exact counterexamples and numerical illustrations",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "local:counterexamples.json",
      "scope": "Original calculations executed for this atlas, with mathematical scope and reproducible code.",
      "inspection": "Executed with Python/NumPy/SymPy; selected identities independently checked by Wolfram"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-AUDIT2026",
      "title": "Observed failures in the new audit and their corrections",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "local:observed_audit_findings.json",
      "scope": "The empty-root-list assertion was an observed defect in this new audit script and was corrected before delivery. Retrieval scope findings include the separate Millennium audit receipt.",
      "inspection": "Direct observation, repair, and rerun"
    },
    {
      "id": "ROOT-ANALYSIS2026",
      "title": "Original mathematical and methodological audit deductions in this atlas",
      "year": 2026,
      "url": "local:XLVII_Failure_Atlas_2026-11-19.md",
      "scope": "Conditional diagnostics and explicitly derived countermodels; these are not claims that a historical source discussed every modern implementation risk or that every listed risk occurred.",
      "inspection": "Derivations and targeted cross-review; numerical execution is claimed only where a corresponding check is provided"
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-PLANCK",
      "title": "The Genesis and Present State of Development of the Quantum Theory",
      "year": 1920,
      "url": "https://www.nobelprize.org/prizes/physics/1918/planck/lecture/",
      "scope": "Planck's retrospective account of radiation and the development of the quantum hypothesis.",
      "inspection": "Official lecture text retrieved through search; direct open returned 403."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-MILLIKAN",
      "title": "A Direct Photoelectric Determination of Planck's h",
      "year": 1916,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/pdf/10.1103/PhysRev.7.355",
      "scope": "Primary photoelectric measurements and separation of equation fit from proposed interpretation.",
      "inspection": "Original-paper search excerpt and prior report's PDF inspection; no new raw-data reanalysis."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-COMPTON",
      "title": "A Quantum Theory of the Scattering of X-rays by Light Elements",
      "year": 1923,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.21.483",
      "scope": "Kinematic wavelength shift and the paper's stated limits of other approximations.",
      "inspection": "Publisher original abstract including the wavelength equation."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-ROBERTSON",
      "title": "The Uncertainty Principle",
      "year": 1929,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/pr/abstract/10.1103/PhysRev.34.163",
      "scope": "Historical anchor for the variance-commutator relation; algebraic counterexamples in this atlas are independently derived.",
      "inspection": "Publisher metadata; full text access wall in this pass."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-DIRAC",
      "title": "The Quantum Theory of the Electron",
      "year": 1928,
      "url": "https://www.math.ucsd.edu/~nwallach/Dirac1928.pdf",
      "scope": "Relativistic spinor equation, not a complete interacting field theory.",
      "inspection": "Original scan inspected in the earlier report; retained with that inspection scope."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-LINDBLAD",
      "title": "On the generators of quantum dynamical semigroups",
      "year": 1976,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01608499",
      "scope": "Bounded generators of completely positive semigroups and a class of Markovian master equations.",
      "inspection": "Publisher abstract, not full proof."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-VQE",
      "title": "A variational eigenvalue solver on a quantum processor",
      "year": 2014,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1304.3061",
      "scope": "A specified small-scale hybrid variational demonstration; not a general trainability or scaling theorem.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract and publication metadata."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-BARREN",
      "title": "Barren plateaus in quantum neural network training landscapes",
      "year": 2018,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/1803.11173",
      "scope": "Vanishing-gradient behavior under stated random-circuit ensemble assumptions.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract; not generalized to all ansätze."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-GROVER",
      "title": "A fast quantum mechanical algorithm for database search",
      "year": 1996,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9605043",
      "scope": "Quadratic query scaling for the specified unstructured-search oracle model.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract and publication history."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-LANDAUER",
      "title": "Irreversibility and Heat Generation in the Computing Process",
      "year": 1961,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1147/rd.53.0183",
      "scope": "Information erasure, entropy and physical implementation constraints.",
      "inspection": "Original publisher abstract; modern generalized erasure claims are not attributed to this source."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-BENNETT",
      "title": "Logical Reversibility of Computation",
      "year": 1973,
      "url": "https://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall04/cos576/papers/bennett73.html",
      "scope": "Reversible embedding and uncomputation of intermediate records.",
      "inspection": "Original-paper transcription on university site."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-CLONING",
      "title": "A single quantum cannot be cloned",
      "year": 1982,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1038/299802A0",
      "scope": "Universal exact cloning restriction; scope is not a ban on preparing known states.",
      "inspection": "Original publisher abstract and metadata; linearity derivation supplied independently."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-TELEPORT",
      "title": "Teleporting an unknown quantum state via dual classical and Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen channels",
      "year": 1993,
      "url": "https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.70.1895",
      "scope": "State-transfer protocol uses entanglement and classical information.",
      "inspection": "Primary publisher source inspected in earlier report; independently derived marginal check in this atlas."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-QEC",
      "title": "Suppressing quantum errors by scaling a surface code logical qubit",
      "year": 2023,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/2207.06431",
      "scope": "A finite experimental code-scaling result; does not itself certify arbitrary code distances or circuits.",
      "inspection": "Author paper page and abstract in prior report; no raw-data reanalysis."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-FOCK",
      "title": "Näherungsmethode zur Lösung des quantenmechanischen Mehrkörperproblems",
      "year": 1930,
      "url": "https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01340294",
      "scope": "Historical single-determinant approximation anchor; modern diagnostics in this atlas are independent scope deductions.",
      "inspection": "Bibliographic identifier cross-checked in publisher references in the prior report; direct retrieval timed out."
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-THRESHOLD",
      "title": "Fault-Tolerant Quantum Computation With Constant Error Rate",
      "year": 1999,
      "url": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/9906129",
      "scope": "Expanded preprint following 1996/1997 versions; fault-tolerance guarantee under stated noise and computational assumptions.",
      "inspection": "Author abstract and historical versions; not a complete proof replay."
    },
    {
      "id": "EARLY-GALILEO1638",
      "title": "Galileo, Dialogues Concerning Two New Sciences, First Day",
      "year": 1638,
      "url": "https://galileoandeinstein.phys.virginia.edu/tns_draft/tns_001to061.html",
      "edition": "English translation by Henry Crew and Alfonso de Salvio, first published 1914; university transcription identifies Dover and National Edition page numbering.",
      "scope": "The opening discussion explicitly challenges inference from geometrically similar small structures to larger structures made of the same material.",
      "inspection": "University-hosted primary translation opened and opening structural-scaling discussion inspected; independently compared with the Wikisource transcription. No modern universal biological scaling law is attributed to Galileo.",
      "locator": "First Day, opening dialogue; English pages 1–4 and National Edition pages 50–52."
    },
    {
      "id": "EARLY-BOYLE1672",
      "title": "Boyle, Tracts Containing New Experiments Touching the Relation Between Flame and Air",
      "year": 1672,
      "url": "https://web.lemoyne.edu/Giunta/boyle.html",
      "edition": "University-hosted extract from the 1672 text, reproduced via Leicester and Klickstein's 1952 Source Book in Chemistry.",
      "scope": "Boyle distinguishes admitting air by removing a receiver from admitting a little air through a stopcock without moving it.",
      "inspection": "Primary-text extract inspected, especially First Title, Experiments III and IV. The edited excerpt is not a complete audit of the 1672 volume.",
      "locator": "First Title, Experiments III–IV: alternative explanation involving escape of fumes, followed by the stopcock comparison."
    },
    {
      "id": "EARLY-NEWTON1687",
      "title": "Newton, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, Book I, Section XI",
      "year": "1687 work; inspected 1729 English edition",
      "url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Mathematical_Principles_of_Natural_Philosophy_(1729)/Book_1/Section_11",
      "edition": "Andrew Motte's 1729 translation. The source is a later edition witness; the exact wording is not represented as an inspection of the 1687 Latin printing.",
      "scope": "The section moves from an immovable force center to mutually attracting bodies and their common center of gravity.",
      "inspection": "Primary translation's opening passage and Propositions LVII–LIX inspected. Broader historical priority and changes between Latin editions were not investigated.",
      "locator": "Book I, Section XI, introduction and Propositions LVII–LIX."
    },
    {
      "id": "EARLY-FOURIER1822",
      "title": "Fourier, The Analytical Theory of Heat, Chapter IX, Article 342",
      "year": "1822 French original; 1878 English translation",
      "url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/analytical-theory-of-heat/of-the-diffusion-of-heat/85ACC8B6A30D2310AFA3DD980CA6C90B",
      "edition": "Alexander Freeman's 1878 English translation, republished by Cambridge; the page also records later print and online publication dates.",
      "scope": "Article 342 specifies an infinite homogeneous solid, a structured initial temperature distribution, and an alternative thin prism with an insulating lateral surface.",
      "inspection": "The publisher's displayed primary-text passage for Article 342 and edition metadata were inspected. The complete chapter's proofs were not audited.",
      "locator": "Chapter IX, First Section, Article 342; displayed publisher passage corresponding to the chapter beginning on printed page 333."
    },
    {
      "id": "EARLY-CARNOT1824",
      "title": "Carnot, Reflections on the Motive Power of Heat, original treatise within Thurston's edition",
      "year": "1824 original; inspected 1897 revised English edition",
      "url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Reflections_on_the_Motive_Power_of_Heat/Chapter_3",
      "edition": "R. H. Thurston's second revised English edition, 1897; copyright 1890. Chapter III contains Carnot's treatise, distinct from the editor's introduction and Thomson's later account.",
      "scope": "Constant-temperature reservoirs, forward and inverse operations, loss-free idealization, and the explicit caveat about a small temperature excess driving heat transfer.",
      "inspection": "Primary-text translation inspected through the reservoir construction and reversible-cycle discussion. Front matter was cross-checked in the Gutenberg transcription. No modern entropy notation is attributed to the 1824 text.",
      "locator": "Chapter III, reservoir construction and ideal operations, especially the passage corresponding to printed pages 50–60."
    }
  ],
  "modes": [
    {
      "id": "SPIN-001",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "Pauli matrices and spin operators use different normalizations",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "H0"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Substituting S=σ/2 into −JΣSzSz−hΣSx gives Pauli coefficients J/4 and h/2. Retaining the same numerical labels changes both the exchange scale and the field-to-exchange ratio.",
      "presentation": "A factor-of-two or factor-of-four discrepancy, and an apparent critical field h=J/2 instead of h=J, can be a convention error rather than new physics.",
      "diagnostic": "Write each local 2×2 matrix and its eigenvalues; compare the one-spin gap before studying an interacting chain.",
      "remedy": "Publish the operator normalization and convert all coefficients together.",
      "scope": "Exact algebra for spin one-half; not a claim that the supplied table used the wrong convention.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Atomic and molecular spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Angular-momentum operators and dimensionless Pauli generators must carry the corresponding coupling constants."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "H0"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-002",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "Setting J=1 hides the physical energy calibration",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Hphysical=Jphysical Hdimensionless implies Δphysical=Jphysical Δdimensionless. A dimensionless number cannot independently specify joules, kelvin, hertz, or electronvolts.",
      "presentation": "A plot appears to predict a measurable resonance without an exchange-energy calibration; angular frequency and ordinary frequency can additionally differ by 2π.",
      "diagnostic": "Track J, ℏ, kB, and the frequency convention through one complete conversion.",
      "remedy": "Report dimensionless results separately from calibrated energies and propagate calibration uncertainty.",
      "scope": "All rows of the supplied table use J=1; no physical material was specified.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Chemistry and metrology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Conversion of dimensionless computed energies into transition frequencies requires traceable scales."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-003",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "The dimensionless field h is confused with a laboratory magnetic field",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A laboratory Zeeman term includes an effective magnetic moment and possibly an anisotropic g tensor. The coefficient called h in the table is already an energy divided by J.",
      "presentation": "The numerical critical value h=1 is read as one tesla or transferred between materials with different magnetic moments.",
      "diagnostic": "Derive the laboratory field-to-Hamiltonian map for the chosen spin normalization and field direction.",
      "remedy": "Store the calibration function h(B), its assumptions, and its uncertainty alongside data.",
      "scope": "A physical-identification risk; the ideal mathematical table has no tesla units.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Semiconductor qubits and magnetic resonance",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Control amplitudes and detunings need a calibrated map into the effective Hamiltonian."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-004",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "The sign of exchange is changed without auditing frustration",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An alternating spin rotation can exchange ferro- and antiferromagnetic nearest-neighbor couplings on a bipartite even ring. It cannot satisfy all bonds of an odd antiferromagnetic ring.",
      "presentation": "Even-N agreement is used to claim that exchange sign never matters; odd rings then contain a frustrated bond and a different low-energy structure.",
      "diagnostic": "Check whether the interaction graph is bipartite and whether the proposed unitary preserves the boundary bond.",
      "remedy": "Separate even and odd rings and show the explicit unitary when asserting spectral equivalence.",
      "scope": "Nearest-neighbor rings with uniform couplings; extra interactions may invalidate the even-ring equivalence.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Graph optimization and frustrated magnets",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Odd cycles obstruct assigning alternating signs consistently around every edge."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-005",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "Only part of a basis rotation is applied",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A global unitary maps all terms and observables together. Rotating ZZ into XX but leaving the field and probe unchanged generally defines a different experiment or Hamiltonian.",
      "presentation": "A literature formula in a rotated convention is combined with unrotated code, producing incorrect conserved parity or selection rules.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute UHU† and UAU† term by term; compare complete small-N spectra and physical matrix elements.",
      "remedy": "Maintain one explicit convention dictionary for axes, states, and observables.",
      "scope": "Exact unitary equivalence requires transformation of the whole problem.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum chemistry and polarization optics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Changing representation preserves predictions only when states and measured operators are transformed consistently."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-006",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "Open and periodic boundaries are silently exchanged",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Deleting the last-to-first bond changes the Hamiltonian and its edge states. The executed N=4,h=0.5 gap is 0.03549043264 for the ring and 0.09478758774 for the open chain.",
      "presentation": "Two accurate implementations disagree even though both are labeled an Ising chain.",
      "diagnostic": "Print the bond list and compare an explicit dense four-spin matrix for both boundary choices.",
      "remedy": "Include boundary conditions in every dataset key, formula, and plot caption.",
      "scope": "The displayed six endpoint values correspond to the periodic convention; the comparison is a numerical check, not an interval certificate.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Vibration analysis and photonic cavities",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Changing boundary conditions changes the domain or matrix and therefore its spectrum."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2019,
          "event": "Oshikawa analyzed finite-size gaps across boundary and defect choices.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S04"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01",
        "SP-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-007",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "Small rings contain ambiguous bond counting",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For N=2, the literal periodic sum over i contains Z1Z2 and Z2Z1, whereas a simple undirected two-vertex graph usually contains one edge. At N=1 the periodic bond becomes the identity.",
      "presentation": "Tests on N=1 or N=2 disagree by a factor of two or a constant even when the N≥4 production Hamiltonian is correct.",
      "diagnostic": "Declare whether the object is a periodic indexed lattice or a simple graph and inspect the edge multiplicities.",
      "remedy": "Use N≥3 for ring comparisons or explicitly define exceptional small-N conventions.",
      "scope": "A definition issue, not a defect in the N=4 through N=14 table.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Network science and finite elements",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Multigraph edge multiplicities and duplicate assembly contributions alter operators."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-008",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "A two-level local space is substituted for a larger physical space",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A spin-one, multiorbital, bosonic, or leaky hardware site has states excluded from the two-dimensional qubit model. Eliminated states can shift low energies or introduce lower transitions.",
      "presentation": "The computed qubit gap looks stable while a physical system has an additional excitation or leakage channel.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the retained subspace with the physical local spectrum and bound couplings to discarded states.",
      "remedy": "Derive an effective Hamiltonian with a controlled elimination error, or enlarge the local basis.",
      "scope": "Conditional on applying the ideal spin-one-half table to another substrate.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Electronic structure and chemical effective models",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Basis truncation must control the omitted-state contribution, not merely the retained eigenproblem."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-009",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "Additional interactions are treated as harmless without a bound",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "WEYL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Next-neighbor exchange, long-range tails, multispin terms, or anisotropy change the operator. A term small compared with J need not be small compared with an exponentially tiny doublet splitting.",
      "presentation": "An eight-digit ideal-model gap is presented as robust despite unspecified interactions larger than that gap.",
      "diagnostic": "Estimate the perturbation in the relevant low-energy subspace and compare it with the separation being claimed.",
      "remedy": "Include measured terms and uncertainty bands; use locality-sensitive stability results only under their hypotheses.",
      "scope": "The finite ideal-chain calculation remains valid; its robustness is a separate question.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Celestial mechanics and molecular spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A small correction relative to the total energy can dominate a nearly resonant splitting."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "WEYL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-010",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "A longitudinal field destroys the parity assumptions",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Adding −gΣZi yields PHP≠H for P=∏Xi. Near the ordered doublet, a bias of order gN times the order parameter can exceed the tunneling splitting and rotate the low-energy states.",
      "presentation": "A presumed dark transition becomes allowed, a nominal doublet is biased, or an unperturbed critical formula is used after adding a field.",
      "diagnostic": "Evaluate [H,P] and compare the projected longitudinal perturbation with ΔN.",
      "remedy": "Treat g as an explicit independent parameter and recompute states, selection rules, and limits.",
      "scope": "The supplied Hamiltonian has g=0; confinement or E8 claims require additional precise conditions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Molecular tunneling and symmetry-breaking sensors",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A biased two-state tunneling system changes its splitting and eigenvectors even for a weak absolute bias."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2010,
          "event": "Coldea and collaborators measured excitations in a perturbed quasi-one-dimensional Ising material.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S19"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S19"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-011",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "Clean-chain scaling is carried into disordered chains",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Random Ji or hi create a distribution of local scales. Rare weak links or rare ordered regions can dominate the smallest gap while typical samples and disorder averages behave differently.",
      "presentation": "A single clean critical exponent, a mean gap, or one sample is used to characterize a broad random ensemble.",
      "diagnostic": "Record sample distributions, median and logarithmic statistics, extreme events, and disorder-dependent finite-size trends.",
      "remedy": "Choose a disorder-specific model and distinguish typical, average, and worst-case statements.",
      "scope": "Fisher’s random-chain results concern a different ensemble; they do not describe the uniform table automatically.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Reliability engineering and random media",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Rare bottlenecks can control a system-level response while averages describe typical components."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1995,
          "event": "Fisher developed the random transverse-field Ising-chain critical theory.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S13"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S13"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-012",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "An equilibrium spectrum is used as a complete prediction of a driven state",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Knowing instantaneous eigenvalues does not determine populations or coherences after a ramp. Initial state, protocol, transition matrix elements, and time evolution are additional inputs.",
      "presentation": "A computed gap is read directly as a measured post-quench oscillation amplitude or as evidence that the system stayed in its ground state.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the initial density operator and solve or bound the actual preparation dynamics.",
      "remedy": "Keep equilibrium spectral calculations and protocol-dependent state predictions distinct in data and claims.",
      "scope": "Applies whenever the table is used to design or interpret a time-dependent experiment.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Reaction kinetics and control engineering",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "The stationary operator does not by itself specify the trajectory from a chosen initial condition."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-013",
      "category": "Model definition and physical identification",
      "title": "A material realization is identified with an isolated ideal chain",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Interchain coupling, anisotropy, lattice effects, and the neutron or optical probe can all matter in a quasi-one-dimensional material. Agreement with one ideal-model ratio does not determine every microscopic term.",
      "presentation": "Evidence for a particular emergent excitation pattern is advertised as validation of all ideal-chain energies or of an unrelated field theory.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the experiment’s Hamiltonian, dimensional crossover, temperature, and measured structure factor with the ideal assumptions.",
      "remedy": "Fit competing physical models and state the energy and parameter window in which the effective description applies.",
      "scope": "The table is an ideal Hamiltonian calculation, not experimental data for CoNb2O6 or another material.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Biophysical and chemical model systems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A useful model organism or effective molecule still requires a documented mapping to the target system."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2010,
          "event": "Coldea et al. used a quasi-one-dimensional ferromagnet to study Ising-related excitation structure.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S19"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S19"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-014",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "Multiplicity is confused with distinct energy levels",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Eigenvalues ordered with multiplicity differ from a list of distinct energies. For diag(0,0,2), E1−E0=0 but the energy above the whole ground eigenspace is 2.",
      "presentation": "One calculation reports zero and another reports a positive gap because they ask different questions.",
      "diagnostic": "Publish the ground multiplicity and the exact definition of the excluded subspace.",
      "remedy": "Use Δabove-ground-space=inf(spec(H) outside the ground energy)−E0 when that is the intended object.",
      "scope": "Exact counterexample; both gap conventions can be useful but are not interchangeable.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Structural mechanics and graph Laplacians",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Rigid motions or disconnected components create multiple zero modes before the first positive eigenvalue."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-015",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "The ordered doublet splitting is called the bulk excitation gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "In the ordered periodic chain the lowest two states form an increasingly degenerate pair. Their splitting can vanish while excitations above that pair remain separated.",
      "presentation": "At N=14,h=0.5, the computed E1−E0≈1.66536×10^−5 is interpreted as the energy of a local bulk particle; E2−E0 is instead about 2.09789.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect several levels, parity labels, and probe matrix elements; identify the ground-state manifold before taking a limit.",
      "remedy": "Label tunneling splitting, gap above the low-energy manifold, and probe-specific threshold separately.",
      "scope": "The periodic ordered result does not identify E2−E0 with the elementary one-kink mass 2(1−h).",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Molecular inversion and macroscopic tunneling",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Nearly degenerate symmetry combinations can split much less than local vibrational or intrawell excitations."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01",
        "SP-S03",
        "SP-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-016",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "A symmetry-sector gap is passed off as the full gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Because [H,P]=0, diagonalizing only P=+1 excludes every odd state. The first omitted odd state can lie below the first excited even state.",
      "presentation": "A positive, apparently stable same-sector gap hides the exponentially small global ordered doublet splitting.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute the lowest levels in every relevant block and then merge them in energy order.",
      "remedy": "Record the sector for each eigenpair and name a restricted gap explicitly.",
      "scope": "The executed first two states have opposite parity for the nine tested (N,h) combinations.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Particle spectroscopy and selection-constrained optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An extremum within one invariant subspace need not be the global extremum."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01",
        "SP-S03"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-017",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "The Jordan–Wigner boundary string is dropped",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "On a ring the fermion boundary term carries the total parity string. Treating both spin-parity sectors as the same fermionic boundary problem changes allowed momenta and low levels.",
      "presentation": "A bulk dispersion looks correct but the finite-N gap and critical coefficient are wrong.",
      "diagnostic": "Derive the last-to-first bond before Fourier transformation and verify the fermion parity projection.",
      "remedy": "Implement each parity-dependent boundary sector explicitly and compare against a small spin-basis spectrum.",
      "scope": "The precise sign convention depends on the spin rotation and fermion definition; the consistency check is invariant.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Gauge systems and topological boundary conditions",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Global holonomy or sector data cannot be recovered from the local bulk differential expression alone."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1928,
          "event": "Jordan and Wigner introduced their spin–fermion transformation.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S26"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1961,
          "event": "Lieb, Schultz, and Mattis developed soluble-chain fermion methods.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S02"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S02",
        "SP-S03",
        "SP-S26"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-018",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "Special momentum modes and fermion parity are filled incorrectly",
      "equationIds": [
        "JW",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Pairing k with −k leaves possible self-paired k=0 and π modes requiring separate treatment. The quasiparticle vacuum may not have the physical parity required by its spin sector.",
      "presentation": "Summing positive dispersion energies gives an apparently valid vacuum that is not an allowed state, especially across the ordered-to-disordered change.",
      "diagnostic": "Track occupation and physical parity of unpaired modes and reconstruct the small-N many-body spectrum.",
      "remedy": "Apply the spin-sector parity constraint after the Bogoliubov transformation instead of assuming every formal vacuum is physical.",
      "scope": "Mode availability depends on N and boundary sector.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Superconducting quasiparticles",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Bogoliubov transformations do not erase physical fermion-parity constraints."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2013,
          "event": "Damski and Rams revisited size, field, and parity dependence.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S03"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S03",
        "SP-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "JW",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-019",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "A spectral level is assumed visible to every observable",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "With P=∏Xi, PX1P=X1 and PZ1P=−Z1. Between an even ground state and odd first state, ⟨1|X1|0⟩ equals its own negative and is exactly zero.",
      "presentation": "At N=14,h=0.5, the executed Z1 transition weight is about 0.93060486 whereas X1 gives approximately 4.2×10^−29, numerical zero.",
      "diagnostic": "Calculate symmetry-resolved matrix elements in S_A(ω), not only eigenvalue differences.",
      "remedy": "Report Δ_A=inf{En−E0>0:⟨n|A|0⟩≠0} with an operational detection threshold when using experimental data.",
      "scope": "The parity argument is exact; tiny nonzero numerical weights are not physical symmetry violation.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Molecular and atomic spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Dark states and dipole-selection rules separate available eigenlevels from observable absorption lines."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-007",
        "CROSS-035",
        "YM-013"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-020",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "An elementary kink mass is confused with a local two-particle threshold",
      "equationIds": [
        "JW",
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The dispersion minimum 2|1−h| describes an elementary free-fermion or kink mass under the stated normalization. Boundary and parity constraints can require an allowed local excitation to contain two such objects.",
      "presentation": "For h=0.5, a mass scale 1 is compared with periodic E2−E0≈2.09789 and called a numerical error, even though the even local channel approaches the two-particle threshold 2.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify topological charge, particle number parity, boundary sector, and the probe’s creation operator.",
      "remedy": "State whether a value is a one-particle mass, a multiparticle threshold, or a finite-ring many-body level.",
      "scope": "The threshold 4(1−h) refers to the ordered, ideal, large periodic chain and the appropriate local even channel; perturbations can bind particles.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Nuclear and high-energy spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A constituent mass and the lowest allowed multiparticle invariant energy are different quantities."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01",
        "SP-S01"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "JW",
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-021",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "An edge mode is used to declare the bulk gap closed",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An open system may have boundary-localized states with exponentially small splitting while extended bulk excitations remain gapped.",
      "presentation": "The smallest full-system gap collapses with length and is interpreted as a bulk critical point without inspecting localization.",
      "diagnostic": "Measure boundary versus bulk support, compare open and periodic spectra, and inspect the gap above edge states.",
      "remedy": "Report the boundary-mode splitting and bulk excitation threshold separately.",
      "scope": "Kitaev’s wire supplies a precise related example; spin-chain symmetry breaking and topological protection should not be identified without a mapping.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Topological photonics and superconducting wires",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Boundary spectra and bulk bands answer different spectral questions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2000,
          "event": "Kitaev described a gapped bulk with near-degenerate boundary-associated states.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S15"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S15"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-022",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "The exactly degenerate h=0 point is replaced by a small nonzero field",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For a ferromagnetic ring at h=0 the all-up and all-down states are exactly degenerate. Any reported positive E1−E0 at that point must arise from the gap convention, an added term, or numerical handling.",
      "presentation": "A weak-field tunneling formula is evaluated at a singular endpoint without rechecking multiplicity.",
      "diagnostic": "Diagonalize the classical ZZ energies directly and count domain walls and ground states.",
      "remedy": "Treat h=0 exactly and state whether the gap excludes the entire ground manifold.",
      "scope": "For N≥3, the first domain-wall-pair cost at J=1 is 4; this is not E1−E0 when multiplicity is counted.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Degenerate perturbation theory in chemistry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A degenerate reference manifold requires a matrix effective Hamiltonian rather than a scalar nondegenerate expansion."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-023",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "Zero finite-system magnetization is taken to rule out order",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An exact parity eigenstate has ⟨Zi⟩=0 by symmetry, including the finite-ring ground state in the ordered regime. This does not determine large-distance correlations or a symmetry-broken limit.",
      "presentation": "A numerical solver preserving symmetry is accused of missing the ordered phase because its one-point order parameter vanishes.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect ⟨ZiZj⟩, order-parameter distributions, response to a small longitudinal field, and the relevant limit order.",
      "remedy": "Use symmetry-compatible diagnostics and distinguish finite symmetric states from infinite broken-symmetry states.",
      "scope": "The zero one-point result follows algebraically from parity; existence and value of infinite-volume order require further analysis.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Statistical mechanics and finite-size biological models",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A symmetric ensemble average can vanish while individual states or correlations exhibit structured order."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-024",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "The symmetry-breaking field and size limits are interchanged",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Setting a longitudinal field to zero at every finite N preserves the symmetric state. Taking N→∞ first and then removing an infinitesimal bias can select a different limiting state.",
      "presentation": "Two calculations agree on local Hamiltonians but disagree on magnetization because they implement different limiting procedures.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the nested limits explicitly and record whether boundary conditions or preparation select a phase.",
      "remedy": "Specify the state-selection prescription before comparing infinite-volume observables.",
      "scope": "A limit-order risk in the ordered regime; it does not imply the finite table is inconsistent.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Ferroelectricity and bifurcation theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An infinitesimal symmetry-breaking perturbation can select a branch after a macroscopic limit."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-025",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "Momentum-resolved response is replaced by the minimum over all momenta",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A probe at wavevector q can couple only to compatible momentum sectors in a translation-invariant system. The global minimum gap may occur elsewhere or have zero weight at that q.",
      "presentation": "A neutron-scattering or optical spectrum is expected to show a line at E1−E0 even though the measurement geometry excludes it.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute S_A(q,ω) with the same q, polarization, and form factor as the measurement.",
      "remedy": "Label global, sector, and wavevector-resolved thresholds independently.",
      "scope": "Disorder and boundaries can relax exact momentum conservation but do not justify assuming all weights equal.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Acoustics and electromagnetic mode excitation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A source’s spatial pattern determines which normal modes it excites."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-026",
      "category": "Symmetry, spectral sectors, and measurable transitions",
      "title": "The exact critical finite-ring formula is used outside its domain",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "ΔN=2tan(π/(4N)) is the quoted full first gap for the specified even periodic Pauli-normalized chain at h=J=1. It is not a formula for every boundary, field, sector, or observable.",
      "presentation": "Agreement at h=1 is used to certify ordered or open-chain results without an independent formula.",
      "diagnostic": "Attach hypotheses to the expression and compare the full state labeling when changing any one of them.",
      "remedy": "Use the exact formula as a targeted critical benchmark, not as a universal gap identity.",
      "scope": "Its large-N expansion is π/(2N)+O(N^−3), so it explicitly tends to zero.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Finite-size scaling in field theory",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Universal-looking coefficients still depend on sector, normalization, geometry, and boundary conditions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S04",
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-027",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "Pointwise positive finite gaps are mistaken for a uniform lower bound",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The statements ∀N,ΔN>0 and ∃c>0∀N,ΔN≥c have different quantifiers. The exact sequence ΔN=2tan(π/(4N)) satisfies the first and violates the second.",
      "presentation": "Every numerical row is positive and is therefore presented as proof of a positive thermodynamic gap.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the proposed constant c and show why it is independent of N over the full required family.",
      "remedy": "Demand a uniform theorem or a properly qualified extrapolation; positivity of finitely many rows is insufficient.",
      "scope": "This is an exact counterexample already contained in the h=1 table’s model.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "PDE coercivity, optimization, and statistical consistency",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Finite-dimensional positivity does not ensure a dimension-independent coercivity or conditioning constant."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-028",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "A sampled subsequence is mistaken for all system sizes",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Data only at N=4,6,…,14 do not establish behavior for odd sizes, other boundaries, or all larger N. A general sequence can agree on all sampled points and diverge elsewhere.",
      "presentation": "A fit to one parity class is reported as a theorem over every finite volume.",
      "diagnostic": "State the quantifier domain and examine whether model-specific identities justify extending the sampled subsequence.",
      "remedy": "Keep subsequence claims explicit; use structural analysis rather than adding a few arbitrary sizes to imply universality.",
      "scope": "The uniform ferromagnetic ring has additional exact structure; arbitrary adversarial sequences are an inference counterexample, not its predicted behavior.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Sampling theory and numerical analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A sampling pattern can omit a whole systematic class of cases."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-030",
        "FORM-004",
        "SPIN-035",
        "SPIN-036",
        "SPIN-037"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-029",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "The thermodynamic limit is confused with a continuum limit",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "TFIM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "At fixed lattice spacing a, N→∞ sends L=Na to infinity. At fixed physical L, a→0 requires N→∞ with couplings and units scaled appropriately. These operations answer different questions.",
      "presentation": "A large spin chain is described as a constructed continuum quantum field theory solely because N increased.",
      "diagnostic": "Track a,L,J(a),h(a), observable normalization, and the target limiting correlation functions.",
      "remedy": "State separately the infinite-volume construction and the regulator-removal or scaling-limit construction.",
      "scope": "The finite table has neither a continuum regulator-removal proof nor a four-dimensional Yang–Mills construction.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Lattice field theory and finite-element PDEs",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Enlarging a domain and refining a mesh are distinct limits with different uniform estimates."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "TFIM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-030",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "The approach to the critical point is hidden inside the size limit",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Near h=1 the correlation length competes with N. Holding h fixed, taking h−1∝1/N, or tuning still faster yields different crossover behavior even when all sequences approach the critical point.",
      "presentation": "A finite-size crossing is attributed to a new phase when the samples follow different parameter paths.",
      "diagnostic": "Plot the appropriate scaling variable and report how h depends on N in every sequence.",
      "remedy": "Separate fixed-parameter limits from critical crossover trajectories and include correction terms when fitting.",
      "scope": "The ideal clean Ising critical theory has its own scaling variables; they are not automatically appropriate for disorder or long-range interactions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Critical phenomena and singular perturbations",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Two small parameters can combine into a fixed crossover variable, making the limiting path essential."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-031",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "The zero-temperature limit is not uniform in the small gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For two states separated by Δ, the thermal population ratio is exp(−βΔ). If ΔN shrinks while β is fixed, cooling sufficient at small N no longer isolates the same ground state at larger N.",
      "presentation": "A finite-temperature calculation is labeled a pure-ground-state result even though the ordered doublet is thermally mixed.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare βΔ for every relevant level and ask whether the target observable distinguishes the doublet.",
      "remedy": "Specify the thermal state or justify a ground-state approximation for the particular observable; do not impose a doublet-resolution requirement when the observable is insensitive to it.",
      "scope": "Bulk local quantities may converge even when the unique finite-N ground state is not isolated thermally.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Cryogenic spectroscopy and chemical populations",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Boltzmann occupation depends on the energy difference times inverse temperature, not temperature alone."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-032",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "A weak perturbation is not controlled uniformly with system size",
      "equationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For V=εΣvi, an operator-norm estimate can grow as Nε. Taking ε→0 for each fixed N does not show that the perturbation stays small when N also grows.",
      "presentation": "A perturbative calculation has an excellent small-chain error but no volume-independent remainder.",
      "diagnostic": "Track the N dependence of every remainder, radius of convergence, and low-energy denominator.",
      "remedy": "Prove an appropriate uniform local stability bound or state the joint scaling of ε and N.",
      "scope": "A global norm can be overly pessimistic; its failure is not proof of physical instability.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Thermodynamic chemistry and distributed control",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Many individually small contributions can accumulate, and near-resonant denominators can amplify them."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-033",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "Correlation distances exceed the trustworthy finite-volume window",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "On a ring, sites separated by r are also connected around the other arc of length N−r. Fitting an infinite-line exponential to distances comparable with N can mistake wraparound or plateau effects for a correlation length.",
      "presentation": "A fitted decay length tracks system size or changes when the fitting range is moved.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare both arc distances, fit the appropriate finite-volume form, and vary the excluded short- and long-distance ranges.",
      "remedy": "Use a geometry-aware correlator and obtain N substantially beyond the scale being estimated when possible.",
      "scope": "A practical estimation issue; it does not invalidate the exact finite-ring spectrum.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Spatial statistics and periodic molecular simulations",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Periodic images alter correlations and distance-dependent responses."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-034",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "A theorem is exported beyond its quantified hypothesis set",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "WEYL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A result for one dimension, finite-range interactions, bounded local Hilbert space, or a specified symmetry sector need not survive dropping those restrictions.",
      "presentation": "The exactly soluble chain is used as evidence that a theorem holds for arbitrary many-body Hamiltonians or a four-dimensional gauge theory.",
      "diagnostic": "Write a hypothesis-to-target checklist with every dimension, locality, symmetry, domain, and limit assumption.",
      "remedy": "Supply a separate theorem or controlled reduction for every changed assumption.",
      "scope": "This is a general logical risk; the table remains a valid example within its own model.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "All mathematical sciences",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A theorem applies to its quantified domain; an analogy does not enlarge that domain."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "WEYL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-035",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "An apparent plateau is mistaken for an asymptotic limit",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A finite sequence can remain nearly flat through the accessible window and change beyond it. Short-distance crossover scales or small perturbation amplitudes can postpone asymptotic behavior.",
      "presentation": "The last two gaps are nearly equal and a nonzero limit is announced without a remainder estimate.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare plausible crossover models, exact solvable benchmarks, and bounds on the unobserved tail.",
      "remedy": "Call the plateau finite-size evidence and attach the model assumptions needed for its extrapolation.",
      "scope": "At h=1.5 the known ideal model supports the paramagnetic limit 1; the same visual criterion alone would not establish another model’s limit.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Climate, epidemiology, and long-time dynamics",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A stable-looking finite observation window need not reveal a system’s ultimate asymptotic behavior."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-030",
        "FORM-004",
        "QH-018",
        "SPIN-028",
        "SPIN-036",
        "SPIN-037"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-036",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "The fitting family determines the conclusion in advance",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An exponential decay, a power law, a positive constant plus corrections, and a crossover curve can fit a small data set comparably well. Constraining the offset positive makes a positive inferred gap partly an assumption.",
      "presentation": "The quoted uncertainty is tiny inside one fit family while competing families extrapolate differently.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect residual structure and compare fits with different asymptotic hypotheses using held-out sizes or exact predictions.",
      "remedy": "Report model dependence separately from within-model parameter uncertainty.",
      "scope": "The Ising example allows exact asymptotic checks; a fit should not replace available exact structure.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Astronomy and inverse problems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Model-selection uncertainty can dominate conditional parameter error."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-030",
        "FORM-004",
        "SPIN-028",
        "SPIN-035",
        "SPIN-037"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-037",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "Only endpoints are retained and the informative shape is discarded",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The two endpoint values N=4 and N=14 cannot reveal curvature, crossings, or solver anomalies at intermediate sizes. Compressing a sequence can erase the evidence distinguishing competing laws.",
      "presentation": "An exponential and a power law are both inferred from the same two numbers with no independent shape test.",
      "diagnostic": "Recover the full N=4,6,8,10,12,14 series and the underlying uncertainty and provenance.",
      "remedy": "Preserve the full data and distinguish a display summary from the evidence used for a claim.",
      "scope": "The user’s short table is a presentation subset; the prior project report contained additional sizes.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Data engineering and time-series analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Lossy summarization can destroy identifiable features of the generating process."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-030",
        "FORM-004",
        "SPIN-028",
        "SPIN-035",
        "SPIN-036"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-038",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "The dynamic exponent z=1 is assumed in another universality class",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A critical relation Δ∼N^−z depends on the low-energy dynamics. Disorder, long-range interactions, conserved dynamics, or another transition can change the exponent or replace simple power-law scaling.",
      "presentation": "Multiplying every gap by N is assumed to produce a crossing, and its failure is blamed solely on bad numerics.",
      "diagnostic": "Establish the relevant dynamical scaling theory and test whether algebraic scaling is appropriate.",
      "remedy": "Treat z and the scaling form as model-specific hypotheses with independent support.",
      "scope": "The clean critical Ising chain has z=1; the warning concerns transfer to other models.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Critical dynamics and stochastic reaction systems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Static similarity does not determine temporal scaling."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-039",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "A bare lattice gap is equated with a renormalized continuum mass",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The dimensionless lattice gap and a physical mass are related only after fixing the energy scale, limiting dispersion, field normalization, and trajectory toward the continuum. A finite regulator can retain artifacts.",
      "presentation": "A positive finite-lattice eigenvalue is advertised as a nonzero mass of a constructed continuum theory.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify which renormalized observable defines the mass and show convergence with all regulators removed.",
      "remedy": "Track lattice spacing and physical units and prove or bound regulator errors separately from volume errors.",
      "scope": "The one-dimensional spin example does not itself satisfy the existence or mass-gap obligations of Yang–Mills theory.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum field theory and multiscale materials",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Effective parameters depend on the scale and matching prescription that define them."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-040",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "Gap–correlation theorems are reversed or stripped of assumptions",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Results connecting a gap to connected-correlation decay require hypotheses such as suitable locality. Observing one rapidly decaying correlator does not by itself prove a full spectral gap.",
      "presentation": "A short fitted correlation length is presented as proof that every excitation is gapped, even if the probe is blind to a low-energy sector.",
      "diagnostic": "State the theorem’s direction and assumptions and inspect all sectors that may carry low-energy spectral weight.",
      "remedy": "Use the correlation result as a consequence or diagnostic within its proven scope; obtain a separate spectral lower bound when required.",
      "scope": "Hastings–Koma addresses rigorous implications under specified interactions; it is not an unrestricted equivalence for every observable.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Inverse spectral problems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Information from one transfer channel can miss unobservable modes of the underlying operator."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2005,
          "event": "Hastings and Koma formulated rigorous gap-to-correlation-decay results.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S07"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-041",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "An energy gap is confused with charge, optical, or transport gaps",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A neutral excitation, charge-addition energy, optical threshold, and transport activation energy are defined by different sectors, operators, ensembles, or processes.",
      "presentation": "One spectral number is used to infer insulating behavior, optical transparency, thermal transport, and qubit protection simultaneously.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the operational definition and conservation-law sector for each proposed observable.",
      "remedy": "Compute the corresponding response or addition/removal energies rather than reusing the smallest full-system spacing.",
      "scope": "The spin chain has no electronic charge-addition sector unless an additional physical mapping is supplied.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Solid-state chemistry and electronic materials",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Different experiments probe different excitations even in the same sample."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-042",
      "category": "Limits, scaling, and inference across models",
      "title": "A quantum Hamiltonian gap is equated with a stochastic mixing rate",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Unitary time evolution oscillates with energy differences; a Markov generator has decay rates and a stationary state. Similar eigenvalue notation does not identify the two operators or their physical timescales.",
      "presentation": "A positive energy gap is used to claim rapid equilibration without specifying a bath or transition rates.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the generator of the actual dynamics and verify any similarity transformation or detailed-balance mapping.",
      "remedy": "Compute the stochastic or dissipative spectral gap independently unless a rigorous mapping is given.",
      "scope": "Certain specially constructed models admit mappings, but the existence of one such mapping is not universal.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Population dynamics and Markov-chain Monte Carlo",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Eigenvalue separations control distinct evolution equations only after their generators and units are specified."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-043",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "The solver targets the wrong end of the spectrum",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For a Hamiltonian with negative ground energy, smallest magnitude is generally not smallest algebraic value. Shift-invert selections refer to transformed eigenvalues, which creates an additional interpretation step.",
      "presentation": "Accurate interior eigenpairs are labeled ground and first excited states.",
      "diagnostic": "Audit which, sigma, mode, and sort order against the operator’s spectral range.",
      "remedy": "Use the intended algebraic target and validate with a complete small-N spectrum.",
      "scope": "The executed checks used eigsh(which=\"SA\"); this item is not an observed error in them.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Structural dynamics and stability analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The desired physical mode must match the numerical spectral targeting rule."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-044",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Partial convergence is accepted as a complete answer",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An iterative solver can stop before all requested Ritz pairs converge. Its returned subset may not include every low-energy state, especially near a cluster.",
      "presentation": "A script catches an exception, prints the available values, and treats an incomplete list as the ordered low spectrum.",
      "diagnostic": "Record convergence status, iteration settings, residuals, and the actual number of converged pairs.",
      "remedy": "Handle incomplete solves explicitly and change numerical settings only to resolve the identified convergence risk.",
      "scope": "No incomplete solve was observed in the executed nine-point check.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Large-scale numerical PDEs",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An iterative routine’s output contract and convergence status are part of the scientific result."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-045",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "A symmetry-pure starting vector cannot reach another sector",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ],
      "mechanism": "If q lies in an invariant parity sector, every Krylov vector H^kq remains in that sector in exact arithmetic. A full-space matrix alone does not guarantee that a one-vector iteration explores both sectors.",
      "presentation": "The algorithm converges perfectly but misses the opposite-parity first excited state.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect starting-vector parity and the sectors represented by returned vectors.",
      "remedy": "Use explicit sector calculations or starting blocks that cover all required invariant subspaces.",
      "scope": "Random starts usually have both components but do not substitute for a documented sector audit.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Control-theory reachability",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The Krylov subspace generated by a chosen input may exclude invariant modes."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "JW"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-046",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "A zero residual is mistaken for proof that the eigenpair is lowest",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For H=diag(0,1,2), the vector (0,0,1) has eigenvalue 2 and exactly zero residual. The residual establishes an eigenpair, not its index in the ordered spectrum.",
      "presentation": "Tiny residuals are used to claim that no unseen lower state exists.",
      "diagnostic": "Combine residual checks with eigenvalue counting, certified enclosures, variational bounds, or a complete small example.",
      "remedy": "State separately the eigenpair accuracy and the evidence for spectral ordering and completeness.",
      "scope": "This exact counterexample was also executed in spin_checks.py.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Optimization and stability certification",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Stationarity or a locally exact solution does not establish global optimality."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-005"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-047",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Duplicate or nonorthogonal vectors manufacture a false small gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "If a solver or postprocessor returns the same eigenvector twice, subtracting the associated repeated eigenvalue gives zero without finding a second independent state. Loss of orthogonality can create related ghost Ritz values.",
      "presentation": "An apparent degeneracy disappears when the returned basis is orthogonalized or its Gram matrix is checked.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute V†V and verify independence, residuals, and multiplicities together.",
      "remedy": "Reorthogonalize or use a stable block method; retain genuine degeneracy only with independent eigenvectors.",
      "scope": "The explicit duplicate-vector counterexample has Gram matrix [[1,1],[1,1]] of determinant zero.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Principal-component analysis and modal identification",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Repeated numerical directions do not represent independent physical or statistical modes."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-048",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Near-degenerate eigenvectors are treated as individually stable objects",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Small perturbations can rotate eigenvectors strongly inside a nearly degenerate subspace while changing eigenvalues little. Observables assigned to a particular arbitrary basis vector can therefore fluctuate.",
      "presentation": "Successive runs give different parity mixtures or matrix elements although the low-energy subspace and summed spectral weight agree.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare projectors, principal angles, conserved-operator matrices within the cluster, and cluster-summed weights.",
      "remedy": "Resolve symmetry inside the degenerate subspace and report invariant quantities when individual vectors are not uniquely defined.",
      "scope": "Exact symmetry can fix a preferred basis; numerical splitting alone may not.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "PCA, molecular conical intersections, and vibration modes",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Small eigenvalue separation worsens eigenvector conditioning."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1970,
          "event": "Davis and Kahan analyzed eigenvector rotation under perturbation.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S16"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S16"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-049",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Subtracting extensive energies loses a tiny gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The gap is a difference of two close numbers. In float64, (10^16+1)−10^16 evaluates to 0 because the unit spacing at 10^16 is 2, despite an exact gap of 1.",
      "presentation": "A physically irrelevant energy offset changes the reported numerical gap, or an exponentially small splitting saturates at machine noise.",
      "diagnostic": "Check the absolute energy scale, spacing of the numeric type, residuals, and invariance under controlled shifts.",
      "remedy": "Use appropriate precision or a direct stable low-energy formulation; rescaling and shifting must themselves be performed without losing the splitting.",
      "scope": "The executed cancellation example illustrates a numerical mechanism; the provided six endpoints were reproduced accurately at their displayed precision.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Computational chemistry and gravitational binding energies",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Small reaction or binding energies can be differences of much larger totals."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-050",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Numeric type silently truncates the intended operator",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Integer assembly can discard fractional fields; float32 can lose a tiny splitting; dropping imaginary parts can remove physical couplings. The resulting matrix may still diagonalize cleanly.",
      "presentation": "Residuals are small for the wrong rounded matrix, and increasing solver iterations does not repair the discrepancy.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect dtype and representative entries at every construction boundary, including serialization and accelerator transfers.",
      "remedy": "Choose types from the needed absolute resolution and retain complex arithmetic when the operator requires it.",
      "scope": "Type adequacy depends on scale and target precision, not on the software language alone.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Scientific computing and embedded sensing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Precision and representation errors can occur before the main numerical algorithm runs."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-051",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "A Hermitian eigensolver is applied to a non-Hermitian matrix",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A missing transpose, directional coupling, gain/loss term, or complex phase error can violate H=H†. A routine assuming Hermiticity may use only one triangle or otherwise solve an unintended problem.",
      "presentation": "Real-looking returned energies conceal matrix asymmetry or disagree with a general eigensolver.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute a scaled norm of H−H† and verify the operator’s intended physical class.",
      "remedy": "Fix unintended asymmetry; if non-Hermitian dynamics are intended, use appropriate definitions and algorithms.",
      "scope": "The ideal TFIM Hamiltonian is Hermitian; open-system generators require a different treatment.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Acoustics, photonics, and stability theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Self-adjoint and nonnormal spectral problems have different numerical and physical properties."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-052",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Bit indexing or operator assembly changes the Hamiltonian",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Endianness, a wrong XOR mask, omitted bonds, duplicate bonds, or mixing local and global tensor indices can create a perfectly valid matrix for the wrong model.",
      "presentation": "An eigensolver passes residual tests but fails known one-spin, classical, or small-ring limits.",
      "diagnostic": "Build an independent Kronecker-product Hamiltonian and compare full small-N spectra and selected matrix entries.",
      "remedy": "Keep a transparent small reference constructor independent of the optimized bitwise implementation.",
      "scope": "The executed N=4,h=0.5 dense Kronecker comparison matched the bit-basis spectrum below 10^−12.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Finite-element assembly and quantum circuits",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Correct local rules can be wired into an incorrect global operator."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-053",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Residual tolerance is reported without normalization or units",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An absolute residual ε has energy units, while relative stopping criteria scale with an eigenvalue or operator norm. The same tolerance number can have different significance after rescaling H.",
      "presentation": "A tolerance of 10^−8 is called eight-digit gap accuracy even when the gap is much smaller or the spectral scale is large.",
      "diagnostic": "Report absolute residuals, the operator scale, and the gap scale separately; use the Hermitian residual-to-spectrum bound correctly.",
      "remedy": "Choose tolerances from the desired absolute uncertainty and supplement them with ordering/completeness checks.",
      "scope": "A residual controls proximity to some eigenvalue; it does not alone label that eigenvalue or certify a difference.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Numerical linear algebra across sciences",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Backward and forward error depend on normalization and conditioning."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-054",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Solver precision is confused with physical parameter certainty",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "WEYL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Computing eigenvalues to many digits conditions on exact J and h. Uncertainty in those inputs, omitted terms, or calibration can produce a much larger uncertainty in the predicted physical gap.",
      "presentation": "Eight printed decimals are interpreted as eight physically meaningful decimals.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate numerical error from parameter uncertainty and model discrepancy; estimate derivatives or interval bounds with respect to inputs.",
      "remedy": "Attach uncertainty to the physical prediction and retain exact-model digits only as a mathematical benchmark.",
      "scope": "The quoted table is legitimately precise for the stated ideal parameters; it does not supply experimental error bars.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Metrology and all simulation-based sciences",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A deterministic solver can be precise about an uncertain model."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "WEYL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "QH-013",
        "SPIN-057",
        "SPIN-066"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-055",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Formatting destroys the distinction between tiny, zero, and unresolved",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Rounding a small positive gap to zero or taking its logarithm after rounding changes the displayed mathematical claim. Conversely, a tiny nonzero floating result can be numerical noise rather than certified positivity.",
      "presentation": "A plot has missing log-scale points, spurious zero plateaus, or excessive decimal places unsupported by error estimates.",
      "diagnostic": "Preserve unrounded values, precision metadata, and a separate resolution or uncertainty flag.",
      "remedy": "Use scientific notation and distinguish exactly zero, numerically unresolved, and estimated positive values.",
      "scope": "At h=0.5,N=14, 0.00001665 is a rounded representation of approximately 1.66535986×10^−5.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Analytical chemistry and detection limits",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Below-resolution results and exact absence are different statements."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-056",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Too few levels are requested to identify the relevant threshold",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Computing only E0 and E1 cannot determine the gap above a two-state manifold or locate the first transition allowed by a probe. Degeneracy can consume several requested slots.",
      "presentation": "A table of first gaps is used to describe a two-particle onset or a parity-even observable without the relevant excited states.",
      "diagnostic": "Request enough levels to cover the intended manifold and calculate their symmetry labels and matrix elements.",
      "remedy": "Choose the spectral window from the scientific question rather than a fixed k=2 default.",
      "scope": "The executed audit requested six low eigenpairs, sufficient for the explicitly reported comparisons, not a complete N=14 spectrum.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Spectroscopy and modal engineering",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A truncated mode list must include the modes that couple to the intended observable."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-057",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "A variational upper bound is mistaken for a lower bound on the gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Rayleigh–Ritz gives an upper bound on the ground energy. For Hε=diag(0,ε,1), 0<ε<1, the exact ground energy is always 0 while the gap can be arbitrarily small; perfect ground-energy accuracy supplies no positive uniform gap bound.",
      "presentation": "Optimization success is presented as proof that all orthogonal states cost at least a specified energy.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify which side of each eigenvalue is bounded and whether the excited-state min–max constraints are certified.",
      "remedy": "Combine valid lower and upper eigenvalue bounds, or a coercivity estimate on the orthogonal complement, to certify a gap.",
      "scope": "Variational estimates remain useful evidence; the failure is reversing the inequality they establish.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Electronic structure and finite-element eigenproblems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Trial-space eigenvalues have directional variational bounds that do not automatically certify a spectral separation."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-008",
        "QH-013",
        "SPIN-054",
        "SPIN-058",
        "SPIN-059",
        "SPIN-060",
        "SPIN-066"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-058",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "The difference of two upper bounds is called a bound on their difference",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "If E0≤U0 and E1≤U1, U1−U0 has no general one-sided relation to E1−E0. For actual energies (0,1), ordered upper bounds (100,100) give a difference 0 while (0,101) give 101.",
      "presentation": "Two separate variational energies are subtracted and the result is labeled a rigorous lower or upper gap bound.",
      "diagnostic": "Propagate intervals: if Ei∈[Li,Ui], then Δ∈[L1−U0,U1−L0].",
      "remedy": "Obtain both needed sides of the energy enclosures and account for possible degeneracy or mislabeling.",
      "scope": "Exact interval arithmetic logic; statistical correlated-error cancellation requires a different, explicitly justified analysis.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Thermochemistry and optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Subtracting bounds requires attention to their inequality directions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-008",
        "SPIN-057",
        "SPIN-059",
        "SPIN-060"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-059",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "A nonpositive lower bound is read as proof that the gap vanishes",
      "equationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The statement Δ≥b with b≤0 is compatible with every nonnegative gap. A lower-bound method can become uninformative without the physical quantity becoming zero.",
      "presentation": "The estimate 2h−2N|J| crosses zero and is interpreted as the phase transition.",
      "diagnostic": "Ask what conclusion follows logically from the inequality after enforcing Δ≥0.",
      "remedy": "Report max(0,b) as the elementary bound and distinguish loss of the certificate from closure of the actual gap.",
      "scope": "For h=1.5,N=14,J=1 the elementary bound is negative while the executed gap is about 1.00123.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Stability certificates and error bounds",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Failure of a sufficient condition does not establish failure of the property."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-008",
        "SPIN-057",
        "SPIN-058",
        "SPIN-060"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-060",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "An extensive norm estimate is expected to prove a thermodynamic gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "H0",
        "WEYL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "With H0=−hΣXi and V=−JΣZiZi+1, Δ(H0)=2h for h>0 and ||V||≤N|J| yield Δ(H0+V)≥2h−2N|J|. The right side deteriorates linearly with N.",
      "presentation": "An elementary finite-volume perturbation bound is used as if it were a uniform proof at fixed nonzero J.",
      "diagnostic": "Track every constant’s volume dependence before passing to N→∞.",
      "remedy": "Use exact model structure or a valid locality-sensitive stability argument when seeking a uniform lower bound.",
      "scope": "The norm estimate is mathematically correct but too coarse for that thermodynamic objective; at h=0 the reference ground space is degenerate.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "PDE and many-body perturbation theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A bound on an extensive total perturbation can obscure local stability."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "H0",
        "WEYL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-008",
        "SPIN-057",
        "SPIN-058",
        "SPIN-059"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-061",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Finite-matrix inequalities are applied to unbounded operators without domains",
      "equationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "TFIM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Continuum differential operators and bosonic Hamiltonians may be unbounded. Their sum, self-adjointness, lower boundedness, and perturbation control depend on operator or quadratic-form domains.",
      "presentation": "A finite-dimensional norm inequality is copied into a continuum proof even though the perturbation has infinite operator norm or the domains differ.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the Hilbert space, common domain or form domain, and the exact relative-boundedness assumptions.",
      "remedy": "Use an appropriate unbounded-operator theorem and prove its hypotheses before taking a regulator limit.",
      "scope": "Every finite spin-chain matrix in this audit is bounded; the failure arises during transfer to a different operator class.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum field theory, quantum chemistry, and PDEs",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Differential expressions do not define self-adjoint operators without domain information."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "TFIM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-062",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Two implementations share the same hidden error",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Two solvers using the same assembled matrix, indexing helper, rounded input, or copied formula are not independent tests of those shared parts.",
      "presentation": "Agreement to machine precision is advertised as an independent model validation even though only the diagonalization backend changed.",
      "diagnostic": "Draw the dependency graph of model construction, parameter ingestion, solver, and postprocessing for each check.",
      "remedy": "Choose independence at the layer under question, such as Kronecker versus bitwise assembly or exact versus numerical calculation.",
      "scope": "The local N=4 comparison independently constructed the matrix; it does not certify every larger-size construction path by itself.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Software verification and experimental replication",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Common-mode errors survive replication that reuses the same dependencies."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-063",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "Data provenance silently changes the problem",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A stale cache, mislabeled h, wrong N, switched boundary flag, reordered columns, or truncated export can attach correct numbers to the wrong scientific claim.",
      "presentation": "A plot appears to violate a known theorem while the underlying solver output was correct for another configuration.",
      "diagnostic": "Store immutable parameter records, code versions, units, boundary conditions, and precision with every row.",
      "remedy": "Validate joins and plot inputs against source records and make regeneration deterministic.",
      "scope": "No such mismatch was found in the six quoted endpoints; this is a pipeline failure mode.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Laboratory information systems and data science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Correct values with incorrect metadata produce incorrect conclusions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-064",
      "category": "Numerical eigensolvers, conditioning, and certification",
      "title": "A finite numerical check is promoted to a theorem or an observation",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Executing a model checks its numerical consequences for selected inputs. It does not by itself establish an infinite theorem, measure a physical system, or prove that a real substrate implements that model.",
      "presentation": "The table is called experimental confirmation, a continuum existence result, or a Millennium-problem solution.",
      "diagnostic": "Label every statement as algebraic proof, numerical check, empirical observation, conjecture, or analogy and trace the bridge between them.",
      "remedy": "Keep the finite benchmark as evidence at its actual scope and state the missing proof or measurement obligations.",
      "scope": "This audit reproduced the displayed endpoints; it does not claim to solve Yang–Mills or another prize problem.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "All computational sciences",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Simulation validity, mathematical validity, and empirical validity are different claims."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-022"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-065",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Finite tensor-network bond dimension creates an artificial length scale",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Restricting a matrix-product state to finite bond dimension χ limits its entanglement and can induce an effective correlation length even at a critical Hamiltonian.",
      "presentation": "A finite-χ state looks exponentially correlated or gapped, and its apparent transition shifts as χ changes.",
      "diagnostic": "Vary χ independently of N and distinguish finite-size from finite-entanglement scaling.",
      "remedy": "Use controlled joint convergence and compare an exactly soluble critical benchmark.",
      "scope": "This is an approximation artifact risk, not a change in the exact Hamiltonian spectrum.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Tensor-network electronic structure",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An ansatz’s representational limit can create an apparent physical cutoff."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2007,
          "event": "Tagliacozzo and collaborators analyzed finite-entanglement scaling in matrix-product approximations.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S10"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-066",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Accurate variational energy is taken to imply accurate long-range structure",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Energy emphasizes local terms and may change little when a state has incorrect long-range correlations, order, or a wrong mixture inside a near-degenerate subspace.",
      "presentation": "A tiny energy error is used to certify magnetization, entanglement, or spectral weights without checking them.",
      "diagnostic": "Measure the observables of interest, variance, symmetry, and overlaps or rigorous error bounds where available.",
      "remedy": "Converge the intended observables directly and avoid equating energy convergence with state convergence.",
      "scope": "The 1961 soluble-chain paper explicitly motivated exact analysis partly by limitations of variational inference; no numerical ansatz is automatically invalid.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum chemistry and reduced-order modeling",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A surrogate can optimize its objective while remaining inaccurate for another observable."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1961,
          "event": "Lieb, Schultz, and Mattis discussed the limits of extracting order from variational approximations.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S02"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1992,
          "event": "White introduced the density-matrix renormalization method.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S09"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S02",
        "SP-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "QH-013",
        "SPIN-054",
        "SPIN-057"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-067",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "An excited-state ansatz relaxes back into the ground manifold",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Approximate orthogonality constraints, penalty terms, or deflation can fail when the target state nearly overlaps a converged ground state. An ansatz may return another representative of the same low-energy manifold.",
      "presentation": "A computed excitation is too low or vanishes as optimization proceeds, without correct multiplicity or quantum numbers.",
      "diagnostic": "Check overlap matrices, parity, variance, penalty dependence, and the exact objective being minimized.",
      "remedy": "Enforce the intended orthogonal subspace and audit excited-state completeness separately from ground-state optimization.",
      "scope": "Especially relevant for variational tensor networks and quantum variational algorithms near a doublet.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Electronic excited-state methods",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Orthogonality and state tracking are essential when optimizing nearby eigenstates."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-068",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Trotter discretization changes the effective Hamiltonian",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "When the field and interaction terms do not commute, a finite product of exponentials is not the exact exponential of their sum. Commutator corrections depend on time step and decomposition order.",
      "presentation": "A digital simulation or imaginary-time partition function shows a shifted gap or critical point that survives increasing N at fixed time step.",
      "diagnostic": "Vary the time step independently and compare decomposition orders or exact small-system propagation.",
      "remedy": "Extrapolate or bound the product-formula error in the observable of interest.",
      "scope": "A Trotter limit is an additional limit, separate from volume and bond-dimension convergence.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Molecular dynamics and operator-splitting PDE methods",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Splitting noncommuting generators introduces a controlled but nonzero discretization error."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1959,
          "event": "Trotter studied limits of products of semigroups.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S24"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1976,
          "event": "Suzuki developed quantum–classical correspondence and systematic approximants.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S12"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S12",
        "SP-S24"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-069",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Real-time entanglement growth exceeds the numerical ansatz",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A state simple enough at t=0 can develop entanglement under evolution that a fixed-χ representation cannot retain. Truncation then alters long-time correlations and Fourier spectra.",
      "presentation": "Late-time oscillations decay artificially, a spectral line broadens, or a fitted gap depends on the simulation stopping time and χ.",
      "diagnostic": "Monitor discarded weight, conservation laws, entanglement, and convergence of the time series as χ changes.",
      "remedy": "Limit claims to the converged time window and propagate that window into the frequency-resolution claim.",
      "scope": "Ground-state area-law results do not guarantee efficient simulation of arbitrary quenched states.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Computational wave dynamics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A reduced basis that resolves the initial state can become inadequate as dynamics populate new structures."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-070",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "A multi-exponential imaginary-time signal is fit too early",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A correlator has contributions Σn wn exp(−Δnτ). For C(τ)=ε exp(−τ)+exp(−10τ), the apparent decay rate is near 10 while τ is well below log(1/ε)/9, although the lowest rate is 1.",
      "presentation": "The inferred gap drifts with the fit window or disagrees between operators having different overlaps.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect effective slopes over τ, compare probes, and test whether the lowest allowed mode is actually resolved.",
      "remedy": "Use a justified spectral model or bound contamination; state a threshold accessible to the chosen observable.",
      "scope": "Even noiseless data over a finite interval can make a weak low-energy mode difficult to resolve.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Chemical kinetics and fluorescence lifetime analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Mixtures of exponentials do not have one time-independent effective decay rate."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-071",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Correlated Monte Carlo samples are counted as independent",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Slow transitions between configurations or sectors reduce effective sample size. Naive standard errors can shrink while the chain has not explored relevant rare configurations.",
      "presentation": "Repeated samples produce very narrow error bars around a biased or poorly mixed estimator.",
      "diagnostic": "Estimate autocorrelation times, compare independent starts, inspect sector transitions, and test sensitivity to bin size.",
      "remedy": "Report effective sample size and use sampling updates appropriate to the physical bottleneck.",
      "scope": "The sparse diagonalization audit is deterministic conditional on its numerical start and does not have this sampling error.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Bayesian inference and statistical mechanics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Dependence and nonstationarity invalidate independent-sample uncertainty formulas."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-072",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Sign-problem hardness is either ignored or universalized",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Some quantum Monte Carlo representations have severe sign cancellations, while the ferromagnetic TFIM with h≥0 is stoquastic in the Z basis. Neither easy sampling of this model nor generic hardness settles every other model.",
      "presentation": "The chain’s tractability is exported to arbitrary fermionic systems, or generic NP-hardness is used to dismiss this specific solvable benchmark.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect off-diagonal matrix elements and the actual sampling representation; state the model class in any complexity claim.",
      "remedy": "Use model-specific algorithms and preserve the quantified scope of hardness results.",
      "scope": "Troyer–Wiese establishes a generic complexity obstruction, not that every instance has a sign problem.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Computational complexity and statistical inference",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Worst-case hardness and the tractability of a restricted family can both be true."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2004,
          "event": "Troyer and Wiese analyzed the complexity of the generic fermionic sign problem.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S11"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S11"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-073",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Analytic continuation supplies an apparently precise but nonunique spectrum",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Recovering a real-frequency spectral density from noisy imaginary-time data inverts a smoothing transform. Different low-frequency spectra can fit the data within its uncertainty.",
      "presentation": "A reconstructed gap appears only under one regularization prior or broadening parameter.",
      "diagnostic": "Vary regularization, generate synthetic data with known spectra, and examine the family of spectra consistent with the measurements.",
      "remedy": "Report resolution and prior dependence; use rigorous bounds or direct real-time probes when available.",
      "scope": "The issue concerns an inverse problem, not direct exact diagonalization of the finite matrix.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Medical imaging and astronomical deconvolution",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Inverting a smoothing operator amplifies noise and requires additional assumptions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-074",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Noise mitigation or postselection changes the effective measured state",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Readout error, coherent gate error, conditional acceptance, and mitigation can alter correlators or bias a fitted transition. A corrected curve is still an estimator whose assumptions need validation.",
      "presentation": "A small gap appears only after discarding certain runs or extrapolating a noise model, while raw observables do not resolve it.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare raw and processed data, acceptance rates, calibration controls, and uncertainty propagated through the entire estimator.",
      "remedy": "Describe the measurement model and conditioning explicitly and validate with known-spectrum circuits.",
      "scope": "A practical risk for hardware realization; no hardware measurement was used to produce the quoted table.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Experimental particle physics and biomedical measurement",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Selection and correction pipelines can change estimands and uncertainty."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-075",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "The most favorable size, seed, or fitting window is selected after inspection",
      "equationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Trying many numerical settings or extrapolation windows and reporting only the one supporting a preferred conclusion biases the apparent evidence. Deterministic outputs do not remove selection bias in how they are chosen.",
      "presentation": "A striking positive gap or universal collapse disappears when all attempted analyses are shown.",
      "diagnostic": "Maintain an analysis log and distinguish prespecified validation from exploratory selection.",
      "remedy": "Report robust conclusions across reasonable settings and confirm new hypotheses on independent checks.",
      "scope": "Exploration is legitimate; unreported outcome-dependent selection is the failure mode.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Statistics and reproducible science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Multiple analytical choices can overfit evidence even without stochastic measurement noise."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SCALING",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-019",
        "CROSS-013",
        "CROSS-014",
        "CROSS-018"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-076",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Finite observation time is mistaken for unlimited frequency resolution",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A time record of duration Tobs cannot generically distinguish arbitrarily close frequencies; sampling interval, aliasing, and the window function also shape a Fourier estimate.",
      "presentation": "A near-zero doublet splitting is assigned many significant digits from a time trace too short to resolve its period.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the target splitting with 1/Tobs, the sampling rate, and the estimator’s noise-dependent resolution.",
      "remedy": "Extend the physical or simulated record where justified, use an explicit parametric model, and report its assumptions and resolving power.",
      "scope": "A model-based fit can outperform simple Fourier-bin spacing under strong assumptions; that is not assumption-free resolution.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Seismology, radio astronomy, and spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Temporal windows and sampling constrain spectral identification."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-077",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Finite-temperature transitions are read using a zero-temperature spectrum formula",
      "equationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "At finite temperature the response includes transitions among thermally occupied excited states. A system with energies (0,2,3) and an operator coupling the last two states has a thermal line at energy 1, below its ground-state gap 2.",
      "presentation": "Thermally activated low-frequency weight is taken to show a zero-temperature gap closure, or a thermal absence of weight is taken to prove a gap.",
      "diagnostic": "Use the full thermal Lehmann sum and check temperature dependence and detailed-balance conventions.",
      "remedy": "State whether a threshold refers to the ground-state response or finite-temperature response.",
      "scope": "This differs from merely cooling insufficiently: the mathematical response function itself changes.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Infrared and rotational spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Hot-band transitions originate from thermally populated excited levels."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SPECTRAL",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-078",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "A positive gap alone is used to guarantee adiabatic preparation",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Transition suppression depends on the ramp, matrix elements of the time derivative of H, the minimum relevant gap, and endpoint regularity. A nonzero gap at sampled endpoints does not control an unsampled avoided crossing.",
      "presentation": "A fast ramp creates defects or excitations although every measured finite-N static gap was positive.",
      "diagnostic": "Examine the entire protocol, relevant transition matrix elements, and the minimum separation along it.",
      "remedy": "Choose and validate a protocol-specific adiabatic or nonadiabatic control strategy rather than inferring preparation fidelity from one static table.",
      "scope": "Critical crossing and finite-size avoided crossings require different quantitative treatments.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Chemical reaction dynamics and quantum control",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Following an instantaneous mode requires control of rates and couplings, not only its existence."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1995,
          "event": "Zurek reviewed non-equilibrium defect formation across transitions and its cross-domain connections.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S22"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S22"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-079",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Hamiltonian excitation energies are substituted for Liouvillian relaxation rates",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An open quantum system evolves under a superoperator acting on density matrices. Its decay rates depend on dissipators as well as H; a Hamiltonian gap can remain unchanged while relaxation changes drastically.",
      "presentation": "An energy-gap plot is presented as a lifetime or thermalization-time prediction without specifying system–bath coupling.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the generator, its stationary subspace, and the real parts of its relevant nonzero eigenvalues.",
      "remedy": "Calculate the dissipative spectrum and observables with the correct generator and time units.",
      "scope": "A Lindblad generator describes a specified Markovian completely positive dynamics; it is not an automatic model of every environment.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Chemical master equations and driven optics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Relaxation is governed by the evolution generator, which may act in a different state space from H."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1976,
          "event": "Lindblad characterized generators of quantum dynamical semigroups under his hypotheses.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S14"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S14"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-042",
        "QH-011",
        "SPIN-080"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-080",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Markov and secular approximations fail near unresolved level splittings",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A bath-memory approximation and a separation of oscillation frequencies require scale hierarchies. Nearly degenerate transitions can violate a full secular approximation even if system–bath coupling is weak.",
      "presentation": "Predicted relaxation or coherence changes discontinuously when an extremely small splitting is rounded or grouped differently.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare bath correlation times, coupling scales, and differences of Bohr frequencies; examine retained versus discarded coherences.",
      "remedy": "Use an approximation valid for the actual hierarchy or a non-Markovian treatment where necessary.",
      "scope": "This is a conditional model-reduction risk; it does not claim that every weak-coupling master equation fails for the chain.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Multiscale kinetics and resonance theory",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Terms averaged away are negligible only when the assumed frequency separation is real."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-042",
        "QH-011",
        "SPIN-079"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-081",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Floquet quasienergies are ordered like ordinary ground-state energies",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For a periodic drive, quasienergies are defined modulo the drive quantum ℏΩ. Selecting a branch and sorting its numbers does not produce a unique ordinary ground energy.",
      "presentation": "E1−E0 across an arbitrary quasienergy branch cut is called a ground-state mass gap.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the Floquet operator, branch convention, and whether the relevant gap is around zero or the quasienergy-zone boundary.",
      "remedy": "Use a driven-system gap and state-preparation definition appropriate to the observable.",
      "scope": "The supplied static Hamiltonian has ordinary real energies; this issue arises only on transfer to a driven model.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Periodically driven photonics and parametric mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Eigenphases on a circle are not globally ordered real energies."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1965,
          "event": "Shirley formulated a spectral treatment of time-periodic Hamiltonians.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S23"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S23"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-082",
      "category": "Approximation methods, dynamics, and measurement",
      "title": "Non-Hermitian eigenvalue gaps are used as complete stability certificates",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A nonnormal generator can exhibit transient amplification even when all eigenvalues have stable real parts. Non-Hermitian boundary sensitivity can also invalidate a naive periodic-to-open spectral comparison.",
      "presentation": "A large real-part gap is used to guarantee no transient growth, or Bloch bands incorrectly predict the open-system boundary spectrum.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect eigenvector conditioning, singular values, pseudospectra, and the actual boundary problem.",
      "remedy": "Use norm-growth and robustness bounds appropriate to the generator, and a justified non-Bloch analysis where required.",
      "scope": "This is outside the Hermitian TFIM; it demonstrates why a spectral analogy needs additional hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Fluid stability, ecology, and active photonics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Nonnormal linear generators share transient and sensitivity phenomena across these applications."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2018,
          "event": "Yao and Wang analyzed non-Hermitian skin effects and revised bulk–boundary predictions for their model.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S25"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S25"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-036",
        "FORM-006",
        "FORM-007"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-083",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "Generic spectral-gap undecidability is mistaken for undecidability of this chain",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An undecidability theorem for a constructed class of Hamiltonians quantifies over that class. It does not imply that every member or every other model lacks an exact solution.",
      "presentation": "The soluble transverse-field Ising benchmark is declared unknowable because a general spectral-gap decision problem is undecidable.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare dimension, local Hilbert-space size, interaction construction, and promise conditions with the theorem’s exact input family.",
      "remedy": "Use the theorem to limit universal algorithms and retain model-specific exact analysis where available.",
      "scope": "The cited Cubitt–Pérez-García–Wolf result concerns constructed two-dimensional lattice families; it does not settle Yang–Mills independence.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Logic and computational complexity",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A problem class can be undecidable while particular structured instances are decidable."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2015,
          "event": "Cubitt, Pérez-García, and Wolf announced spectral-gap undecidability for a constructed lattice class.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S17"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S17"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-084",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "A stable gap is used to identify every property of the phase",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The gap is only one invariant. Constructed systems can change their ground-state structure beyond a size threshold while retaining a constant spectral gap.",
      "presentation": "Finite-size gap stability is used to certify topology, uniqueness, or the form of the eventual thermodynamic ground state.",
      "diagnostic": "Track the particular phase diagnostic, state degeneracy, correlations, and topology rather than substituting gap stability for all of them.",
      "remedy": "Use each invariant for the property it actually constrains and document finite-size limitations.",
      "scope": "Bausch and collaborators constructed special models; their example is not evidence that the clean spin-one-half Ising chain hides the same effect.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Materials classification and inverse problems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "One stable measured feature does not uniquely determine the system’s full structure."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2015,
          "event": "Bausch and collaborators introduced size-driven quantum phase-transition constructions; publication followed in 2018.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S18"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S18"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-085",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "Dividing the gap by system size manufactures a gapless limit",
      "equationIds": [
        "H0",
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For H0=−hΣXi with h>0, the excitation gap is exactly 2h for every N. The energy-density difference (E1−E0)/N=2h/N nevertheless tends to zero.",
      "presentation": "Convergence of energy densities is taken to imply a vanishing excitation energy.",
      "diagnostic": "Check whether the reported quantity is total energy, energy per site, or a physical excitation frequency.",
      "remedy": "Use extensive energies to define the excitation gap and density quantities for their separate thermodynamic purpose.",
      "scope": "An exact counterexample requiring no interacting calculation.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Thermodynamic chemistry and bulk materials",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A finite localized excitation changes an extensive system’s energy density by an amount that vanishes with volume."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "H0",
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-086",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "A sharp finite-size curve is called a thermodynamic singularity",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For a fixed finite matrix and real finite β, Z=Tr exp(−βH) is a finite positive analytic function of smoothly analytic finite parameters. Sharp finite-system crossovers alone are not an infinite-volume phase singularity.",
      "presentation": "A steep susceptibility peak at N=14 is treated as an actual nonanalytic thermodynamic transition.",
      "diagnostic": "Distinguish finite-temperature finite-size analyticity, zero-temperature level crossings, and the infinite-volume limiting free energy.",
      "remedy": "Analyze the limiting sequence and its nonuniformity instead of assigning a singularity from plot sharpness.",
      "scope": "The analyticity statement does not exclude exact ground-state level crossings at zero temperature or complex-parameter zeros.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Statistical mechanics and complex analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A limit of analytic functions can become nonanalytic when convergence loses the needed uniformity."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1952,
          "event": "Yang and Lee investigated thermodynamic phase transitions through complex-variable methods.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S21"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S21"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-087",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "An infinite-system gap is defined without specifying the state representation",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An infinite spin system is not obtained by literally listing eigenvalues of one finite matrix of ever larger size. The chosen infinite-volume state and representation determine the Hamiltonian generating its excitations.",
      "presentation": "A collapsing finite-volume tunneling splitting is assumed to imply zero excitation gap above a selected pure broken-symmetry vacuum.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the ground state, ground-state sector, local-observable algebra, and the spectral definition used in the infinite system.",
      "remedy": "Relate the finite-volume sequence to the intended infinite-state excitation problem with a theorem or explicit construction.",
      "scope": "The ordered Ising doublet illustrates why global finite-volume spacing and pure-phase excitations need separate language.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Algebraic quantum theory and thermodynamic phases",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Different state representations can encode different sectors of an infinite system."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-088",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "A Lieb–Schultz–Mattis-type obstruction is invoked after its symmetry assumptions are removed",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The mere presence of a spin one-half per site does not reproduce every hypothesis of a particular Lieb–Schultz–Mattis theorem. The transverse field changes the relevant continuous spin symmetries.",
      "presentation": "A unique gapped paramagnetic Ising state is declared impossible solely because there is one spin one-half in each cell.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the exact translation and internal-symmetry representation assumptions of the theorem being used.",
      "remedy": "Use the theorem appropriate to the actual symmetry group, or show the required reduction explicitly.",
      "scope": "The product-state H0 at h>0 is a direct warning against an assumption-free half-spin slogan.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Symmetry and anomaly arguments in field theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Obstructions depend on the symmetry action and representation, not on a name or local dimension alone."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1961,
          "event": "Lieb, Schultz, and Mattis proved a ground-state obstruction for their specified spin-chain setting.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S02"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S02"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-089",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "A near-degenerate pair is assumed to be a protected quantum memory",
      "equationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Small splitting only addresses one coherent energy difference. Local matrix elements, environmental noise, thermal excitations, leakage, and available error correction determine memory performance.",
      "presentation": "The ordered doublet is advertised as immune to decoherence because E1−E0 is exponentially small.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute noise-operator matrix elements in the encoded subspace and analyze leakage and relaxation under a specified noise model.",
      "remedy": "Distinguish symmetry-breaking degeneracy, topological encoding, and operational fault tolerance with their actual assumptions.",
      "scope": "For the audited ordered chain, Z1 has a large matrix element between the two lowest parity states; small splitting does not make that coupling disappear.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum information and magnetic memory",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An energy spectrum alone does not determine sensitivity to every physical error channel."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-C01",
        "SP-S15"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GAP",
        "SPECTRAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "SPIN-090",
      "category": "Scope of structural theorems and cross-field transfers",
      "title": "Finite-range propagation bounds are carried into arbitrary long-range systems",
      "equationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The classic finite-velocity spin-system result assumes finite-range interactions. Long-range couplings need bounds matched to their decay and dimension; the original assumptions cannot simply be deleted.",
      "presentation": "A local-chain light cone is used to guarantee a latency or causal spreading rate for an all-to-all or slowly decaying interaction network.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect the actual interaction graph, strength decay, and constants in the propagation theorem.",
      "remedy": "Apply a theorem for the actual interaction class and keep a mathematical propagation bound separate from a fitted group velocity.",
      "scope": "The nearest-neighbor table falls within a local setting; this warning concerns extension to other substrates.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum simulators, neural networks, and distributed dynamics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Propagation constraints depend on the coupling structure, so visual similarity of networks is insufficient."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1972,
          "event": "Lieb and Robinson established a finite-velocity bound for finite-range quantum spin interactions.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "SP-S20"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "SP-S20"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "spin",
      "componentTitle": "Spin-chain spectra and measurement",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TFIM",
        "SPECTRAL",
        "SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-001",
      "title": "A classical field equation is substituted for a quantum field theory",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Solving the classical Euler–Lagrange equations supplies neither a quantum Hilbert space nor its Hamiltonian spectrum.",
      "presentation": "A smooth connection, instanton, or classical stability calculation is labeled a quantum mass-gap proof.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the actual quantum measure or operator algebra, reconstruction map, vacuum, and domain of H. Ask which theorem constructs each object.",
      "remedy": "State the classical result at its actual level and supply the missing quantum construction before discussing its spectrum.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Semiclassical chemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A stationary classical configuration or energy minimum does not by itself determine the quantized excitation spectrum."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1954,
          "event": "Yang and Mills introduce non-Abelian gauge fields; the official statement separates the resulting classical theory from the quantum existence problem.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S04"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-002",
      "title": "Every finite regulator has a gap, but no uniform positive lower bound survives",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The quantifiers ∀L∃Δ_L>0 and ∃Δ>0∀L are different.",
      "presentation": "A positive first eigenvalue at every simulated volume is used to claim an infinite-volume gap.",
      "diagnostic": "The exact matrices H_N=diag(0,1/N) have positive finite gaps tending to zero. Require a lower bound independent of volume in the target limiting regime.",
      "remedy": "Track the ground-state sector and prove a bound uniform in the regulator/volume variables actually taken to their limits.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Elasticity and waveguides",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Finite boxes can have discrete positive mode spacing while the unbounded-domain spectrum touches zero."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-003",
      "title": "A gap in lattice units is mistaken for a finite nonzero physical mass",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A dimensionless eigenvalue separation and a physical mass have different scaling with lattice spacing.",
      "presentation": "A constant plotted lattice gap is treated as the physical continuum mass without scale setting.",
      "diagnostic": "Write m_phys=Δ_lat/a in a fixed relativistic convention. Test Δ_lat=a, a², and 1: their physical limits differ despite finite positivity.",
      "remedy": "Define units using a physical reference observable and establish finite nonzero renormalized ratios along the continuum trajectory.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Numerical continuum mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Grid-dependent eigenvalues require dimensional rescaling before they describe a mesh-independent frequency or decay rate."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04",
        "MIL-S13"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-004",
      "title": "The existence of the continuum limit is replaced by an extrapolation curve",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Fitting a few cutoffs does not construct limiting correlation distributions or prove consistency of all their moments.",
      "presentation": "A smooth fit of selected observables versus a is presented as existence of the full theory.",
      "diagnostic": "List which distributions converge, in which topology, with what tightness or uniform bounds, and whether all subsequences give compatible limits.",
      "remedy": "Supply convergence estimates and verify the target axioms on the limit; label finite-cutoff extrapolation as numerical evidence.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Stochastic PDEs",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Convergence of a few statistics does not construct a limiting random distribution with the asserted dynamics."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04",
        "MIL-S11"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-005",
      "title": "Noncommuting limits are exchanged without uniform control",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Volume, cutoff, coupling, and long-distance limits can change one another's estimates.",
      "presentation": "A bound derived at fixed cutoff is sent to infinite volume and then reused after a continuum limit without tracking constants.",
      "diagnostic": "The test f(a,L)=aL/(1+aL) has iterated limits 0 and 1 in opposite orders. Write the intended joint scaling and every constant's dependence.",
      "remedy": "Prove a joint bound on the intended parameter region, or establish a theorem authorizing the particular order of limits.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Statistical mechanics and singular perturbations",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Thermodynamic, low-temperature, weak-noise, and long-time limits can select different states when interchanged."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-006",
      "title": "Euclidean positivity is assumed without reflection positivity",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A pointwise positive density is not the operator positivity required to reconstruct a physical Hilbert space.",
      "presentation": "A numerically stable Euclidean measure or action is called unitary after analytic continuation.",
      "diagnostic": "Test the reflection-positive quadratic forms for the relevant observable algebra; record the reflection operation and null-space quotient.",
      "remedy": "Verify the reconstruction hypotheses or state precisely which axiom remains open. Check corrected theorem versions rather than citing a name alone.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Kernel methods and inverse problems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Positive individual kernel entries do not imply positive semidefiniteness of all associated quadratic forms."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1973,
          "event": "Osterwalder and Schrader formulate Euclidean reconstruction conditions.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S11"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1975,
          "event": "Their second paper explicitly extends and corrects the earlier conditions.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S12"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S11",
        "MIL-S12"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-007",
      "title": "The computed gap belongs to an unphysical gauge sector",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Gauge fixing may introduce auxiliary degrees of freedom; their spectra need not equal the physical gauge-invariant spectrum.",
      "presentation": "A propagator pole for a gauge-dependent field, ghost, or constrained coordinate is called the mass of the physical theory.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the physical state space, constraints/quotient, observable algebra, and gauge independence of the asserted quantity.",
      "remedy": "Compute or bound the spectrum in the reconstructed physical sector and show how the proposed observable accesses it.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Constrained mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Eigenmodes of redundant coordinates or Lagrange multipliers can be absent after constraints and gauge equivalence are imposed."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-008",
      "title": "The limiting theory is trivial or different from the target",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A rigorous limit may exist while the interaction vanishes or the limit ceases to be the specified Yang–Mills theory.",
      "presentation": "A convergent Gaussian or degenerate limit is accepted because it is mathematically well-defined.",
      "diagnostic": "Check nontrivial gauge-invariant connected observables, normalization, and agreement with the required local field structure; existence alone is insufficient.",
      "remedy": "State a criterion distinguishing the constructed limit from a trivial theory and prove it survives renormalization.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Effective models",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An approximation may converge perfectly to a simpler model while losing the phenomenon the original model was meant to explain."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-009",
      "title": "Lattice symmetry is treated as exact continuum locality and covariance",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Discrete rotation symmetry and lattice locality do not automatically yield the full target axioms in the limit.",
      "presentation": "An exactly gauge-invariant discretization is assumed to be a fully constructed relativistic theory.",
      "diagnostic": "Audit continuum covariance, locality, regularity, spectral positivity, and reconstruction separately; gauge invariance answers only one question.",
      "remedy": "Prove the required restored symmetries and distributional properties in the continuum limit.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Computational materials science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A mesh can inject anisotropy; a discretization's exact discrete symmetries need not establish isotropic continuum behavior."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04",
        "MIL-S13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-010",
      "title": "Ultraviolet perturbative control is promoted to an infrared mass-gap theorem",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A small-coupling expansion at short distances does not control large-distance nonperturbative behavior.",
      "presentation": "Asymptotic freedom, a beta function, or several perturbative coefficients are used to infer a positive long-distance gap.",
      "diagnostic": "A function e^(−1/g²), extended by zero at g=0, has all Taylor coefficients zero yet is positive for g>0. Perturbative coefficients can miss such scales.",
      "remedy": "Specify the nonperturbative estimate bridging short-distance renormalization to long-distance spectral or correlation control.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Tunneling and rare-event theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Exponentially small effects can be invisible to every finite-order power-series approximation."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1973,
          "event": "Asymptotic freedom becomes a major short-distance result in non-Abelian gauge theory; it does not itself close the mass-gap problem.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S04"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-011",
      "title": "A strong-coupling lattice theorem is moved outside its proven regime",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Convergence domains of expansions are part of their hypotheses; a continuum trajectory need not remain inside them.",
      "presentation": "An area law or exponential decay at strong coupling is extended through an unproved phase or convergence region.",
      "diagnostic": "Locate the parameter domain of every expansion and overlay the proposed continuum scaling path. Inspect whether error bounds remain finite along it.",
      "remedy": "Prove continuation/uniform control into the required regime, or limit the conclusion to the lattice theorem's actual domain.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Chemical perturbation expansions",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A convergent expansion around one interaction regime cannot be used elsewhere without controlling its convergence domain."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1974,
          "event": "Wilson's lattice formulation makes strong-coupling confinement calculations precise while identifying continuum issues.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S13"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-012",
      "title": "Confinement and a vacuum spectral gap are treated as identical statements",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A Wilson-loop asymptotic and a spectral lower bound answer different questions until a bridging theorem supplies the hypotheses.",
      "presentation": "An area-law plot is described as the entire quantum existence-and-gap proof.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the exact observable, source sector, scaling limit, and implication claimed. Check whether the proof constructs the vacuum theory as well as the chosen loop statistic.",
      "remedy": "Prove the needed implication in the actual theory; do not replace one observable criterion with a differently quantified spectral assertion.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Transport and localization",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Suppressed transport and a positive excitation gap are distinct properties; analogy suggests an audit question, not an equivalence theorem."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04",
        "MIL-S13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-013",
      "title": "A selected correlator misses states below its fitted mass",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A chosen operator can have zero overlap with the lowest states, so its decay rate can exceed the true gap.",
      "presentation": "A clean single-exponential fit in one channel is called a lower bound for the full spectrum.",
      "diagnostic": "For H=diag(0,1,2), choose an observable coupling the vacuum only to the energy-2 state. Its correlator decays as e^(−2t) although the gap is 1.",
      "remedy": "Control an appropriate generating/dense observable class, selection rules, and spectral weights; distinguish channel masses from the overall gap.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Selection rules and dark states can conceal lower-energy transitions from a particular probe."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-007",
        "CROSS-035",
        "SPIN-019"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-014",
      "title": "A result for another dimension, group, or matter content is substituted",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Changing dimension, gauge group, supersymmetry, boundary conditions, or matter changes the problem and potentially its infrared physics.",
      "presentation": "An exactly solved lower-dimensional or modified gauge model is presented as the four-dimensional pure-theory solution.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the theorem's full parameter signature with the official target, including the quantified class of compact simple groups.",
      "remedy": "Keep the model result and supply a rigorous reduction or extension that preserves every relevant hypothesis.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Model organisms and surrogate systems",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A surrogate can illuminate a mechanism without proving that the target system has the same behavior."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-ACTION",
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-015",
      "title": "Sampling, fit windows, or finite-volume sectors create an apparent gap",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Autocorrelation, metastable sectors, insufficient temporal extent, or an omitted near-degenerate vacuum can bias a fitted spectrum.",
      "presentation": "The error bar only measures variation among correlated samples, while changes of sector or fit window shift the result.",
      "diagnostic": "Run independent starts, monitor relevant sector transitions, estimate effective sample size, vary volume and fitting windows, and certify eigenvalue residuals where applicable.",
      "remedy": "Report the full numerical uncertainty and sector definition; a fit becomes proof only with explicit rigorous error and limiting bounds.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Molecular dynamics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A trajectory trapped in one metastable basin can yield precise-looking but unrepresentative thermodynamic estimates."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S04",
        "MIL-S13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP",
        "MIL-E-YM-CORRELATION"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "YM-016",
      "title": "A family-level undecidability theorem is used to declare this problem unsolvable",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "No algorithm deciding every member of a specified input family does not imply that an individual instance lacks a proof.",
      "presentation": "Spectral-gap undecidability is cited as forbidding an analytic solution of Yang–Mills or the transverse-field Ising chain.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the reduction's input family, local dimension, geometry, promise, and thermodynamic definition. Demonstrate an actual reduction to the target before transferring the conclusion.",
      "remedy": "Keep undecidability scoped to the proved family; investigate particular structured models on their own terms.",
      "scope": "Four-dimensional quantum Yang–Mills for the official compact simple gauge groups; no disproof or completed construction is claimed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Program verification",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Undecidability of a general verification problem does not prevent proving termination or safety of a particular program."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2015,
          "event": "Cubitt, Perez-Garcia and Wolf announce spectral-gap undecidability for a specified two-dimensional lattice family.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S14"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S14"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-YM-GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-001",
      "title": "The polynomial's quantifiers change with the instance",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A separate exponent, machine, or constant for each input is not one polynomial-time algorithm.",
      "presentation": "The claim says each tested input terminates in polynomial time, but the polynomial depends on that input or its solution.",
      "diagnostic": "Write ∃M,k,C before ∀x. Check whether k or the code/advice varies with n or x; fitting a finite set permits many misleading bounds.",
      "remedy": "Provide one finite algorithm with an all-input correctness proof and a uniform polynomial bound.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Uniform error estimation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Pointwise constants need not yield a bound uniform over an entire family of inputs or physical states."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-002",
      "title": "An exponential brute-force algorithm is mistaken for a lower bound on every algorithm",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP",
        "AUX-SAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The cost of a chosen method is an upper bound on what can be done, not a universal lower bound.",
      "presentation": "Enumerating 2^n assignments is cited as proof that SAT cannot have a faster algorithm.",
      "diagnostic": "For parity, enumerating all assignments is possible but unnecessary: one pass computes it. Identify the quantified class of all competing algorithms.",
      "remedy": "Prove a lower bound for the entire target model, or explicitly limit the claim to the analyzed algorithm.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A slow search implementation does not establish that the optimization task inherently requires that search."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-003",
      "title": "Easy instances or average performance are promoted to worst-case correctness",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP",
        "MIL-E-PNP-WITNESS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Benchmarks and input distributions can omit rare hard or erroneous instances.",
      "presentation": "Near-perfect success on random formulas is reported as P=NP, or poor performance near a phase transition as P≠NP.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the input distribution, failure probability, all-input guarantee, and adversarial cases. A single rejected satisfiable instance defeats an exact SAT solver.",
      "remedy": "Separate heuristic, average-case and worst-case statements; add a certified fallback and count its worst-case cost.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Machine-learning validation",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Strong test-set performance cannot establish correctness under every admissible distribution or adversarial input."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP",
        "MIL-E-PNP-WITNESS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-004",
      "title": "Arithmetic magnitude is confused with encoded input length",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An algorithm polynomial in a number N may be exponential in its binary encoding length log₂N.",
      "presentation": "A dynamic program using O(nW) time is called polynomial without counting the bits needed to encode W.",
      "diagnostic": "Set W=2^n: the value-dependent term becomes exponential in n. Count bit operations and growth of intermediate numbers.",
      "remedy": "State pseudo-polynomial complexity accurately and include representation/precision costs in the proof.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Computational number theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Loops over numerical values and arithmetic on huge integers can hide exponential costs in a short input."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-005",
      "title": "Efficient witness checking is mistaken for efficient witness discovery",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP-WITNESS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The verifier's existential certificate is not an algorithm that finds a certificate or proves none exists.",
      "presentation": "A proposed proof substitutes a satisfying assignment into the formula and concludes that all SAT instances are easy.",
      "diagnostic": "Given only the original instance, identify every step that constructs the witness and detects nonexistence; count those steps.",
      "remedy": "Provide a complete search/decision algorithm, using self-reduction only with a justified polynomial decision subroutine.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Inverse design",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Verifying a candidate design meets constraints can be much easier than finding any feasible design."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1971,
          "event": "Cook's completeness framework formalizes the distinction between polynomial verification and the difficulty of deciding satisfiability.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S05"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP-WITNESS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-006",
      "title": "The direction of a reduction is reversed",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A≤pB lets an algorithm for B solve A; it does not let an algorithm for A solve B.",
      "presentation": "A hard problem can encode an easy one, so solving the easy one is presented as solving the hard one.",
      "diagnostic": "Draw the actual map x↦f(x), the equivalence x∈A iff f(x)∈B, and the direction in which the proposed solver is called.",
      "remedy": "Prove the reduction in the needed direction and compose actual algorithms, not verbal associations.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Scientific identifiability",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A general model can reproduce a special case without the special case solving the full inverse problem."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-007",
      "title": "The reduction or output construction contains an exponential expansion",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Preserving satisfiability is insufficient if the transformed instance has exponential size or takes exponential time to construct.",
      "presentation": "An algorithm is polynomial in an expanded truth table or an enumerated set of constraints that was not part of the input.",
      "diagnostic": "Bound the size and computation cost of f(x) in the original input length; include explicit output, algebraic degrees and precision.",
      "remedy": "Use polynomially bounded representations and prove that downstream operations remain polynomial in the original encoding.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Symbolic algebra and compilation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A compact expression can expand into exponentially many monomials or instructions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-008",
      "title": "Nonuniform advice or infinite precomputation is counted as free",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A separate circuit or lookup table for each input size is not automatically a uniformly constructible algorithm.",
      "presentation": "Every answer is stored in a table, or an optimal circuit exists for each n, and only query time is measured.",
      "diagnostic": "Ask how the table/circuit is generated, how many bits it contains, and whether a single algorithm produces it within the claimed bound.",
      "remedy": "State a nonuniform class such as P/poly when appropriate; prove uniform generation if the conclusion concerns P.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Surrogate modeling",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Cheap inference can conceal an enormous or uncomputable training/precomputation stage."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-009",
      "title": "Randomized success or simulation is converted into deterministic exact decision",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Bounded-error, zero-error expected-time and deterministic worst-case guarantees have different quantifiers.",
      "presentation": "A randomized solver usually succeeds, or its failure probability is small, so it is called a deterministic polynomial solver.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the probability space, per-input guarantee, error type, stopping time, and whether a deterministic seed is constructible.",
      "remedy": "Prove a valid derandomization or retain the randomized class and error statement. Count amplification and verification costs.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Monte Carlo science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A confidence bound or expected runtime is not a deterministic guarantee for every execution."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-010",
      "title": "Quantum speedup or factoring is treated as a classical P versus NP solution",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A quantum computation model differs from the classical one, and factoring is not known to be NP-complete.",
      "presentation": "A polynomial quantum factoring algorithm or a quantum heuristic for optimization is declared to settle P versus NP.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the exact decision language, gate/precision model, success guarantee and any classical simulation or NP-hardness reduction.",
      "remedy": "State the quantum result in its own class and prove any transfer to classical uniform computation.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum simulation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A task's cost depends on the permitted computation model; model changes must be explicit."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1994,
          "event": "Shor's quantum factoring approach provides a historical example of a model-specific speedup; the extended author paper was submitted in 1995.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S18"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05",
        "MIL-S18"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-011",
      "title": "Analog real numbers, precision, or an oracle carry the missing computation",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An exact real parameter or unit-cost operation can encode arbitrarily many answer bits.",
      "presentation": "A physical wave, real constant, or minimization oracle returns an exact solution with no accounting for preparation, noise, or readout.",
      "diagnostic": "Bound the information content, required precision, initialization cost, conditioning, and measurement complexity in input length.",
      "remedy": "Translate to a finite encoded model and include all resource costs; keep idealized analog claims distinct.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Analog computing and inverse sensing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Resolution and conditioning can dominate the apparent simplicity of an ideal continuous computation."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-012",
      "title": "A lower bound for a restricted circuit model is generalized to all algorithms",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Depth, monotonicity, arithmetic operations or circuit architecture restrict the class being ruled out.",
      "presentation": "A monotone or constant-depth lower bound is reported as a lower bound against unrestricted polynomial-time computation.",
      "diagnostic": "List the exact prohibited operations and structural restrictions; exhibit which step depends on them.",
      "remedy": "Prove an extension to the full target model or state the restricted lower bound without enlarging its conclusion.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Neural-network expressivity",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A lower bound for one architecture does not establish a lower bound for every architecture or computational representation."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05",
        "MIL-S16"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-013",
      "title": "A counting argument for hard functions does not identify a hard NP language",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Most Boolean functions can require large circuits while the counted functions lack a succinct uniform verifier.",
      "presentation": "There are more truth tables than small circuits, so an explicit NP-complete problem is declared hard.",
      "diagnostic": "Track where the selected function is shown to belong to NP and how its membership predicate is defined uniformly across lengths.",
      "remedy": "Add explicitness and NP membership to the lower-bound argument; do not infer them from cardinalities.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Information theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Most strings are incompressible, but that counting fact does not certify the complexity of a particular structured string."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S05",
        "MIL-S16"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-014",
      "title": "Relativization is ignored or its barrier is inflated into impossibility",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A method that behaves identically relative to every oracle cannot settle a question whose answer changes between oracle worlds.",
      "presentation": "An oracle proof is treated as an unrelativized proof, or opposite oracle worlds are called proof of independence from ordinary mathematics.",
      "diagnostic": "Locate every oracle-respecting step and compare it with the two oracle constructions; independence from ZFC is a different assertion.",
      "remedy": "Identify a genuinely nonrelativizing ingredient or correctly state the method limitation.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Black-box lower bounds",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A black-box impossibility result can cease to apply when an algorithm exploits the internal structure of its input."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1975,
          "event": "Baker, Gill and Solovay construct oracle worlds with opposite P versus NP outcomes.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S15"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S15"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-015",
      "title": "The natural-proofs barrier is stripped of its hypotheses",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The barrier concerns constructive, large, useful circuit properties under a strong pseudorandomness assumption.",
      "presentation": "The statement becomes 'no proof can ever separate P and NP' or is cited as an unconditional independence theorem.",
      "diagnostic": "Check all three naturalness conditions, circuit class and hardness assumption. Determine whether the proposed method actually satisfies them.",
      "remedy": "Keep the conditional scope explicit; show which condition a candidate method evades rather than claiming all mathematics is blocked.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Cryptographic reductions",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Conditional security and impossibility statements retain their computational assumptions and adversary models."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1997,
          "event": "Razborov and Rudich publish the natural-proofs barrier, conditional on sufficiently strong pseudorandomness.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S16"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S16"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PNP-016",
      "title": "Algebrization is conflated with every algebraic proof or with logical independence",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Access to an oracle and its low-degree extension defines a technical method class; using algebra in a proof is much broader.",
      "presentation": "A proof uses polynomials and is automatically dismissed, or the barrier is presented as a theorem that P versus NP is unprovable.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the algebraic oracle model and identify exactly which proof steps survive its extension.",
      "remedy": "Demonstrate a nonalgebrizing ingredient where required, while retaining the barrier's technical definition.",
      "scope": "Classical deterministic uniform worst-case polynomial time for decision languages unless a different model is explicitly stated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Algebraic algorithm analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A limitation of a formalized technique does not forbid every argument written in the same mathematical vocabulary."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2008,
          "event": "Aaronson and Wigderson formulate algebrization as a barrier beyond ordinary relativization.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S17"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S17"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PNP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-001",
      "title": "Forced and unforced alternatives are silently exchanged",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Clay's unforced regularity alternatives and its admissible forced-breakdown alternatives have different quantifiers.",
      "presentation": "A forced example is dismissed solely because f is nonzero, or it is advertised as a blowup result for f=0.",
      "diagnostic": "Map the theorem to A, B, C or D, recording domain, ν, data, force and claimed conclusion. The announced 2026 theorem explicitly targets C/D.",
      "remedy": "Audit the appropriate alternative. Keep any unresolved f=0 conclusion separate even if a forced alternative is established.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Control theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Autonomous dynamics and driven dynamics are distinct systems; conclusions transfer only with an argument controlling the input."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2026,
          "event": "The announced smooth-forced construction claims alternatives C/D; Clay lists the problem as Active during evaluation.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S31",
            "MIL-S01",
            "MIL-S02"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09",
        "MIL-S31"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-002",
      "title": "A constructed force or initial datum violates the admissibility conditions",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Choosing f to make a singular ansatz satisfy the PDE may simply move the singularity into the prescribed force.",
      "presentation": "Substituting an arbitrary exploding velocity into the equation is presented as an admissible counterexample.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute f, every required derivative, spatial decay/periodicity, compatibility and regularity through the singular time; check the initial datum too.",
      "remedy": "Prove all forcing/data conditions independently. A singular source can be a valid different problem while failing the prize formulation.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Inverse PDE design",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An inverse construction can hide the desired pathology in its control input unless input constraints are checked."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09",
        "MIL-S31"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-003",
      "title": "Existence of a weak solution is confused with smoothness or uniqueness",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Distributional equations, finite energy, the Leray–Hopf inequality, and classical regularity define different classes.",
      "presentation": "A global generalized solution is called a global smooth solution, or nonuniqueness in a broad weak class is declared nonuniqueness among smooth solutions.",
      "diagnostic": "List time continuity, derivatives, initial trace, energy inequality and integrability for both the constructed solution and the target class.",
      "remedy": "State the exact class and prove the regularity or weak–strong uniqueness implication needed for the conclusion.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Continuum mechanics with defects",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Generalized solutions can accommodate oscillation or concentration excluded by classical solution definitions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1934,
          "event": "Leray develops global generalized solutions while distinguishing their existence from everywhere smooth evolution.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S28"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 2017,
          "event": "Buckmaster and Vicol establish nonuniqueness in a specified finite-energy weak class.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S30"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S28",
        "MIL-S30"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-004",
      "title": "Bounded kinetic energy is used as a pointwise or derivative bound",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY",
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An L² norm controls total mass of |u|², not concentration into progressively smaller regions.",
      "presentation": "An energy estimate is declared to rule out all velocity blowup.",
      "diagnostic": "For nonzero smooth compactly supported divergence-free v, v_λ(x)=λv(λx) has ||v_λ||₂=λ^(−1/2)||v||₂ while ||v_λ||∞=λ||v||∞. This is a norm counterexample, not an NS solution.",
      "remedy": "Obtain a continuation-controlling norm or a concentration-exclusion estimate from the PDE; do not infer it from energy alone.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Wave concentration and imaging",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Bounded integrated intensity can coexist with increasingly tall and narrow peaks."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S28",
        "MIL-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY",
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FLUID-005"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-005",
      "title": "An energy hierarchy closes only after assuming the desired regularity",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A derivative estimate may contain an uncontrolled norm whose finiteness is the original problem.",
      "presentation": "Gronwall is invoked on y'(t)≤C||∇u||∞y(t), while integrability of ||∇u||∞ is merely asserted.",
      "diagnostic": "Trace every coefficient in the differential inequality back to known data and already proved norms. Mark circular dependencies explicitly.",
      "remedy": "Prove the coefficient's time integrability independently or state the result as a conditional continuation criterion.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Nonlinear stability theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A stability estimate with an unknown Lipschitz or growth coefficient can assume the stability it purports to prove."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-006",
      "title": "A subcritical-looking bound is misclassified by incorrect scaling",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The amplitude, space and time rescalings jointly determine which norms can see concentration.",
      "presentation": "A bounded norm is called scale-critical after checking only one factor or using a two-dimensional exponent in three dimensions.",
      "diagnostic": "Recompute ||u_lambda||_(L^q_t L^p_x(I)) = lambda^(1-3/p-2/q) ||u||_(L^q_t L^p_x(lambda^2 I)); the time interval must rescale as well (or use all time). Check endpoint assumptions of any cited regularity criterion separately.",
      "remedy": "Use the correct scaling and prove the exact critical/subcritical estimate needed; scaling suggests a criterion but does not prove it.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Turbulence and dimensional analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Incorrect rescaling can turn a vanishing measurement into a false claim of uniform control."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-007",
      "title": "Local existence is repeatedly extended using a shrinking lifespan",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Each restart theorem may provide a lifespan depending on a norm that grows without bound.",
      "presentation": "A local solution is restarted infinitely often and assumed to cover every finite time.",
      "diagnostic": "Track continuation times. Positive increments such as 2^(−j) sum to a finite value, so endlessly many restarts need not reach beyond it.",
      "remedy": "Produce a uniform continuation estimate or prove that the sum of guaranteed time increments diverges.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Adaptive integration and hybrid systems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Infinitely many valid local steps can accumulate at a finite time, a phenomenon related to Zeno behavior."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09",
        "MIL-S28"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-008",
      "title": "Two-dimensional vorticity control is copied into three dimensions",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Three-dimensional vortex stretching changes the vorticity evolution and estimate closure.",
      "presentation": "A maximum-principle or enstrophy argument from planar flow is reused after suppressing a stretching term.",
      "diagnostic": "Derive the curl equation and account for (ω·∇)u in 3D. If symmetry removes it, verify that symmetry is preserved and part of the target.",
      "remedy": "Control the stretching term or clearly restrict the theorem to the symmetric/lower-dimensional class proved.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Magnetohydrodynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Stretching mechanisms in vector-field evolution can destroy estimates valid for scalar transport."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-009",
      "title": "Euler behavior or a singular viscosity limit is treated as a fixed-viscosity theorem",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Letting ν→0 can lose uniform derivative bounds, boundary information or energy control.",
      "presentation": "An inviscid singularity or dissipative weak Euler limit is called blowup for every fixed ν>0.",
      "diagnostic": "Write viscosity dependence of all bounds and convergence topology. Identify whether the claimed singular time and solution class survive at fixed ν.",
      "remedy": "Prove the required uniform-in-ν statements and transfer theorem, or retain the Euler/limit result's actual scope.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Singular perturbation theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A parameter limit can change equation type and create boundary layers or discontinuities absent at each fixed parameter."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09",
        "MIL-S30"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-010",
      "title": "Pressure, boundary terms or the spatial domain disappear during an estimate",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The cancellation of transport and pressure terms depends on incompressibility and admissible boundary/decay conditions.",
      "presentation": "A whole-space estimate is copied to a wall-bounded region, or a periodic argument is used after nonperiodic forcing is introduced.",
      "diagnostic": "Perform the integration by parts including surface terms; solve the correct pressure constraint and inspect zero modes and flux.",
      "remedy": "Use domain-specific pressure and boundary estimates, or prove the transfer between periodic and whole-space constructions.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Electromagnetic and elastic boundary-value problems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Boundary conditions determine which integration identities and constrained potentials are valid."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09",
        "MIL-S31"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-011",
      "title": "Weak convergence is passed through the nonlinear product without compactness",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Weak convergence of u_n does not imply convergence of u_n⊗u_n to u⊗u.",
      "presentation": "A bounded Galerkin sequence is weakly convergent, so its nonlinear limit is asserted to satisfy the target equation without a defect.",
      "diagnostic": "The scalar sequence sin(nx) converges weakly to zero while sin²(nx) converges weakly to 1/2 on a periodic domain. Identify the missing strong compactness or compensated structure.",
      "remedy": "Prove the required product convergence or include and analyze the residual stress/defect measure.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Homogenization and turbulence closure",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Unresolved oscillations can survive as effective stresses even when the mean field converges."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S28",
        "MIL-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-038",
        "FLUID-008"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-012",
      "title": "The energy identity is used where only an inequality or defect balance is justified",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Multiplication by u, integration by parts and time differentiation require regularity; forcing contributes real work.",
      "presentation": "A weak solution is assumed to conserve/dissipate energy exactly, or the term ⟨f,u⟩ is dropped in a forced construction.",
      "diagnostic": "Justify every operation by approximation and passage to the limit; record possible defects and all work/boundary terms.",
      "remedy": "Use the correct inequality in the proved class and supply additional regularity before upgrading to equality.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Shock waves and weak conservation laws",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Generalized solutions may satisfy entropy or energy inequalities rather than the formal smooth identity."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S28",
        "MIL-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-013",
      "title": "A numerical singularity fit is treated as an infinite-resolution proof",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Finite grids, finite time windows and fitting assumptions cannot resolve arbitrarily small scales or exclude alternative asymptotics.",
      "presentation": "A power-law fit to growing vorticity is declared finite-time blowup; a smooth simulation is declared proof of global regularity.",
      "diagnostic": "Vary mesh, time step, precision, dealiasing, domain, fitting window and conservation residuals. A fit's extrapolated singular time is not a theorem.",
      "remedy": "Provide verified error bounds up to the needed regime plus an analytic blowup or continuation criterion; retain simulations as evidence otherwise.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Critical phenomena and material failure",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A finite-range trend can mimic a singular law while crossing over outside the observed range."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S09"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-014",
      "title": "The averaged Navier–Stokes model is substituted for the original nonlinearity",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Sharing energy cancellation does not mean sharing the full nonlocal and geometric structure of the original bilinear operator.",
      "presentation": "Blowup in Tao's modified equation is cited as a counterexample to standard Navier–Stokes.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the operators term by term and mark the averaging transformation; identify the exact theorem that would transfer solutions.",
      "remedy": "Use the modified model to falsify energy-only proof strategies, while preserving the distinction between the two equations.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Reduced-order fluid models",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Two models can obey the same conservation law while having different stability and singularity behavior."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2014,
          "event": "Tao constructs blowup for an averaged equation retaining energy cancellation, exposing a limit of energy-only arguments.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S29"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S29"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-015",
      "title": "Smooth forcing is conflated with analytic forcing or local vanishing",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "C∞ regularity does not imply real analyticity; a theorem with additional core symmetry and Type II bounds is not a universal theorem for all smooth forcing.",
      "presentation": "The 2026 analytic-forcing regularity result is described as refuting every smooth-forced construction.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare forcing class, spatial analyticity uniform in time, core symmetry and anisotropic bounds line by line. The flat function e^(−1/x²), extended by zero, separates C∞ from analytic.",
      "remedy": "Retain all additional hypotheses when applying the regularity theorem; inspect which one an announced construction does or does not satisfy.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Unique continuation and inverse analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Analytic functions and smooth functions permit different continuation and flatness arguments."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2026,
          "event": "Constantin, Ignatova and Vicol prove regularity under analytic forcing plus specified asymptotic structure.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S32"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S32",
        "MIL-S31"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "NS-016",
      "title": "An announcement, formalization label or institutional category is treated as a completed verification",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A manuscript's theorem, a machine-checked fragment, and acceptance of the complete theorem are different evidence objects.",
      "presentation": "'Active' becomes 'Solved'; a proof-assistant build is assumed to verify all analytic constructions and hypotheses.",
      "diagnostic": "Pin the manuscript version, theorem statement, dependency graph and any formal artifact. For formal work inspect axioms, admitted lemmas, trusted code and equivalence to the paper's claim.",
      "remedy": "Report what was actually checked. Keep proof validation, journal/field acceptance and Clay prize eligibility distinct.",
      "scope": "Three-dimensional incompressible Navier–Stokes. Exact Clay alternative and solution/data/force class must accompany every claim.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Safety-critical software assurance",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A certified component or successful build does not verify an entire system unless all assumptions and interfaces are covered."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S01",
        "MIL-S02",
        "MIL-S03",
        "MIL-S31"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-001",
      "title": "The defining Dirichlet series is evaluated outside its convergence region",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A meromorphic continuation can exist where the original series no longer represents it by ordinary summation.",
      "presentation": "Termwise positivity or a numerical partial sum in the critical strip is presented as an identity for ζ(s).",
      "diagnostic": "Record Re(s)>1 for the displayed series; test s=0, where ordinary Σ1 diverges although continuation is finite.",
      "remedy": "Use a valid continuation formula with explicit truncation and remainder bounds; state any alternative summation convention.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Perturbative field theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A resummed or analytically continued object need not equal the ordinary sum of its original expansion outside convergence."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1859,
          "event": "Riemann's treatment makes analytic continuation and the critical strip central to the prime-counting problem.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S06"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-002",
      "title": "An Euler product is used where it does not converge absolutely",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Nonvanishing of each finite factor is insufficient to control a divergent or vanishing infinite product.",
      "presentation": "Since no factor is zero, the argument declares ζ nonzero throughout the critical strip.",
      "diagnostic": "For comparison, every factor 1/2 is nonzero but the product of n factors tends to zero. Specify the product's convergence theorem and domain.",
      "remedy": "Keep Euler-product arguments within their justified domain or use a rigorously continued representation.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Reliability and statistical mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Positive component factors can accumulate into a vanishing infinite-system probability or partition factor."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-003",
      "title": "Reflection and conjugation symmetry are mistaken for confinement of zeros to the symmetry axis",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A symmetric zero set can contain off-axis pairs or quartets.",
      "presentation": "The functional equation and conjugation relation alone are presented as the final step proving Re(ρ)=1/2.",
      "diagnostic": "Choose a=1/4+i and form P(s)=(s−a)(s−conj(a))(s−(1−a))(s−(1−conj(a))). Its roots are symmetric but off the line. This is a counterexample to the inference, not to RH.",
      "remedy": "Identify the additional positivity, spectral, or analytic constraint that excludes symmetric off-line configurations.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Crystallography and symmetric dynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An invariant set may consist of symmetry-related points away from a fixed-point locus."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-001"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-004",
      "title": "Zeros, poles, trivial factors or another L-function are merged into one target",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Multiplication by gamma or polynomial factors changes apparent zeros/poles and requires cancellation analysis.",
      "presentation": "Trivial zeros, the pole at 1, or a Dirichlet L-function result is counted as proving or refuting zeta RH.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the exact completed function, its domain, singularities and cancellations; identify which zeros correspond to nontrivial ζ zeros.",
      "remedy": "Track the divisor of every transformation and keep each L-function's conductor, character and functional equation explicit.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Transfer functions and resonance analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Changing a representation by multiplying factors can create or cancel poles and zeros unless equivalence is verified."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-005",
      "title": "Finite-height verification is generalized to infinitely many zeros",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An arbitrarily large finite verified range leaves an unbounded unexamined region.",
      "presentation": "A rigorous computation of many zeros is described as a universal proof.",
      "diagnostic": "State the certified height T and what theorem controls all t>T. A universal statement cannot follow solely from a finite prefix without extra structure.",
      "remedy": "Retain the finite theorem and supply an independent all-height argument.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Model checking",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Bounded verification needs an induction, invariant or completeness threshold before it becomes unbounded verification."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2020,
          "event": "Platt and Trudgian report rigorous verification up to height 3·10^12, an explicitly finite result.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S19"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S19"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-006",
      "title": "Locating plausible zeros is confused with certifying that no zeros were missed",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Floating-point roots or sign changes alone do not necessarily count all roots, multiplicities or off-line zeros.",
      "presentation": "A list of numerically accurate critical-line zeros is treated as an exhaustive zero inventory.",
      "diagnostic": "Use interval bounds, a rigorous argument-principle/Turing-type count, endpoint control and multiplicity handling; compare located and certified totals.",
      "remedy": "Publish both existence certificates for located zeros and an independent completeness count over the stated region.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Computational spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A solver can find many eigenvalues while missing clustered, weakly coupled or numerically ill-conditioned modes."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S19",
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-007",
      "title": "The argument principle omits boundary zeros, poles or contour contributions",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A zero-count formula requires a valid contour and all poles counted with signs and multiplicities.",
      "presentation": "A contour integral is rounded to an integer after ignoring a near-boundary zero or a pole.",
      "diagnostic": "Prove the function is nonzero on the contour, bound the integrand, list enclosed poles, and fix the branch convention.",
      "remedy": "Move/deform the contour with justified residue accounting and rigorously enclose the resulting count.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Control-system stability",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Nyquist-style counts fail when contour hypotheses, imaginary-axis roots or pole contributions are omitted."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06",
        "MIL-S19"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-008",
      "title": "A formally symmetric differential expression is declared self-adjoint without a domain",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Self-adjointness is a property of an operator together with its domain, boundary conditions and closure.",
      "presentation": "Integration by parts appears symmetric, so a proposed zeta operator is asserted to have a real spectrum.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the dense domain, adjoint domain and boundary form. Check essential self-adjointness or the selected self-adjoint extension.",
      "remedy": "Prove the operator-theoretic statement on the actual Hilbert space before deriving spectral reality.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Quantum mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Different self-adjoint extensions of the same differential expression can have different spectra and physical interpretations."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-009",
      "title": "A self-adjoint operator lacks a proven exact correspondence with zeta zeros",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Real eigenvalues do not say anything about ζ unless a rigorous spectral identity identifies every relevant zero.",
      "presentation": "An attractive Hamiltonian or matching sequence is offered as a Hilbert–Pólya solution.",
      "diagnostic": "Check completeness, multiplicity, normalization and the identity mapping spectral data to ξ(s). Fitting finitely many ordinates is insufficient.",
      "remedy": "Prove the determinant/trace/spectral correspondence without assuming RH in its construction.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Inverse spectral problems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Matching selected eigenvalues does not identify the full operator or certify equality of complete spectra."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-010",
      "title": "Random-matrix statistics are promoted to pointwise zero-location theorems",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Agreement of spacings or correlation statistics does not constrain every individual zero.",
      "presentation": "A close statistical match is called proof that no exceptional off-line zero exists.",
      "diagnostic": "Ask whether the statistic was computed only from zeros already on the line and whether its theorem excludes exceptional sets.",
      "remedy": "State the statistical evidence separately and provide a deterministic argument for the universal location claim.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Statistical physics and signal analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A distributional fit can tolerate rare exceptions that invalidate a universal statement."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-011",
      "title": "Density one, infinitely many, or a positive proportion becomes every zero",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A set can have density zero while still containing infinitely many counterexamples.",
      "presentation": "A theorem placing most zeros on the line is treated as eliminating all remaining zeros.",
      "diagnostic": "The square numbers form an infinite density-zero subset of the positive integers. Explicitly quantify the exceptional set remaining after the theorem.",
      "remedy": "Supply an argument ruling out even one exception, rather than only controlling its density.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Ergodic theory and population studies",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Almost-everywhere or asymptotic-frequency claims do not automatically become everywhere claims."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-012",
      "title": "A positivity criterion is verified on too few test functions or coefficients",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An equivalent positivity statement may quantify over an infinite test class; finite samples do not establish it.",
      "presentation": "A finite matrix, first several coefficients, or chosen basis elements are positive, so the whole criterion is declared proved.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the full quantified class and closure topology. In ℓ², diag(1,…,1,−1,1,…) passes all earlier coordinate tests but has a negative direction.",
      "remedy": "Prove positivity uniformly on a dense class with continuity and all required constraints, or certify a complete finite-dimensional reduction.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Moment problems and kernel learning",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Finite principal blocks can miss a negative direction appearing later in an infinite operator."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-013",
      "title": "An exchange of sums, limits, integrals or derivatives lacks domination",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Conditional convergence or nonuniform convergence can invalidate otherwise plausible algebra.",
      "presentation": "A proof differentiates a series in the critical strip or interchanges a contour integral and prime sum without a bound.",
      "diagnostic": "Name the theorem authorizing each exchange and verify its integrable majorant, uniform convergence or distributional interpretation.",
      "remedy": "Work first in an absolutely convergent region, establish continuation carefully, and retain explicit remainder estimates.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Statistical field theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Formal rearrangements of infinite expansions can change their value or leave their domain of validity."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-014",
      "title": "Logarithm branches and residues are suppressed during analytic continuation",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The logarithm of a function with zeros is multivalued; contour deformation can cross singularities.",
      "presentation": "A globally smooth log ζ is assumed in a region whose zero-freeness is exactly what must be proved.",
      "diagnostic": "Track branch cuts, winding numbers and zero/pole crossings. Check whether defining the logarithm already assumes the desired zero-free region.",
      "remedy": "Use local branches on proved zero-free domains or account explicitly for jumps and residues.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Geometric phase and complex response theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Locally valid phases need not glue to a single-valued global phase around singularities."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-015",
      "title": "An equivalent criterion or prime-error estimate is assumed in disguise",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Rewriting RH as positivity, an arithmetic inequality or a sharp remainder estimate does not make the missing estimate established.",
      "presentation": "An intermediate lemma already implies RH, but the text treats it as an elementary bound.",
      "diagnostic": "Build a dependency graph and check each lemma against known equivalences. Test whether a cited result is conditional on RH.",
      "remedy": "Prove the decisive lemma independently, or report the result as an equivalence/conditional implication rather than a solution.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Causal modeling and inverse problems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A reformulated assumption can re-enter an argument as if it were newly inferred evidence."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA",
        "MIL-E-RH-XI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "RH-016",
      "title": "The de Bruijn–Newman inequality is reversed or an outdated energy estimate is reused",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-NEWMAN"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A lower bound Λ≥0 does not provide the upper bound Λ≤0 equivalent to RH; proof-version changes may alter boundary estimates.",
      "presentation": "The nonnegativity theorem is said to prove RH, or a heat-flow proof omits boundary terms noted in a later revision.",
      "diagnostic": "Write both inequalities explicitly; Λ=1 satisfies nonnegativity but not the RH condition. Track the 2021 correction to the energy argument if reusing that method.",
      "remedy": "Seek the missing upper bound, and use the corrected theorem version with all boundary contributions.",
      "scope": "The Riemann zeta function and all its nontrivial zeros. Similar statements for other L-functions require their own hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Bifurcation and stability thresholds",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Knowing a threshold lies above a reference value does not show it lies below that value."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2018,
          "event": "Rodgers and Tao prove nonnegativity of the de Bruijn–Newman constant.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S20"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 2021,
          "event": "Their revision corrects the treatment of boundary energy contributions without turning the result into RH.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S20"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S20"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RH-NEWMAN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-001",
      "title": "An integral counterexample is mistaken for a counterexample over the rationals",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE",
        "AUX-RATIONAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Changing Z to Q changes which multiples and denominators are allowed; known integral obstructions do not settle the rational conjecture.",
      "presentation": "Atiyah–Hirzebruch counterexamples are announced as a disproof of the Millennium Hodge problem.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the coefficient ring in every group and cycle map. Identify whether the obstruction survives tensoring with Q.",
      "remedy": "Keep the integral theorem and audit the rationalized target separately.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Integer optimization and lattice theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A system may have a rational solution while having no integral solution; relaxing coefficients changes the problem."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1962,
          "event": "Atiyah and Hirzebruch publish obstructions to the integral formulation; the rational projective question remains distinct.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S21",
            "MIL-S07"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07",
        "MIL-S21"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-002",
      "title": "Torsion information is inferred from de Rham or complex cohomology",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Tensoring with a characteristic-zero field kills torsion, so differential-form calculations can erase the obstruction under study.",
      "presentation": "A zero de Rham class is treated as a zero integral class, or a differential-form equality is claimed to certify all integral cycle data.",
      "diagnostic": "The nonzero element of Z/2 becomes zero after tensoring with Q. Compute the integral group and torsion maps explicitly.",
      "remedy": "Use integral cohomology/cohomology operations for integral claims and avoid reconstructing erased information from real forms.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Topological phases and lattice charges",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Discrete torsion invariants can be invisible to continuous differential-form measurements."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S21",
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-003",
      "title": "A compact-Kähler counterexample is imported into the projective conjecture",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Projectivity is a substantive hypothesis; the Kähler category is larger.",
      "presentation": "Voisin's failed Kähler extension is summarized as disproving rational Hodge for smooth projective varieties.",
      "diagnostic": "Check whether the constructed manifold admits the required projective structure and compare the cycle-generation statement in the actual theorem.",
      "remedy": "Preserve the author's geometric category. Correct generated summaries against the primary theorem.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Model-class generalization",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A counterexample in a larger model class does not refute a theorem restricted to a smaller class."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2002,
          "event": "Voisin gives a counterexample to an extension involving compact Kähler varieties.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S22"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S22"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-071",
        "FORM-010"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-004",
      "title": "Being closed or of Hodge type is treated as constructing an algebraic cycle",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The analytic necessary condition does not supply the algebraic subset or rational combination sought by the conjecture.",
      "presentation": "A harmonic representative of type (p,p) is exhibited and labeled the desired algebraic cycle.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the actual codimension-p algebraic subvarieties and rational coefficients; a form or cohomology class is not that construction.",
      "remedy": "Supply a cycle with a certified equality of cohomology classes, or state the result as a Hodge-type calculation.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Inverse geometry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Satisfying necessary field constraints does not construct an object whose invariant realizes them."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-005",
      "title": "Arbitrary complex or real (p,p) classes replace rational Hodge classes",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The target includes rationality in cohomology; the full complex (p,p) subspace is usually a different set.",
      "presentation": "A dimension calculation in H^(p,p)(X,C) is used to claim every element is a rational combination of algebraic cycle classes.",
      "diagnostic": "Given a nonzero rational class α, the class sqrt(2)α illustrates why real scalar multiplication need not preserve rationality.",
      "remedy": "Intersect the Hodge subspace with rational cohomology exactly, including an explicit comparison map.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Rational reconstruction",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A real vector space and its rational lattice cannot be identified from dimension alone."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-006",
      "title": "Numerical periods are treated as exact rationality or exact Hodge type",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Finite-precision integration cannot by itself distinguish an exact zero or rational relation from an extremely small nonzero value.",
      "presentation": "A near-zero period or an integer-relation algorithm produces a purported algebraic Hodge class without certification.",
      "diagnostic": "Bound quadrature and conditioning errors, record denominator limits, and distinguish candidate relations from exact identities.",
      "remedy": "Provide exact algebraic/analytic certificates or a rigorous exclusion interval with stated bounds.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Experimental mathematics and spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A close numerical resonance can suggest an exact relation without proving it."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-007",
      "title": "The codimension-one theorem is extended to arbitrary codimension",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The line-bundle/first-Chern-class mechanism in degree two does not automatically generate higher-codimension cycles.",
      "presentation": "A proof invokes the Lefschetz (1,1) theorem for a class in H^(2p) with p>1.",
      "diagnostic": "Check the cohomological degree, codimension, and exact surjectivity theorem used. Products of known divisors need not span the whole target without proof.",
      "remedy": "Prove generation in the specific higher degree, or confine the result to divisors.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Higher-order inverse reconstruction",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Reconstructing first-order features does not establish that all higher-order structures are generated by them."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-008",
      "title": "A topological or smooth cycle is substituted for an algebraic cycle",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Poincaré duality and singular homology provide topological representatives, not necessarily algebraic subvarieties.",
      "presentation": "A chain, smooth submanifold or numerical mesh representing the cohomology class is called an algebraic solution.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect defining polynomial equations and the algebraic category of every proposed component.",
      "remedy": "Supply algebraic representatives and the required class equality; keep topological representability as a weaker result.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Geometric modeling",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A surface with the correct topology need not satisfy a specified algebraic realization constraint."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07",
        "MIL-S21"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-009",
      "title": "Only smooth irreducible representatives are allowed even though the conjecture permits singular cycles",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Adding an unnecessary smoothness restriction can create a harder or false surrogate problem.",
      "presentation": "A failed search for smooth subvarieties is described as an obstruction to all algebraic cycles.",
      "diagnostic": "Read the actual allowed objects: finite combinations of codimension-p algebraic subvarieties may include singular components.",
      "remedy": "Allow the full cycle category, and distinguish any stronger smooth-representative conjecture from the target.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Optimization with relaxed feasible sets",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Failure in an artificially restricted feasible set says nothing about feasibility in the larger permitted set."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07",
        "MIL-S21"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-010",
      "title": "Effectivity or integer coefficients are demanded where signed rational combinations are allowed",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An algebraic cycle class in the conjecture can be a rational linear combination, not necessarily one positive geometric object.",
      "presentation": "A class outside an effective cone is called nonalgebraic even though signed combinations may represent it.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the proposed coefficient constraints and compare them with CH^p(X)⊗Q. Separate the effective cone from its rational span.",
      "remedy": "Search or prove in the full permitted vector space, and label stronger positivity constraints explicitly.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Convex geometry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Membership in a span differs from membership in the positive cone generated by the same vectors."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-011",
      "title": "Matching dimensions is used without proving the cycle map's rank",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Two spaces can have equal dimension while the linear map between them is zero or non-surjective.",
      "presentation": "A dimension count of candidate cycle families and Hodge classes is presented as proof of surjectivity.",
      "diagnostic": "The zero map Q→Q has equal-dimensional source and target but is not surjective. Compute the actual image or a nonzero determinant/minor.",
      "remedy": "Establish independence and spanning of the cycle classes under the specified map.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "System identification",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The number of sensors can match the number of unknowns while the measurement matrix remains rank-deficient."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-012",
      "title": "Algebraicity of a Hodge locus is confused with algebraicity of a representing cycle",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A theorem about the parameter values where a class has Hodge type does not supply a cycle on each fiber.",
      "presentation": "Cattani–Deligne–Kaplan is cited as directly proving Hodge by showing a locus is algebraic.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify whether the theorem concerns a subset of the moduli/base space or a cycle inside the fiber. They are different geometric objects.",
      "remedy": "Add the missing realization theorem for classes on the fibers; preserve the parameter-locus conclusion.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Bifurcation theory",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Characterizing the parameter set where a necessary condition holds does not construct the sought solution at each parameter."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1994,
          "event": "Cattani, Deligne and Kaplan circulate their Hodge-locus result, published in 1995.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S23"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S23"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-013",
      "title": "Algebraicity in a special fiber is transferred across a family without controlling Hodge type",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A transported cohomology class can cease to be of type (p,p), and cycles can specialize or deform unevenly.",
      "presentation": "A cycle on one member of a family is assumed to yield the desired cycle on every nearby member.",
      "diagnostic": "Track the local system, parallel transport, Hodge filtration and actual relative cycle. Distinguish specialization from deformation.",
      "remedy": "Prove the cycle extends in the family and its transported class remains in the target Hodge locus.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Parameterized inverse problems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A solution at one parameter need not continue when constraints or solution dimensions change."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S23",
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-014",
      "title": "A singular, noncompact, or positive-characteristic variant is silently substituted",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The ordinary pure Hodge decomposition and cycle statement have specific hypotheses; changing the category can require different theories.",
      "presentation": "A singular variety calculation, a noncompact example, or a finite-field analogue is described as settling the complex smooth projective problem.",
      "diagnostic": "Record smoothness, compact/projective status, base field, cohomology theory and comparison theorem for every object.",
      "remedy": "State the variant accurately and prove a legitimate reduction to the target rather than transferring vocabulary alone.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Boundary-value and singular-space analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Theorems on compact smooth domains can change when singularities, boundaries or coefficient fields are introduced."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-015",
      "title": "Cohomological surjectivity is conflated with equality or uniqueness in the Chow group",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The conjecture asks for some preimage under the cycle-class map, not an inverse map or uniqueness of the representing cycle.",
      "presentation": "Finding homologous but distinct cycles is treated as a contradiction, or rational equivalence is assumed from matching cohomology.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate rational equivalence, homological equivalence and numerical equivalence. A map can be surjective while having a large kernel.",
      "remedy": "Prove only the needed image statement and track which equivalence relation each calculation establishes.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Inverse problems with nonuniqueness",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Existence of a preimage and identifiability of that preimage are different questions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "HOD-016",
      "title": "A bounded search over degrees or equations is interpreted as nonexistence",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "No general search cutoff follows merely from having failed to find a cycle of low degree.",
      "presentation": "A symbolic search exhausts a finite catalogue and declares a rational Hodge class nonalgebraic.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify degree, coefficient-height and component-count bounds. Ask for a theorem showing every representing cycle could be chosen inside them.",
      "remedy": "Treat the search as a bounded result; prove an effective completeness bound before drawing a universal negative conclusion.",
      "scope": "Rational Hodge classes on smooth projective complex varieties, with codimension and coefficient ring fixed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Chemical structure search",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Failure to find a structure in a finite catalogue does not rule out structures outside its size or complexity limits."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S07"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-HODGE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-001",
      "title": "The object is singular, has the wrong base field, or is not an elliptic curve",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A cubic equation alone does not establish a nonsingular genus-one curve with the required rational base point.",
      "presentation": "A singular cubic, a curve over another field or a higher-dimensional variety is entered into the elliptic-curve BSD formula unchanged.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute the discriminant, specify the base field and group identity, and verify the model's nonsingularity.",
      "remedy": "Use the correct object and conjecture, or prove a reduction preserving its arithmetic data.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Algebraic model identification",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A familiar equation shape can hide a degenerate or categorically different object with different invariants."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-002",
      "title": "Point counts over finite fields are treated as the rank of rational points",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL",
        "AUX-EC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "#E(F_p) and rank E(Q) belong to different groups; local counts enter an L-function rather than directly giving the free rational rank.",
      "presentation": "A large number of points modulo p is described as evidence of a large rational rank without the missing analytic/global argument.",
      "diagnostic": "Label the field on every point and group operation. Identify the theorem relating the observed finite local data to a certified global rank.",
      "remedy": "Compute local factors accurately, then establish independent algebraic and analytic information with quantified bounds.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Local-to-global inverse reconstruction",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Measurements of projections or reductions need a reconstruction theorem before they identify a global invariant."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-003",
      "title": "The good-prime Euler factor is applied at bad reduction",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The degree-two expression using p+1−#E(F_p) assumes good reduction; bad local factors require reduction-type information.",
      "presentation": "One formula is used for every prime, producing a plausible but incorrect L-function or leading constant.",
      "diagnostic": "Factor the discriminant/conductor, determine reduction type and minimal models, and verify every bad-prime factor separately.",
      "remedy": "Use the correct local conventions and include Tamagawa data when testing the refined formula.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Piecewise physical regimes",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A constitutive rule valid in a regular regime may require different terms at singular or defective sites."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-004",
      "title": "The raw Euler product is evaluated at s=1 without a justified continuation",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The value and order at the central point concern the analytically continued L-function, not an uncontrolled product truncation.",
      "presentation": "A finite product at s=1 appears small or divergent and is used as a rank certificate.",
      "diagnostic": "State the representation's domain and the error bound for evaluating L and its derivatives near 1.",
      "remedy": "Use a rigorously valid analytic continuation or approximate functional equation with certified truncation errors.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Spectral zeta methods",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A regularized/continued value can differ from naive truncations of the original series or product."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08",
        "MIL-S26"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LOCAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-005",
      "title": "Near-zero floating-point derivatives are interpreted as exact vanishing order",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A small computed derivative can reflect cancellation, precision loss or a genuinely tiny nonzero value.",
      "presentation": "Several decimal zeros are reported as an analytic rank, or the first visible nonzero derivative is assumed to establish all previous vanishings.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute rigorous enclosures and distinguish proving nonzero from proving exactly zero; record functional-equation constraints and theorem-based vanishing information.",
      "remedy": "Certify an analytic lower and upper bound using exact identities and rigorous error control.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Numerical bifurcation analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A nearly vanishing determinant or derivative need not be exactly zero, especially near ill-conditioned configurations."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-006",
      "title": "Found rational points are counted without proving independence",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Finding r distinct points gives no rank-r certificate if they are torsion or integer combinations of fewer generators.",
      "presentation": "A list of many rational points is called a basis of E(Q).",
      "diagnostic": "Compute torsion status and canonical-height pairings or an exact descent certificate for linear independence.",
      "remedy": "Report a certified independent subgroup as a lower bound until an upper bound and saturation are established.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Experimental design and linear algebra",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Many observations or vectors can be redundant; cardinality is not rank."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-007",
      "title": "The Selmer bound is equated with the Mordell–Weil rank",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A Selmer group incorporates possible Tate–Shafarevich contributions as well as rational points.",
      "presentation": "The dimension of a p-Selmer group is simply declared to be the number of independent rational generators.",
      "diagnostic": "Use the exact sequence 0→E(Q)/pE(Q)→Sel_p(E)→Sha(E)[p]→0, including rational p-torsion. Identify which term is independently controlled.",
      "remedy": "Combine certified points, descent, torsion and Sha information; retain a rank interval if the bounds do not meet.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Obstruction theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A space of locally admissible candidates can be larger than the space of globally realizable solutions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08",
        "MIL-S25"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-008",
      "title": "Torsion is mistaken for free rank or omitted from the leading coefficient",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Finite-order points contribute to E(Q)_tors but not to the Z-rank; the refined formula uses torsion differently.",
      "presentation": "An order-two point increases the claimed rank, or the torsion denominator is absent from a numerical BSD check.",
      "diagnostic": "Decompose the finitely generated group into free and torsion parts and certify finite orders exactly.",
      "remedy": "Use free generators for the regulator and the complete torsion subgroup in the normalization.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Finite and continuous invariants",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Discrete finite-order information and independent unbounded directions are distinct algebraic components."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1922,
          "event": "Mordell's finite-generation theorem supplies the group-theoretic foundation for the rational rank; the official BSD statement recounts this predecessor.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S08"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-009",
      "title": "An independent subgroup is assumed saturated, corrupting the regulator",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Independent points may generate a subgroup of finite index I>1 in the full free group.",
      "presentation": "A height determinant of found points is inserted as the full regulator with no saturation certificate.",
      "diagnostic": "For a subgroup of index I, its regulator is I² times the full regulator. Audit possible divisibility and saturation at all relevant primes. For example, replacing a rank-one generator P by 2P multiplies the height regulator by 4.",
      "remedy": "Certify a Mordell–Weil basis or retain the subgroup index as an explicit unknown factor.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Lattice metrology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An independent lattice basis for a sublattice can have the wrong fundamental volume for the full lattice."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-010",
      "title": "Inconsistent periods, models or local constants create a false match or mismatch",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The refined formula combines quantities whose normalization depends on consistent choices.",
      "presentation": "A numerical discrepancy is announced as a BSD counterexample after mixing real periods, nonminimal differentials and local factors.",
      "diagnostic": "Record the differential, minimal model, real-component convention, regulator basis, Tamagawa numbers and torsion normalization.",
      "remedy": "Recompute every factor in one documented convention before interpreting the ratio.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Dimensional analysis and calibration",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A product of correctly measured quantities can still be wrong when their units or normalization conventions differ."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-011",
      "title": "Finiteness or order of Sha is assumed because a numerical quotient looks integral",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The refined conjectural formula contains #Sha; using it to infer that number cannot independently verify the formula.",
      "presentation": "An apparent integer ratio is declared a computed Sha order and then substituted back as a proof of BSD.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify an independent finiteness/order theorem or certificate. Mark values deduced using BSD as conditional predictions.",
      "remedy": "Separate unconditional arithmetic certificates from conjecture-dependent values and avoid circular verification.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Inverse parameter estimation",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Fitting an unknown parameter to force an equation to hold does not validate the equation independently."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08",
        "MIL-S25"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-012",
      "title": "Modularity is treated as the entire rank theorem",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Modularity gives powerful analytic structure to L(E,s), but it does not identify its central vanishing order with every algebraic rank.",
      "presentation": "The theorem that every E/Q is modular is said to prove BSD for every curve.",
      "diagnostic": "Locate the missing link between the resulting analytic L-function and generators/Sha data for the specific curve or arbitrary rank.",
      "remedy": "Use modularity as an input and prove the additional rank and leading-term statements separately.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Interoperability of mathematical representations",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Showing two representations describe the same object does not automatically compute every invariant of that object."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2001,
          "event": "Breuil, Conrad, Diamond and Taylor establish modularity for all elliptic curves over Q.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S26"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S26",
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-013",
      "title": "Low-rank Heegner-point results are extrapolated to arbitrary rank",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The hypotheses and mechanisms of established rank-zero/rank-one results do not automatically cover higher analytic rank or the full refined formula.",
      "presentation": "Gross–Zagier/Kolyvagin are cited as if no rank, sign, auxiliary-field or local conditions remain.",
      "diagnostic": "Quote the exact theorem used and check each hypothesis; distinguish a rank equality from finiteness or a complete leading-coefficient identity.",
      "remedy": "Keep the proven range explicit and identify the new mechanism needed outside it.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Perturbation and induction",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A mechanism verified in the first cases does not establish a general induction step."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1986,
          "event": "Gross and Zagier relate Heegner heights to L-series derivatives.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S24"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1988,
          "event": "Kolyvagin establishes arithmetic consequences for specified classes using an Euler-system mechanism.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S25"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S24",
        "MIL-S25",
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-014",
      "title": "Functional-equation parity is interpreted as an exact rank",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The root number constrains parity of the analytic order, not its exact size.",
      "presentation": "Root number −1 is called proof of rank exactly one; sign +1 is called proof of rank zero.",
      "diagnostic": "For a local analytic function around the center, odd symmetry allows orders 1,3,5,…; even symmetry allows 0,2,4,…. This directly constrains analytic rank; any transfer to algebraic rank needs its own justified theorem.",
      "remedy": "Combine the parity information with independent lower and upper bounds; do not infer equality from parity alone.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Symmetry-constrained bifurcations",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A symmetry can force the parity of an expansion without fixing the first nonzero coefficient."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-015",
      "title": "Average rank or a positive-proportion theorem becomes a theorem for every curve",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Population averages and density results permit exceptional families and individual exceptions.",
      "presentation": "A positive proportion satisfying BSD or a low average rank is described as settling the conjecture universally.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the ordering by height, the family, the limiting measure and the exceptional set not controlled by the theorem.",
      "remedy": "Report the quantified population result and seek a separate all-curve argument.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Population statistics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An average and a universal pointwise bound have different quantifiers and allow different exceptions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2015,
          "event": "Bhargava and Shankar publish average Selmer and positive-proportion rank-zero results with explicit family/ordering structure.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S27"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S27"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BSD-016",
      "title": "Local solubility or a bounded point search is interpreted as a complete global certificate",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Local compatibility does not automatically produce a rational point on a covering; failure to find points up to a height does not prove none exist.",
      "presentation": "A descent covering passes local tests, so it is declared globally soluble, or a finite search is declared a proof of rank zero.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate local tests, global point construction, covering obstructions and proven height bounds. Identify where Sha may intervene.",
      "remedy": "Produce a global certificate or a complete descent/height-bound argument; retain unresolved coverings and unsearched heights explicitly.",
      "scope": "Elliptic curves over Q, with a specified nonsingular model and consistently normalized arithmetic invariants.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Constraint satisfaction and arithmetic geometry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Every local subsystem can be feasible while the global compatibility problem remains obstructed."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S08",
        "MIL-S25"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-BSD-RANK",
        "MIL-E-BSD-LEAD"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-001",
      "title": "A homology sphere is treated as a simply connected sphere",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Homology loses nonabelian fundamental-group information.",
      "presentation": "A candidate has the same homology as S³, so it is called a counterexample or a verified sphere without checking π₁.",
      "diagnostic": "The Poincaré homology sphere has sphere-like homology but a nontrivial fundamental group. Compute or certify π₁, not only its abelianization.",
      "remedy": "Retain the simple-connectivity hypothesis and distinguish homological data from the full group.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Topological data analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Betti numbers and homology summaries can miss nonabelian loop information."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1904,
          "event": "Poincaré's homology-sphere example corrects the earlier homology-only claim and motivates the fundamental-group formulation.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S10"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-002",
      "title": "Compactness is dropped from the theorem",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The conclusion for closed manifolds cannot be applied to arbitrary noncompact manifolds.",
      "presentation": "A simply connected open three-manifold is declared a sphere, or a noncompact example is advertised as refuting the closed theorem.",
      "diagnostic": "R³ is simply connected and boundaryless but is not compact, hence cannot be homeomorphic to S³.",
      "remedy": "Verify compactness separately and apply a theorem appropriate to open manifolds if it fails.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Global PDE estimates",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Compact and noncompact domains have different global topological and analytic constraints."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-003",
      "title": "The no-boundary condition is omitted",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A compact simply connected manifold with boundary need not be a sphere.",
      "presentation": "A three-ball is used as a counterexample to a theorem that actually assumes closedness.",
      "diagnostic": "B³ is contractible and compact but has boundary S². Check local charts at every boundary point.",
      "remedy": "Use closed to mean compact without boundary, and state relative/boundary variants separately.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Finite-element geometry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A volume mesh with an external boundary is not topologically equivalent to a closed manifold."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-004",
      "title": "A simplicial complex or quotient is assumed to be a manifold",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A three-dimensional combinatorial object can have singular points whose neighborhoods are not Euclidean.",
      "presentation": "A glued or simulated complex is treated as a valid manifold based only on dimension and connectivity.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect links of vertices/strata. The cone on a torus is contractible but its apex has a torus link, not the sphere link of an ordinary interior three-manifold point.",
      "remedy": "Certify the manifold and boundary conditions before testing the global theorem.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Digital geometry and mesh repair",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Nonmanifold edges and vertices can invalidate continuum geometric assumptions even when a mesh renders convincingly."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-005",
      "title": "The three-dimensional simple-connectivity criterion is copied into other dimensions",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Simple connectivity alone is unusually strong in the closed three-dimensional setting; higher-dimensional homology remains unconstrained.",
      "presentation": "Any simply connected closed n-manifold is declared S^n by citing Poincaré.",
      "diagnostic": "S²×S² is a closed simply connected four-manifold with nonzero H₂, unlike S⁴.",
      "remedy": "Use the correct dimension-specific hypotheses, such as the appropriate homotopy-sphere statement, rather than changing n in the three-dimensional theorem.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Dimensional model reduction",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Dimension controls which independent topological invariants and geometric mechanisms can exist."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-006",
      "title": "Topological, smooth and metric equivalence are conflated",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A homeomorphism asserts continuity and a continuous inverse; it does not by definition provide a chosen smooth map or preserve a metric.",
      "presentation": "A topological classification is said to certify a particular coordinate transformation as differentiable or distance-preserving.",
      "diagnostic": "Name the requested equivalence: homeomorphism, diffeomorphism or isometry. Inspect the regularity of the proposed map and the dimension-specific upgrade theorem.",
      "remedy": "Prove any stronger equivalence explicitly and distinguish existence of a smooth identification from regularity of a supplied map.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Shape registration",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Two shapes can share topology while differing in smooth parameterization or all geometric distances."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-007",
      "title": "The initial metric must look round because the topology is spherical",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The theorem identifies an underlying manifold, not every metric placed on it.",
      "presentation": "A distorted or highly curved metric on S³ is called topological evidence against spherical classification.",
      "diagnostic": "Fix the manifold and vary its smooth Riemannian metric; topology remains unchanged while curvature and distances can vary.",
      "remedy": "Separate a topological sphere from a round constant-curvature metric and prove the geometric evolution connecting them when needed.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Elastic deformation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Geometric distortion can preserve topology while changing energy, curvature and observable shape."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-008",
      "title": "Hamilton's positive-Ricci case is treated as the unrestricted theorem",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An argument requiring an initially positive Ricci tensor does not cover arbitrary initial metrics.",
      "presentation": "A convergence proof invokes positivity that was never established for the chosen metric.",
      "diagnostic": "Locate the positivity assumption and its preservation theorem. Determine whether the initial metric is shown to satisfy it.",
      "remedy": "Supply the machinery needed for arbitrary geometry, or state the restricted curvature theorem.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Invariant-region methods in dynamical systems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A convergence proof inside a preserved favorable region need not cover trajectories starting outside it."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1982,
          "event": "Hamilton proves convergence in the positive-Ricci three-dimensional setting, an essential restricted predecessor documented by Milnor.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S10"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10",
        "MIL-S36"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-009",
      "title": "A Ricci-flow singularity is mistaken for a topological counterexample",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI",
        "AUX-SPHERE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Curvature blowup of an evolving metric does not imply that the underlying manifold is not S³.",
      "presentation": "The flow becomes singular, so the topological theorem is declared false.",
      "diagnostic": "For a round S³ of radius r, unnormalized Ricci flow gives r²(t)=r²(0)−4t. It reaches a geometric singularity while starting on the standard sphere.",
      "remedy": "Track normalization and analyze singularity models/surgery instead of interpreting metric breakdown as topological failure.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Geometric evolution and collapse",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A representation or evolution can degenerate even when the underlying classified object is known."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10",
        "MIL-S33"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-010",
      "title": "Diffeomorphism invariance is ignored in a parabolic existence or numerical argument",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Coordinate freedom introduces degeneracy; the unmodified tensor equation is not an arbitrary strictly parabolic componentwise system.",
      "presentation": "A scalar heat-equation theorem is applied directly to all metric components without handling the gauge.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect the principal symbol, coordinate choice and recovery of the geometric flow from any gauge-adjusted evolution.",
      "remedy": "Use a valid geometric short-time existence argument or a controlled DeTurck-type gauge, including its inverse coordinate transformation.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "General relativity and constrained PDEs",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Gauge freedom must be handled before importing unconstrained PDE well-posedness or numerical stability results."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1983,
          "event": "DeTurck supplies a gauge-adjusted approach to the analytic formulation of Ricci evolution.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S36"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S36"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-011",
      "title": "Surgery is treated as arbitrary deletion of troublesome geometry",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Cutting and capping can change topology; the proof depends on precisely controlled necks and bookkeeping.",
      "presentation": "A singular region is removed numerically and the resulting simpler manifold is declared equivalent to the original.",
      "diagnostic": "Document the geometry of every surgery neck, the allowed caps, connected-sum decomposition and discarded component classification.",
      "remedy": "Use the controlled surgery theorem and carry topological information through each operation.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Mesh surgery and medical segmentation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Removing narrow connections can change connectedness, handles and the inferred topology."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S34"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-012",
      "title": "Curvature rescaling is assumed to yield a noncollapsed limiting manifold",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Curvature bounds alone do not guarantee injectivity-radius or volume control needed for the desired pointed limit.",
      "presentation": "A blowup sequence is rescaled and its limit is assumed to have the required dimension and canonical geometry.",
      "diagnostic": "Check scale-compatible volume lower bounds/noncollapse, completeness, injectivity behavior and the compactness theorem's hypotheses.",
      "remedy": "Prove noncollapse and all compactness assumptions before classifying the limiting singularity model.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Multiscale geometry and homogenization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A family can collapse in some directions even when selected curvature or energy measurements remain controlled."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2002,
          "event": "Perelman's entropy and noncollapsing framework supplies control crucial to blowup-limit analysis.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S33"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S33"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-013",
      "title": "A monotone functional is treated as a complete geometric classification",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI",
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Monotonicity gives an inequality along a flow; it does not alone identify all limits or rule out every singular scenario.",
      "presentation": "An entropy decreases, so convergence to the unique desired geometry is announced without compactness or rigidity.",
      "diagnostic": "A scalar monotone F(t) alone says nothing about an unobserved state's convergence. Audit coercivity, compactness, equality cases and limit classification.",
      "remedy": "Combine monotonicity with the precise geometric estimates and rigidity theorems needed to conclude.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Optimization and Lyapunov theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A decreasing objective can coexist with nonconvergent states or degenerate limiting sequences unless additional hypotheses hold."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S33"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI",
        "MIL-E-PC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-014",
      "title": "Finite extinction is asserted for all closed three-manifolds",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI",
        "AUX-SPHERE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The extinction theorem has a prime-decomposition hypothesis; aspherical factors change the conclusion.",
      "presentation": "A proof assumes every closed three-manifold disappears under Ricci flow with surgery.",
      "diagnostic": "Check the hypothesis excluding aspherical factors. A flat three-torus has Ric=0 and a stationary unnormalized Ricci flow, so universal extinction is false.",
      "remedy": "Apply extinction only in its proved topological class and account for the other geometric pieces separately.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Dynamical systems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A decay theorem for one invariant class does not eliminate equilibria in another class."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2003,
          "event": "Perelman proves finite extinction for a specified class, including the setting needed for the Poincaré application.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S35"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S35"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-015",
      "title": "A finite mesh, simplified group presentation or homology computation is treated as a complete certificate",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Numerical geometry and incomplete algebraic simplification can overlook singular gluing or nontrivial loops.",
      "presentation": "A mesh looks spherical, a few loops contract, or a group simplifier stalls/returns a heuristic result, and simple connectivity is asserted.",
      "diagnostic": "Check the exact triangulation, manifold links, group presentation transformations and independently verifiable certificates. Finite homology data alone do not suffice.",
      "remedy": "Use certified topological algorithms and exact transformations; retain visualizations as explanatory evidence.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Scientific visualization",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A rendering can conceal topological defects below resolution or behind a projection."
        }
      ],
      "history": [],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S10"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "PC-016",
      "title": "Historical proof versions are flattened into one timeless argument",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An auxiliary claim can be withdrawn, corrected or replaced without invalidating the final theorem; reusing it uncritically can still break a new argument.",
      "presentation": "A later result is supported by an early uncorrected lemma, or a historical correction is misrepresented as refuting the accepted Poincaré proof.",
      "diagnostic": "Pin versions and trace which conclusions actually depend on the revised claim. Perelman's surgery abstract explicitly marks earlier unjustified auxiliary assertions as unnecessary to other conclusions.",
      "remedy": "Use the corrected dependency chain and current accepted theorem; preserve historical corrections as methodological evidence, not a fabricated contradiction.",
      "scope": "The solved three-dimensional topological theorem and the precise analytic/geometric obligations in its proof; examples diagnose weakened statements, not counterexamples to Poincaré.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "Scientific provenance and software dependencies",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A dependency update can remove a defective component while preserving the final result; downstream users must track the replacement."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2003,
          "event": "Perelman explicitly qualifies earlier horn-volume/eventual-smoothness assertions in his surgery paper.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "MIL-S34"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "MIL-S34",
        "MIL-S01"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "millennium",
      "componentTitle": "The seven Millennium proof contracts",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MIL-E-PC",
        "MIL-E-RICCI"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-001",
      "title": "A correct number is attached to the wrong unit.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "DATA",
        "OBS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The producer and consumer attach different physical meanings to the same numeric field. The equation can be algebraically correct while its operands are incompatible.",
      "presentation": "A persistent multiplicative offset, unexplained navigation residual or parameter that compensates for a conversion error.",
      "diagnostic": "Trace units through the entire interface; inject a physically known reference value and inspect the value at the receiving calculation.",
      "remedy": "Use typed quantities, explicit conversion at interfaces and independent physical sanity checks; investigate residuals rather than fitting them away.",
      "scope": "Every dimensional calculation; this is a failure in data interpretation rather than a contradiction in a physical law.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "spaceflight",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "NASA documented an actual unit-interface mismatch in the Mars Climate Orbiter investigation."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemistry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A concentration supplied in mol/L to an equation expecting mol/m³ introduces an analogous scale error."
        },
        {
          "field": "orbital tracking",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A position or time conversion must be checked independently of a successful API response."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1999,
          "event": "The Mars Climate Orbiter board identified an impulse-unit interface mismatch and additional process failures.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX06",
            "HFX03"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX06",
        "HFX03"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "DATA",
        "OBS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-002",
      "title": "Dimensional consistency is mistaken for a complete physical theory.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "MODEL",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Several different functions of the same dimensionless arguments have the right units. Dimensional analysis constrains form but does not choose the governing function or prove that all relevant variables were included.",
      "presentation": "A scaling law appears inevitable because its units match, although different materials or regimes require another dimensionless dependence.",
      "diagnostic": "List independently variable dimensionless groups and ask which are fixed, negligible or omitted. Construct two dimensionally valid alternatives.",
      "remedy": "Treat dimensional form as a constraint; determine remaining functions by derivation or appropriately varied experiments.",
      "scope": "Similarity reasoning in mechanics, chemistry, transport and biology; the Buckingham method itself does not fail.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "fluid mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Equal units do not fix the dependence of drag on Reynolds number."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A biomass scaling relation requires justified variables and a population range."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Dimensionless constitutive functions can differ between material classes."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1914,
          "event": "Buckingham formalized dimensional similarity; completeness of the physical variable list remains an additional modeling obligation.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX03"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX03"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "MODEL",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-003",
      "title": "Nondimensionalization hides the scale that is changing.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "GAP",
        "TFIM",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Dividing by a parameter-dependent reference value can turn a vanishing dimensional quantity into an apparently constant dimensionless result, or create an apparent divergence when the reference vanishes.",
      "presentation": "Two plots disagree because one reports Δ/J, another Δ/h, or lengths are rescaled differently at each sample size.",
      "diagnostic": "Restore dimensional variables and record every scaling factor before comparing curves or limits.",
      "remedy": "Carry the scale map with each dataset; specify which dimensional quantities remain fixed in a limiting process.",
      "scope": "Comparisons between model conventions or experimental systems; a change of units alone cannot create a physical transition.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A normalized peak position is not a fixed energy without its reference scale."
        },
        {
          "field": "fluid mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Holding a plotted nondimensional parameter fixed need not hold the physical forcing fixed."
        },
        {
          "field": "economics",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Changing a price deflator can alter an apparent trend; the statistical and institutional assumptions differ."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1914,
          "event": "Dimensional-similarity methods make the choice of characteristic scales explicit.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX03"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX03"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "GAP",
        "TFIM",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-004",
      "title": "Printed precision is treated as established accuracy.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "DATA",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The number of displayed digits records representation, not the closeness to a physical or mathematical target. Solver tolerance, calibration, model bias and rounding are separate error sources.",
      "presentation": "A table with eight decimals is used to resolve a difference smaller than the combined uncertainty.",
      "diagnostic": "Attach uncertainty or a certified error enclosure to the derived difference; repeat the calculation with independently tighter precision and error controls.",
      "remedy": "Report justified digits and distinguish numerical error, measurement error and model discrepancy.",
      "scope": "Any measured or computed scalar, especially subtraction of nearby eigenvalues.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "metrology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A measurement result requires an uncertainty statement."
        },
        {
          "field": "spectral computation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Absolute energy errors may dominate a tiny difference."
        },
        {
          "field": "geochemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Instrument readout resolution does not certify an inferred age or concentration."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2008,
          "event": "The GUM organizes uncertainty around a stated measurand and measurement model.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX04",
            "HFX39"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX04",
        "HFX39"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "DATA",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-005",
      "title": "Shared error is dropped when uncertainties are propagated.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "STAT",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Var(X+Y)=Var(X)+Var(Y)+2Cov(X,Y). Dropping covariance may understate or overstate uncertainty; for a difference the covariance term has the opposite sign.",
      "presentation": "Replicate averages appear extremely precise despite a common calibration offset, or an energy difference is assigned the sum of unrelated error bars.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate common and independent error sources. Our executed example X=Y with variance one gives variance four for the sum, rather than two.",
      "remedy": "Propagate the full covariance or a justified uncertainty model; retain shared nuisance parameters.",
      "scope": "The identity assumes finite second moments; uncertainty outside that framework needs another representation.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "analytical chemistry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Standards shared across samples correlate concentration errors."
        },
        {
          "field": "cosmology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Common calibration parameters correlate multiple spectra."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials simulation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Two energies computed with the same approximation need not have independent errors."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2008,
          "event": "Modern uncertainty guidance includes correlation between input quantities.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX04"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX04"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "STAT",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-006",
      "title": "A traceability label substitutes for validation of the measurement chain.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A calibrated component does not guarantee that the entire deployed pipeline measures the intended quantity within stated uncertainty. Drift, environment, preprocessing and transfer standards can break the chain.",
      "presentation": "A trustworthy instrument certificate is cited while the assembled apparatus develops unexplained offsets.",
      "diagnostic": "Test the complete chain against references under operating conditions; inspect drift and the uncertainty contributed by each transformation.",
      "remedy": "Maintain calibration history, check standards and end-to-end verification tied to the actual measurand.",
      "scope": "A methodological risk, not a claim that a particular instrument in this project drifted.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "laboratory metrology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Traceability concerns the result and its chain of comparisons."
        },
        {
          "field": "satellite sensing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "On-orbit processing and environmental changes need verification."
        },
        {
          "field": "industrial control",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A sensor certificate does not validate controller input conversion."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1999,
          "event": "The Mars Climate Orbiter inquiry illustrates why correct components do not establish a correct operational interface.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX05",
            "HFX06"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX05",
        "HFX06"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "DATA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-007",
      "title": "The sensor response is mistaken for the underlying state.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The observation is y=R(x)+noise. Finite resolution, convolution, saturation or a many-to-one response can erase distinctions in x; downstream fitting cannot recover information that the observation model does not identify.",
      "presentation": "A flat signal is called a physical plateau despite detector saturation, or a broadened instrumental line is interpreted as intrinsic broadening.",
      "diagnostic": "Vary gain, resolution or the observation channel; calibrate R independently and compare the modeled signal with raw measurements.",
      "remedy": "Fit a forward observation model and report unresolved distinctions rather than assigning a unique microscopic state.",
      "scope": "Conditional risk wherever inferred states are separated from observations by a response function.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A beam and detector response transform the incoming field."
        },
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A recorded signal requires a justified mapping to neural activity."
        },
        {
          "field": "spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Line shape is a convolution of physical and instrumental effects."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1963,
          "event": "Regularization research formalized the separate difficulty of recovering hidden quantities from observed outputs.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX04",
            "HFX21"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX04",
        "HFX21"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-035",
        "QH-003",
        "SPIN-019",
        "YM-013"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-008",
      "title": "Sampling aliases different frequencies into the same data.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "INFO",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "At uniform rate fs, sin(2πfn/fs) and sin(2π(f+fs)n/fs) have identical samples. Sampling cannot distinguish those frequencies without bandwidth or other structural assumptions.",
      "presentation": "A fast oscillation appears slow, periodic monitoring misses an event, or a time series seems to support a unique frequency.",
      "diagnostic": "Vary sampling rate and timing; inspect the acquisition bandwidth and anti-alias filtering. The accompanying code checks the exact alias identity numerically.",
      "remedy": "Match the acquisition protocol to a justified bandwidth and retain timing metadata; do not infer unsampled frequency content uniquely.",
      "scope": "Uniform sampling example; irregular sampling introduces different identification questions, not automatic immunity.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "signal processing",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The alias identity is explicit."
        },
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Periodic observation windows can obscure true variability."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Sparse population counts can hide oscillations or seasonal dynamics."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1949,
          "event": "Shannon gave band-limited communication and reconstruction a precise mathematical framework.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX08"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX08"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "INFO",
        "DATA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-009",
      "title": "Truncation and window artifacts become invented physical structure.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "INFO",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A finite expansion and a finite observation window alter the spectrum or reconstructed curve. Fourier partial sums near a discontinuity need not converge uniformly; localized oscillations are not automatically new physical modes.",
      "presentation": "Ringing beside a sharp boundary is reported as a wave, or leakage around a strong line is reported as additional weak peaks.",
      "diagnostic": "Change the window, resolution and reconstruction method; compare with synthetic signals passed through the same acquisition pipeline.",
      "remedy": "Report the transfer function and test feature persistence under controlled refinement.",
      "scope": "Gibbs ringing and spectral leakage are distinct mechanisms grouped here as reconstruction-created features, not asserted to be identical.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "imaging",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Truncated Fourier representations can ring at edges."
        },
        {
          "field": "spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Windowing redistributes spectral content."
        },
        {
          "field": "numerical PDEs",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A sharp reconstructed feature requires a convergence and conservation check."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1899,
          "event": "Gibbs' 1899 note corrected a statement about Fourier partial sums and described the limiting behavior near a jump.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX09",
            "HFX08"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX09",
        "HFX08"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "INFO",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-010",
      "title": "Missing or censored observations are treated as random omissions.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The probability of observation may depend on the outcome or an unobserved variable. Complete cases, zeros substituted for absent values and detectable-only samples then target a different distribution.",
      "presentation": "An apparent benefit arises because failures disappear from follow-up, or an abundance estimate ignores values below a detection threshold.",
      "diagnostic": "Model how records become missing or censored; compare plausible mechanisms and conduct sensitivity analyses for unobserved outcomes.",
      "remedy": "Use an analysis justified by the observation process and state the assumptions needed for ignorability.",
      "scope": "Missing at random is conditional on specified observed variables; it is not synonymous with random missingness in everyday language.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Dropout can change the estimand and bias an outcome comparison."
        },
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Detection thresholds produce truncated samples."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Below-detection measurements are censored observations, not exact zeros."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1976,
          "event": "Rubin specified conditions under which a missingness mechanism can be ignored for particular inferential procedures.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX15"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX15"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS",
        "DATA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-011",
      "title": "Aggregation reverses an association and is read as a contradiction.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "CAUSAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Different group weights can reverse the sign of a marginal comparison relative to every stratum. The pooled and conditional quantities answer different questions.",
      "presentation": "One method wins in each difficulty stratum but loses after pooling; the reversal is labeled impossible or used to select whichever story is preferred.",
      "diagnostic": "Display denominators and strata. Our checked counts give A rates 81/87 and 192/263 above B rates 234/270 and 55/80, yet pooled A=273/350 is below B=289/350.",
      "remedy": "Specify the target population and causal role of the stratification variable before choosing an adjustment.",
      "scope": "A reversal alone does not establish which analysis is causally appropriate.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "epidemiology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Conditional and pooled risks need not order interventions alike."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials testing",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Different batch compositions can reverse pooled performance."
        },
        {
          "field": "education",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Group composition can reverse institution-level comparisons."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1951,
          "event": "Simpson analyzed interaction and interpretation in contingency tables.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX10"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX10"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "CAUSAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-012",
      "title": "Repeated measurements are counted as independent experimental units.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Measurements share a treatment allocation, organism, site, device or time history. Treating them as independent inflates the effective sample size and can make standard errors too small.",
      "presentation": "Hundreds of images from a few specimens are presented as hundreds of independently treated specimens.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the level at which treatment or exposure varies; inspect within-cluster dependence and resample at the relevant unit.",
      "remedy": "Use a design and covariance model reflecting clustering; increase independent units when that is the source of information.",
      "scope": "Repeated measurements can be useful; the failure is misrepresenting their information structure.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Hurlbert analyzed field experiments with inadequate independent replication."
        },
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Many cells from a few animals do not automatically supply independent animal-level evidence."
        },
        {
          "field": "manufacturing",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Repeated readings from one batch cannot estimate between-batch variation."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1984,
          "event": "Hurlbert named and analyzed pseudoreplication in ecological experiments.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX11"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX11"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-013",
      "title": "A discovery threshold is applied to an unspecified family of searches.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Testing many hypotheses increases opportunities for false positives. FDR controls an expected proportion under specified conditions, while family-wise error concerns the chance of at least one false positive.",
      "presentation": "One impressive association is selected from thousands of unreported comparisons, or an FDR-adjusted value is called the probability that this finding is false.",
      "diagnostic": "Inventory all tested outcomes, subgroups and analysis choices; identify the error criterion and dependence assumptions of the adjustment.",
      "remedy": "Define the family, report the search and choose an error-control procedure suited to the claim.",
      "scope": "No universal correction repairs an undisclosed adaptive search after the fact.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "genomics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Large panels require an explicit multiplicity criterion."
        },
        {
          "field": "particle searches",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Scanning many candidate locations changes the discovery question."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical text mining",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Searching many motifs can produce striking accidental matches."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1995,
          "event": "Benjamini and Hochberg introduced a false-discovery-rate procedure with a stated error target and assumptions.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX14",
            "HFX13"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX14",
        "HFX13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-019",
        "CROSS-014",
        "CROSS-018",
        "SPIN-075"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-014",
      "title": "Adaptive stopping changes the procedure but retains a fixed-sample guarantee.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A decision rule calibrated for one prespecified sample size need not retain its error probability when the analyst repeatedly looks, stops on significance or adds data after an unfavorable result.",
      "presentation": "The first passing p-value is reported without the earlier looks, or repeated simulation runs end as soon as one desired counterexample appears.",
      "diagnostic": "Reconstruct the stopping rule and simulate or prove its operating characteristics under the null.",
      "remedy": "Use a justified sequential procedure or fix the sampling rule in advance; preserve the complete analysis path.",
      "scope": "Optional stopping is not inherently invalid; the guarantee must apply to the actual procedure and inferential framework.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Interim analyses require a design appropriate to repeated looks."
        },
        {
          "field": "online experiments",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Continuous monitoring changes false-alarm behavior."
        },
        {
          "field": "computational searches",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A selected run cannot represent the distribution of all runs."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1933,
          "event": "Neyman–Pearson theory specifies errors for a complete testing procedure rather than an isolated numerical statistic.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX12",
            "HFX13"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX12",
        "HFX13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-019",
        "CROSS-013",
        "CROSS-018",
        "SPIN-075"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-015",
      "title": "A p-value is converted into a posterior probability or causal conclusion.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "CAUSAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A tail probability calculated under a statistical model does not by itself give the probability that the null is true, the probability the result will replicate or the probability of a causal explanation.",
      "presentation": "p=0.03 is translated into a 97% probability that a theory is correct.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the conditioning event in the probability expression and compare it with the sentence being claimed.",
      "remedy": "State what the statistic measures; evaluate causal identification and substantive alternatives separately.",
      "scope": "The warning concerns interpretation, not a claim that every p-value calculation is defective.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A statistical association does not remove confounding."
        },
        {
          "field": "psychology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The conditional probability reversal has the same form."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A significant change does not establish the proposed microscopic mechanism."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2016,
          "event": "The ASA statement explicitly distinguished p-values from probabilities of hypotheses.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX13"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "CAUSAL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-016",
      "title": "An inconclusive test is presented as proof of equivalence or absence.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Failure to reject a null can reflect insufficient information. An equivalence claim requires a meaningful tolerance and an inference that excludes effects outside it.",
      "presentation": "Two treatments, algorithms or spectral estimates are declared the same because their difference is not significant.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect the uncertainty interval and test power against scientifically relevant alternatives.",
      "remedy": "Define an equivalence or noninferiority margin where appropriate, and report unresolved effect sizes.",
      "scope": "A mathematical identity requires proof; a statistical equivalence statement concerns a stated practical margin.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "experimental physics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A null detection bounds a signal only relative to sensitivity."
        },
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Non-significance alone does not establish equivalent outcomes."
        },
        {
          "field": "software benchmarking",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "No detected speed difference may simply reflect noisy measurements."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1933,
          "event": "The separation of error probabilities and power makes the relevant alternative part of the testing problem.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX12"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX12"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-017",
      "title": "Statistical detectability is substituted for scientific importance.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A tiny effect can be highly detectable with enough data, while an important effect can remain uncertain with limited data. A threshold on a test statistic does not specify practical consequence.",
      "presentation": "A negligible calibration shift receives more attention than a consequential but imprecisely estimated bias.",
      "diagnostic": "Report effect sizes in physical or operational units with uncertainty and compare them with a prespecified relevance threshold.",
      "remedy": "Tie conclusions to magnitude, consequences and uncertainty rather than threshold crossing alone.",
      "scope": "Practical thresholds are domain decisions and must not be smuggled into statistical notation.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "large-scale sensing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Massive datasets can detect tiny systematic offsets."
        },
        {
          "field": "biology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A detectable expression change need not be functionally large."
        },
        {
          "field": "engineering",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Operational tolerance is different from a p-value cutoff."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2016,
          "event": "The ASA statement distinguishes statistical significance from the size or importance of an effect.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX13"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX13"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-018",
      "title": "The data used to select a feature are reused to certify it.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "MODEL",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Selection favors large noise fluctuations. Evaluating the selected region, variable or model on the same fluctuations overstates evidence or performance.",
      "presentation": "A brain region is chosen for its strong group difference, then the same observations estimate that difference as if the region had been fixed beforehand.",
      "diagnostic": "Trace every selection step and identify which data influence it; compare with fully held-out evaluation or nested resampling.",
      "remedy": "Separate selection from assessment, or use an inference explicitly conditional on the selection process.",
      "scope": "A conceptual overlap with leakage; this record specifically concerns selection-induced inflation of the chosen quantity.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Circular region selection is a documented example."
        },
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Hyperparameter selection can overfit a noisy validation criterion."
        },
        {
          "field": "spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Choosing the strongest unexplained peak then testing it needs selection-aware treatment."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2009,
          "event": "Kriegeskorte and colleagues analyzed double dipping in systems neuroscience.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX18",
            "HFX19"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX18",
        "HFX19"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "MODEL",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-019",
        "CROSS-013",
        "CROSS-014",
        "SPIN-075"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-019",
      "title": "Only favorable analyses enter the evidence record.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "PROVENANCE",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "If reporting depends on the result, the visible studies or analysis variants are a selected sample. Combining them without modeling or investigating selection can preserve rather than remove bias.",
      "presentation": "Many plausible model specifications were tried, but only the strongest association appears in the report.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the protocol, registered outcomes, repository history and available analyses with the published account.",
      "remedy": "Preserve the analysis ledger and report material alternatives, null findings and deviations; use sensitivity analysis when the unseen selection process is uncertain.",
      "scope": "This is a conditional risk; the catalogue does not accuse any named study of undisclosed reporting.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Selective outcome reporting can distort synthesis."
        },
        {
          "field": "computational science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Discarded seeds and failed parameter searches affect reproducibility."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical research",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A surviving archive is selected, but its selection process differs from statistical publication."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2016,
          "event": "Modern statistical and reproducibility statements require transparency about the analyses that generated a reported result.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX13",
            "HFX20"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX13",
        "HFX20"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "PROVENANCE",
        "DATA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-020",
      "title": "An observational fit is treated as identification of a causal effect.",
      "equationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "INVERSE",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Different causal systems can generate the same observed distribution. In the checked example X=U,Y=X and X=U,Y=U both give X=Y, yet intervening on X changes Y only in the first model.",
      "presentation": "A perfect predictive correlation is called proof that manipulating the predictor changes the outcome.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the causal estimand and assumptions; construct observationally equivalent models and compare their interventional answers.",
      "remedy": "Seek an appropriate intervention, valid design or justified structural restriction; report nonidentification when compatible models disagree.",
      "scope": "Failure of one sufficient adjustment criterion does not itself prove nonidentification.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "epidemiology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Exposure associations need exchangeability or another identifying design."
        },
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Predictive neural signals do not alone establish a causal mechanism."
        },
        {
          "field": "economics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A fitted demand association need not identify an intervention on price."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1986,
          "event": "Greenland and Robins distinguished causal identifiability from observational association; later data-fusion work develops structural identification.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX16",
            "HFX17"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1672,
          "event": "Boyle recognizes that one apparatus change can alter more than one cause. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-BOYLE1672"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX16",
        "HFX17",
        "EARLY-BOYLE1672"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "INVERSE",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-021",
      "title": "Conditioning on a shared consequence creates an association.",
      "equationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Selecting on a collider can associate otherwise independent causes. Our checked fair-bit example selects X+Y=1, making independent X and Y perfectly anticorrelated in the selected sample.",
      "presentation": "A relationship appears only among admitted, detected, published or surviving cases and is interpreted as a relation in the source population.",
      "diagnostic": "Map how each case enters the dataset and identify variables affected by both sides of the comparison.",
      "remedy": "Analyze the selection mechanism and target population; avoid automatic adjustment for every measured variable.",
      "scope": "Not every selected sample is biased for every estimand; the causal graph and target determine the issue.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Conditioning on admission can distort associations."
        },
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Selecting detectable objects can couple intrinsic properties."
        },
        {
          "field": "recruitment analytics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Conditioning on selection can reverse candidate-attribute associations."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2016,
          "event": "Structural data-fusion work treats selection mechanisms explicitly rather than assuming that more adjustment is always better.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX17"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX17"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-011",
        "BELL-012",
        "BELL-013"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-022",
      "title": "An identified effect is transported to a different population without a bridge.",
      "equationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "STAT",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The source and target differ in effect modifiers, mechanisms, measurement or selection. Identification in the source does not establish identification or invariance in the target.",
      "presentation": "A laboratory relation or trial effect is applied directly to another population because the variables have the same names.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify source and target mechanisms, overlap and measurement equivalence; identify which differences can be adjusted and which require new data.",
      "remedy": "Use a justified transport formula or bounded target claim, and collect target information where the source cannot supply it.",
      "scope": "Transfer may be valid under explicit assumptions; similarity alone is insufficient.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Trial and target populations may differ in effect modifiers."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A species or site response need not transfer to a new environment."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials science",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Transferring a constitutive law also needs a regime map, though the causal-population formalism may differ."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2016,
          "event": "Bareinboim and Pearl developed formal conditions for combining heterogeneous causal information.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX17"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX17"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "STAT",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-023",
      "title": "A causal contrast requires observations that the design never supplies.",
      "equationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "STAT",
        "INVERSE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "If a relevant covariate stratum receives only one treatment or exposure, an observational contrast in that stratum is unsupported. Extreme weighting can reveal near-absence rather than create information.",
      "presentation": "A weighted estimate is dominated by a few cases, or a fitted model supplies a counterfactual entirely outside observed support.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect conditional exposure probabilities and overlap in the variables needed for identification.",
      "remedy": "Change the target population, improve the design or make the extrapolation assumptions explicit with sensitivity analysis.",
      "scope": "Positivity is relative to a causal estimand and adjustment set; it is not the same as positivity of an energy gap.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "epidemiology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Untreated and treated comparisons need relevant support."
        },
        {
          "field": "policy evaluation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A policy never applied in a class of settings cannot be nonparametrically compared there."
        },
        {
          "field": "adaptive experimentation",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A policy that stops exploring can eliminate support for later evaluation."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1986,
          "event": "Identifiability research separates what observational data contain from what additional assumptions supply.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX16",
            "HFX17"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX16",
        "HFX17"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "STAT",
        "INVERSE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-024",
      "title": "The treatment or intervention is not the same object across units.",
      "equationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An outcome can depend on treatment versions, neighbors' treatments or network exposure. Replacing this structure with a single binary label changes the estimand and can violate the proposed causal model.",
      "presentation": "Two deployments with the same label differ in dose or implementation, or an untreated unit changes because nearby units were treated.",
      "diagnostic": "Define the intervention operationally and record spillovers, network structure and treatment versions.",
      "remedy": "Model the relevant exposure mapping or design the experiment to identify it; report the intervention for which the estimate is valid.",
      "scope": "Conditional methodological risk; no specific trial or network in this project has been inspected for this problem.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "infectious-disease methodology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "One unit's treatment can affect another unit's exposure."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Interventions can spill across plots through movement or shared resources."
        },
        {
          "field": "online systems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A recommender or market intervention can alter the environment faced by control users."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2016,
          "event": "Structural causal analysis makes the intervention and its mechanisms part of the formal object being identified.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX17"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1672,
          "event": "Boyle recognizes that one apparatus change can alter more than one cause. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-BOYLE1672"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX17",
        "EARLY-BOYLE1672"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-025",
      "title": "The inverse map is nonunique even with noiseless measurements.",
      "equationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "OBS",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "If the forward operator has a nontrivial null space, different hidden states produce exactly the same observation. More numerical precision cannot identify the unobserved component.",
      "presentation": "An optimizer returns one very precise parameter vector and it is reported as the only possible state.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute rank, symmetries and null directions; in the executed example x1+x2=1 admits both (1,0) and (0,1).",
      "remedy": "Report an identified set or add genuinely independent measurements or justified constraints.",
      "scope": "The example is linear; nonlinear models require a corresponding identifiability analysis.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "tomography",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Incomplete projections can leave invisible components."
        },
        {
          "field": "spectral unmixing",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Dependent response columns make compositions nonunique."
        },
        {
          "field": "geophysics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Different subsurface structures can fit the same observations."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1963,
          "event": "Tikhonov's regularization work is a historical anchor for the mathematical treatment of ill-posed inverse problems.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX21"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX21"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "OBS",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-026",
      "title": "A unique inverse is too unstable to support the reported digits.",
      "equationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "OBS",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Uniqueness does not imply stability. Small changes in measured data can create large changes in inferred parameters when the inverse amplifies weakly observed directions.",
      "presentation": "Tiny noise perturbations yield radically different reconstructions despite essentially identical residuals.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect singular values and perturbation sensitivity. For diag(1,10⁻⁸), a data change of 10⁻⁸ in the second component produces a unit parameter change.",
      "remedy": "Report uncertainty in poorly determined directions; improve the measurement design or use justified regularization with its bias exposed.",
      "scope": "A small residual is not an error bound on the recovered state.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "medical imaging methodology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An inverse can amplify measurement noise."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical kinetics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Weakly observed rate combinations can be unstable."
        },
        {
          "field": "gravitational inference",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Data sensitivity limits parameter resolution."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1963,
          "event": "Regularization was developed to stabilize classes of ill-posed recovery problems.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX21"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX21"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "OBS",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-027",
      "title": "Regularization creates certainty that belongs to the prior or penalty.",
      "equationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A penalty selects among weakly supported solutions. The resulting smoothness, sparsity or parameter concentration can come from the imposed restriction rather than the observations.",
      "presentation": "A clean reconstruction is described as directly measured structure, or a tight conditional interval ignores uncertainty about the penalty family.",
      "diagnostic": "Vary plausible penalties and strengths; compare data likelihood with regularization contribution and test recovery on known alternatives.",
      "remedy": "Report the imposed structure and sensitivity; collect data capable of discriminating between regularized solutions.",
      "scope": "Regularization can be useful and necessary; the error is confusing a stabilized answer with uniquely data-determined truth.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "imaging",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Smoothness penalties suppress some real structures as well as noise."
        },
        {
          "field": "geoscience",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A smooth subsurface model may reflect the prior."
        },
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A predictive inductive bias need not establish a causal mechanism."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1963,
          "event": "Regularization formalizes a stability tradeoff; Bayesian calibration makes additional uncertainty assumptions explicit.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX21",
            "HFX22"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX21",
        "HFX22"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-028",
      "title": "Good predictions are taken to mean that every model parameter is known.",
      "equationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Outputs can be sensitive to a few parameter combinations and insensitive to many others. Predictions may be constrained while individual parameters remain highly uncertain.",
      "presentation": "A fitted biochemical model predicts a measured curve well, but very different rate constants reproduce the same curve.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect sensitivity singular values, profile likelihoods and posterior parameter combinations; design perturbations that excite weak directions.",
      "remedy": "Report prediction uncertainty and parameter uncertainty separately; target new experiments at the unresolved combinations.",
      "scope": "Sloppiness is a property of a model, parameterization, observations and regime, not a universal defect of biology.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "systems biology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "The cited paper examines wide sensitivity spectra in biological models."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical engineering",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Reaction parameters may enter outputs in compensating combinations."
        },
        {
          "field": "cosmology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A derived observable can be tighter than the individual parameters generating it."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2007,
          "event": "Gutenkunst and colleagues examined sloppy sensitivity spectra across a collection of systems-biology models.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX24"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX24"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-029",
      "title": "A calibration parameter absorbs model discrepancy and loses its physical meaning.",
      "equationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL",
        "OBS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "In y=f(x,θ)+δ(x)+ε, changes in θ and discrepancy δ can compensate each other. A good fit does not show that the fitted θ equals the physical parameter.",
      "presentation": "A calibrated coefficient changes across datasets or lies outside independent physical measurements while predictions inside the calibration range remain good.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare independent parameter measurements, residual structure and discrepancy priors; test whether different θ and δ combinations fit equally well.",
      "remedy": "Use credible discrepancy information and independent experiments; distinguish effective calibration parameters from physical constants.",
      "scope": "Adding an unrestricted discrepancy term alone can worsen identification; useful restrictions must be justified.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "engineering simulation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A simulator tuning parameter can compensate for omitted physics."
        },
        {
          "field": "climate modeling",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A fitted coefficient may absorb structural model error."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical kinetics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Missing reaction paths can distort inferred rate constants."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2014,
          "event": "Brynjarsdóttir and O'Hagan examined how discrepancy affects inference about physical parameters.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX22",
            "HFX23"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX22",
        "HFX23"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "INVERSE",
        "MODEL",
        "OBS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-030",
      "title": "A fit to all observed points is promoted to a unique governing law.",
      "equationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "INVERSE",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Any finite observation set can be matched by distinct functions. If g(x)=f(x)+c∏(x−xi), the additional term vanishes at every observed xi but can dominate elsewhere.",
      "presentation": "An interpolating curve is presented as the mechanism because it has zero training error.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare models that agree at observed points but disagree under new conditions; our executed example agrees at x=0,1,2 and gives 9 versus 609 at x=3.",
      "remedy": "Test discriminating predictions and justify the model class; distinguish interpolation accuracy from physical identification.",
      "scope": "The counterexample is elementary and does not imply that every extrapolation is equally plausible.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "historical curve fitting",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Finite trend agreement does not determine the next value."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Several constitutive mechanisms may fit one loading regime."
        },
        {
          "field": "biology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Different mechanisms can reproduce one response curve."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2001,
          "event": "Computer-model calibration explicitly separates fitted predictions from discrepancies with reality.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX22"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX22"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "INVERSE",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-004",
        "SPIN-028",
        "SPIN-035",
        "SPIN-036",
        "SPIN-037"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-031",
      "title": "An approximation is extrapolated beyond the regime that controls its error.",
      "equationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "DIM",
        "QCHEM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An expansion or empirical model can be accurate only when a small parameter is actually small or when the prediction lies within a validated regime. Fit quality within that regime does not bound extrapolation error.",
      "presentation": "A low-density, weak-coupling or narrow-temperature formula is used at a phase boundary or extreme condition without new estimates.",
      "diagnostic": "State the controlling parameter and error bound or validation range; inspect sensitivity to higher-order terms and alternative mechanisms.",
      "remedy": "Use a valid regime-specific model, a matched description or new data; mark unsupported extrapolations as such.",
      "scope": "This is distinct from finite-point nonuniqueness: even a known asymptotic derivation has a domain of control.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemistry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A dilute approximation can fail when interactions matter."
        },
        {
          "field": "engineering",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A constitutive fit may not survive new loading or temperature."
        },
        {
          "field": "cosmology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A parameter inference remains conditional on the assumed model family."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2014,
          "event": "Modern discrepancy analysis emphasizes that accurate calibration need not deliver reliable out-of-domain inference.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX03",
            "HFX23",
            "HFX37"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1638,
          "event": "Galileo separates geometric resemblance from physical strength. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-GALILEO1638"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": "1687 work; 1729 inspected witness",
          "event": "Newton states the boundary between a fixed force center and mutually moving bodies. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-NEWTON1687"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1822,
          "event": "Fourier specifies initial state, geometry and insulation before evolving heat. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-FOURIER1822"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1824,
          "event": "Carnot distinguishes an ideal reversible construction from its physical execution. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX03",
        "HFX23",
        "HFX37",
        "EARLY-GALILEO1638",
        "EARLY-NEWTON1687",
        "EARLY-FOURIER1822",
        "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "DIM",
        "QCHEM"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-032",
      "title": "Local linear behavior is applied to finite perturbations or global motion.",
      "equationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Linearization keeps only first-order terms near a reference state. Farther away, nonlinear terms can change equilibria, create cycles or move the trajectory to another region of state space.",
      "presentation": "A Jacobian calculation near one equilibrium is treated as a global forecast, or linear superposition is used for a nonlinear response.",
      "diagnostic": "Estimate the neighborhood where neglected terms remain controlled; compare finite perturbations and locate other invariant sets.",
      "remedy": "State the locality of the result and use nonlinear analysis or validated simulation for finite excursions.",
      "scope": "Failure of global extrapolation does not invalidate the local linear theorem.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "population dynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Simple nonlinear maps can undergo qualitative changes as parameters vary."
        },
        {
          "field": "structural engineering",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Small-deflection models need not describe buckling or large deformation."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical reactors",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Local response does not determine ignition or extinction transitions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1976,
          "event": "May demonstrated that very simple nonlinear equations can have complicated dynamics.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX26"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX26"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-033",
      "title": "Fast local recovery is mistaken for resilience to large disturbance.",
      "equationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A local restoring rate describes nearby motion, while persistence under large disturbances depends on basin boundaries, alternative states and the form of forcing.",
      "presentation": "A system that returns quickly after small shocks is called safe from a large transition.",
      "diagnostic": "Map relevant attractors and their basins; test the disturbance size and direction that cross a boundary.",
      "remedy": "Report local return rates separately from disturbance tolerance and recovery after state change.",
      "scope": "Resilience has several disciplinary definitions; use the particular one being measured.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Holling distinguished local stability from persistence under changing conditions."
        },
        {
          "field": "power systems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Local eigenvalue stability need not establish transient stability after a large fault."
        },
        {
          "field": "organizations",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Fast routine recovery and survival of a structural shock are different questions, but no common physical law is asserted."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1973,
          "event": "Holling distinguished resilience from stability in ecological systems.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX27"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX27"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-034",
      "title": "Deterministic equations are assumed to provide indefinitely precise forecasts.",
      "equationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL",
        "OBS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Sensitive dependence can amplify small uncertainty in initial conditions or parameters. Determinism of the equation does not guarantee long-horizon predictability from finite information.",
      "presentation": "Diverging forecasts are called evidence of random forcing, or a deterministic simulation is presented as an exact trajectory forecast.",
      "diagnostic": "Propagate initial-condition and parameter uncertainty; quantify finite-time separation rather than relying on one trajectory.",
      "remedy": "Report predictability horizons and distributions or robust statistics suited to the question.",
      "scope": "Not every nonlinear or complicated-looking system is chaotic; establish the relevant dynamics.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "meteorology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Lorenz's model is a primary example of deterministic nonperiodic behavior."
        },
        {
          "field": "celestial mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Sensitive trajectories require uncertainty propagation."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical oscillators",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A deterministic reaction model can have limited trajectory predictability."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1963,
          "event": "Lorenz analyzed deterministic nonperiodic flow and its implications for prediction.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX25"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX25"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL",
        "OBS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-035",
      "title": "A monitored warning statistic is assumed to announce every transition.",
      "equationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "OBS",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A changing stability mode may couple weakly to the measured variable or to the noise that excites it. A warning statistic can therefore remain quiet even as a relevant transition approaches.",
      "presentation": "Stable variance or autocorrelation is treated as proof that a system cannot collapse.",
      "diagnostic": "Check observability of the critical mode, noise direction and the hypothesized transition mechanism; compare multiple measured variables.",
      "remedy": "Treat warning indicators as mechanism-conditional evidence; evaluate false negatives and alternative transition paths.",
      "scope": "Absence of a universal warning is not evidence that warnings are always useless.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "The cited structured ecological models exhibit silent warning statistics."
        },
        {
          "field": "engineering monitoring",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A dangerous mode can be weakly visible to a chosen sensor."
        },
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A proposed transition marker needs an observation model before the ecological result can transfer."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2013,
          "event": "Boerlijst and colleagues provided ecological model counterexamples to universal early-warning claims.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX29"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX29"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "OBS",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-007",
        "SPIN-019",
        "YM-013"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-036",
      "title": "Decaying eigenmodes are treated as a bound on all transient amplification.",
      "equationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MIL-E-NS",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For a non-normal operator, nonorthogonal modes can combine into large transient growth even when every eigenvalue has negative real part.",
      "presentation": "An eigenvalue plot is used as a complete robustness certificate while some disturbances grow greatly before decaying.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect singular values of the propagator, resolvent norms and perturbation directions. The checked matrix [[−1,100],[0,−2]] amplifies e2 by more than 25 at t=log 2.",
      "remedy": "Bound transient response in the relevant norm and include nonlinear effects once disturbances leave the linear regime.",
      "scope": "A self-adjoint Hamiltonian does not have this non-normal mechanism; do not transplant it indiscriminately to quantum energy gaps.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "hydrodynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Non-normal transient amplification is the cited primary example."
        },
        {
          "field": "control engineering",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A stable spectrum does not alone bound disturbance response."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecological networks",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The mechanism applies when the linearized interaction operator is non-normal."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1993,
          "event": "Trefethen and colleagues examined hydrodynamic stability beyond eigenvalue-only reasoning.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX28"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX28"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "NS",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-006",
        "FORM-007",
        "SPIN-082"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-037",
      "title": "A short record without disasters is used to rule out rare events.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Low-probability outcomes may remain unseen in a modest sample even when their consequences dominate a decision. Zero observed events is not a proof of zero event probability.",
      "presentation": "A simulation campaign or service history with no failure is described as demonstrating impossibility.",
      "diagnostic": "Relate exposure count to a stated event model. With independent probability 0.001 per trial, the checked probability of no event in 100 trials is about 0.905.",
      "remedy": "Report bounds tied to exposure and assumptions; use targeted stress testing or rare-event methods when ordinary sampling is inadequate.",
      "scope": "The simple binomial example assumes independence and a fixed probability; real dependence can alter the bound.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "reliability engineering",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "No observed failures does not establish zero failure rate."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A monitoring record may miss rare transitions."
        },
        {
          "field": "numerical mathematics",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Failure to find a counterexample is similarly weaker than proof, although the probability model may not exist."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1933,
          "event": "Classical testing separates a procedure's error probabilities from what one realized dataset happens to contain.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX12"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX12"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-038",
      "title": "A nonlinear operation is applied after averaging as if order did not matter.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "MODEL",
        "QCHEM"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Generally E[f(X)] differs from f(E[X]). For equally likely X=−1 and X=1, the checked second moment is one while the square of the mean is zero.",
      "presentation": "An average temperature, concentration or exposure is inserted into a nonlinear response law and called the average response.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect curvature and input variability; compare averaging before and after applying the forward model.",
      "remedy": "Propagate the distribution through the nonlinear transformation or justify an approximation with an error bound.",
      "scope": "Equality can hold for affine functions or special distributions; it should be demonstrated rather than presumed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemical kinetics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A nonlinear concentration dependence interacts with concentration fluctuations."
        },
        {
          "field": "radiative physics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A temperature power law cannot generally use only mean temperature."
        },
        {
          "field": "risk modeling",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A nonlinear loss depends on more than the average exposure."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2008,
          "event": "Modern uncertainty analysis begins with the actual measurement function rather than assuming every transformation is linear.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX04"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX04"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "MODEL",
        "QCHEM"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FLUID-008",
        "NS-011"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-039",
      "title": "A hierarchy of moment equations is closed without controlling the discarded terms.",
      "equationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "STAT",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Evolution of a mean can depend on variance and higher moments. Replacing E[X²] by E[X]² removes fluctuation information; analogous closure assumptions can alter transport coefficients or dynamics.",
      "presentation": "A mean-field model predicts growth where fluctuations or correlations suppress it.",
      "diagnostic": "Derive the next equations in the hierarchy and identify the omitted terms. Our X∈{0,1} example gives E[X(1−X)]=0 but E[X](1−E[X])=1/4.",
      "remedy": "State the closure and its control parameter; compare with higher-order or direct calculations and include known corrections.",
      "scope": "A closure is an approximation unless an exact factorization or limiting theorem applies.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "fluid turbulence",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Averaged equations contain unresolved correlations."
        },
        {
          "field": "population dynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Population fluctuations change nonlinear average rates."
        },
        {
          "field": "transport theory",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "The 1972 correction explicitly identified neglected fluctuations in an earlier derivation."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1972,
          "event": "Zwanzig and coauthors corrected a 1961 derivation by restoring fluctuation contributions to transport coefficients.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX30",
            "HFX31"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX30",
        "HFX31"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "STAT",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-040",
      "title": "Ensemble-average gain is confused with growth along a single history.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "ODE",
        "INFO"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Multiplicative dynamics depend on sums of logarithms along a trajectory. A positive mean multiplier does not imply positive typical long-run growth.",
      "presentation": "A favorable average return or reproduction factor is interpreted as guaranteeing growth of a repeatedly exposed system.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify arithmetic expectation, typical trajectory or survival as the target. The checked equally likely multipliers 1.5 and 0.6 have mean 1.05 but geometric mean √0.9<1.",
      "remedy": "Analyze the stochastic process and the correct time horizon; include extinction or ruin if relevant.",
      "scope": "The example does not claim that all physical systems are nonergodic or that every mean is inappropriate.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "population biology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Repeated random growth is multiplicative."
        },
        {
          "field": "finance methodology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Expected wealth and typical log growth differ; no investment recommendation follows."
        },
        {
          "field": "information theory",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Kelly's work relates information to a specific multiplicative-growth criterion."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1956,
          "event": "Kelly connected information rate with a long-run multiplicative growth objective.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX45"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX45"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "ODE",
        "INFO"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-041",
      "title": "Two limits are interchanged without uniform control.",
      "equationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "ODE",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A family can converge differently depending on the order of limits. For f(ε,t)=exp(−εt), taking t→∞ first gives zero, while ε→0 first gives one after the remaining limit.",
      "presentation": "A weak coupling, long time, large system or fine resolution argument silently changes its limiting order.",
      "diagnostic": "Write both iterated limits and the joint scaling path; identify a domination, uniform estimate or other theorem that permits exchange.",
      "remedy": "Preserve the physically or mathematically specified order and state any controlled joint limit.",
      "scope": "The explicit counterexample shows a logical risk; it does not prove that a particular pair of limits in another theory fails to commute.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "kinetic theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Long observation time and weak interaction limits can require a joint scaling."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical approximation",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Small mass ratio and near-crossing regimes need separate control."
        },
        {
          "field": "thermodynamic modeling",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A uniform bound is stronger than a pointwise estimate for each finite system."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1999,
          "event": "Studies of Born–Oppenheimer behavior near crossings exemplify the need to control an approximation across a changing regime.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX32"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX32"
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "ODE",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-042",
      "title": "Removing variables is assumed to preserve memoryless dynamics.",
      "equationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL",
        "INFO"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A Markov description of a full state need not remain Markov after hidden variables are eliminated. The reduced evolution can depend on history through a memory kernel and on initial correlations.",
      "presentation": "A one-variable model fits equilibrium statistics but fails after a change of preparation or driving protocol.",
      "diagnostic": "Test whether the chosen reduced state predicts the future independently of earlier observations; inspect lag-dependent residuals and preparation effects.",
      "remedy": "Retain relevant hidden variables or model memory; justify any short-memory approximation through a timescale separation.",
      "scope": "The exact reduced equation and a memoryless approximation are different mathematical objects.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "statistical mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Projection can produce convolution terms in transport equations."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical networks",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Unresolved intermediates can create delayed effective responses."
        },
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A reduced activity variable may omit adaptation or latent state."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "1961; 1972",
          "event": "Zwanzig derived macroscopic memory terms in 1961; the associated nonlinear transport derivation was corrected in 1972.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX30",
            "HFX31"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX30",
        "HFX31"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "ODE",
        "MODEL",
        "INFO"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "QH-011",
        "SPIN-079",
        "SPIN-080"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-043",
      "title": "A separated fast–slow description is continued through a crossing.",
      "equationIds": [
        "QCHEM",
        "MODEL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Adiabatic separation requires control of coupling relative to relevant scales. Near a level crossing or narrow avoided crossing, derivative coupling and transitions can invalidate a single-surface approximation.",
      "presentation": "An electronic potential surface predicts a smooth nuclear path while the actual calculation transfers population between electronic states.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect energy separations, coupling matrix elements, nuclear motion and the approximating theorem's hypotheses.",
      "remedy": "Use a coupled-state treatment or a justified nonadiabatic approximation in the region where separation fails.",
      "scope": "The size of one spectral gap alone is not a complete error estimate; rates and couplings matter.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "molecular physics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Born–Oppenheimer breakdown near crossings is the primary case."
        },
        {
          "field": "quantum control",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Adiabatic passage needs rate and coupling control."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Fast–slow elimination also needs scale separation, but electronic transition formulas do not automatically transfer."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1999,
          "event": "Avron and Gordon studied Born–Oppenheimer behavior near a level crossing.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX32"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX32"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "QCHEM",
        "MODEL",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-044",
      "title": "Self-consistency of an approximate electronic calculation is treated as physical exactness.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DFT",
        "QCHEM",
        "OPT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Convergence of the iterative equations establishes a fixed point of the chosen approximation. It does not remove exchange-correlation error, basis limitations or a mismatch between the calculated quantity and the measured observable.",
      "presentation": "An SCF residual is tiny and the resulting material property is called exact without checking functional, basis or state assumptions.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate numerical convergence from approximation error; compare controlled limits, independent benchmarks and the actual observable definition.",
      "remedy": "State the electronic-structure approximation and uncertainty; validate the property in the regime for which it is used.",
      "scope": "The foundational formalism and a practical approximate functional should not be conflated.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "electronic structure",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Kohn–Sham equations provide a framework containing approximation choices."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials design",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A converged prediction can still be biased for the target material."
        },
        {
          "field": "inverse design",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "An optimizer can exploit model error unless candidates are independently checked."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1965,
          "event": "Kohn and Sham developed self-consistent equations and explicit approximations for exchange and correlation.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX33"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX33"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DFT",
        "QCHEM",
        "OPT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-045",
      "title": "An energy barrier or excitation gap is used as a complete reaction-rate law.",
      "equationIds": [
        "QCHEM",
        "GAP",
        "ODE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Rates require dynamics: couplings, thermal occupation, friction, available pathways and prefactors can matter. An energy difference is not by itself a transition probability per unit time.",
      "presentation": "Two systems with similar barriers are assigned the same lifetime despite different environments or reaction coordinates.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the dynamical model and rate regime; vary temperature and environment and check whether the relevant rate formula applies.",
      "remedy": "Calculate or measure the rate with its kinetic assumptions, rather than translating a barrier into a lifetime without a model.",
      "scope": "A Hamiltonian spectral gap, a free-energy barrier and an activation energy are different quantities.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemical kinetics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Kramers' escape model includes temperature and friction."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Defect migration depends on kinetic pathways and prefactors."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A resilience landscape may suggest barriers, but molecular rate formulas require a separately justified stochastic model."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1940,
          "event": "Kramers studied barrier escape and the role of Brownian motion and viscosity in reaction rates.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX34"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX34"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "QCHEM",
        "GAP",
        "ODE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-046",
      "title": "The equilibrium distribution is assumed to determine the relaxation time.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "ODE",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Different transition operators can share one stationary distribution. For Q=c[[-1,1],[1,−1]], the equilibrium is (1/2,1/2) for every c>0 while the nonzero decay rate is 2c.",
      "presentation": "Matching equilibrium populations is taken as validation of kinetics or mixing speed.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare time correlations, response functions and transition rates as well as stationary statistics.",
      "remedy": "Validate the generator or dynamical model separately from its equilibrium measure.",
      "scope": "The explicit example concerns a classical continuous-time Markov chain; quantum Hamiltonian and open-system gaps need their own definitions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemical kinetics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Equilibrium ratios do not uniquely determine forward and reverse rates."
        },
        {
          "field": "Monte Carlo",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Samplers may target the same distribution but mix at different speeds."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Matching stationary occupancy need not match turnover or recovery rates."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1940,
          "event": "Kramers' work separates kinetic escape behavior from static potential information.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX34"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX34"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "ODE",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-047",
      "title": "A finite observation window turns slow dynamics into apparent permanence.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "ODE",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A relaxation or switching time longer than the record can make a metastable state look invariant. Conversely, averaging over fast motion can hide the dynamics that generate a steady signal.",
      "presentation": "No observed switch is called a conserved state, or a short run is labeled equilibrated because its plotted trace is flat.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare observation duration with independently estimated correlation and escape times; test multiple initial states and sampling windows.",
      "remedy": "Report the temporal resolution and duration of the claim, and extend or redesign the observation where unresolved timescales matter.",
      "scope": "The absence of observed motion is not a proof of an exactly zero transition rate.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "molecular simulation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Barrier crossing can occur beyond the simulated time."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A stable monitoring interval may not reveal rare regime changes."
        },
        {
          "field": "glassy materials",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Very slow relaxation can mimic a stationary state within an experiment."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1940,
          "event": "Barrier-escape theory supplies a mechanism by which a finite record can miss transitions.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX34",
            "HFX29"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX34",
        "HFX29"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OBS",
        "ODE",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-048",
      "title": "Geometric resemblance is treated as dynamical similarity.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "MODEL",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Two objects can have the same shape while different ratios of inertial, viscous, gravitational, capillary, elastic or diffusive effects govern their motion.",
      "presentation": "A tabletop model or small organism is assumed to reproduce the dynamics of a much larger counterpart after simple magnification.",
      "diagnostic": "List the controlling dimensionless groups and boundary conditions; determine which can be matched simultaneously.",
      "remedy": "Design a similarity experiment for the intended regime and disclose unmatched groups.",
      "scope": "This differs from dimensional consistency: the issue is transfer between concrete systems, even when each model has correct units.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "aerodynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A geometrically similar model need not match the relevant flow regime."
        },
        {
          "field": "biomechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Scaling size changes force ratios."
        },
        {
          "field": "microfluidics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Surface and viscous effects can dominate differently from macroscopic flow."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1914,
          "event": "Buckingham's physical-similarity analysis supplies a framework for checking which scale transfers are justified.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX03"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1638,
          "event": "Galileo separates geometric resemblance from physical strength. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-GALILEO1638"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX03",
        "EARLY-GALILEO1638"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DIM",
        "MODEL",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-049",
      "title": "An aggregate correlation is assigned to individuals.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "CAUSAL",
        "INVERSE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Group totals or means discard within-group joint distributions. Many individual-level associations can be compatible with the same aggregate data.",
      "presentation": "Regions with larger average exposure have a larger outcome rate, and the pattern is attributed to the exposed individuals without individual-level evidence.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the unit of each variable and the target claim; examine whether the available data identify within-group relationships.",
      "remedy": "Use appropriate individual or multilevel data, or report bounds and assumptions for ecological inference.",
      "scope": "An aggregate relationship can be meaningful for an aggregate target; the error is an unsupported change of level.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "epidemiology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Area rates do not uniquely determine individual exposure–outcome associations."
        },
        {
          "field": "sociology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Robinson's original paper directly analyzes ecological and individual correlation."
        },
        {
          "field": "single-cell biology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Bulk averages can hide the distribution and dependence of cell-level states."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1950,
          "event": "Robinson demonstrated the distinction between ecological and individual correlations.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX44"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX44"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "CAUSAL",
        "INVERSE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-050",
      "title": "A multimodel ensemble is treated as independent probability sampling.",
      "equationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Models can share code, data, parameterizations or structural assumptions. Ensemble spread need not include every plausible error source, and equal model counts do not establish equal probabilities.",
      "presentation": "A narrow ensemble spread is called a calibrated uncertainty interval without a sampling or weighting argument.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect model genealogy, shared assumptions, common residuals and sensitivity to weighting and model-family inclusion.",
      "remedy": "Separate spread from a justified predictive distribution and evaluate common structural uncertainty.",
      "scope": "A useful ensemble mean can coexist with incomplete uncertainty coverage.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "climate science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Knutti and colleagues analyze challenges of combining climate models."
        },
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Correlated predictors reduce the information gained by ensemble size."
        },
        {
          "field": "computational chemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Several related functionals may share a bias rather than independently corroborate a property."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2010,
          "event": "Knutti and colleagues examined uncertainty and combination rules for multimodel climate projections.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX35"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX35"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-051",
      "title": "Improving the instrument is assumed to remove finite-sample cosmic uncertainty.",
      "equationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS",
        "GR"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A more sensitive detector can reduce measurement noise without supplying additional independent realizations of the cosmological field. Inference from a finite observable sky retains sampling limitations under the assumed stochastic model.",
      "presentation": "A disagreement in a small number of large-scale modes is treated as impossible because instrumental noise is small.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate instrumental noise, sky coverage, mode count and model assumptions in the covariance calculation.",
      "remedy": "Report the irreducible sampling term appropriate to the model and observables; distinguish it from removable detector error.",
      "scope": "Cosmic variance is model- and statistic-dependent, not a universal excuse for every discrepancy.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "cosmology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "CMB parameter forecasts account for limited sky information."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "One observed ecosystem also limits independent replication, but it is not literally the same cosmic-variance formula."
        },
        {
          "field": "geoscience",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A single historical trajectory separates observational precision from replication."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1995,
          "event": "Knox analyzed how CMB observables can constrain inflationary parameters under finite-sky and experimental limitations.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX36"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX36"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "STAT",
        "OBS",
        "GR"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-052",
      "title": "A conditional cosmological estimate is presented as a direct model-free observation.",
      "equationIds": [
        "GR",
        "MODEL",
        "INVERSE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An inferred parameter is obtained through a likelihood, foreground treatment and cosmological model. Changing those assumptions can change the estimate without changing the underlying observed photons.",
      "presentation": "A fitted parameter is called directly measured and a mismatch is assigned to one theory before checking inference dependencies.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate raw observables from inferred quantities; vary justified model extensions, nuisance parameters and data combinations.",
      "remedy": "State the conditioning model and provide sensitivity where it materially affects the interpretation.",
      "scope": "Conditional inference can be powerful and precise; its assumptions remain part of the result.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "cosmology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Planck explicitly states the base cosmological model for quoted parameter estimates."
        },
        {
          "field": "geophysical inversion",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An inferred interior parameter depends on the forward model."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An inferred population depends on response and state assumptions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "2018; 2020 publication",
          "event": "The Planck 2018 cosmological-parameter analysis explicitly conditions parameter estimates on a specified model.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX37"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX37"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GR",
        "MODEL",
        "INVERSE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-053",
      "title": "A singular coordinate representation is mistaken for a physical singularity.",
      "equationIds": [
        "GR",
        "MODEL",
        "OBS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Components of a metric or other description can diverge because a chart fails. An invariant pathology requires an invariant diagnostic, such as relevant curvature or geodesic behavior.",
      "presentation": "A denominator vanishes in one coordinate formula and is taken as proof that spacetime or the physical solution ends there.",
      "diagnostic": "Transform to a regular chart where possible and inspect coordinate-invariant quantities and the intended extension.",
      "remedy": "Distinguish chart boundaries from physical singularities; state the region and regularity of the representation.",
      "scope": "Changing coordinates does not remove genuine curvature singularities or establish completeness by itself.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "general relativity",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Kruskal's extension removes the Schwarzschild horizon coordinate singularity."
        },
        {
          "field": "robotics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An orientation parameterization can become singular while the physical orientation remains regular."
        },
        {
          "field": "fluid simulation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Coordinate mapping degeneracy need not be a physical blow-up."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1960,
          "event": "Kruskal exhibited a regular extension using a different coordinate description.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX38"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX38"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GR",
        "MODEL",
        "OBS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-054",
      "title": "A closed-system conservation statement is applied to an open subsystem.",
      "equationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "ODE",
        "OBS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A subsystem balance includes boundary flux, sources, sinks and exchange with unobserved degrees of freedom. Omitting these terms can make correct dynamics look like creation or destruction of the conserved quantity.",
      "presentation": "An energy, mass or probability budget fails and the failure is interpreted as a new law before boundary transport is checked.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the integral balance over the actual control volume and account for measured and modeled transfers through its boundary.",
      "remedy": "Track the complete budget or state the effective source terms in the reduced model.",
      "scope": "Whether a quantity is conserved depends on the model and symmetry; the existence of a balance equation should not be assumed for every named quantity.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemical engineering",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A reactor concentration changes with inflow, outflow and reaction."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecosystem science",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A local nutrient stock includes boundary transfers."
        },
        {
          "field": "open quantum systems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A reduced subsystem can exchange energy with its environment; the correct dynamical formalism still needs justification."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1961,
          "event": "Projection approaches in statistical mechanics distinguish full dynamics from the effective behavior of selected variables.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX30"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1822,
          "event": "Fourier specifies initial state, geometry and insulation before evolving heat. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-FOURIER1822"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1824,
          "event": "Carnot distinguishes an ideal reversible construction from its physical execution. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX30",
        "EARLY-FOURIER1822",
        "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "ODE",
        "OBS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-055",
      "title": "A stationary numerical solution is treated as the global optimum.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OPT",
        "MODEL",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A small gradient or successful optimizer return code establishes only what the algorithm's stopping condition checks. Nonconvex objectives can have multiple stationary points and local minima.",
      "presentation": "One parameter initialization yields a well-converged result that is called the unique best fit or lowest possible energy.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect objective geometry, alternative starts, constraints and certified lower bounds where available; compare objective values rather than termination labels.",
      "remedy": "Report local-optimum status unless a global certificate or applicable convexity theorem is supplied.",
      "scope": "Different local solutions are not automatically equally physically valid; domain constraints remain essential.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "electronic structure",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Self-consistent iterations can require state and stability checks."
        },
        {
          "field": "inverse problems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A nonconvex fit can return different parameter solutions."
        },
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Optimization convergence differs from global optimality and predictive adequacy."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1965,
          "event": "Self-consistent and model-selection methods expose the distinction between solving chosen equations and validating the larger inference.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX33",
            "HFX19"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX33",
        "HFX19"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OPT",
        "MODEL",
        "DATA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-056",
      "title": "The optimization target does not represent the scientific target.",
      "equationIds": [
        "OPT",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A surrogate loss, average score or reward may omit the property that matters. Optimizing it can improve the metric while degrading calibration, worst-case behavior or physical consistency.",
      "presentation": "A model wins a benchmark by exploiting a shortcut that does not survive the intended experiment or deployment.",
      "diagnostic": "Connect each objective term to the actual claim and evaluate alternatives that score similarly while differing in the target behavior.",
      "remedy": "Use a justified objective, external constraints and independent validation on the intended task.",
      "scope": "A mismatch is not fixed simply by optimizing the same objective more accurately.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Selection criteria can themselves be overfit."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials design",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "An approximate property score can reward unphysical candidates unless the model is checked."
        },
        {
          "field": "operations research",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Optimizing an incomplete cost function can violate omitted requirements."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2010,
          "event": "Cawley and Talbot analyzed how optimizing a noisy selection criterion can harm subsequent performance assessment.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX19",
            "HFX20"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX19",
        "HFX20"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "OPT",
        "MODEL",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-057",
      "title": "Software is reused outside the domain its assumptions and tests cover.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "MODEL",
        "OPT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Correct behavior on the original operating range does not establish correct behavior after changes in inputs, environment, constraints or failure handling. Shared fallback components can share the same failure.",
      "presentation": "A component is described as proven because it worked in a predecessor system, while new conditions trigger an unhandled exception or invalid state.",
      "diagnostic": "Map new operating ranges against assumptions, numeric limits and test coverage; exercise abnormal inputs and complete recovery paths.",
      "remedy": "Revalidate reused components against the new system's requirements and test meaningful failure scenarios.",
      "scope": "The official Ariane summary supports specification and testing failures; this record does not infer additional implementation details beyond that account.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "aerospace",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "The Ariane 501 inquiry identifies deficiencies in software, specification and testing."
        },
        {
          "field": "scientific computing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A solver validated for one class of matrices may fail on another."
        },
        {
          "field": "industrial automation",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A changed operating envelope can invalidate reused control assumptions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1996,
          "event": "Ariane 501 failed on 4 June 1996; the inquiry report was presented in July.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX07"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX07"
      ],
      "verification": "primary-source-result",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "MODEL",
        "OPT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-058",
      "title": "Real-number algebra is assumed to hold exactly in machine arithmetic.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "OPT",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Finite precision introduces rounding, cancellation, overflow and nonassociativity. Algebraically equivalent expressions can yield different machine results.",
      "presentation": "A tiny gap becomes zero after subtracting rounded energies, or parallel reduction order changes the final sum.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect conditioning and intermediate magnitudes; use stable formulations, higher precision and error bounds. The checked example (10¹⁶−10¹⁶)+1=1 but 10¹⁶+(−10¹⁶+1)=0 in the chosen float arithmetic.",
      "remedy": "Use numerically stable algorithms and justify the precision needed for the derived quantity.",
      "scope": "Changing precision does not repair a wrong model or a logically invalid inference.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "spectral computation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Subtracting nearby energies can lose significant digits."
        },
        {
          "field": "geodesy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Large coordinate values can mask small displacements."
        },
        {
          "field": "financial computation",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Summation and rounding rules affect exact accounting results."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1991,
          "event": "Goldberg's 1991 paper systematically explained practical floating-point failure mechanisms.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX39"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX00",
        "HFX39"
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "OPT",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-059",
      "title": "Repeated use of the same implementation is counted as independent verification.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Two outputs can agree because they reuse the same library, cached result, preprocessing or incorrect assumption. Agreement then tests repetition, not the shared point of failure.",
      "presentation": "Several notebooks produce the same number but all call the same function with the same undocumented default.",
      "diagnostic": "Trace dependencies and data lineage; identify what is actually independent in an alternative derivation, implementation or measurement.",
      "remedy": "Choose checks that can fail differently, such as an analytic limiting case, independently implemented formulation or external reference.",
      "scope": "Reproducibility and independent corroboration are both valuable, but they answer different questions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "scientific software",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Shared leakage or preprocessing can propagate across studies."
        },
        {
          "field": "metrology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Independent instruments may still share a calibration bias."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical scholarship",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Several retellings of one source are not several independent witnesses."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2023,
          "event": "Modern reproducibility studies highlight the need to inspect the full path from data to reported performance.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX20",
            "HFX05"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX20",
        "HFX05"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-060",
      "title": "A data join changes the counting unit and inflates the evidence.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "STAT",
        "OBS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Joining records on a nonunique key can duplicate rows or create a many-to-many expansion. Aggregates and standard errors then refer to an unintended population of rows.",
      "presentation": "A total increases after adding descriptive metadata, or a sample size changes without new independent observations.",
      "diagnostic": "Declare the intended record grain; check key uniqueness, join cardinality and conserved totals before and after each transformation.",
      "remedy": "Aggregate or disambiguate at the appropriate level and retain identifiers for the actual observational unit.",
      "scope": "This is a constructed data-pipeline hazard, not an allegation that the supplied gap table contains duplicated observations.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "laboratory informatics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "One sample may have many assays and many annotations."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Repeated visits and species records have different observational units."
        },
        {
          "field": "business analytics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Transactions multiplied by many matching attributes inflate totals."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1984,
          "event": "Experimental-design work distinguishes actual experimental units from the number of records presented for analysis.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX11",
            "HFX20"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX11",
        "HFX20"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "STAT",
        "OBS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-061",
      "title": "Future or related information leaks into a nominally held-out prediction.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "STAT",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Preprocessing, labels, repeated subjects or time alignment can carry information from the evaluation target into model construction. Apparent prediction then partly reconstructs already available target information.",
      "presentation": "Random train–test splitting gives excellent performance, but chronological or subject-level splitting sharply reduces it.",
      "diagnostic": "Audit the time when each feature becomes available and the dependencies between records; fit preprocessing only within the appropriate training partition.",
      "remedy": "Use splits matching the deployment question and prevent related records or future-derived features from crossing the boundary.",
      "scope": "A temporal split is necessary for some tasks, not an automatic universal cure for every dependence.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "forecasting",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Future-derived features invalidate prospective evaluation."
        },
        {
          "field": "biomedical prediction methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Records from one person can leak across partitions."
        },
        {
          "field": "materials informatics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Near-duplicate structures or experiments can make a test set artificially easy."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2023,
          "event": "Kapoor and Narayanan documented leakage mechanisms in machine-learning-based science.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX20"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX20"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "STAT",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-062",
      "title": "The result is disconnected from the exact version of its assumptions and inputs.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Changes in data, code, dependencies, constants, random state or defaults can alter a result while its label remains unchanged. A screenshot or headline number is insufficient provenance.",
      "presentation": "Two runs described as the same study disagree, but the relevant configuration and input versions are unavailable.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare versioned input hashes, configuration, dependency versions, seeds and execution records; distinguish nondeterminism from an actual change in specification.",
      "remedy": "Store a reproducible result bundle and an explicit change log; regenerate claims from the recorded inputs.",
      "scope": "A reproducible bundle establishes what was run, not that the method was scientifically correct.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "computational physics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Boundary or normalization defaults can alter a spectrum."
        },
        {
          "field": "data engineering",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A schema change can silently change a metric."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical editing",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "An edition or translation change can alter the text being compared."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2023,
          "event": "Modern leakage and reproducibility analyses require enough pipeline information to assess how a result was generated.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX20",
            "HFX39"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX20",
        "HFX39"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-063",
      "title": "Display choices change the apparent claim without changing the underlying data.",
      "equationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "OBS",
        "STAT",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Rounding, clipped axes, logarithmic scales, binning or interpolation can conceal uncertainty or make a trend look linear, zero or universal.",
      "presentation": "A very small positive number prints as 0.000, a narrow y-axis exaggerates a difference, or a fitted line hides that only two sizes were observed.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect the unrounded values, scale definitions, residuals and uncertainty; compare views suited to competing hypotheses.",
      "remedy": "Show the data and the transformation explicitly; separate fitted interpolation from observed samples and preserve accessible numeric values.",
      "scope": "No graph alone proves an asymptotic limit or mechanism; the visualization must match the inferential question.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "spectral gaps",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A log plot can reveal orders of magnitude but not certify a limiting gap."
        },
        {
          "field": "epidemiology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Relative scales and absolute effects answer different practical questions."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical datasets",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Uneven sampling and interpolation can fabricate apparent continuity."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "1991; 2008",
          "event": "Measurement uncertainty and finite representation explain why displayed digits must be interpreted with a stated error model.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX04",
            "HFX39"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX04",
        "HFX39"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DATA",
        "OBS",
        "STAT",
        "GAP"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-064",
      "title": "A convenient surrogate is assumed to capture the target outcome.",
      "equationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "OBS",
        "STAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An intervention can change a measured proxy through a pathway that does not improve the target outcome, or can affect the target through pathways the proxy omits.",
      "presentation": "A biomarker, engagement measure or simulation score improves and is treated as proof of the desired real-world benefit.",
      "diagnostic": "Define the target outcome and intervention family; test the assumptions connecting intervention effects on the surrogate to effects on the target.",
      "remedy": "Validate the surrogate for the intended use or measure the target directly; retain uncertainty about the bridge.",
      "scope": "Correlation of surrogate and outcome alone does not establish valid surrogacy for every intervention.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "clinical research methodology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Prentice formalized criteria for surrogate endpoints."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "An indicator species may not fully represent ecosystem function."
        },
        {
          "field": "software performance",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A benchmark score may not capture user-visible reliability or usefulness."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1989,
          "event": "Prentice proposed operational criteria for surrogate endpoints in clinical trials.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX40"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX40"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "OBS",
        "STAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-065",
      "title": "A fitted relationship is assumed invariant when policy or incentives change.",
      "equationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "MODEL",
        "ODE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Agents can change behavior in response to a rule or metric. A fitted relation under one policy can cease to describe the system after the policy changes the decision environment.",
      "presentation": "A historical correlation is used to predict the effect of a new incentive without modeling how participants adapt.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify which behavioral mechanisms respond to the intervention and test the proposed invariance across regimes.",
      "remedy": "Use an appropriate structural or experimental design and monitor adaptation; do not assume a reduced-form coefficient is a policy-invariant constant.",
      "scope": "The risk is conditional; not every policy change invalidates every empirical relationship.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "economics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Lucas' critique targets policy evaluation using unstable decision-rule relationships."
        },
        {
          "field": "education",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A score can change meaning when it becomes an incentive target."
        },
        {
          "field": "online platforms",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Adaptive participants alter the data-generating process after a rule change."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1976,
          "event": "Lucas argued that policy-dependent decision rules limit certain uses of fitted econometric relationships.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX41"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX41"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CAUSAL",
        "MODEL",
        "ODE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-066",
      "title": "A diagram supplies an existence assumption that the formal proof has not stated.",
      "equationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "PROVENANCE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A visual construction may suggest that objects intersect, limits exist or boundaries are regular. Those properties require the appropriate axioms or hypotheses in a formal argument.",
      "presentation": "A point is drawn at an intersection and then used in the proof without establishing the required intersection in the chosen formal system.",
      "diagnostic": "List every object whose existence is used and identify the axiom or theorem supplying it.",
      "remedy": "State the needed existence or continuity assumptions and verify them in the intended model.",
      "scope": "Euclid I.1 is used to examine proof obligations, not to claim that the equilateral-triangle theorem is false.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "geometry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The circle-intersection step illustrates an existence obligation."
        },
        {
          "field": "numerical visualization",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A rendered crossing does not prove an exact intersection."
        },
        {
          "field": "scientific diagrams",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "An arrow or drawn pathway is a proposed relation until evidence supplies it."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "c. 300 BCE",
          "event": "Euclid's equilateral-triangle construction uses the intersection of two circles; modern formalization makes its existence assumptions explicit.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX01"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX01"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "PROVENANCE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-067",
      "title": "A proof is extended to objects outside its stated universe.",
      "equationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "PROVENANCE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A step justified for one class of quantities may fail for another. An Archimedean comparison, ordering, completeness property or regularity assumption cannot be silently carried into a more general setting.",
      "presentation": "A familiar argument with real magnitudes is applied to a new algebraic or geometric object merely because the same symbol is used.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the exact domain and each structural property used in the proof; test a model lacking that property.",
      "remedy": "Restrict the conclusion to the proved domain or supply a new argument for the extension.",
      "scope": "Ancient magnitude theory and modern real analysis are related but not identical formal systems.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "geometry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Elements X.1 uses a comparison of multiples in its magnitude argument."
        },
        {
          "field": "analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Changing the ambient space changes available convergence and ordering theorems."
        },
        {
          "field": "physics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An effective variable need not inherit every property of the microscopic variable it replaces."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "c. 300 BCE",
          "event": "Euclid's magnitude arguments make a historical case for auditing the universe of objects to which a proof applies.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX02"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": "1687 work; 1729 inspected witness",
          "event": "Newton states the boundary between a fixed force center and mutually moving bodies. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-NEWTON1687"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX02",
        "EARLY-NEWTON1687"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "MODEL",
        "PROVENANCE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-068",
      "title": "Shared vocabulary across eras is mistaken for a shared scientific definition.",
      "equationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL",
        "SYMMETRY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Words such as vibration, polarity, energy or correspondence can serve different conceptual roles in different texts. Matching a word does not supply an operator, unit, experiment or preserved mathematical structure.",
      "presentation": "A modern quantum result is presented as a derivation from an earlier philosophical phrase without a translation specifying measurable quantities.",
      "diagnostic": "Read the relevant passage in its edition and context; map meanings explicitly and list what has no mathematical counterpart.",
      "remedy": "Label the comparison as a heuristic analogy unless a precise and supported correspondence is established.",
      "scope": "A heuristic can generate useful questions; it does not acquire empirical validity from antiquity or verbal resemblance.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "history of science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Dating and contextual meaning are necessary for a historical claim."
        },
        {
          "field": "quantum physics",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "The Kybalion's vocabulary is not a substitute for a Hamiltonian or measurement rule."
        },
        {
          "field": "comparative religion",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Similar translated terms need not indicate the same doctrine or textual lineage."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "1908; 1926",
          "event": "The Kybalion's 1908 text offers named principles; Schrödinger's 1926 paper supplies a distinct mathematical and documentary context.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX42",
            "HFX43"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1824,
          "event": "Carnot distinguishes an ideal reversible construction from its physical execution. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX42",
        "HFX43",
        "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL",
        "SYMMETRY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-069",
      "title": "Mathematical equivalence is promoted into a historical influence claim.",
      "equationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Two formulations can be mathematically related without one author having derived the idea from the other. Conversely, documented inspiration does not establish mathematical equivalence.",
      "presentation": "A later representation map is used as proof of a causal lineage across authors, traditions or centuries.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate the mathematical map from documentary evidence such as citations, letters, notebooks, translations and dated access.",
      "remedy": "Record structural correspondence and historical influence as separate relation types, with evidence for each.",
      "scope": "Absence of a documented influence in the inspected corpus is not proof that no influence ever occurred.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "quantum history",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Schrödinger's contemporary comparison contains explicit references and a specific relation between formulations."
        },
        {
          "field": "algorithm history",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Equivalent algorithms do not by themselves establish borrowing."
        },
        {
          "field": "textual studies",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Parallel passages invite investigation but do not uniquely determine transmission."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1926,
          "event": "Schrödinger compared wave and matrix formulations in a contemporaneous paper with explicit references.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX43"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX43"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-070",
      "title": "Composition, manuscript, translation, print and web dates are collapsed into one date.",
      "equationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A digital page can display an upload or reprint date distinct from the original publication; a manuscript witness can be much later than the inferred composition of its text.",
      "presentation": "A historical paper appears to be modern in a timeline, or a modern edition date is assigned to the ancient work itself.",
      "diagnostic": "Store separate dated events and inspect the title page, volume, edition statement and catalog evidence.",
      "remedy": "Use explicit date types and confidence ranges; preserve uncertainty rather than inventing a single exact origin.",
      "scope": "The user's request for coverage across time makes provenance of dates part of the evidence, not a cosmetic citation detail.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "scientific bibliography",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Simpson's original 1951 paper must not be dated by a later publisher web record."
        },
        {
          "field": "textual history",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Euclid's approximate composition and a modern English presentation are different witnesses."
        },
        {
          "field": "data lineage",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Event time, ingestion time and processing time similarly answer different questions."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "1950; 2009",
          "event": "The catalogue distinguishes Robinson's 1950 original from its 2009 reprint, and ancient works from their modern presentations.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX10",
            "HFX01",
            "HFX44"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": "1687 work; 1729 inspected witness",
          "event": "Newton states the boundary between a fixed force center and mutually moving bodies. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-NEWTON1687"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1822,
          "event": "Fourier specifies initial state, geometry and insulation before evolving heat. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-FOURIER1822"
          ]
        },
        {
          "year": 1824,
          "event": "Carnot distinguishes an ideal reversible construction from its physical execution. This is a methodological anchor; the detailed event preserves the inspected edition and claim boundaries.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX10",
        "HFX01",
        "HFX44",
        "EARLY-NEWTON1687",
        "EARLY-FOURIER1822",
        "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "DATA"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-071",
      "title": "Many citations are treated as many independent evidential sources.",
      "equationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A chain of reviews, copied summaries or duplicated datasets can lead back to one observation or one unverified assertion. Counting documents then overstates corroboration.",
      "presentation": "A claim appears well established because many pages repeat it, yet each relies on the same source or on one another.",
      "diagnostic": "Build a citation and data-origin graph; trace each claim to the earliest accessible primary evidence and inspect independent replication.",
      "remedy": "Count independent evidence streams and disclose shared ancestry; cite primary material where it supports the claim.",
      "scope": "Agreement between dependent sources can help recover a text, but it does not create new empirical replications.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "literature synthesis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Several reports may reuse one dataset."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical research",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Several modern retellings can descend from one witness."
        },
        {
          "field": "multimodel science",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Related model families can share errors, although model dependence is not identical to citation copying."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "2010; 2023",
          "event": "Modern reproducibility and ensemble analyses make shared dependencies relevant to the strength of apparent agreement.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX20",
            "HFX35"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX20",
        "HFX35"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "STAT",
        "DATA"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "FORM-010",
        "HOD-003"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "CROSS-072",
      "title": "An unsuccessful search is treated as proof that no evidence or relationship exists.",
      "equationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Search coverage is limited by language, terminology, indexing, access, preservation and the query strategy. Failure to retrieve a document is evidence about that search, not a universal nonexistence theorem.",
      "presentation": "A relation is declared historically impossible because a keyword query returned nothing, or a modern indexed source is called the earliest occurrence without archive checks.",
      "diagnostic": "Record databases, languages, date ranges, synonyms and inaccessible material; distinguish an absent finding from a systematically bounded negative result.",
      "remedy": "Phrase conclusions at the strength supported by the search and keep unresolved provenance as an explicit research question.",
      "scope": "This does not license inventing missing evidence or treating every imagined connection as equally credible.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "history of science",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Surviving and searchable records are an incomplete evidential base."
        },
        {
          "field": "systematic reviews",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A documented search strategy defines coverage and remaining uncertainty."
        },
        {
          "field": "mathematical research",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Failure to find a proof or counterexample is weaker than a theorem of impossibility."
        }
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": "c. 300 BCE–1926; present inspection",
          "event": "Primary texts and modern witnesses support specific inspected claims; they do not exhaust the entire historical record.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "HFX01",
            "HFX43"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "HFX01",
        "HFX43"
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical and cross-disciplinary inference",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PROVENANCE",
        "MODEL"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-001",
      "title": "The score uses a different outcome range from its bound",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The standard CHSH normalization uses outcomes in [-1,1], with deterministic extrema at ±1. Rescaled voltages or spin operators with eigenvalues ±1/2 change the allowed score. A bound cannot be carried across a scale change without rescaling it.",
      "presentation": "A perfectly ordinary classical signal seems to exceed 2, or a valid quantum calculation seems too small by a factor of four.",
      "diagnostic": "Enumerate the actual recorded outcome alphabet; derive the bound with those extrema and verify the measurement-operator norms.",
      "remedy": "Normalize outcomes explicitly or calculate the appropriate bound in the instrument's units. Preserve nondetections rather than deleting them.",
      "scope": "This is a conditional implementation risk. The notebook's Pauli ±1 normalization is explicit.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "metrology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A calibrated gain changes both signal and a comparison threshold."
        },
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An amplitude or unnormalized cross-correlation threshold depends on voltage normalization; a dimensionless Pearson correlation is invariant under positive rescaling."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CHSH1969"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-002",
      "title": "A sign or basis convention changes the target correlation",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH",
        "BELLSTATE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The relative phase in a Bell state changes selected correlators. For example, changing Phi-plus to Phi-minus reverses XX while leaving ZZ unchanged. Outcome relabeling or switching the subtracted CHSH term also changes the optimal setting convention.",
      "presentation": "The data have a strong correlation but the published combination cancels it, or a plot labels an anti-correlation as disagreement with quantum mechanics.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute ZZ, XX, ZX and XZ separately; derive the score from the actual state and recorded outcome labels before optimizing.",
      "remedy": "Version the preparation phase, basis order, setting labels and score convention together. Test known product and Bell states.",
      "scope": "A sign mistake is not evidence against the theorem; a transformed experiment requires a transformed comparison.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Phase conventions alter interference terms."
        },
        {
          "field": "signal processing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A channel sign reversal changes a cross-correlation without changing the physical signal source."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH",
        "BELLSTATE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-003",
      "title": "Degrees, radians, or physical polarizer angles are interchanged",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Trigonometric software commonly accepts radians; displayed controls may use degrees. For polarization, the Bloch-sphere angle and the laboratory polarizer angle can differ by a factor of two.",
      "presentation": "The apparent optimum shifts, a 45-degree control fails to yield the intended observable, or the simulation has a repeated angular pattern at the wrong period.",
      "diagnostic": "Evaluate the observable matrices at labeled cardinal angles and verify their eigenvalues and overlap with a known calibration state.",
      "remedy": "Convert units at one documented boundary and distinguish a Bloch parameter from a hardware rotation.",
      "scope": "The analytic angle in this notebook is the coefficient angle in B0 and B1. A hardware mapping is an additional model.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "orbital mechanics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Angle-unit mismatches corrupt rotations."
        },
        {
          "field": "imaging",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Polarization and spinor parameterizations may not use the detector's geometric angle directly."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-004",
      "title": "A proposed observable is not a valid normalized measurement",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Arbitrary coefficients a and b in aZ+bX give eigenvalues ±sqrt(a²+b²). Unit length is required for the claimed nondegenerate ±1 projective observable. Norm at most one can instead describe a valid unsharp binary measurement and still respects the local bound; norm greater than one changes the normalization. Non-Hermitian matrices do not represent the stated projective observable.",
      "presentation": "An optimizer produces S greater than 2sqrt(2) by quietly increasing operator norms.",
      "diagnostic": "Check Hermiticity, spectrum, B²=I for the claimed projective observables, and positivity/completeness for any replacement POVM.",
      "remedy": "Optimize over the valid measurement set, not over unrestricted matrix entries; carry an explicitly changed normalization into the bound.",
      "scope": "This is an algebraic admissibility check, not a claim that arbitrary generalized measurements are forbidden.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An unconstrained optimizer can leave the feasible set."
        },
        {
          "field": "engineering control",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A controller can achieve a target only by violating an actuator constraint."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-TSIRELSON1980"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-005",
      "title": "The fitted state is not positive semidefinite",
      "equationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "PPT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Trace one and Hermiticity do not suffice for a density matrix. In the declared white-noise family, v=1.1 gives three eigenvalues -1/40 and one 43/40. A fit outside the physical set can yield impossible predictions.",
      "presentation": "A reconstructed state has negative probabilities or a super-quantum score; error bars are reported around an inadmissible central estimate.",
      "diagnostic": "Diagonalize the fitted state with uncertainty-aware tolerances; test trace, Hermiticity and all relevant probabilities. At v=11/10 the negative eigenvalue is exact.",
      "remedy": "Fit within a justified state space and report boundary bias or model inadequacy. Do not silently clip eigenvalues and retain the original uncertainty claims.",
      "scope": "The published notebook restricts v to [0,1]. This executed out-of-range example tests an attempted extrapolation.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "statistics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Estimated covariance matrices must also satisfy positivity constraints."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical kinetics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A fit with negative populations can match a curve while violating its model."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "PPT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-006",
      "title": "One visibility parameter is substituted for an arbitrary noise channel",
      "equationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "S=2sqrt(2)v follows at the optimizing angle for the specified maximally mixed admixture and selected Pauli observables; at a general angle it is 2v(cos theta+sin theta). Dephasing, amplitude damping, asymmetric readout and coherent rotations change different components of the correlation tensor.",
      "presentation": "A single fitted contrast predicts one angle well and fails at others; the best measurement axes move as noise changes.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the measured correlation tensor or several independently chosen settings against the one-parameter model; examine residual structure rather than only the best-fit score.",
      "remedy": "Fit and validate an appropriate channel or use a less model-dependent witness with its own assumptions.",
      "scope": "Visibility here is a model parameter, not a universal proxy for all experimental error.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Several reaction pathways cannot generally be compressed into one rate constant."
        },
        {
          "field": "climate",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Distinct forcing patterns can produce the same one-dimensional summary while differing elsewhere."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-007",
      "title": "No CHSH violation is treated as no entanglement",
      "equationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "PPT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For rho_v, PPT becomes negative at v>1/3, whereas optimized CHSH measurements violate 2 only at v>1/sqrt(2). There is an interval containing entangled states that this Bell test does not detect.",
      "presentation": "A nonviolating score is used to classify an entangled noisy state as separable.",
      "diagnostic": "At v=1/2, calculate the partial-transpose eigenvalue -1/8 and the optimal score sqrt(2) over nondegenerate qubit projective observables a dot sigma. If trivial deterministic observables ±I are included, the larger class can always attain 2; it still cannot violate the CHSH bound here.",
      "remedy": "State exactly what witness failed to detect. Use a valid separability criterion or another justified protocol before asserting absence of entanglement.",
      "scope": "The thresholds concern this two-qubit family without filtering or other preprocessing. The sqrt(2) optimum is explicitly restricted to the nondegenerate Pauli-projective setting class; including deterministic observables gives max(2,2sqrt(2)v).",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "diagnostic testing",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A negative result from an incomplete detector does not establish absence of the property."
        },
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A nondetection can reflect instrument sensitivity rather than absence of a source."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-PERES1996",
        "ROOT-HORODECKI1996",
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "PPT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-008",
      "title": "A two-qubit separability criterion is exported to all dimensions",
      "equationIds": [
        "PPT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Positive partial transpose is necessary for separability in general; its sufficiency is special to 2 by 2 and 2 by 3 systems. The ambient dimension is a theorem hypothesis.",
      "presentation": "A high-dimensional PPT state is automatically called unentangled, or two selected levels are assumed to describe a leaking device completely.",
      "diagnostic": "Record the full bipartite Hilbert-space dimensions and whether a truncation is physically justified. Check the exact direction of each theorem used.",
      "remedy": "Use a criterion valid for the actual dimension, or retain 'PPT, separability unresolved by this test' as the conclusion.",
      "scope": "This does not assert that every higher-dimensional PPT state is entangled.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "algebraic geometry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A theorem valid in a low-dimensional special case can fail in higher codimension."
        },
        {
          "field": "statistics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A two-variable diagnostic need not certify a many-variable distribution."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-HORODECKI1996"
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1996,
          "event": "The dimension-dependent sufficiency of the PPT criterion was established.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "ROOT-HORODECKI1996"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PPT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-009",
      "title": "No-signalling, locality and quantum realizability are collapsed into one property",
      "equationIds": [
        "NOSIGNALLING",
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Local models, quantum correlations and general no-signalling probability distributions are distinct sets. Uniform-marginal correlations with a xor b=xy can attain CHSH 4 while preserving the marginal no-signalling equalities; that does not make them quantum-realizable.",
      "presentation": "Passing a marginal check is presented as proof of locality, or an algebraically admissible table is described as an achievable quantum device.",
      "diagnostic": "Test normalization, positivity and marginal equalities separately from Bell inequalities and quantum constraints. Specify which set membership was actually established.",
      "remedy": "Maintain separate claims for no-signalling, Bell locality and quantum realization.",
      "scope": "The probability table is a mathematical countermodel, not an observed physical device.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "network science",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Different constraint sets can be nested without being equivalent."
        },
        {
          "field": "optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Feasibility in a relaxation does not establish feasibility in the original set."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-PR1994",
        "ROOT-TSIRELSON1980"
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1994,
          "event": "Popescu and Rohrlich separated relativistic no-signalling from the quantum correlation bound.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "ROOT-PR1994"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NOSIGNALLING",
        "CHSH"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-010",
      "title": "Conditional remote information is mistaken for an unconditional signal",
      "equationIds": [
        "NOSIGNALLING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A remote measurement can change the state assigned to a selected outcome branch. Averaging all outcomes of a local trace-preserving operation leaves the other party's reduced state unchanged. The branch label is additional classical information.",
      "presentation": "A demonstration compares only matching remote outcomes and claims that the receiver could see the change without learning those outcomes.",
      "diagnostic": "Calculate the receiver's marginal before receiving any remote label and again after conditioning. Ask which locally accessible distribution encodes the sender's choice.",
      "remedy": "Report conditional correlations and unconditional signalling tests separately; include the classical communication required by the protocol.",
      "scope": "No-signalling depends on the stated bipartite operations; a direct physical channel or joint operation is a different setup.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "causal inference",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Conditioning and intervening or transmitting are different operations."
        },
        {
          "field": "clinical research",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A subgroup selected after observing an outcome is not the original randomized population."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NOSIGNALLING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-011",
      "title": "Detection postselection manufactures an apparent violation",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Detection can depend on the hidden variable and the local setting. Conditioning on both detectors firing changes the hidden-variable mixture differently for each setting pair, invalidating a common-distribution calculation on the selected sample.",
      "presentation": "Only coincidences are retained; selected correlations look ideal despite a low or selective detection rate.",
      "diagnostic": "Execute the eight-instruction model in counterexamples.json: actual settings are independent of lambda, both local efficiencies are 1/2, coincidence efficiency is 1/4, selected S=4, and all-trial bounded-outcome S=1.",
      "remedy": "Use a trial and outcome definition with a valid loss-tolerant inequality, or justify the selection assumptions independently. Preserve all attempted trials.",
      "scope": "This is an exact local counterexample to an inference from selected data, not an allegation about a cited loophole-controlled experiment.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "epidemiology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Selection depending on several causes can induce a collider association."
        },
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A detection threshold can distort the observed population."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-BRANCIARD2011",
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-012",
        "BELL-013",
        "CROSS-021"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-012",
      "title": "Setting-independent detection rates are mistaken for representative sampling",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Aggregate efficiencies can be equal for every setting while the detected hidden-variable subpopulations differ. Equal rates do not establish that detected events represent the same underlying population.",
      "presentation": "A detector-rate balance table is offered as the sole closure of the detection loophole.",
      "diagnostic": "Use the same exact model: each side detects half the trials at each setting, yet conditioning on coincidence yields S=4. Rate equality and representative selection are different conditions.",
      "remedy": "Audit the selection mechanism and the inequality used. A sufficient condition proved in one paper must not be reworded as the only possible necessary condition for a valid experiment.",
      "scope": "The example refutes a rate-only argument, not every fair-sampling analysis.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "survey methods",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Equal response rates do not imply equal respondent composition."
        },
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Equal dataset sizes do not imply equal sampling distributions."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026",
        "ROOT-BRANCIARD2011"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-011",
        "BELL-013",
        "CROSS-021"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-013",
      "title": "Coincidence windows become a setting-dependent selection rule",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "If pair membership is decided by time differences that depend on settings or outcomes, the four score terms can refer to differently selected events even when the detectors themselves are efficient.",
      "presentation": "The violation changes strongly when the coincidence window, delay alignment or pairing algorithm is adjusted.",
      "diagnostic": "Predefine trial boundaries or the justified pairing procedure; inspect delay distributions by setting, retain unpaired detections and vary the window as a sensitivity analysis without choosing the best result.",
      "remedy": "Use event-ready or appropriately time-bin-defined trials, or a bound derived for the actual coincidence procedure.",
      "scope": "Detection loss and coincidence pairing are related but separately testable mechanisms.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "geophysics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Event matching across instruments can create false coincidences."
        },
        {
          "field": "record linkage",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A matching algorithm can induce associations through selection."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-COINCIDENCE2004"
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 2004,
          "event": "Larsson and Gill analyzed setting-dependent coincidence-time selection.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "ROOT-COINCIDENCE2004"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "BELL-011",
        "BELL-012",
        "CROSS-021"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-014",
      "title": "Settings are correlated with the tested hidden variables",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The standard local bound uses a setting-independent hidden-variable distribution. Predictable settings, a common causal source or information leakage can invalidate that premise for the proposed null model.",
      "presentation": "A deterministic setting schedule permits devices to anticipate the next test; apparent setting randomness is tested only by a simple frequency balance.",
      "diagnostic": "Map how setting bits are generated, when they are available, and what correlations are permitted by the null. Random-looking histograms do not establish causal independence.",
      "remedy": "Use an appropriate setting-generation design and a statistical bound that includes any quantified setting predictability.",
      "scope": "An experiment tests an explicit causal model; this is not a claim that every conceivable metaphysical alternative is experimentally eliminable.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "randomized trials",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Allocation concealment and independence matter beyond balanced group counts."
        },
        {
          "field": "cryptography",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A predictable challenge lets an adversarial device tailor its response."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-INDEPENDENCE2011"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-015",
      "title": "A local classical communication path remains available",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "When a setting or outcome can reach the other device before its output is fixed, a communicated classical strategy falls outside the locality-restricted null. A high score then need not distinguish that strategy.",
      "presentation": "Two software widgets exchange state, or laboratory timing leaves an ordinary signal path open.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the physical events at which settings are chosen and outcomes finalized; include propagation distances, clock uncertainty, electronic delays and shared control channels.",
      "remedy": "Close the relevant communication paths or state that the demonstration verifies an operator calculation without an experimental locality claim.",
      "scope": "A simulated Bell score remains a valid calculation when labeled as simulation; spatial separation is a separate experimental requirement.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "distributed systems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A supposed independent replica may share a hidden coordination channel."
        },
        {
          "field": "experimental design",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Cross-talk undermines the intended causal isolation."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-HENSEN2015"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-016",
      "title": "Trial memory is analyzed as independent sampling",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Devices may adapt to previous settings and outcomes. A binomial or Gaussian uncertainty calculation based on independent identically distributed trials can then misstate the null tail probability even when an appropriate local conditional expectation bound remains valid.",
      "presentation": "Long blocks of correlated outcomes produce narrow standard errors based only on the raw number of trials.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect sequential dependence and the actual randomization; derive a martingale or otherwise justified test against the allowed memory model.",
      "remedy": "Use a memory-robust inference procedure with its assumptions and stopping rule specified.",
      "scope": "A valid expectation bound does not imply that no finite sample can exceed it. Finite chance excursions must still be quantified.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "econometrics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Serial dependence invalidates naive standard errors."
        },
        {
          "field": "reliability engineering",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Repeated failures from one latent fault are not independent trials."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-MEMORY2002",
        "ROOT-GILL2003"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-017",
      "title": "A finite excess over the bound is treated as deductive certainty",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Observed score estimates fluctuate. A small apparent excess can occur under a local null, and uncertainty in counts, settings or trial inclusion must be incorporated in a valid test.",
      "presentation": "A chart labels S=2.01 as definitive nonlocality without a sample size or a null-tail bound.",
      "diagnostic": "Provide the full counts or trial sequence, the estimator, a valid null distribution or concentration bound, and the achieved significance with its assumptions.",
      "remedy": "Distinguish an exact algebraic expectation from a finite-sample statistical result; report precision and evidence at the scale supported.",
      "scope": "This concerns statistical inference, not the exact 16-assignment algebra.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "particle physics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A finite excess needs a calibrated background probability."
        },
        {
          "field": "biomedicine",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A point estimate crossing a threshold is not a certainty statement."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-GILL2003",
        "ROOT-HENSEN2015"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-018",
      "title": "A p-value is read as the probability that a theory is true",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A p-value bounds or measures the probability of at least as extreme data under a specified null and procedure. It does not by itself give the posterior probability of that null or of an interpretation of quantum mechanics.",
      "presentation": "A result with p=.01 is described as a 99 percent chance that a broad worldview is correct.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the conditional probability actually computed; list the null class, test statistic and sampling/stopping design.",
      "remedy": "Describe the evidence against the specified null. A posterior claim requires an explicit model set, likelihoods and prior assumptions.",
      "scope": "No single statistical test selects among all quantum interpretations that share its predictions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "statistics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The conditioning direction is different."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical inference",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Evidence inconsistent with one account does not assign exact probabilities to every alternative."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-GILL2003"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-019",
      "title": "Angles, windows or trials are selected after seeing the largest violation",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT",
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Optimizing many choices on the same finite data and reporting only the maximum changes the null distribution. Optional stopping can have the same effect if the test is not designed for it.",
      "presentation": "One configuration crosses the threshold after hundreds were tried, or acquisition stops at the first favorable excursion.",
      "diagnostic": "Recover the full search and stopping history; test whether calibration and evaluation sets were independent.",
      "remedy": "Preregister or freeze a procedure, use independent confirmation data, or use a valid multiplicity- and stopping-aware test.",
      "scope": "Analytically maximizing a known exact expectation is legitimate; selecting the best noisy observation is a different operation.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Hyperparameter selection on the test set overstates generalization."
        },
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Scanning many locations requires a look-elsewhere correction."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-GILL2003"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT",
        "CHSHANGLE"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-013",
        "CROSS-014",
        "CROSS-018",
        "SPIN-075"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-020",
      "title": "Background subtraction changes the probability model",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Removing estimated dark counts or accidental coincidences can create corrected frequencies that no longer correspond to the raw trial process; estimated nuisance quantities also carry uncertainty.",
      "presentation": "A violation appears only after a correction, negative corrected counts occur, or the error bars ignore calibration uncertainty.",
      "diagnostic": "Report raw and corrected analyses, derive the correction within the null model, and propagate uncertainty and dependence from the calibration data.",
      "remedy": "Use a validated likelihood or a conservative bound that includes the nuisance process rather than treating corrected counts as exact observations.",
      "scope": "Correction is not inherently invalid; unsupported correction and a mismatched test are the failure modes. CHSH supplies the original bound and experimental structure; the contemporary implementation and composition risks are conditional audit deductions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Baseline subtraction can create or erase a weak peak."
        },
        {
          "field": "clinical assays",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Calibration uncertainty belongs in the final inference."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CHSH1969",
        "ROOT-ANALYSIS2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-021",
      "title": "Readout drift and cross-talk masquerade as changes in the state",
      "equationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Observed correlations combine preparation, measurement and readout. Time-varying thresholds, common electronics or calibration drift can change the score even when the intended state is unchanged.",
      "presentation": "A score changes with acquisition order or detector temperature; the same state reconstructed with a later calibration gives a different result.",
      "diagnostic": "Interleave settings and calibration checks, retain timing, test independent reference states and examine shared channels.",
      "remedy": "Model or constrain the measurement process and validate the complete apparatus; avoid assigning every discrepancy to one state visibility parameter.",
      "scope": "The risk requires experimental evidence to diagnose; it is not observed in the matrix-only notebook.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "metrology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Instrument drift can mimic a changing measurand."
        },
        {
          "field": "neuroscience",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Common reference electronics can generate apparent synchrony."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-HENSEN2015"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "BELLNOISE",
        "CHSHSTAT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-022",
      "title": "A simulation is promoted to an experimental result",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH",
        "BELLSTATE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Evaluating Tr(rho B) establishes the prediction of the supplied matrices. It does not verify preparation, detectors, space-time separation, random setting generation or laboratory trial accounting.",
      "presentation": "A rendered animation or 91-angle calculation is described as closing Bell loopholes in the physical world.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the provenance of every number: analytic expression, matrix calculation, synthetic shot sample or measured instrument record.",
      "remedy": "Label the laboratory obligations separately and use simulations to test code and hypotheses within their stated inputs.",
      "scope": "The existing notebook correctly labels its numbers as matrix expectations. This mode guards downstream reuse.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "climate",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A model run is not a new observation."
        },
        {
          "field": "structural engineering",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A finite-element calculation does not by itself validate material and load assumptions."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026",
        "ROOT-HENSEN2015"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH",
        "BELLSTATE"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "SPIN-064"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-023",
      "title": "The same word entanglement hides different subsystem structures",
      "equationIds": [
        "BELLSTATE",
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Nonseparability of classical optical modes can share tensor-product algebra with a quantum state without realizing the spatially separated, single-event measurement scenario of a Bell test. The physical subsystem and measurement model matter.",
      "presentation": "A classical beam calculation is announced as either disproving Bell's theorem or establishing a loophole-free quantum nonlocality experiment.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify what constitutes each subsystem, what an individual event is, how probabilities arise, and whether the locality assumptions apply to the actual apparatus.",
      "remedy": "Name the demonstrated mode nonseparability and separately evaluate any operational Bell claim.",
      "scope": "Shared mathematics can be useful without equating all physical realizations of that mathematics. CHSH supplies the original bound and experimental structure; the contemporary implementation and composition risks are conditional audit deductions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "wave mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Different substrates can implement similar linear spaces."
        },
        {
          "field": "systems architecture",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A shared interface does not imply the same causal isolation."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CHSH1969",
        "ROOT-ANALYSIS2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "BELLSTATE",
        "CHSH"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "BELL-024",
      "title": "A Bell violation is treated as a complete device-security certificate",
      "equationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A score constrains a defined correlation experiment. A cryptographic conclusion additionally depends on the protocol, randomness, finite-key analysis, leakage paths, authenticated communication and the adversarial model.",
      "presentation": "A demo labels all payloads or secrets unextractable merely because it uses quantum terminology or an ideal Bell score.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the exact security theorem and confirm that the implementation and threat model satisfy its assumptions; inspect classical interfaces and data handling separately.",
      "remedy": "Bound the specific security property under explicit assumptions. Do not promise that browser-delivered code, public data or configurations can be made universally uninspectable.",
      "scope": "This is a scope audit, not a penetration test or a claim about the security of the deployed site. CHSH supplies the original bound and experimental structure; the contemporary implementation and composition risks are conditional audit deductions.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "software security",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A secure primitive does not automatically secure its composition."
        },
        {
          "field": "engineering safety",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "One passing component test does not certify an entire system."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CHSH1969",
        "ROOT-ANALYSIS2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CHSH"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-001",
      "title": "A reflected zero set is assumed to lie on the reflection axis",
      "equationIds": [
        "POLYNOMIAL",
        "MIL-E-RH-ZETA"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Reflection invariance allows pairs or quadruples away from the fixed axis. P(s)=[(s-1/4)²+1][(s-3/4)²+1] is invariant under s↦1-s and conjugation, yet all four roots have real part 1/4 or 3/4.",
      "presentation": "An argument reaches the critical line using only the functional equation's symmetry.",
      "diagnostic": "Substitute the four exact roots and apply the proposed inference to this countermodel. Identify what additional property of the actual zeta function the proof uses.",
      "remedy": "Supply an independent positivity, spectral or analytic argument that excludes off-axis pairs for the actual target.",
      "scope": "This disproves the symmetry-only implication; it neither disproves RH nor shows that all symmetry-based methods are useless.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemistry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A symmetric potential can have symmetry-related minima away from its center."
        },
        {
          "field": "optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An invariant objective need not attain every minimizer at a fixed point."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "REFLECTION",
        "POLYNOMIAL",
        "RH"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "RH-003"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-002",
      "title": "An empty result makes a universal check pass vacuously",
      "equationIds": [
        "POLYNOMIAL",
        "VALIDATION"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A solver restricted to real s returned no roots for this polynomial. The first audit checked all roots were off the critical line; all over an empty list returned true, concealing the domain error.",
      "presentation": "A green test has an empty evidence list or processed zero records. An API error that returns an empty collection can produce the same outcome.",
      "diagnostic": "Assert expected cardinality or a justified nonemptiness condition before testing properties. Independently substitute each returned root and compare against a separate representation.",
      "remedy": "The audit now uses an unrestricted complex symbol, requires four roots and checks all substitutions and locations. The corrected script was rerun; Wolfram independently supplied the four roots.",
      "scope": "This was an observed defect in this new audit script and is corrected in delivered outputs. It was not a defect in the earlier spectral table.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "software verification",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Universal quantification over an empty set is true."
        },
        {
          "field": "data pipelines",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A validation rule can pass after accidentally filtering out every row."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-AUDIT2026",
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "POLYNOMIAL",
        "VALIDATION"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-003",
      "title": "An algebraic simplification silently changes the domain",
      "equationIds": [
        "SYMBOLIC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "x/x=1 excludes x=0; sqrt(x²)=|x| for real x, not x for all x. Squaring sqrt(x+2)=x introduces x=-1 unless the original sign and domain are retained.",
      "presentation": "A proposed solution satisfies a transformed equation but not the original, or an omitted pole becomes a spurious value.",
      "diagnostic": "Track denominators, branch conventions and inequality constraints through every transformation; substitute candidates into the original expression.",
      "remedy": "Attach the domain to each identity and filter candidates using the original conditions. Distinguish equivalence from a one-direction implication.",
      "scope": "These are exact elementary counterexamples; they do not imply that symbolic software is generally unreliable.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "complex analysis",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Branch choices control analytic identities."
        },
        {
          "field": "physical modeling",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A formally valid root may violate positivity, causality or conservation constraints."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "SYMBOLIC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-004",
      "title": "Matching every tested size is taken to determine the limit",
      "equationIds": [
        "FINITEFIT",
        "SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "On the six tested sizes, f(N)=2tan(pi/(4N)) and g(N)=f(N)+c q(N)/(1+q(N)), with q the product of squared distances from those sizes, agree exactly. Their limits are 0 and c.",
      "presentation": "Several fitted extrapolation models are visually indistinguishable on available data but imply different phase classifications.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare allowed extrapolation classes, quantify sensitivity to excluded sizes and demand model-derived control of the remainder.",
      "remedy": "Use the exact Ising solution where it applies. In an unknown model, separate empirical fit preference from an analytic uniform bound.",
      "scope": "The constructed g is not asserted to be another solution of the specified Ising Hamiltonian. It demonstrates the insufficiency of the finite table alone.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "cosmology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Finite observations cannot identify unrestricted continuation functions."
        },
        {
          "field": "econometrics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Extrapolation requires structural restrictions beyond fit."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "FINITEFIT",
        "CRITICAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-030",
        "SPIN-028",
        "SPIN-035",
        "SPIN-036",
        "SPIN-037"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-005",
      "title": "Zero eigenvector residual is mistaken for correct spectral ordering",
      "equationIds": [
        "RESIDUAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Exact eigenpairs of diag(0,2,5) at eigenvalues 2 and 5 have residual zero, but subtracting them reports 3 instead of the lowest gap 2. Residual accuracy does not establish completeness or ordering.",
      "presentation": "An iterative solver converges tightly to the wrong sector or wrong part of the spectrum.",
      "diagnostic": "Verify the requested spectral target, sector coverage, orthogonality and lower-spectrum count; compare with exact or dense spectra where feasible.",
      "remedy": "Add independent ordering or enclosure evidence. Keep residual size and the claim that these are the lowest two levels as separate checks.",
      "scope": "This exact example diagnoses a logical gap in validation; the supplied endpoints were separately reproduced.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "modal engineering",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Accurately finding a vibration mode does not establish that no lower mode was missed."
        },
        {
          "field": "optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A stationary point certificate is not a global minimum certificate."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "RESIDUAL",
        "GAP"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "SPIN-046"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-006",
      "title": "A Hermitian residual theorem is applied to a nonnormal operator",
      "equationIds": [
        "RESIDUAL",
        "NONNORMAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For Hermitian A, a normalized residual controls distance to the spectrum. With A=[[0,K],[0,0]], trial lambda=1 and v=(K,1)/sqrt(K²+1), the residual is 1/sqrt(K²+1) although the entire spectrum is zero.",
      "presentation": "A non-Hermitian effective model reports highly accurate eigenvalues solely because residuals are small.",
      "diagnostic": "Check normality and the applicable conditioning or pseudospectral bound. At K=10^6 the residual is about 10^-6 while spectral distance is 1.",
      "remedy": "Use a bound valid for the operator class and report eigenvalue conditioning; do not import Hermitian guarantees silently.",
      "scope": "A small residual still certifies an approximate equation, but not the same spectral conclusion for every operator.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "fluid stability",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Non-self-adjoint generators can be spectrally sensitive."
        },
        {
          "field": "open quantum systems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A Liouvillian is not generally a Hermitian Hamiltonian."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026",
        "ROOT-TREFETHEN1993"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "RESIDUAL",
        "NONNORMAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-036",
        "FORM-007",
        "SPIN-082"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-007",
      "title": "Stable eigenvalues are treated as a bound on transient amplification",
      "equationIds": [
        "NONNORMAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For A=[[-1,100],[0,-2]], both eigenvalues are negative. Nevertheless e^{At}(0,1) has norm about 25.00125 at t=log 2, starting from norm one. Nonorthogonal modes can amplify before eventual decay.",
      "presentation": "A linearized system is called harmless because its eigenvalues have negative real parts, while perturbations grow enough to activate nonlinear behavior.",
      "diagnostic": "Examine finite-time propagator norms, singular values, numerical abscissa and the actual forcing/noise directions.",
      "remedy": "State separately asymptotic linear stability, transient gain and nonlinear robustness.",
      "scope": "The displayed matrix is a dimensionless demonstration, not a fitted fluid, ecological or neural system.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "hydrodynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "The same nonnormal mechanism arises in linearized flow."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Interaction matrices can permit transient population amplification despite asymptotic stability."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026",
        "ROOT-TREFETHEN1993"
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1993,
          "event": "Trefethen and collaborators emphasized transient amplification in hydrodynamic stability.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "ROOT-TREFETHEN1993"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NONNORMAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-036",
        "FORM-006",
        "SPIN-082"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-008",
      "title": "A one-sided bound is interpreted as an exact value or a contrary proof",
      "equationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "VARIATIONAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A lower bound below zero says little about a nonnegative gap; an upper bound on ground energy does not lower-bound an excitation gap. Subtracting two upper bounds is not generally a bound on their difference.",
      "presentation": "A negative Weyl estimate is announced as proof of gap closure, or two variational energies are subtracted and called a certified gap.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the direction of every inequality and the exact target quantity before combining them; use interval arithmetic on separately justified upper and lower enclosures.",
      "remedy": "Report an inconclusive bound as inconclusive. Obtain the missing enclosure or additional structural theorem.",
      "scope": "The published 2h-2N|J| estimate was already labeled inconclusive when nonpositive.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Primal and dual bounds play different roles."
        },
        {
          "field": "statistics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Two confidence limits cannot be combined arbitrarily while retaining coverage."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "WEYL",
        "VARIATIONAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "SPIN-057",
        "SPIN-058",
        "SPIN-059",
        "SPIN-060"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-009",
      "title": "A certificate is valid but proves a different formal statement",
      "equationIds": [
        "VALIDATION"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A proof assistant or symbolic engine verifies the formal input it receives. An omitted hypothesis, a differently defined object, an unproved axiom or a mistranslated informal claim can leave the intended theorem unestablished.",
      "presentation": "A green build is cited without identifying the theorem, axioms, definitions and correspondence to the announced claim.",
      "diagnostic": "Inspect the exact formal statement and dependencies; replay the proof in a specified environment and audit the bridge from informal to formal definitions.",
      "remedy": "Publish the statement, assumptions, trusted components and replay result. Keep external replay and mere repository existence as distinct evidence levels.",
      "scope": "This is a general proof-contract risk. No external Millennium formal-proof replay is claimed in this atlas.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "software assurance",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Verification against an incomplete specification can miss the real requirement."
        },
        {
          "field": "legal or textual analysis",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "An accurate conclusion about a differently worded proposition does not settle the intended question."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-AUDIT2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "VALIDATION"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FORM-010",
      "title": "An automated summary reverses necessity and sufficiency",
      "equationIds": [
        "VALIDATION",
        "CAUSAL"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A discovery tool may compress a theorem into an incorrect converse or an ambiguous scope label. Here a Hodge summary enlarged a Kähler result to the projective conjecture. A causal extraction overcompressed failure of a sufficient method, although its companion diagnostic preserved sufficiency. A Bell extraction required an explicit expectation-versus-finite-fluctuation qualification.",
      "presentation": "A literature table says a failed sufficient criterion proves impossibility, or changes a rational/projective hypothesis while retaining the original conclusion.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare the summary against the primary theorem statement, including quantifiers, domains, coefficient fields and negation. Record abstract-only access instead of implying a full proof inspection.",
      "remedy": "Use generated summaries for discovery and triage; attach conclusions to the primary text and preserve uncertainty where full text is unavailable.",
      "scope": "These are documented retrieval-summary scope problems, including one ambiguity already qualified in a companion extraction cell. They are not allegations that the original papers contain those mistakes.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "all evidence synthesis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Compression can remove the condition that makes a statement true."
        },
        {
          "field": "historical scholarship",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A later paraphrase can alter the proposition attributed to an earlier author."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-AUDIT2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "VALIDATION",
        "CAUSAL"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-071",
        "HOD-003"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-001",
      "title": "Velocity is rescaled without pressure, forcing or time",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "In three dimensions the standard transformation is u_lambda= lambda u(lambda x,lambda²t), p_lambda=lambda²p and f_lambda=lambda³f at transformed coordinates. Rescaling only velocity does not preserve the same equation.",
      "presentation": "A claimed scale family has mismatched powers among inertia, viscosity, pressure and forcing.",
      "diagnostic": "Differentiate each transformed term explicitly and compare its factor; check units and the viscosity convention.",
      "remedy": "Transform the entire equation and its data, then state whether the family remains in the admissible class.",
      "scope": "The displayed scaling keeps viscosity fixed; other physical rescalings require their own calculation.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "electromagnetism",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A symmetry transformation must preserve all coupled equations and sources."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemical transport",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Advection and diffusion scale differently if time is not transformed."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026",
        "ROOT-NSFORM"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSSCALING",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-002",
      "title": "A whole-space scaling is applied on an unchanged bounded domain",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The substitution y=lambda x also transforms the domain and boundary data. A fixed container, periodicity length or imposed inflow need not be invariant under the same operation.",
      "presentation": "A plot uses whole-space exponents while comparing solutions in the same physical box with incompatible boundaries.",
      "diagnostic": "Write the transformed domain, initial condition and boundary condition, and identify any length scale held fixed.",
      "remedy": "Restrict the claim to a compatible setting or include the extra dimensionless parameters and boundary effects.",
      "scope": "A valid local dimensional calculation is not automatically a global symmetry of the boundary-value problem.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "solid mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Geometric similarity requires loads and boundary conditions to scale consistently."
        },
        {
          "field": "laboratory hydrodynamics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A scaled tank experiment must preserve the relevant dimensionless groups."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSSCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-003",
      "title": "The dimension or norm power is changed without changing the exponent",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "In d dimensions ||u_lambda||p scales as lambda^{1-d/p}; its p-th power scales as lambda^{p-d}. In three dimensions squared L2 scales as lambda^-1, but L2 itself scales as lambda^-1/2.",
      "presentation": "Energy, speed, norm and squared norm are compared with the same exponent, or a two-dimensional identity is copied into three dimensions.",
      "diagnostic": "Perform the Jacobian change of variables and label whether the table contains a norm, its power, a density or a spatial integral.",
      "remedy": "Retain d, p and the power symbolically until the final substitution. Use separate labels for each displayed quantity.",
      "scope": "The original fluid table already separates these quantities; this protects later reuse.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "probability",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Standard deviation and variance have different scaling powers."
        },
        {
          "field": "imaging",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Changing spatial dimension changes normalization under resampling."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSSCALING"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-004",
      "title": "Spatial criticality is mistaken for the entire space-time regularity condition",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A mixed Lq in time and Lp in space norm scales as lambda^{1-3/p-2/q}. A spatial exponent alone does not capture time integrability, endpoint hypotheses or the precise theorem being invoked.",
      "presentation": "An invariant L3 scaling is presented as an automatic global regularity proof, or a time-averaged estimate is used as a pointwise one.",
      "diagnostic": "Calculate the full exponent, retain the time interval transformation, and compare each hypothesis with the actual regularity criterion.",
      "remedy": "State which norm is controlled and in what sense. Scaling compatibility is a necessary organizational guide, not by itself a proof of the required estimate.",
      "scope": "This atlas derives the exponent; it does not assert a new endpoint theorem.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "parabolic PDE",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Space and time contribute differently to critical exponents."
        },
        {
          "field": "exposure modeling",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "A time average and a peak level answer different questions."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSSCALING",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-005",
      "title": "A concentration family is presented as an actual singular trajectory",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-SCALING",
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The divergence-free field phi=(-y,x,0)exp(-|x|²) yields lambda phi(lambda x), whose squared L2 norm decreases as lambda^-1 while its maximum grows as lambda. This demonstrates failure of an L2-only bound, not a time evolution solving Navier–Stokes.",
      "presentation": "A sequence of smooth fields with large peaks is announced as finite-time blowup without satisfying the dynamical equation and admissible forcing.",
      "diagnostic": "Substitute the proposed time-dependent field into the full PDE; calculate the residual forcing and verify its required regularity and decay.",
      "remedy": "Label the example as a norm-control counterexample until all equation, data and time-evolution obligations are satisfied.",
      "scope": "The example is exact and divergence free; it is not an unforced singular solution or a check of the 2026 announced construction.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A family of feasible snapshots need not be generated by a specified algorithm."
        },
        {
          "field": "biology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A sequence of plausible states is not evidence of a realizable developmental trajectory."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "executed-check",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSSCALING",
        "NSENERGY"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "NS-004"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-006",
      "title": "Integration by parts discards a boundary or forcing contribution",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The usual energy cancellation uses incompressibility and compatible decay or boundary conditions. Boundary flux, work done by forcing and unsuitable regularity can leave terms that a whole-space smooth derivation omits.",
      "presentation": "A forced or open-boundary simulation claims monotonically decreasing energy from the unforced closed-system identity.",
      "diagnostic": "Re-derive the balance on the actual domain, retaining boundary integrals and integral f dot u. Check signs and numerical fluxes.",
      "remedy": "Use the correct energy budget for the actual problem and measure each source, sink and boundary term.",
      "scope": "The smooth identity is valid under its hypotheses; the failure is applying it after those hypotheses change.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "thermodynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Energy accounting depends on whether the system is open or closed."
        },
        {
          "field": "ecology",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An unmeasured input can invalidate an apparent conservation deficit."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-NSFORM",
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSENERGY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-007",
      "title": "A smooth energy identity is asserted for every weak solution",
      "equationIds": [
        "MIL-E-NS-ENERGY",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Weak formulations allow less regularity than the manipulations used in a smooth derivation. Whether equality, inequality, admissibility and uniqueness hold depends on the solution class and additional estimates.",
      "presentation": "Formal cancellation is used to claim regularity or uniqueness without justifying the required products, derivatives or limiting procedure.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the function spaces and test functions; identify each integration-by-parts and limit step and the estimate that justifies it.",
      "remedy": "Prove the required energy property in the stated class or work with the appropriate weaker inequality and its limitations.",
      "scope": "This is an obligation audit. It does not claim that no weak solution can satisfy energy equality.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "kinetic theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Distributional solutions require justified nonlinear products."
        },
        {
          "field": "continuum mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Weak balance laws and constitutive admissibility are separate constraints."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-NSFORM"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSENERGY",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-008",
      "title": "Weak convergence is passed through a nonlinear operation",
      "equationIds": [
        "WEAKLIMIT",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "On [0,2pi], sin(nx) converges weakly to zero while sin²(nx) converges weakly to 1/2. Therefore the weak limit of a product need not equal the product of weak limits.",
      "presentation": "An approximation sequence has bounded energy, but the claimed limiting nonlinear term drops oscillation or concentration defects.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the required convergence topology for each product; test whether compactness, uniform integrability or another compensating estimate is available.",
      "remedy": "Obtain stronger convergence or retain the defect measure/stress and show it vanishes if the target equation requires that.",
      "scope": "The trigonometric example is an exact generic counterexample, not a constructed Navier–Stokes counterexample.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "homogenization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Microscopic oscillations can survive in effective nonlinear quantities."
        },
        {
          "field": "turbulence",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Averaged products require fluctuation correlations."
        },
        {
          "field": "statistics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Averages of products need not be products of averages."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "WEAKLIMIT",
        "NS"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-038",
        "NS-011"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-009",
      "title": "Two-dimensional vorticity control is transferred unchanged to three dimensions",
      "equationIds": [
        "VORTICITY",
        "MIL-E-NS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The three-dimensional vorticity equation contains the stretching term (omega dot grad)u. The structurally simpler two-dimensional setting does not supply the same uncontrolled mechanism.",
      "presentation": "A proof repeats a two-dimensional maximum-principle argument while silently omitting stretching.",
      "diagnostic": "Derive the vorticity equation in the actual dimension and geometry; identify the sign or estimate of every nonlinear term.",
      "remedy": "Control the stretching contribution with valid three-dimensional estimates or restrict the theorem to the special symmetry class actually treated.",
      "scope": "Special three-dimensional classes can have additional structure; that structure must be stated rather than assumed universal.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Changing dimension changes available modes and tensor identities."
        },
        {
          "field": "network modeling",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Adding an interaction channel can invalidate a lower-dimensional stability argument."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-NSFORM"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "VORTICITY",
        "NS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "FLUID-010",
      "title": "Numerical stabilization is mistaken for physical regularity",
      "equationIds": [
        "NSNUMERIC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A grid, time step, filter or artificial viscosity can remove small-scale growth. A computation may remain smooth because it solves a regularized discrete model, while an underresolved method may also generate spurious blowup.",
      "presentation": "Peak velocity or enstrophy saturates at the mesh scale, changes with filtering, or diverges only after the stability condition is violated.",
      "diagnostic": "Perform targeted resolution/time-step checks, inspect spectra and divergence errors, and compare the residual and numerical dissipation with physical terms.",
      "remedy": "Report a resolved finite simulation with error evidence; a continuum regularity or blowup theorem needs validated limiting estimates.",
      "scope": "This is a conditional risk for future fluid simulations; the original notebook's scaling rows are analytic multipliers, not a fluid solver.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "computational chemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Basis truncation can hide or manufacture a feature."
        },
        {
          "field": "engineering simulation",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A stable discretization is not automatically an accurate continuum model."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-NSFORM"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "root",
      "componentTitle": "Bell tests, formal inference and fluid calculations",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "NSNUMERIC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-001",
      "title": "A radiation density is mistaken for a radiance or a different spectral measure",
      "equationIds": [
        "PLANCK"
      ],
      "mechanism": "u_nu is energy per volume per frequency; B_nu is radiance per solid angle. Converting frequency to wavelength requires the Jacobian |dnu/dlambda|=c/lambda². Substituting nu=c/lambda without this factor changes the spectrum and its peak.",
      "presentation": "The inferred temperature or total power changes according to the plotting axis; factors of c, 4pi or pi are missing.",
      "diagnostic": "Write units including per-hertz, per-metre and per-steradian factors; verify that integrating either correctly transformed density gives the same total.",
      "remedy": "Use a declared spectral measure and geometric convention throughout the pipeline. Compare like instrument response functions.",
      "scope": "This is an exact change-of-variables and geometry issue, not a failure of Planck's equilibrium law.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "probability",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A probability density changes by a Jacobian under a coordinate transformation."
        },
        {
          "field": "astronomy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Flux density and radiance are distinct calibrated quantities."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-PLANCK"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PLANCK"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-002",
      "title": "An equilibrium blackbody formula is extended to an arbitrary emitter",
      "equationIds": [
        "PLANCK"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The thermal equilibrium spectrum does not automatically describe a selective, optically thin, nonthermal or time-dependent emitter. Emissivity, absorption along the path and the instrument response can alter a measured spectrum.",
      "presentation": "A good fit over one band is treated as proof of a unique temperature or mechanism; different bands give incompatible temperatures.",
      "diagnostic": "Test equilibrium and emissivity assumptions, instrument calibration and band coverage; compare plausible competing emission and transfer models.",
      "remedy": "Model the actual emission and observation process, and report whether temperature is a thermodynamic property or an effective fit parameter.",
      "scope": "The classical limiting forms also have restricted regimes; extending a low-frequency asymptote over all frequencies can create a divergent integral.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A constitutive equilibrium relation need not describe driven kinetics."
        },
        {
          "field": "remote sensing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An observed spectrum combines source and propagation effects."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-PLANCK"
      ],
      "history": [
        {
          "year": 1900,
          "event": "The radiation-law development addressed a measured regime failure; the 1920 lecture retrospectively documents it.",
          "sourceIds": [
            "QH-PLANCK"
          ]
        }
      ],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PLANCK"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-003",
      "title": "Stopping potential is equated with an uncorrected apparatus voltage",
      "equationIds": [
        "PHOTOELECTRIC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "eVs=hnu-Phi concerns a specified maximum electron kinetic energy and work function. Contact potentials, surface contamination, band structure, space charge and multiphoton regimes can change what an instrument's voltage or current threshold represents.",
      "presentation": "An intercept is interpreted as a universal material constant despite surface changes, or intensity-dependent behavior is declared inconsistent with every photoelectric process.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the emission regime and measured endpoint; calibrate contact potentials and vary intensity, frequency and surface conditions independently.",
      "remedy": "Keep the simple one-photon relation within its scope and add an appropriate material/apparatus model where required.",
      "scope": "Millikan's historical agreement with a relation and dispute about its explanation are separate propositions; matching a formula alone need not establish every interpretation. The multiphoton and broader apparatus-regime checks are present-day audit deductions, not a claim that Millikan's paper covers all modern cases.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "electrochemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "An electrode voltage contains interface contributions."
        },
        {
          "field": "measurement science",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An offset changes an inferred intercept while leaving an ideal slope relation possible."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-MILLIKAN",
        "ROOT-ANALYSIS2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "PHOTOELECTRIC"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-007"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-004",
      "title": "The free, initially stationary electron Compton formula is used outside its kinematics",
      "equationIds": [
        "COMPTON"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Delta lambda=h(1-cos theta)/(m_e c) follows for scattering from an initially stationary free electron in the specified single-event kinematics. Initial momentum, binding and multiple scattering alter the observed line or its interpretation.",
      "presentation": "A broadened or shifted spectrum is treated as a failed conservation law, or the angular shift is confused with the scattering probability.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify the incident state, target momentum/binding distribution, angle convention and event multiplicity; distinguish a kinematic locus from a differential cross section.",
      "remedy": "Use the full energy-momentum balance and a model of the target and detector resolution appropriate to the experiment.",
      "scope": "Compton's original paper itself distinguished the shift relation from less rigorous parts of its scattering-intensity treatment.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "nuclear physics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Target motion and binding change scattering kinematics."
        },
        {
          "field": "spectroscopy",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A line location and its intensity are different observables."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-COMPTON"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "COMPTON"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-005",
      "title": "A finite matrix is claimed to satisfy the exact canonical commutator",
      "equationIds": [
        "CCR",
        "BASIS"
      ],
      "mechanism": "For any finite square matrices X and P, tr([X,P])=0. But tr(i hbar I)=i hbar d is nonzero for d>0 and hbar nonzero. Thus a finite truncation cannot satisfy the canonical commutation identity on the entire truncated space.",
      "presentation": "A truncated oscillator looks accurate in a few low levels, and that success is used to assert an exact operator identity at the cutoff.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute the trace and inspect the commutator on the highest retained states; measure low-state errors as the cutoff grows.",
      "remedy": "State a controlled low-energy approximation and the operator domains instead of asserting an impossible finite-dimensional identity.",
      "scope": "The trace argument is an exact finite-dimensional proof. It does not undermine infinite-dimensional canonical quantum mechanics. The trace obstruction is derived here; Robertson is a historical uncertainty anchor, not the cited origin of this finite-truncation proof.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "numerical PDE",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Discretization can preserve selected predictions while changing an exact continuum algebra."
        },
        {
          "field": "signal processing",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A finite window changes boundary relations of ideal translation operators."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-ANALYSIS2026",
        "QH-ROBERTSON"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CCR",
        "BASIS"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-006",
      "title": "A representation change is treated as exact after incompatible truncations",
      "equationIds": [
        "BASIS",
        "SCHRODINGER"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An exact unitary change of basis preserves spectra and matrix elements when objects and domains are mapped consistently. Independently truncating two representations can destroy that equivalence at finite cutoff.",
      "presentation": "Wave and matrix calculations disagree and the disagreement is assigned to different physical theories rather than different retained subspaces.",
      "diagnostic": "Construct the explicit overlap map, check orthonormality/completeness on the compared subspace, and vary both cutoffs while comparing the same observables.",
      "remedy": "Separate representation equivalence from approximation error; compare converged quantities or bound the truncation discrepancy.",
      "scope": "Matching a few eigenvalues also does not prove that all observables or interpretations are equivalent.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "computational chemistry",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Different basis sets can converge differently for the same Hamiltonian."
        },
        {
          "field": "data analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Two compressed feature representations need not preserve all information."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "BASIS",
        "SCHRODINGER"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-007",
      "title": "A preparation-variance bound is used as a universal measurement-error formula",
      "equationIds": [
        "UNCERTAINTY"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The Robertson expression concerns standard deviations in a specified state and the expectation of a commutator, with appropriate operator domains and finite moments. Instrument error and measurement-induced disturbance require their own operational definitions and relations.",
      "presentation": "A small commutator expectation is called proof that the observables commute, or an instrument's accuracy is inferred directly from a state's preparation variance.",
      "diagnostic": "List the state, operators, domains and random variables defining each variance. Check whether the claim concerns intrinsic spread, estimation error or disturbance.",
      "remedy": "Use the inequality for the quantities it actually bounds, and derive any additional measurement statement in a specified measurement model.",
      "scope": "A zero right-hand side makes this bound uninformative; it does not force both variances to vanish or both operators to commute.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "statistics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Population variance and estimator error are different quantities."
        },
        {
          "field": "control",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "State uncertainty and sensor disturbance must be modeled separately."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-ROBERTSON"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "UNCERTAINTY"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-008",
      "title": "A wavefunction amplitude is read as a probability without its measure or measurement",
      "equationIds": [
        "BORN",
        "SCHRODINGER"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Squared amplitudes give probabilities only with the relevant normalization, basis or position-space measure and measurement model. A probability density at a point is not a dimensionless probability; interference also depends on relative amplitudes before squaring.",
      "presentation": "A grid refinement changes total probability, two amplitudes are squared separately before adding when paths remain coherent, or a nonorthogonal basis is treated as orthonormal.",
      "diagnostic": "Check normalization under the actual inner product, include quadrature weights or overlap matrices, and verify the POVM/projector associated with the reported outcome.",
      "remedy": "Compute probabilities through a consistent Born rule and distinguish coherent sums from incoherent mixtures.",
      "scope": "This mode concerns implementation and interpretation of the rule, not a new derivation of its physical status.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "wave optics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Coherent fields add before intensity is computed."
        },
        {
          "field": "probability",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Densities require integration with the correct measure."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "BORN",
        "SCHRODINGER"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-009",
      "title": "A free Dirac equation is treated as a complete interacting theory",
      "equationIds": [
        "DIRAC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The free relativistic spinor equation imposes kinematic and representation constraints. Interactions require specified couplings and, when particle creation matters, an appropriate quantum-field description; renormalization is not supplied by the free equation alone.",
      "presentation": "A correct dispersion relation is used to claim all radiative corrections, many-body effects or material spectra have been captured.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify omitted interactions, the energy regime, the number of particles and the observables; check gamma-matrix, metric-signature and unit conventions.",
      "remedy": "Use a model with the required interactions and controlled approximations, and retain the free result as a limiting check.",
      "scope": "An effective Dirac-like equation in a material shares mathematics under an approximation; it does not automatically reproduce every property of an elementary relativistic field.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "condensed matter",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Effective quasiparticles can obey Dirac-like dispersion within a bandwidth."
        },
        {
          "field": "systems modeling",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Correct component dynamics do not supply missing interactions."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-DIRAC"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "DIRAC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-010",
      "title": "A reduced density matrix is mistaken for a unique global state or outcome",
      "equationIds": [
        "REDUCED",
        "DECOHERENCE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Tracing out an environment is many-to-one. Different global states can produce the same local density operator; a locally diagonal reduced state does not by itself select one globally realized outcome or determine a unique interpretation of measurement.",
      "presentation": "Loss of local interference is announced as a complete solution of every measurement question, or the reduced state is used to reconstruct environmental details it does not contain.",
      "diagnostic": "Specify which subsystem observables are retained and which joint correlations distinguish alternative global states. State the basis in which off-diagonal terms are examined.",
      "remedy": "Report the reduced-state prediction and decoherence mechanism within the modeled partition; mark additional interpretive claims separately.",
      "scope": "This is an information-loss property of partial trace, not a rejection of decoherence as a physical process.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "inverse problems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A many-to-one observation map does not identify a unique underlying state."
        },
        {
          "field": "statistical mechanics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Marginal distributions omit joint correlations."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "REDUCED",
        "DECOHERENCE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-011",
      "title": "Markovian semigroup evolution is assumed merely because a system is open",
      "equationIds": [
        "LINDBLAD"
      ],
      "mechanism": "An open system can retain environmental memory or initial system-environment correlations. The displayed time-independent Lindblad form is tied to a specified completely positive semigroup setting; openness alone does not establish it.",
      "presentation": "A one-rate exponential fit fails on recurrence or long-time data, or the fitted generator changes with preparation history.",
      "diagnostic": "Compare timescales, preparation dependence and held-out multi-time observations; test whether a semigroup composition law is justified in the intended regime.",
      "remedy": "Use a validated reduced model, include memory where necessary, and state the validity interval of any Markov approximation.",
      "scope": "A temporary negative rate in a time-local representation does not by itself prove that the total dynamical map is unphysical; the complete map and its assumptions must be checked.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "chemical kinetics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Eliminating hidden intermediates can produce memory."
        },
        {
          "field": "econometrics",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A fitted memoryless transition can fail when unobserved state persists."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-LINDBLAD"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "LINDBLAD"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "CROSS-042",
        "SPIN-079",
        "SPIN-080"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-012",
      "title": "Positivity on isolated states is mistaken for complete positivity",
      "equationIds": [
        "LINDBLAD",
        "PPT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A map can preserve positivity on one system while failing when applied to that system as part of an entangled composite. Matrix transposition is the standard algebraic example; partial transposition of a Bell state has a negative eigenvalue.",
      "presentation": "A purported universal physical channel passes tests on several single-system states but produces a negative joint density matrix with an ancilla.",
      "diagnostic": "Test the appropriate complete-positivity criterion or apply the map to half of a maximally entangled state; also check trace preservation.",
      "remedy": "Use a valid channel model for the intended domain. If initial correlations restrict the allowed preparations, describe that restricted assignment problem explicitly rather than claiming a universal channel.",
      "scope": "The partial-transpose negative-eigenvalue calculation is exact for the stated Bell state; the physical interpretation depends on whether the map is meant to act independently on arbitrary inputs.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "systems composition",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A property on isolated components need not survive extension to correlated composites."
        },
        {
          "field": "software verification",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Local tests can omit interactions present in a larger environment."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-LINDBLAD",
        "ROOT-PERES1996",
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "LINDBLAD",
        "PPT"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-013",
      "title": "A variational estimate is interpreted as an exact ground-state or gap certificate",
      "equationIds": [
        "VARIATIONAL",
        "VQE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The exact expectation of the same Hamiltonian in a normalized state is at least its ground energy. A finite-shot estimate can fluctuate below it; an approximate Hamiltonian or functional changes the reference. Low energy also need not imply high ground-state fidelity unless a suitable gap is known.",
      "presentation": "A noisy VQE value below the exact energy is called a violation of quantum mechanics, or a small energy error is used to certify the wavefunction without a gap estimate.",
      "diagnostic": "Separate exact expectations, estimator uncertainty, ansatz error and Hamiltonian error. For a normalized state rho, E=Tr(rho H), F=<0|rho|0> (ground-state probability or squared fidelity), and a known nondegenerate ground gap Delta>0, 1-F <= (E-E0)/Delta. For a degenerate ground space use F=Tr(P0 rho) and the gap above that space.",
      "remedy": "Report energy and uncertainty for a specified Hamiltonian; certify fidelity or excitation gaps only with the additional spectral information required.",
      "scope": "An upper bound on energy is not a lower bound on an excitation gap. Approximate density functionals need not share the exact variational reference.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "optimization",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Objective error bounds distance to a minimizer only with additional curvature or gap structure."
        },
        {
          "field": "chemistry",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A good total energy can coexist with an inaccurate property or energy difference."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-VQE"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "VARIATIONAL",
        "VQE"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "SPIN-054",
        "SPIN-057",
        "SPIN-066"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-014",
      "title": "A single determinant is assumed to contain every relevant electronic correlation",
      "equationIds": [
        "HF"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Hartree–Fock treats exchange within a determinant but restricts the wavefunction class. Near degeneracy, bond breaking and strong correlation can require more than one determinant. A self-consistent solution can also be a local stationary solution rather than the desired minimum.",
      "presentation": "Convergence is achieved while spin symmetry, dissociation limits or reaction-energy differences remain wrong.",
      "diagnostic": "Check state and symmetry stability, compare physically relevant alternative solutions, vary the basis and use a suitable correlated reference where feasible.",
      "remedy": "Separate basis incompleteness, variational-class limitations and solver convergence. Select an approximation justified for the target observable and regime.",
      "scope": "This is a conditional approximation risk; it does not mean Hartree–Fock is useless or that every discrepancy is caused by correlation. Fock supplies the historical approximation anchor; the present diagnostics are the atlas's analysis, rather than claims that every modern failure case is discussed in that paper.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "many-body physics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A restricted variational manifold can miss entangled correlations."
        },
        {
          "field": "statistical modeling",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A converged fit cannot recover structure excluded from its model class."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-FOCK",
        "ROOT-ANALYSIS2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "HF"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-015",
      "title": "An oracle-query improvement is reported as the total computational cost",
      "equationIds": [
        "GROVER",
        "QCOMPUTE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Grover's O(sqrt(N)) bound counts queries in a specified search model. Building and executing the oracle, preparing data, error correction, success amplification and readout can dominate a real implementation. With N=2^n candidates the query count remains O(2^{n/2}) in n.",
      "presentation": "A quadratic search advantage is called a polynomial-time algorithm for arbitrary NP-complete problems or a guaranteed practical speedup.",
      "diagnostic": "Express input length and candidate count separately; cost the complete circuit and data interface under a documented access model.",
      "remedy": "State query complexity and end-to-end resources side by side, using the best relevant classical comparison for that task.",
      "scope": "A quantum algorithm for factoring also does not resolve P versus NP; the computational classes and target problem differ.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "database systems",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A fast lookup primitive can hide expensive index construction."
        },
        {
          "field": "numerical analysis",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Iteration counts do not include the cost of each iteration."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-GROVER"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "GROVER",
        "QCOMPUTE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-016",
      "title": "Circuit expressiveness is treated as trainability",
      "equationIds": [
        "VQE",
        "BARREN"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A circuit may represent a useful state but offer gradients too small to estimate with the available shots, or a landscape with inaccessible minima. Barren-plateau results concern specified ensembles and cost functions, not every quantum ansatz.",
      "presentation": "Adding depth improves representational capacity while optimization becomes noise-dominated and empirical progress stalls.",
      "diagnostic": "Measure gradient scaling, shot cost, initialization dependence and problem structure; distinguish optimizer failure from an ansatz that cannot express the target.",
      "remedy": "Use physically informed ansätze, initialization and cost design where justified; evaluate scaling rather than extrapolating from a tiny circuit.",
      "scope": "Neither a small demonstration nor a random-circuit obstruction establishes the performance of every variational method.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Expressive parameterizations can be hard to train."
        },
        {
          "field": "inverse problems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Representability does not establish identifiable or stable recovery."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-BARREN",
        "QH-VQE"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "VQE",
        "BARREN"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-017",
      "title": "A threshold theorem's noise assumptions are replaced by one average error rate",
      "equationIds": [
        "QEC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Fault-tolerance conclusions depend on a stated error model, locality/correlation properties, operations and decoder assumptions. Two devices with the same average gate infidelity can have different leakage, coherent accumulation or correlated bursts.",
      "presentation": "A device is called below threshold from one summary number despite end-to-end logical errors that grow with circuit size.",
      "diagnostic": "Characterize relevant temporal/spatial correlations and leakage; measure logical failure for complete operations and compare it with the theorem's actual hypotheses.",
      "remedy": "Use a matched noise model and a measured logical scaling test. Include state preparation, measurement, decoder and control errors.",
      "scope": "A threshold is not a universal hardware constant independent of code, architecture and noise.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "reliability engineering",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Common-mode failures can defeat redundancy."
        },
        {
          "field": "distributed systems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Independent-failure guarantees do not cover correlated outages."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-THRESHOLD",
        "QH-QEC"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "QEC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-018",
      "title": "A few code distances are extrapolated to arbitrary reliable computation",
      "equationIds": [
        "QEC",
        "FINITEFIT"
      ],
      "mechanism": "Improvement between measured finite code sizes supports that operating regime. It does not by itself establish the asymptotic error law, arbitrary algorithm depth, scalable decoding latency or absence of a rare correlated-error floor.",
      "presentation": "A finite memory experiment is described as a complete fault-tolerant computer with unlimited depth.",
      "diagnostic": "Measure relevant logical operations, circuit duration and resource overhead; test for floors and rare-event sensitivity in the range needed by the target task.",
      "remedy": "State the finite demonstrated result and the untested scaling obligations separately.",
      "scope": "This is not a criticism that finite experiments should prove infinity; it identifies the boundary of what they establish.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "structural reliability",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Observed component reliability does not establish arbitrary lifetime."
        },
        {
          "field": "machine learning",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A favorable scaling interval can precede a new bottleneck."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-QEC"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "QEC",
        "FINITEFIT"
      ],
      "relatedEntries": [
        "SPIN-035"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-019",
      "title": "An erasure bound is applied to every gate or every logical bit",
      "equationIds": [
        "LANDAUER",
        "SHANNON"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The familiar k_B T ln 2 scale concerns erasing one unbiased bit under a specified thermodynamic setup. Logical reversibility, known or biased information, correlations, bath conditions and finite-time dissipation change the accounting. A logical operation and an erasure are not synonyms.",
      "presentation": "An estimate multiplies all operations by k_B T ln 2, or a reversible truth table is claimed to consume no energy in a real machine.",
      "diagnostic": "Identify the information actually discarded, its distribution, the physical memory and bath, and all reset/control costs.",
      "remedy": "Use an explicit entropy and energy budget for the complete physical protocol, distinguishing an ideal lower bound from achieved dissipation.",
      "scope": "The entry does not supply a universal generalized Landauer formula for correlated quantum memories; those require separate hypotheses.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "thermodynamics",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "Entropy changes depend on the defined system and environment."
        },
        {
          "field": "computing architecture",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "Reset and control overhead can dominate a logical primitive."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-LANDAUER",
        "QH-BENNETT"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "LANDAUER",
        "SHANNON"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-020",
      "title": "A reversible embedding hides discarded intermediate information",
      "equationIds": [
        "REVERSIBLE"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The map (x,0) to (x,f(x)) preserves x and can be embedded in a reversible computation. If an implementation erases x or intermediate garbage without accounting for it, the total operation is no longer the claimed closed reversible transformation.",
      "presentation": "A reversible circuit diagram omits ancillary resets, storage growth or the uncomputation stage.",
      "diagnostic": "Track every register and environment record through preparation, computation, output copying where allowed, uncomputation and reset.",
      "remedy": "Include ancilla, memory, time and physical dissipation costs in the complete process.",
      "scope": "Logical reversibility does not guarantee an experimentally reversible thermodynamic protocol at finite speed.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "data provenance",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A transformation is invertible only while enough original information is retained."
        },
        {
          "field": "software engineering",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "An undo operation depends on preserved state and side effects."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-BENNETT"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "REVERSIBLE"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-021",
      "title": "The no-cloning theorem is either overextended or evaded by relabeling encoding",
      "equationIds": [
        "CLONING",
        "QEC"
      ],
      "mechanism": "A universal exact cloner for unknown nonorthogonal pure states conflicts with linear evolution. Including an input-dependent final machine state gives c=c²<e_psi|e_phi>; hence |c|<=|c|², impossible for 0<|c|<1. With the same final machine state this reduces to c=c². Known states or an orthogonal set can be copied under a specified procedure; error correction encodes correlations, not independent perfect copies of an arbitrary state.",
      "presentation": "The theorem is said to forbid all redundancy or classical copying, or a proposed quantum encoder is claimed to create unlimited independent copies.",
      "diagnostic": "Test the map on two nonorthogonal inputs and their superposition; distinguish an encoded joint state from a tensor product of separate input copies.",
      "remedy": "State the allowed input set and fidelity/probability requirements. Use a valid encoding or approximate/probabilistic protocol within its proper scope.",
      "scope": "The simple proof covers universal deterministic exact cloning; other tasks require their own statements.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "information theory",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "A transformation can preserve information jointly without replicating it independently."
        },
        {
          "field": "redundant engineering",
          "relationship": "analogy",
          "explanation": "Different forms of redundancy have different operational guarantees."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-CLONING"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "proved-counterexample",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "CLONING",
        "QEC"
      ]
    },
    {
      "id": "QH-022",
      "title": "Teleportation is treated as copying or message transmission without a classical channel",
      "equationIds": [
        "TELEPORT",
        "NOSIGNALLING"
      ],
      "mechanism": "The standard protocol consumes shared entanglement and uses a measurement outcome to select a receiver correction. Without the classical outcome, the receiver's unconditional state does not expose the unknown input as a controllable message; the original is not retained as an independent perfect copy.",
      "presentation": "An animation omits the classical bits or leaves two perfect copies, yet calls the result standard quantum teleportation.",
      "diagnostic": "Compute the receiver's state averaged over all sender outcomes and after the conditional correction; track the original subsystem and entanglement resource.",
      "remedy": "Include the classical communication and resource accounting in the diagram and claims.",
      "scope": "This describes the specified state-transfer protocol and does not imply transport of matter or faster-than-light communication.",
      "transfers": [
        {
          "field": "communication systems",
          "relationship": "shared-method",
          "explanation": "A conditional decoder needs its side information."
        },
        {
          "field": "causal inference",
          "relationship": "same-mathematics",
          "explanation": "An outcome-conditioned state differs from the accessible marginal."
        }
      ],
      "sourceIds": [
        "QH-TELEPORT",
        "ROOT-CALC2026"
      ],
      "history": [],
      "verification": "conditional-risk",
      "component": "quantum_history",
      "componentTitle": "Historical quantum equation families",
      "originalEquationIds": [
        "TELEPORT",
        "NOSIGNALLING"
      ]
    }
  ],
  "observedAuditFindings": [
    {
      "findings": [
        {
          "id": "AUDIT-ROOTS-001",
          "status": "corrected and rerun",
          "component": "compute_failure_examples.py",
          "observation": "The first root check declared s real; the polynomial has no real roots, so solve returned an empty list. Python all over that empty list was true. The independent Wolfram calculation had already returned the four complex roots.",
          "mechanism": "A domain mismatch combined with a vacuously true universal assertion concealed an empty result.",
          "repair": "Declare the polynomial variable without a real-only restriction, require exactly four roots, substitute each root into the polynomial, and test that each real part differs from one half.",
          "scope": "An observed defect in the new audit script, not in the previously published spectral data. Corrected outputs are in counterexamples.json."
        },
        {
          "id": "AUDIT-SCISPACE-001",
          "status": "clarified by cross-check; corrected in catalogue",
          "component": "SciSpace custom extraction, Failure mechanism and Diagnostic and limit columns",
          "observation": "For Bareinboim and Pearl's data-fusion paper, the Failure mechanism cell labeled a condition that prevents recovery by the described method as a Non-identifiability condition and called it an identification failure. The companion Diagnostic and limit cell correctly explained that the S-backdoor criterion is sufficient and its failure does not establish that recovery is impossible. The first cell's compressed labeling could therefore be read as an unjustified converse.",
          "mechanism": "A method-specific failure was compressed into language suggesting a general impossibility claim; another extracted cell retained the necessary sufficiency qualification.",
          "repair": "The catalogue states that failure of one sufficient causal adjustment criterion does not prove non-identifiability. A valid non-identifiability claim requires the applicable theorem or compatible causal models yielding different target effects; an explicit two-model counterexample was executed separately.",
          "scope": "An observed ambiguity/overstatement in generated research extraction, not an error attributed to the primary paper. The extraction's complete diagnostic cell already contained the correction.",
          "sourceReference": {
            "paperId": "causal-inference-and-the-data-fusion-problem-51m8qosm4q",
            "title": "Causal inference and the data-fusion problem",
            "authors": "Elias Bareinboim and Judea Pearl",
            "year": 2016,
            "primaryUrl": "https://www.pnas.org/content/pnas/113/27/7345.full.pdf",
            "scispaceUrl": "https://scispace.com/papers/causal-inference-and-the-data-fusion-problem-51m8qosm4q",
            "failureColumnId": "cc_eyJrIjoibTI3YmV0ZXBoYyIsIm4iOiJGYWlsdXJlIG1lY2hhbmlzbSJ9",
            "diagnosticColumnId": "cc_eyJrIjoiZTgwb283cjA4NiIsIm4iOiJEaWFnbm9zdGljIGFuZCBsaW1pdCJ9",
            "failureCellExcerpt": "This is an identification failure, not merely noisy estimation.",
            "diagnosticCellExcerpt": "The S-backdoor criterion is sufficient, not a universal remedy."
          }
        },
        {
          "id": "AUDIT-SCISPACE-BELL-001",
          "status": "scope qualified",
          "component": "SciSpace extraction of quantum-nonlocality-bell-inequalities-and-the-memory-1ye8alty2c",
          "observation": "The short extraction phrased the linearized CHSH result as memory not producing a violation, without retaining an explicit finite-sample fluctuation qualification.",
          "mechanism": "An expectation-level constraint can be overread as a deterministic claim about every finite empirical sample.",
          "repair": "The atlas distinguishes conditional expectation bounds from finite-sample tail probabilities and uses memory-robust statistical inference.",
          "scope": "This records an ambiguity in a generated extraction, not an error attributed to the original Barrett et al. paper.",
          "primarySource": "https://arxiv.org/abs/quant-ph/0205016"
        }
      ]
    },
    {
      "schemaVersion": "1.0",
      "checkedAt": "2026-11-19",
      "findings": [
        {
          "id": "MIL-OBS-SCISPACE-HODGE-001",
          "kind": "observed-retrieval-summary-error",
          "service": "SciSpace",
          "observedOperation": "scispace_search",
          "query": "Which counterexamples show why the integral Hodge conjecture and its extension to compact Kähler manifolds differ from the rational projective Hodge conjecture? limit:8 sort:relevance",
          "recordId": "a-counterexample-to-the-hodge-conjecture-for-kaehler-3tfxu54x53",
          "recordUrl": "https://scispace.com/papers/a-counterexample-to-the-hodge-conjecture-for-kaehler-3tfxu54x53?utm_source=chatgpt&utm_medium=tool",
          "recordTitle": "A counterexample to the Hodge conjecture for Kaehler varieties",
          "recordMetadata": "2001; Claire Voisin; arXiv: Algebraic Geometry; Posted Content",
          "field": "generated TL;DR",
          "verbatimExcerpt": "rational Hodge classes on a smooth projective manifold are not generated by algebraic subsets",
          "observedFailure": "The generated summary promotes a counterexample to a compact-Kähler extension into a claimed counterexample to the rational smooth-projective conjecture. The same record's abstract preserves the Kähler distinction.",
          "primaryCorrection": {
            "url": "https://webusers.imj-prg.fr/~claire.voisin/Articlesweb/hodgeimrn.pdf",
            "title": "A Counterexample to the Hodge Conjecture Extended to Kähler Varieties",
            "author": "Claire Voisin",
            "year": 2002,
            "location": "Introduction and Theorem 1.1",
            "scope": "A compact Kähler complex torus with a degree-four Hodge class provides a counterexample to the proposed Kähler generation statement; this is not a counterexample to rational Hodge on smooth projective complex varieties.",
            "inspection": "Primary author PDF introduction and theorem inspected directly.",
            "sourceRef": "turn157951307view5"
          },
          "selectedRecordId": "a-counterexample-to-the-hodge-conjecture-extended-to-kahler-3mu8eyiotr",
          "duplicateRecordIds": [
            "a-counterexample-to-the-hodge-conjecture-for-kaehler-3h9d2ry4ww",
            "a-counterexample-to-the-hodge-conjecture-for-kaehler-vf5tshu8pmga",
            "a-counterexample-to-the-hodge-conjecture-for-kaehler-3tfxu54x53"
          ],
          "impact": "Would falsely report the Millennium Hodge conjecture disproved if used without checking the theorem.",
          "remedy": "Use the primary theorem statement; retain the geometric category and coefficient ring; deduplicate versions and do not treat summaries as proof evidence.",
          "relatedModeIds": [
            "HOD-001",
            "HOD-003",
            "HOD-014"
          ],
          "certainty": "Observed in this session, with primary-source correction.",
          "excerptWordCount": 14
        }
      ],
      "review": {
        "scope": "Focused exact-contract review of all 112 entries, especially NS, Hodge, PNP barriers and BSD.",
        "substantiveContractErrorsFound": 0,
        "clarificationsApplied": [
          {
            "modeId": "NS-006",
            "change": "Made the time interval rescaling explicit in the mixed space-time norm identity."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "BSD-014",
            "change": "Made explicit that functional-equation parity directly constrains analytic rank and needs a separate bridge for algebraic rank."
          }
        ],
        "limitations": "This is a focused statement-and-inference audit, not independent reconstruction of the cited research proofs."
      }
    }
  ],
  "calculationFiles": [
    "spin_checks.json",
    "counterexamples.json",
    "history_checks.json",
    "wolfram_checks.json"
  ],
  "reproductionFiles": [
    "spin_checks.py",
    "compute_failure_examples.py",
    "history_checks.py"
  ],
  "earlyHistoricalAnchors": {
    "title": "Early modern and early nineteenth-century primary-text anchors",
    "checkedOn": "2026-11-19",
    "scope": "Five inspected primary-text witnesses from works published between 1638 and 1824, mapped to existing CROSS audit modes. The modern audit mapping is ours; these are not allegations that each historical author committed the associated failure. No causal lineage is inferred from mathematical or methodological resemblance.",
    "sources": [
      {
        "id": "EARLY-GALILEO1638",
        "title": "Galileo, Dialogues Concerning Two New Sciences, First Day",
        "year": 1638,
        "url": "https://galileoandeinstein.phys.virginia.edu/tns_draft/tns_001to061.html",
        "edition": "English translation by Henry Crew and Alfonso de Salvio, first published 1914; university transcription identifies Dover and National Edition page numbering.",
        "scope": "The opening discussion explicitly challenges inference from geometrically similar small structures to larger structures made of the same material.",
        "inspection": "University-hosted primary translation opened and opening structural-scaling discussion inspected; independently compared with the Wikisource transcription. No modern universal biological scaling law is attributed to Galileo.",
        "locator": "First Day, opening dialogue; English pages 1–4 and National Edition pages 50–52."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-BOYLE1672",
        "title": "Boyle, Tracts Containing New Experiments Touching the Relation Between Flame and Air",
        "year": 1672,
        "url": "https://web.lemoyne.edu/Giunta/boyle.html",
        "edition": "University-hosted extract from the 1672 text, reproduced via Leicester and Klickstein's 1952 Source Book in Chemistry.",
        "scope": "Boyle distinguishes admitting air by removing a receiver from admitting a little air through a stopcock without moving it.",
        "inspection": "Primary-text extract inspected, especially First Title, Experiments III and IV. The edited excerpt is not a complete audit of the 1672 volume.",
        "locator": "First Title, Experiments III–IV: alternative explanation involving escape of fumes, followed by the stopcock comparison."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-NEWTON1687",
        "title": "Newton, Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy, Book I, Section XI",
        "year": "1687 work; inspected 1729 English edition",
        "url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/The_Mathematical_Principles_of_Natural_Philosophy_(1729)/Book_1/Section_11",
        "edition": "Andrew Motte's 1729 translation. The source is a later edition witness; the exact wording is not represented as an inspection of the 1687 Latin printing.",
        "scope": "The section moves from an immovable force center to mutually attracting bodies and their common center of gravity.",
        "inspection": "Primary translation's opening passage and Propositions LVII–LIX inspected. Broader historical priority and changes between Latin editions were not investigated.",
        "locator": "Book I, Section XI, introduction and Propositions LVII–LIX."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-FOURIER1822",
        "title": "Fourier, The Analytical Theory of Heat, Chapter IX, Article 342",
        "year": "1822 French original; 1878 English translation",
        "url": "https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/abs/analytical-theory-of-heat/of-the-diffusion-of-heat/85ACC8B6A30D2310AFA3DD980CA6C90B",
        "edition": "Alexander Freeman's 1878 English translation, republished by Cambridge; the page also records later print and online publication dates.",
        "scope": "Article 342 specifies an infinite homogeneous solid, a structured initial temperature distribution, and an alternative thin prism with an insulating lateral surface.",
        "inspection": "The publisher's displayed primary-text passage for Article 342 and edition metadata were inspected. The complete chapter's proofs were not audited.",
        "locator": "Chapter IX, First Section, Article 342; displayed publisher passage corresponding to the chapter beginning on printed page 333."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-CARNOT1824",
        "title": "Carnot, Reflections on the Motive Power of Heat, original treatise within Thurston's edition",
        "year": "1824 original; inspected 1897 revised English edition",
        "url": "https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Reflections_on_the_Motive_Power_of_Heat/Chapter_3",
        "edition": "R. H. Thurston's second revised English edition, 1897; copyright 1890. Chapter III contains Carnot's treatise, distinct from the editor's introduction and Thomson's later account.",
        "scope": "Constant-temperature reservoirs, forward and inverse operations, loss-free idealization, and the explicit caveat about a small temperature excess driving heat transfer.",
        "inspection": "Primary-text translation inspected through the reservoir construction and reversible-cycle discussion. Front matter was cross-checked in the Gutenberg transcription. No modern entropy notation is attributed to the 1824 text.",
        "locator": "Chapter III, reservoir construction and ideal operations, especially the passage corresponding to printed pages 50–60."
      }
    ],
    "events": [
      {
        "id": "EARLY-001",
        "year": 1638,
        "title": "Galileo separates geometric resemblance from physical strength.",
        "paragraph": "The opening dialogue in Two New Sciences questions whether a structure that works at one size can simply be enlarged while retaining the same material and proportions. Galileo's interlocutors distinguish geometric similarity from resistance under physical loading, including self-weight. This is a concrete early anchor for auditing scale transfer: our modern mapping asks which loads, material properties and dimensionless ratios are preserved. It does not turn every sentence in the dialogue into a modern engineering theorem or assert that geometric similarity always fails. The inspected witness is the Crew–de Salvio English translation, not the original Italian printing.",
        "sourceIds": [
          "EARLY-GALILEO1638"
        ],
        "modeIds": [
          "CROSS-048",
          "CROSS-031"
        ],
        "links": [
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-048",
            "relationship": "same-mathematics",
            "explanation": "Changing size can change the ratio between physical loading and resistance even when shape is preserved; the relevant mechanical assumptions must be specified."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-031",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "A successful small realization does not independently validate extrapolation to a larger operating regime."
          }
        ],
        "claimBoundary": "A documented discussion of scale dependence; no first-discovery or exclusive historical influence claim."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-002",
        "year": 1672,
        "title": "Boyle recognizes that one apparatus change can alter more than one cause.",
        "paragraph": "In the flame-and-air extract, Boyle reports that removing a receiver allows sulphur to reignite, then explicitly considers an alternative explanation: the operation admits air but also allows fumes to escape. The following experiment admits a little air through a stopcock without removing the receiver and compares the appearance and disappearance of flashes. This supplies an unusually direct primary-text anchor for causal audit: distinguish the intended intervention from other conditions it changes and devise a comparison that separates candidate explanations. We do not claim that these observations alone identified oxygen, quantified modern reaction kinetics, or removed every possible confounder.",
        "sourceIds": [
          "EARLY-BOYLE1672"
        ],
        "modeIds": [
          "CROSS-020",
          "CROSS-024"
        ],
        "links": [
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-020",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "An observed association following a manipulation does not isolate a causal pathway if the manipulation changes several relevant conditions."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-024",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "Operationally different versions of admitting air should not be collapsed into one treatment label without checking what else changes."
          }
        ],
        "claimBoundary": "The historical author explicitly raises and tests an alternative explanation; modern causal terminology is our interpretation of that documented procedure."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-003",
        "year": "1687 work; 1729 inspected witness",
        "title": "Newton states the boundary between a fixed force center and mutually moving bodies.",
        "paragraph": "Book I, Section XI of the inspected Motte translation opens by distinguishing earlier treatment of attraction toward an immovable center from reciprocal attraction between bodies. It then treats their motion relative to a common center of gravity. Our audit mapping is the obligation to retain the assumptions of a solved mathematical problem when applying it physically: a fixed-center construction and the mutually moving system are different specifications, even when one approximates the other. This is a positive example of the author making a modeling boundary explicit. The work first appeared in 1687; the exact passage inspected here belongs to the 1729 English witness.",
        "sourceIds": [
          "EARLY-NEWTON1687"
        ],
        "modeIds": [
          "CROSS-031",
          "CROSS-067",
          "CROSS-070"
        ],
        "links": [
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-031",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "Using a fixed-center result as an approximation requires control of the motion and interactions omitted by that specification."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-067",
            "relationship": "same-mathematics",
            "explanation": "A result proved for one dynamical system does not automatically become a theorem about a differently coupled system."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-070",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "The original publication date and the date of the translation actually inspected remain separate."
          }
        ],
        "claimBoundary": "No claim that Newton overlooked mutual attraction, nor that the inspected English wording was verified in the first Latin edition."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-004",
        "year": 1822,
        "title": "Fourier specifies initial state, geometry and insulation before evolving heat.",
        "paragraph": "Article 342 of The Analytical Theory of Heat describes an infinite homogeneous solid, an initial temperature depending on position along a selected axis, and the alternative of a thin prism with an insulating lateral surface. Those conditions explain why the reduced one-dimensional problem is appropriate. Our audit mapping is that a heat equation alone does not specify the whole prediction: geometry, initial data and boundary heat exchange remain part of the problem. Changing them can change the solution without contradicting the governing equation. The inspected primary passage is Freeman's 1878 translation of Fourier's 1822 work; the publisher's later digitization date is kept distinct.",
        "sourceIds": [
          "EARLY-FOURIER1822"
        ],
        "modeIds": [
          "CROSS-031",
          "CROSS-054",
          "CROSS-070"
        ],
        "links": [
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-031",
            "relationship": "same-mathematics",
            "explanation": "A reduced diffusion problem depends on homogeneity, geometry and a specified family of initial conditions."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-054",
            "relationship": "same-mathematics",
            "explanation": "Replacing an insulating boundary by a heat-transmitting one changes the boundary flux and energy balance."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-070",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "Original French publication, English translation and modern republication are separate bibliographic events."
          }
        ],
        "claimBoundary": "Only the displayed primary passage was inspected here; no claim of a complete audit of Fourier's convergence arguments or all chapters."
      },
      {
        "id": "EARLY-005",
        "year": 1824,
        "title": "Carnot distinguishes an ideal reversible construction from its physical execution.",
        "paragraph": "Carnot's treatise introduces two bodies maintained at constant temperatures, compares forward and inverse operations, and specifies the absence of losses in the ideal construction. It also explicitly notes that real heat transfer requires a temperature excess, then treats that excess as arbitrarily small for the theoretical argument. The modern audit connection is to distinguish an ideal limiting model from achieved finite-operation performance and to account for reservoirs and restoration of the initial state. The text speaks in caloric-era terms; we do not attribute a modern entropy formula to it. The original work is from 1824, while the inspected Thurston edition is the revised English printing of 1897.",
        "sourceIds": [
          "EARLY-CARNOT1824"
        ],
        "modeIds": [
          "CROSS-031",
          "CROSS-054",
          "CROSS-068",
          "CROSS-070"
        ],
        "links": [
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-031",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "A loss-free limiting construction is not an empirical assertion that a particular physical machine attains its ideal performance."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-054",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "The working body, reservoirs and reset of the starting state must remain visible in the complete process specification."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-068",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "Caloric-era vocabulary must be interpreted in context rather than silently replaced with later thermodynamic definitions."
          },
          {
            "modeId": "CROSS-070",
            "relationship": "shared-method",
            "explanation": "The original 1824 treatise, 1890 copyright and revised 1897 English edition are different events."
          }
        ],
        "claimBoundary": "No modern efficiency formula, historical priority claim, or blanket verdict on every caloric-theory argument is inferred from this excerpt."
      }
    ],
    "excludedOrUnresolved": [
      "Cauchy's 1821/1853 convergence historiography was not added because a precise primary-text and interpretation check would exceed this focused pass.",
      "Boyle's 1662 gas-law table was located but not used as the principal Boyle anchor; the inspected 1672 flame-and-air passage provided a clearer directly documented causal-design example.",
      "A University of Chicago Carnot excerpt displayed 1825 on its cover. It was not used to date the original work; the identified Thurston edition and primary treatise were used instead.",
      "These anchors fill specified chronological gaps; they are not a continuous history or a claim that only European sources contain relevant reasoning."
    ]
  }
}
